Back to California Disability

Kai Rivera

SDI certification requires social security benefit verification letter and W2 why is EDD asking for this

So I finally got my medical certification submitted and thought I was done with my part, but now I'm seeing something in SDI Online about needing a social security benefit verification letter and a W2 and I am completely lost. I work part time at a daycare and I've been out since my back injury and I really can't afford for this to drag out. Why would EDD need a social security benefit verification letter and a W2 just for the disability certification? I already put my wages on my claim. Is this something everyone has to do or did I do something wrong when I filed? I'm getting really scared this is going to delay my payments and I don't know who to call or where to even start.

Waiting period on my own claim cleared up something I was confused about for weeks, so I'll start there since it's related. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person at EDD disability after the phone line dropped me four mornings in a row. The agent pulled up my account and told me the first seven days of a new claim don't pay, full stop, that's the waiting period and it's not processing time. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Now on your actual question, EDD shouldn't be asking the general population for a social security benefit verification letter or a W2 as part of a standard DI certification. Something about how the claim was filed may have flagged your wage data as unverifiable from the base period quarters they're looking at.

0 coins

four mornings and you got through? every time I call that line it either rings forever or cuts me off before I even hear a menu. what did you actually do differently here, because I've been at this for going on three weeks

0 coins

Tried Claimyr, it stayed on the line in my place and my phone rang when an agent was there. That's genuinely all that happened. The person I talked to was EDD staff and knew my file.

0 coins

I used it too when my payment date was a mystery, honestly just needed to know if the check had actually been issued yet. The agent looked it up and told me the payment had gone out two days before, so it was already on its way to my Money Network card. After that I just had to wait the extra couple days for it to arrive.

0 coins

Before anything else, I want to gently say: take a breath. What you're describing doesn't match the standard SDI filing process, and that's actually useful information. EDD does not routinely ask disability claimants for a Social Security benefit verification letter. When I filed my own claim a couple of years ago, nothing like that came up. It makes me wonder if you may have received something that was meant for a different program, or if there was a data mismatch in your wage history from the base period quarters.

0 coins

okay that actually helps a little. I was so panicked I didn't even think it might be from a different program. How would I figure out which one sent it?

0 coins

Look very carefully at the letterhead and the return address on whatever you received. EDD communications about disability claims come from the SDI program specifically and reference your claim ID. If it says something else, it may not be related to your DI claim at all.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared of this same thing happening to me. I haven't gotten anything weird yet but I'm only a week into my claim, not sure if that's too early to worry about it yet.

0 coins

EDD asking for W2s during a disability certification is not standard. I've been through two SDI claims and neither time did they ask me for tax documents at the certification stage. What exactly does the message in SDI Online say, word for word? Because 'certification requires' and 'you must provide' are very different things.

0 coins

it said something like additional documentation may be required to verify wages and listed those two things. I didn't screenshot it which I regret now

0 coins

If it said 'may be required' that's not a demand, that's a heads-up. Very different. Don't send anything until you know for certain what they actually need and why.

0 coins

Always screenshot stuff in SDI Online. Always. Learned that the hard way.

0 coins

The wage base period for a DI claim goes back 5 to 18 months before the claim start date, pulling from the highest-paid quarter inside a 12-month window of four quarters. EDD gets wage data from employer reports, not from the claimant directly in most cases. If something in that quarter didn't match, say if your daycare employer reported wages late or under a different identifier, EDD might ask for backup documentation. The Notice of Computation is where you'll see which quarter they used and what benefit amount they calculated.

0 coins

my employer is really small, like six of us total. is it possible they haven't filed their wage reports with EDD yet? I had no idea that was even a thing

0 coins

That's a real possibility with very small employers. The employer's SDI wage reports feed into what EDD can verify on your end. If the quarter they're checking shows no wages on their end but you know you worked, that's exactly the kind of gap that can generate a documentation request.

0 coins

I did not know employers could file late and that it would affect your claim. That seems like a massive problem waiting to happen for anyone at a small business.

0 coins

Thirty years working job sites and I've filed SDI twice. Never once did anyone ask me for a Social Security letter. That's a different agency entirely. Something's off about what you're seeing.

0 coins

Social Security is federal, SDI is California. Two completely different things. EDD doesn't need anything from Social Security for a disability claim.

0 coins

Exactly. If EDD thinks you're also getting Social Security benefits, they might want to know because of how the two interact, but that's a specific situation, not routine.

0 coins

oh I didn't realize they were separate. I've been saying SDI and Social Security like they were the same thing this whole time

0 coins

wait is this person sure theyre looking at the right thing in sdi online because ive had random messages in there that were old and didnt apply to me anymore, like leftover stuff from a previous claim thing

0 coins

oh no I didn't think of that either. I do have an old claim from two years ago when I had a minor surgery. could it be pulling something from that?

0 coins

yeah log out and log back in and make sure youre clicking the right claim id, the current one not the old one

0 coins

this is actually a really good catch lol, two claims can look similar and if you tap the wrong one you're reading totally different stuff

0 coins

Sorry to jump in here but we had this exact mess when my wife filed, anyway, the daycare thing matters. Some small employers in California have voluntary disability plans instead of the state SDI, different coverage entirely. Might be worth confirming with your employer that you're actually covered under EDD's SDI and not some separate plan.

0 coins

how do I even find that out? my employer never mentioned anything like that

0 coins

Ask HR or your manager directly whether the SDI deduction on your pay stub says CASDI or something else. If it says CASDI you're in EDD's program.

0 coins

The CASDI deduction on each pay stub is the clearest indicator that you're contributing to EDD's SDI program and not a Voluntary Plan. Worth checking those stubs before doing anything else.

0 coins

Base period quarter question on my end got sorted out when I finally reached an EDD agent. Claimyr got me there after I genuinely couldn't crack the phone line on my own. The agent went through my account and found that the quarter they were using wasn't the one I expected at all, it was an earlier quarter with higher wages, which actually worked in my favor on the benefit amount! She walked me through what the Notice of Computation was showing and it all made sense after that.

0 coins

Claimyr, what is that exactly? I keep seeing people mention it but I don't know what it does.

0 coins

It's a service that handles the hold time with EDD for you so when a live person picks up you're the one on the line with them. That's really the whole thing.

0 coins

That's genuinely useful to know. I have a question about whether my employer's late wage report affected the base period quarter on my own claim and I'd want to raise that directly with someone at EDD.

0 coins

W2 requests are not part of EDD's standard DI certification process. When EDD can't verify wages from their own records, they may ask for wage documentation, but they typically use their internal employer wage data first. A W2 request specifically usually means that data isn't reconciling for some reason. Talk to your employer before anything else.

0 coins

should I bring this up with my employer directly or is that going to be awkward? we're a really small team and I don't want them to think I'm accusing them of something

0 coins

Just ask if their quarterly wage reports are current with EDD. Frame it as you trying to sort out a documentation issue on your claim. That's exactly what it is.

0 coins

most decent employers won't take it personally if you ask that way. it's a pretty normal admin question

0 coins

not sure if this is the same situation but I read somewhere that if you get any kind of Social Security payments, like SSDI or SSI, that's supposed to be reported when you file a DI claim. maybe that's why they're asking for the letter, to see if you're getting both?

0 coins

That's actually a reasonable theory. If there's something in the filing that indicated possible other income or benefits, EDD might want documentation of it to confirm how the claim should be calculated. Worth checking what you answered on the original claim form about other benefits.

0 coins

I don't get any Social Security payments at all, I'm only 29. But maybe I accidentally checked something wrong when I filed? the form had a lot of questions

0 coins

Go back into myEDD and look at your original Claimant's Statement if you can. If you accidentally answered yes to something about other benefits, that could be the source of the whole thing.

0 coins

EDD's system will request documentation if it can't match your wage data from the standard sources. The W2 is just a wage verification tool they're falling back on. Standard stuff when employer records are incomplete. Annoying but not a denial.

0 coins

Annoying is the word. Mine took two extra weeks because a quarter was wrong and by the time anyone noticed I was already past the first month out.

0 coins

That's the thing, delays from wage verification issues are frustrating but they don't mean you're being denied. The claim keeps moving, just slower.

0 coins

slower is an understatement when you have zero income coming in

0 coins

Payment method on a previous claim was something I couldn't get straight just from SDI Online, so I used Claimyr to reach someone at EDD disability and ask directly. The agent confirmed my account was still set for the Money Network card and that a payment had been issued that week. Gave me the exact date and that was it. On your situation, if the documentation request is specifically about wages, your best move is to gather your pay stubs from the base period quarters first.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself not long back and glad I did. The agent told me which weeks of my claim had actually been paid out and which ones were still sitting. Good to have those specifics in front of you. Having that list made it easier to know what I was still waiting on.

0 coins

which weeks being paid is the kind of thing SDI Online should just tell you clearly and it doesn't

0 coins

You've got to actually talk to someone to get the straight answer sometimes, that's just how it is

0 coins

Can I say something kind of sideways here? When I was going through my claim, my own doctor's office mixed up which receipt number to use and submitted the medical certification under an old claim. The whole thing looked weird in my account for a week and a half and I kept thinking something was wrong with my wages. Sometimes the weird thing showing up is a symptom of a totally different problem.

0 coins

oh wow I didn't even consider that. how did you figure out what actually happened?

0 coins

I called my provider's billing office and asked them to confirm what claim ID they submitted the certification under. Turned out they had an old number saved and used that one. They had to resubmit with the right one.

0 coins

going to do this first thing tomorrow, I gave the receipt number to my doctor's office but honestly I'm not 100% sure they wrote it down correctly

0 coins

the daycare worker situation is what's sticking with me here. a lot of people working in childcare are paid partly in cash or have irregular schedules and sometimes those wages just don't show up cleanly in the EDD wage records because of how they were reported. nothing wrong with you, it's the reporting chain.

0 coins

it's all on the books at my job, I'm an official employee with pay stubs. but I do have some weeks where my hours varied a lot depending on enrollment numbers

0 coins

variable hours reported accurately still can show up inconsistently in a quarterly summary depending on when pay periods fell. your pay stubs from those quarters are going to be the clearest thing you can hand them.

0 coins

Pay stubs plus a letter from the employer confirming the employment dates and compensation type would cover most of what EDD would need to verify the base period wages in a situation like this.

0 coins

There's a difference worth noting between EDD asking for documentation to verify wages before they issue a Notice of Computation versus asking after they've already computed your benefit amount. Do you have a Notice of Computation yet? That document tells you whether they were even able to calculate a benefit amount with the wage data they have. If you don't have one yet, the wage verification is probably the step standing between you and that notice.

0 coins

I don't have a Notice of Computation yet, nothing like that. So that's actually what's holding it up?

0 coins

Probably yes. EDD needs to verify wages before it can compute what you'd receive, so if the wage data isn't reconciling the notice doesn't generate. Once the documentation is in and they can verify, the notice should follow.

0 coins

That tracks with how the base period calculation works. The notice comes after EDD confirms which quarter they're using and what the wage amounts are.

0 coins

Medical certification process on my last claim got tangled up and I ended up using Claimyr to reach EDD and find out what was actually happening. The agent checked and told me the certification had been received but wasn't matched to my claim ID yet because the receipt number my provider submitted had a digit off. That one piece of information saved me from waiting another two weeks not knowing why nothing was moving.

0 coins

That sounds exactly like marketing to me, honestly. 'One call solved everything' doesn't reflect how EDD actually works in my experience.

0 coins

thought the same thing before. tried it anyway when my number kept going to that recording that just ends the call. agent pulled up my DE 2593 status and told me they had it and when it was due back. that was real EDD information about my actual account, not a pitch.

0 coins

okay that's a different kind of answer than I expected. I'll give it a look, I've got a question about my own medical certification that I haven't been able to get answered.

0 coins

side question but are you sure the message was in SDI Online and not in the myEDD portal inbox? because I've gotten generic messages in the myEDD general inbox that weren't about my disability claim at all, they were about a UI claim from two years before. different programs, same inbox, super confusing lol

0 coins

now that you say that I think it might have been the general myEDD inbox and not inside SDI Online specifically. I need to go check

0 coins

if it's in the general inbox check the sender section carefully because it'll say which division of EDD sent it. that narrows down which claim or program it's actually about

0 coins

EDD's portal design has caused more unnecessary panic than any single rule change. multiple programs dumped in one inbox with minimal labeling is a nightmare.

0 coins

To move this forward practically: check the myEDD inbox sender, confirm with your employer that CASDI was deducted and that their wage reports are filed, verify with your provider's office that the medical certification went in under your current receipt number, and then contact EDD through SDI Online's Request Claim Update if you still need clarification on the documentation request. That sequence covers the most likely causes before you have to escalate.

0 coins

this is the most organized answer I've gotten so far and I genuinely needed it laid out like this. thank you

0 coins

Get the pay stubs pulled together at the same time so you have them ready if EDD does confirm they need wage documentation. Having them before they formally ask saves another round of waiting.

0 coins

I'm going to do most of this same checklist for my own claim just to make sure everything is lined up before it becomes a problem

0 coins

Last thing I'll say: don't send documents EDD didn't formally request. If the message said 'may be required' and nothing has actually come asking for them, wait until you've confirmed what they actually need. Sending random stuff you weren't asked for can slow things down.

0 coins

noted. I was about to just send everything I had because I panicked. glad I didn't do that yet

0 coins

Waiting until you know exactly what they're asking for is the right call. If EDD formally needs documentation they will tell you clearly and usually by mail.

0 coins

Yep. Mail from EDD is the definitive ask. Something in the portal inbox that says 'may' is not.

0 coins

been dealing with a wage verification hold on mine for three weeks now and no one at EDD can tell me anything useful through the online system. just getting generic status messages. at some point you have to actually talk to a person

0 coins

three weeks of generic messages is EDD doing what EDD does. the phone line isn't much better if you can't get through, I've spent whole mornings on that thing

0 coins

yeah I tried calling twice this week and both times got the recording that says high call volume and ends it. not even put on hold, just ended

0 coins

that's the worst version, at least being on hold means you're in the queue. getting cut off means you have to start the whole thing over

0 coins

update on this would be good. did you figure out if it was the wrong inbox or an actual documentation request?

0 coins

looked into it last night. it was the myEDD general inbox and the sender was not SDI, it was something else entirely. I think this whole thing might have been unrelated to my disability claim.

0 coins

that is such a relief to read. the portal inbox confusion is so real, I've had the same panic over messages that turned out to be nothing

0 coins

Please do check with your provider's office to confirm the medical certification came in under your current receipt number just to be thorough. With that confirmed and the inbox mystery solved, your claim should be on track.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure