Back to California Disability

Giovanni Rossi

SDI claim denied appeal employer religious exemption what to do next

My SDI claim got denied and I'm honestly not sure where to start. I work at a small private school that has a religious affiliation, and when I filed my disability claim through SDI Online after a back injury kept me out for several weeks, the denial notice came saying I wasn't eligible. I think it has something to do with the fact that my employer might have a religious exemption from participating in SDI, but I'm not totally clear on that. The notice did have an appeal form attached, the DE 1000A I think, and it mentioned a 30-day deadline from the date on the notice. I'm scared I'm going to miss that window or fill something out wrong. Has anyone dealt with something like this? Do I even have a case to appeal or is a religious exemption just a dead end?

The denial notice having an appeal form attached is the key detail here. Whatever the reason for the denial, you have 30 days from the date printed on that notice to send in the DE 1000A with a written explanation of why you disagree. If the form is lost, a detailed letter mailed to the return address on the notice works just as well. What I would do first in your place is write down exactly what the notice says the reason is, because the explanation you send with the appeal needs to address that specific reason directly.

0 coins

The notice says something about wages not subject to SDI contributions, which I think is the religious exemption showing up. Does that mean my employer never deducted CASDI from my check?

0 coins

That wage language on a denial usually means EDD found no SDI-covered wages in the base period tied to your employer. If your employer holds a religious exemption, they may never have withheld CASDI from your pay at all. Check your pay stubs for a CASDI line. If it's missing, that's what drove the denial, and your appeal explanation needs to address whether those wages should have been covered.

0 coins

Exactly right. The appeal is the place to lay that out. Gather every pay stub you have and include them with the DE 1000A so the administrative law judge can see what was or wasn't withheld.

0 coins

Thirty days goes fast. Mail that appeal form today, not next week. Even if you're not sure of your whole argument yet, get the form in with whatever you have. You can add more later.

0 coins

Can I really add information after I send the initial appeal?

0 coins

You'll get a hearing date. That's when you present everything. The form just gets you in the door before the deadline closes.

0 coins

He's right, don't sit on it. I missed an appeal window once on a different thing and there's no coming back from that.

0 coins

Receipt number on my own claim was causing issues a few weeks back and I couldnt get anyone at EDD to pick up no matter how many mornings I tried. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally got an agent on the line. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the receipt number my provider had used matched the one from my filing, so the certification went through fine after that. For you the appeal question is different but getting someone on the phone might help you understand exactly what the denial is based on.

0 coins

What did you actually have ready when the agent got on? Like did you need your claim ID or anything specific?

0 coins

Had my Social Security number and the claim ID from SDI Online open on my phone. Agent found everything pretty quick once I gave those two things.

0 coins

Been hitting that line since Tuesday morning and it just rings into nothing. How many days did it take you to get through before you tried that?

0 coins

The religious exemption piece is worth understanding before the hearing. Some employers with a religious affiliation are exempt from SDI, which means their workers don't pay the CASDI deduction and generally aren't covered. But the specific facts of your employer's status matter, and that's exactly the kind of thing an administrative law judge looks at. Your pay stubs showing whether CASDI was ever withheld are probably your most important documents.

0 coins

My stubs don't show a CASDI line at all, which is what I was afraid of. So is the appeal basically hopeless then?

0 coins

Not necessarily hopeless, but the appeal needs to be honest about what the stubs show. The hearing lets you present the full picture and have a judge review whether the exemption applies correctly to your situation. That's different from just accepting the denial.

0 coins

There are also sometimes questions about whether the exemption was properly established or whether the work you do falls within the exemption's scope. Those are fact-specific, so the hearing is genuinely the right place for them.

0 coins

My cousin went through an appeal last year and she said the scariest part was just not knowing what to expect at the hearing. She ended up writing a really thorough letter explaining her whole situation and the judge actually read it carefully. For what it's worth she felt like she got a fair shot even though the process was stressful.

0 coins

Did she have a lawyer or did she go by herself? I'm in a kind of similar situation and the idea of a hearing is really intimidating.

0 coins

She went by herself. Said the judge explained things as they went. It's not like a courtroom.

0 coins

The hearing is administrative, not a court. You can bring someone to help you but you don't need a lawyer. Coming in with organized paperwork and a clear written statement goes a long way.

0 coins

Denials tied to no covered wages are tough. The appeal doesn't create covered wages if they were never there. Worth going to the hearing anyway because exemption status can have its own wrinkles, but go in with clear eyes about what the stubs show.

0 coins

That's kind of what I figured but I wanted to hear it said plainly. I'll still file the appeal because I want the judge to actually look at the employer's exemption claim.

0 coins

That's the right reason to appeal. Make the record.

0 coins

wait so your employer just never paid into sdi for you at all and edd is the one denying you because of that? thats rough

0 coins

That's essentially what a religious exemption can mean for the workers covered by it. The employer opted out of SDI participation, so CASDI was never deducted, and without those contributions EDD finds no covered wages in the base period.

0 coins

so the worker just gets nothing even though they had no choice in it? thats kind of messed up

0 coins

The appeal process exists partly because of situations where the exemption's application might be disputed. It's worth pursuing for that reason.

0 coins

Payment on my own injury claim dropped off and I couldnt figure out why. The EDD phone line ate four mornings of mine, just endless ringing or the recording cutting me off. I tried Claimyr and got through to an agent who looked at my claim and told me the payment for the week in question had issued on a specific date that was actually later than I expected. Turned out it was already on its way. That was for a date question on my payment, different from an appeal, but at least I stopped panicking.

0 coins

I need to find out which weeks on my claim are still pending, been wondering about that for days now. Might try Claimyr for that, what should I have ready when the agent picks up?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and your claim ID pulled up. The agent can see which weeks are showing and what their status is once you give those.

0 coins

been trying that line since last week, every morning around eight, never got past the recording once

0 coins

File the appeal. Keep it factual. State your dates of disability, attach your pay stubs, and explain that you believe your employer's exemption status is at issue. Let the judge sort out the rest.

0 coins

Should I also include any documentation about the school's religious affiliation or is that the employer's thing to establish?

0 coins

Include anything you have. The more the judge can see without having to ask, the better.

0 coins

The 30-day deadline is real and it really does count from the date on the notice, not the day you got it in the mail! I sent mine in on day 29 once and it was fine, but I would not recommend cutting it that close!

0 coins

Day 29 is way too close. Mail it at least a few days early so there's no question about when it arrived.

0 coins

Totally agree, I was just illustrating that the date on the notice is the reference point, not when you receive it. Mail it now!

0 coins

From an organizational standpoint, before you drop that appeal in the mail, make a copy of everything: the denial notice, the DE 1000A, every pay stub, and the explanation letter. Keep them together. If anything gets lost in transit or the hearing requires additional documentation, you have your own record of exactly what you submitted.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about keeping copies. I'll do that. The notice itself has a date of about two weeks ago so I need to move fast.

0 coins

Two weeks gone means roughly two weeks left. Send it this week.

0 coins

Certified mail with return receipt is worth the extra few dollars for something this important. You'll have proof of the mailing date and delivery.

0 coins

I'm going through my first SDI claim right now and reading this thread is making me realize I don't fully understand how the appeal process works. If the denial says no covered wages, does the appeal actually change whether wages were covered or does it just let you argue about it?

0 coins

The appeal gives an administrative law judge the chance to review the facts and the law. It doesn't automatically change anything, but if there's a question about whether the exemption was validly applied to your employer or your specific job, the hearing is where that gets examined.

0 coins

So it's not pointless even if the stubs don't show CASDI withheld. Got it, that actually helps.

0 coins

I'd also double check the date on that notice one more time before you assume you have two weeks. Holidays and weekends don't pause the 30-day clock.

0 coins

Checked it again. I have 13 days from today. Sending the appeal tomorrow.

0 coins

Good. Don't wait for tomorrow morning either.

0 coins

Appeals feel overwhelming but a lot of people go in thinking they have no chance and walk out with at least a clearer answer. Even if the outcome isn't what you want, the hearing puts everything on the record and sometimes turns up details the initial denial missed.

0 coins

Agreed. The worst thing that can happen at the hearing is the same denial, but now you understand exactly why.

0 coins

That framing actually helps. I've been dreading it like it's going to be worse than the denial but at minimum I'll know more than I know now.

0 coins

DE 2593 caught me completely off guard on my own claim. Showed up after ten weeks of automatic payments and I almost missed the 20-day return window. I tried the EDD line for a week straight with nothing, so I used Claimyr and got an agent on the phone who confirmed the form had been received and was being processed. No more mystery about where it stood.

0 coins

The 20-day window on that form surprised me too. Got through to an agent using Claimyr on my own claim and once she confirmed the DE 2593 was in, I asked about the Notice of Computation while I had her. She read me the weekly amount off my own notice and confirmed which quarter of my base period EDD had used. At least I knew what to expect from the payment side.

0 coins

I didn't even know there was a form at that stage of a claim. So after ten weeks of automatic payments EDD sends you a form and you have to return it within 20 days or benefits stop?

0 coins

That's the rule. Twenty days from when EDD sends it. Keep an eye on your mail after the ten-week mark.

0 coins

been trying to reach that line myself for days just to ask one question about my claim status

0 coins

For the appeal letter itself, focus on the facts of your employment: how long you worked there, that you had no choice about whether CASDI was withheld, and that you're asking the judge to review whether the exemption was correctly applied. You don't need legal language. Clear and factual is enough.

0 coins

I keep trying to make it sound formal and I'm tying myself in knots. Plain factual language is probably better anyway.

0 coins

Plain is better. Judges read a lot of these. A clear timeline with specific dates and attached stubs is easier to work with than a lot of formal phrasing.

0 coins

late appeal also possible but you need to explain the delay and an alj reviews it. dont push it if you can avoid it.

0 coins

Correct, a late appeal requires you to explain why it was late and an administrative law judge decides whether to accept it. Much cleaner to file on time if you still have days left.

0 coins

yeah just file it. not worth the extra step

0 coins

Notice of Determination I got last month said I had appeal rights and I genuinely didn't know what to do with it. I tried calling EDD disability and spent most of a morning getting nowhere. Eventually I tried Claimyr and an agent pulled up my claim and told me the notice had been issued because a form EDD was waiting on hadn't been matched to my claim yet. That was actually fixable, nothing like I'd feared from reading the notice alone.

0 coins

Honestly I have a hard time believing you can just get through to an EDD agent that easily. I've tried that line every day for almost two weeks and gotten the recording every single time, so something about that sounds off to me.

0 coins

I get the doubt. I felt the same way before I tried it. The person I talked to knew exactly what was on my claim and answered the specific question I had about that notice. She worked for EDD, not for anyone else.

0 coins

I had a similar experience when I finally got someone on the line about my own waiting period question. The agent confirmed my claim's start date and told me the first seven days were the non-payable waiting period, so my first payable day was day eight. I'd been counting wrong and thought I was owed more. At least I knew the real number after.

0 coins

Okay. I might give it a shot. My situation isn't going to fix itself waiting for the line to open up.

0 coins

Appealing a denial when you believe the employer's exemption was applied wrong is exactly what the appeal process is for. Put the facts down, mail the form, show up to the hearing.

0 coins

Appeal is going out tomorrow morning with pay stubs, the denial notice copy, and a one-page letter laying out the timeline and the CASDI question. Thanks to everyone who weighed in here.

0 coins

Good. That's how it's done.

0 coins

just want to flag that someone earlier said you can add information after sending the appeal form. i thought the appeal had to be complete when you send it or it gets tossed out

0 coins

To be clear on the rule: getting the form in by the deadline is what matters. The hearing itself is where you present your full case, with documents and testimony. What you send with the form gets things started, but the hearing is not limited to only what was in the initial mailing.

0 coins

ok that makes more sense. i was picturing it like a one-shot thing with no hearing.

0 coins

The hearing is genuinely where the case is decided. The form is the entry point.

0 coins

did you ever get a Notice of Computation before the denial? like did edd send that at all

0 coins

No Notice of Computation came. The denial was the first thing I received after my doctor submitted the certification. I think without covered wages in the base period there was nothing to compute.

0 coins

That tracks. The Notice of Computation shows a potential benefit amount based on wages found in the base period. If EDD found no SDI-covered wages, there would be nothing to put on that notice.

0 coins

One more practical note: the return address for the appeal is the one printed on the denial notice itself, not EDD's general address. Send it there specifically.

0 coins

I almost missed that. The address on the notice is different from what comes up when I search EDD. Good catch.

0 coins

Always use the address on the notice for anything related to that notice. Different offices handle different things.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure