Back to California Disability

Amara Nwosu

SDI automated message says not eligible before receiving letter — what does that mean?

So I called the SDI line to check on my claim status and the automated message says not eligible before receiving letter and I didn't even know what that meant at first. No letter has shown up yet, nothing in the mail, and SDI Online just shows the claim as pending still. I filed about three weeks ago for a back issue that my doctor certified and I thought everything was in order. Now I'm panicking a little because I have no idea if this is a denial or just some intermediate status thing. Has anyone else heard that message and then had it work out okay? Or does that message basically mean I'm denied?

The DE 2525XX my doctor submitted got processed a little late because his office mixed up the receipt numbers, and the automated line was giving me odd status messages the whole time I was waiting. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach someone at the disability office, and they pulled up my extension request and confirmed EDD had received it and assigned it to my claim. Video on getting a live person on EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent told me the form was matched and my continued benefits period would start from the date the form showed on the claim, which was reassuring because I'd been worried the late receipt number mix-up would void the whole extension.

0 coins

Tried that line 11 times across three mornings last week, got a recording every single time that ended the call. How does Claimyr actually get a person when that keeps happening?

0 coins

Every call I'd made on my own hit the same wall, so I know exactly what you mean. Claimyr stays on the line with EDD in your place and your phone rings the moment a live agent picks up. Got through to someone and that was it.

0 coins

Added mine to Claimyr too and it worked! The agent checked and told me my payment method had been set to the debit card but that I still had the option to switch to direct deposit through SDI Online while my claim was active. Went right into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ to change it after the call!

0 coins

Alright, I'll give it a try. I need to ask about which weeks are still showing unpaid on mine anyway.

0 coins

Wait, so that automated message isn't necessarily a denial? I got the same one a few days ago and I've been terrified ever since. My claim is for a pregnancy complication and my doctor did submit everything. Does the letter always come after that message, or can the message just be wrong?

0 coins

That message means EDD has made a determination and a notice is on its way. It isn't always a denial. The notice, the DE 2517, will tell you what was decided and whether you can appeal.

0 coins

That is such a relief to hear. So I should just wait for the letter and read it carefully when it arrives?

0 coins

Read every line of the notice when it comes and check the date it was issued. EDD's rules give you 30 days from that date to file an appeal, using the DE 1000A form that comes with it, so don't set it aside.

0 coins

Noted, I'll open it right away. What if I disagree with what it says?

0 coins

The DE 1000A is the appeal form, and it comes attached to the determination notice. Fill it out and send it to the return address on the notice itself, with a written explanation of why you disagree. File within those 30 days.

0 coins

That automated message drove me up the wall when I heard it. EDD couldn't just say 'letter is coming' like a normal system. I spent two days redialing thinking I'd done something wrong before anyone told me what it actually meant.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me. Heard it, assumed denied, stressed out for a week for nothing.

0 coins

Nobody warns you about how cryptic that system is. You're already dealing with being out of work and then you get mystery messages.

0 coins

EDD phone automation has always been its own genre of frustrating. Par for the course.

0 coins

Went through this last spring with a shoulder repair. That message showed up on the automated line before any letter hit my mailbox. Letter came four days later and it was just the Notice of Computation, not a denial. Yours may be the same thing.

0 coins

Really glad to hear that. Four days is way better than what I was imagining.

0 coins

Don't read too much into the automated message. Wait for the actual letter, then you'll know what you're dealing with.

0 coins

My notice came in about a week after I heard that message. It was fine.

0 coins

Worth clarifying something I got wrong myself at first: the Notice of Computation is not an approval, it just shows your potential weekly and maximum benefit amounts. The actual eligibility decision is a separate thing. Heard that message, got the NoC, assumed I was approved, then got a DE 2517 denial notice two days later because my medical certification had an error. Always read whatever the letter actually says.

0 coins

Wait, so you can get the Notice of Computation AND still get denied afterward?

0 coins

Yes, that caught me completely off guard too. The NoC is just the calculation of what you'd get if approved. The determination is separate. If EDD finds a problem with the claim, the DE 2517 comes later.

0 coins

I didn't know that either. I thought the computation notice meant it was approved for sure. Good to know the difference before I assume anything about my own claim.

0 coins

Pending on SDI Online still and the automated line just gave me that same not eligible message. My claim start date in the system looks wrong to me, it's showing a date that's two days after I actually stopped working. Used Claimyr to reach someone at EDD to check, and the agent confirmed the start date on the system and said it was based on when my doctor certified the disability, not exactly when I stopped working. That cleared it up for me even though I'd been panicking about whether the wrong start date would affect my waiting period count.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I've seen it mentioned and I'm not sure what it does.

0 coins

You put in your info and it stays on hold with EDD's disability line for you. When someone there picks up, your phone rings and you're talking to the agent. That's basically it. I'd probably still be redialing otherwise.

0 coins

My claim has a weird eligibility quarter issue I need to sort out. Might try it for that because I've been redialing for three days with nothing.

0 coins

my claim had that message for like five days and then a letter showed up and it was totally fine, just the computation notice. dont panic yet

0 coins

Five days I can handle. Thank you.

0 coins

yeah it felt way longer at the time but it was fine

0 coins

The DE 2517 is the notice that actually spells out a denial or conditional approval. If what arrives in the mail is the DE 429D, that is the Notice of Computation and it means EDD calculated your benefit amount. Two different notices, two different things.

0 coins

So I need to look at which form number is on the envelope or at the top of the letter?

0 coins

The form number is at the top of the document itself. DE 429D is the computation, DE 2517 is the determination. Know which one you're holding before you do anything.

0 coins

Wrote those down, thank you.

0 coins

Had a client in my chair last month going through this exact same thing, she kept describing that message and I had no idea what to tell her at the time. Coming back here now because I finally looked it up and it sounds like the safest thing is to just wait for the actual letter and then read it fast in case the 30 days to appeal starts ticking.

0 coins

That 30-day clock on the DE 2517 is real and it starts from the date printed on the notice itself, not the day it shows up in your mailbox.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the letter, got it. That's the part I didn't realize.

0 coins

Called the number three weeks in a row before anyone picked up. When I finally got through the agent told me my medical certification was in and matched. All that time wasted redialing and everything was fine.

0 coins

Three weeks of that is absolutely brutal. I did six days straight before giving up once.

0 coins

You just keep going back because you have no way to know if something's actually wrong.

0 coins

That's the worst part. No way to tell if the hold music means your claim is fine or on fire.

0 coins

Saw someone upthread mention the waiting period in connection with start dates. Just want to flag: the first seven days of a new claim are the unpaid waiting period. That's not EDD taking a week to process, it's just not a payable period by design. First payment covers day eight onward.

0 coins

Does pregnancy affect that waiting period? I'm trying to figure out if the same rule applies to my maternity claim.

0 coins

Same rule applies: seven unpaid days at the start of the claim, whether it's pregnancy or any other condition. After day seven, the payable period starts.

0 coins

EDD lays that out clearly: the waiting period is the first seven days of every new DI claim. No exceptions based on condition type.

0 coins

heard that message two weeks ago. letter still hasnt come. starting to wonder if it got lost

0 coins

Two weeks without a letter is worth following up on. Try the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online through myEDD, or use Ask EDD to check the status without waiting on the phone line.

0 coins

didnt know ask edd was an option. trying that today

0 coins

Ask EDD is good for exactly this, a status question that doesn't need a live person right away.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my claim showed up and I had no idea what the weekly amount was based on. Used Claimyr to reach someone at EDD and the agent told me which quarter of my base period they'd used to calculate it and what that quarter's wages were showing in their system. It matched my own records so at least I knew the number wasn't a mistake.

0 coins

Used Claimyr for mine too and it was such a relief, lol. Agent pulled up my claim and told me a Notice of Determination had been issued and what date it went out. Hadn't even hit my mailbox yet so at least I knew to watch for it.

0 coins

Did they say what was on the determination, or just that it was sent?

0 coins

Just that it had been sent on a specific date and that I'd need to read it and appeal within 30 days if I disagreed with what it said. Didn't tell me the actual decision, just the date and the form name.

0 coins

Something I wish someone had told me: mail from EDD can take longer in some zip codes. Heard that message on a Tuesday, letter didn't arrive until the following Thursday. Almost filed an online inquiry before it showed up.

0 coins

Good to know. I'll give it at least a week before I do anything.

0 coins

A week is reasonable. If nothing comes by then, the SDI Online message option is a solid next step.

0 coins

My claim was for a mental health condition and I wasn't sure if my therapist could certify it. Turns out a licensed psychologist can certify, but I had to double check that my provider held the right license. If someone is in a similar situation, the provider does need to be one of the specific types EDD lists.

0 coins

Is a physical therapist on that list? My PT suggested she could fill out the form.

0 coins

I'm not sure about PT, I'd double check that before having her submit anything.

0 coins

A physical therapist is not on EDD's list of providers who can certify a disability claim. It needs to be a licensed physician, nurse practitioner, physician assistant, psychologist, chiropractor, podiatrist, optometrist, dentist, or licensed midwife for pregnancy-related conditions, among others EDD specifies. A PT cannot certify it.

0 coins

Okay, I need to get my OB to do it then. Thank you for the correction.

0 coins

Took three attempts at filling out Part A before SDI Online accepted mine. Each time I'd miss saving something and have to start over. When the certification finally matched and payments showed, I'd almost forgotten what it felt like to expect good news.

0 coins

Part A gave me trouble too. Did not realize the receipt number you get at the end is what you give your doctor.

0 coins

That receipt number is the whole link between your part and theirs. Without it your doctor can't find the claim in the system.

0 coins

I told my OB's office the receipt number before they even asked. They said most patients don't know to give it and it slows everything down.

0 coins

Does anyone know if you can still get paid while appealing a determination? Asking because if I get a denial letter I can't just go without income while EDD takes its time reviewing.

0 coins

Filing the appeal doesn't automatically restart payments. The appeal goes to a hearing and an administrative law judge decides. Keep all your records and your pay stubs in the meantime.

0 coins

So there's no payment while the appeal is pending? That's rough.

0 coins

Correct. No automatic payment during the appeal. That's why getting the appeal in quickly and completely is important, the 30 days go by fast.

0 coins

My sister told me to file for Paid Family Leave while waiting on my disability decision and I almost did it! Glad I didn't because they're completely separate. DI is for when you personally can't work, PFL is for bonding with a baby or caring for a family member. You can't claim both for the same days.

0 coins

Good catch. You'd file PFL after your DI claim ends if you're bonding with a newborn, not at the same time. Different program, different claim.

0 coins

My doctor actually mentioned it too so I'm glad someone set me straight before I confused EDD with two claims at once!

0 coins

Automated messages from EDD are designed to give you no useful information. Truly a masterpiece of ambiguity.

0 coins

Years of practice.

0 coins

They've refined it.

0 coins

Letter came today. It was the Notice of Computation, DE 429D. No denial. I feel like I can breathe again. Thank you all for talking me down off the ledge this week.

0 coins

Keep an eye out for payments starting after your seven-day waiting period. Good outcome.

0 coins

About time you got some good news. Keep tabs on your SDI Online account too.

0 coins

told you it would be fine lol

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure