Resident working out of state, no SDI deducted from paycheck — can I still file?
So I've been working remotely for a California company for the past two years, but I live in another state. My pay stubs have never shown any SDI deduction at all, not a single pay period. Now I'm dealing with a back injury and my doctor says I need at least six weeks off. I tried to look into filing a disability claim through California EDD but I'm not sure I even qualify if nothing was ever withheld. Did my employer just not set this up right? Is there any way to still get benefits, or am I basically out of luck? I don't even know where to start with this.
83 comments

Nolan Carter
Waiting period on my claim tripped me up more than I expected, so I ended up phoning EDD directly. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live agent on the line since I'd been disconnecting all morning. Video on reaching someone at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent confirmed the first seven days of the claim are a non-payable waiting period, not processing lag, so the eighth day is actually the first day any payment can cover. Cleared up a lot of confusion on my end.
0 coins
Natalia Stone
The waiting period piece is exactly what threw me off too, and I'd used Claimyr for a question about a payment date on my claim. Agent pulled up my record and told me the payment had been issued on a specific date and to check SDI Online for the deposit details. Ended up sorting it out same afternoon.
0 coins
Tasia Synder
How many mornings did you spend trying that line before you got through? I've redialed from 8 a.m. and gotten a recording that just ends the call. Every single time.
0 coins
Natalia Stone
Three separate mornings for me before I tried a different approach. The recording thing is brutal.
0 coins
Selena Bautista
The SDI deduction on a California paycheck, the CASDI line, is what funds the claim. If your pay stubs show no CASDI withheld at all across two years, that is the core issue. Whether your employer should have been deducting it depends on how your work arrangement is classified under California law, which is a question for your employer's payroll department first, and possibly EDD if the employer hasn't been remitting correctly.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorSo if my employer just never set it up, does that mean I personally can't file, or would it be EDD going after the employer?
0 coins
Selena Bautista
EDD handles employer compliance separately from a claimant's own situation. Worth asking your HR or payroll exactly why the CASDI line is absent, and then contacting EDD directly to ask how your specific case is treated.
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
This is making me nervous for a friend who works remotely for a CA company. Not sure how to even check if the right deduction is being taken.
0 coins
Selena Bautista
The CASDI line should appear on every California SDI-covered pay stub. If it's not there, that is worth raising with payroll sooner rather than later.
0 coins
Ellie Perry
No CASDI on the stub, no SDI base period wages. That's the short version. The base period needs at least $300 in wages that had SDI taken out. Without that you've got nothing to draw from.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorThat $300 threshold, is that just one quarter or the whole base period added up?
0 coins
Ellie Perry
Total across the base period as far as I know, but your Notice of Computation will spell it out when EDD runs the numbers.
0 coins
Landon Morgan
EDD's published rule is at least $300 in wages subject to SDI in the base period overall. The Notice of Computation shows what they actually used, so that's the document to watch for.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
There's a distinction worth flagging here. Working remotely for a California employer doesn't automatically make you subject to California's SDI withholding. Your state of residence and the tax nexus your employer has set up for you can affect which state's payroll taxes apply. It's genuinely unclear without knowing more, and that's a question for a tax professional or your employer's payroll team, not just EDD.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorMy W-2 shows my home state taxes, not California taxes, so I think they set me up as a resident of my home state. Does that mean California EDD would just say I'm not covered at all?
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
That's consistent with what I'd expect if they're running payroll in your home state. California EDD disability coverage depends on CASDI being withheld. Without it, filing a California SDI claim doesn't have a foundation to stand on.
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
My wife had a similar remote setup and HR had it wrong for over a year, anyway she only found out when she tried to file.
0 coins
Bruno Simmons
Before you do anything else, pull every pay stub from the past couple of years and confirm there's truly no CASDI line anywhere. Some employers list it differently or bundle deductions. If it really is absent across the board, you have a payroll issue to resolve before EDD can do much for your claim.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorChecked again, every stub. There's a state income tax line for my home state but nothing that says CASDI or SDI at all.
0 coins
Bruno Simmons
Then it sounds like your employer set up payroll under your home state, not California. Worth a direct conversation with HR in writing so there's a record of what you asked and what they said.
0 coins
Aileen Rodriguez
Same situation two years ago. HR had no idea until I pointed it out.
0 coins
Zane Gray
From a payroll standpoint, the CASDI deduction should appear as a separate line item if California SDI coverage applies. If your W-2 shows only your home state's withholding and no California wages, EDD's base period calculation would have no California SDI-subject wages to work with. The base period covers wages from roughly 5 to 18 months before the claim start date, pulled from four quarters.
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
If wages weren't reported to California at all during that base period, would filing in SDI Online even be possible, or does the system just reject it?
0 coins
Zane Gray
SDI Online would let you file, but EDD's review would likely find no qualifying wages, and you'd receive a Notice of Determination explaining the outcome. You'd have 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal if you believe there's an error.
0 coins
Landon Morgan
The appeal form is the DE 1000A, it comes with the Notice of Determination. Keep the envelope because the postmark date matters.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
Quarter used for my base period was something I actually had to call EDD about because SDI Online wasn't showing what I expected. Tried the disability line on my own for four mornings straight and kept hitting the same recording. Ended up getting through to an agent using Claimyr and they looked up which quarter EDD pulled as my highest-paid period. Confirmed the right one was being used, so my weekly amount matched what the Notice of Computation had shown.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Four mornings and nothing? I've had the same thing happen and I find it hard to believe anything actually reaches a live person on that line. How is this even a real service?
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
Honestly I had the same thought. Tried it anyway because I was out of options and the agent I spoke with knew exactly which quarter was flagged and read it back to me. Person worked for EDD, not some outside company.
0 coins
Monique Byrd
ive been trying that line for two weeks and gotten through zero times so hearing someone actually talked to a person is wild to me
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Alright, I'll take that at face value. My own issue is a question about which weeks EDD marked as paid, which is different from yours. Might give it a shot.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
Employer set up payroll in your home state, so that's where your wages live. EDD can't pay benefits on wages that were never subject to CASDI. That's the whole mechanism.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorIs there any path at all, like filing in my home state's disability program instead?
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
Depends on your state. Some states have their own programs, some don't. That's outside EDD's territory.
0 coins
Selena Bautista
Exactly right. Each state runs its own program. EDD handles California SDI only. Your home state's labor or employment agency would be the place to ask about coverage where you live.
0 coins
Tasia Synder
Two years of no CASDI and your employer never caught it. Classic. Even if you could file, the base period wages just aren't there to calculate a benefit amount from. The EDD calculator on their site is worth running just to see what happens when California SDI wages are zero.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorI ran the calculator with zero California wages and it did come back with nothing. So that confirms it I guess.
0 coins
Tasia Synder
Yeah that's your answer right there. The machine doesn't lie about the math.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Does your employer have any kind of short-term disability insurance as a separate benefit? Some companies carry a private plan that's separate from state SDI, especially for employees not covered by a state program.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorI actually don't know. I've never really looked at the full benefits package closely. I'll check the employee handbook.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Worth a look. HR should be able to tell you in one email whether there's a voluntary or employer-paid disability policy in place.
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
My employer had something like that, wasn't much but it covered part of the gap, anyway check with HR before you assume there's nothing.
0 coins
Monique Byrd
if ur employer never took out casdi and never reported your wages to california edd theres no claim to file, like the whole thing runs on what was withheld
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
What if the employer was supposed to deduct it and just didn't? Does the employee get penalized for the employer's mistake?
0 coins
Selena Bautista
EDD has a process for employer compliance issues, and in some cases wages that should have been subject to SDI can be treated as covered even if the deduction was missed. That's a situation to raise directly with EDD, not something to assume goes one way or the other.
0 coins
Monique Byrd
yeah ok fair i didnt know that part
0 coins
Lia Quinn
Medical certification had a matching issue on my claim that I had to clear up by phoning EDD. My surgeon's office submitted it but it wasn't showing as received on my claim, so I used Claimyr to reach an agent. Agent confirmed the certification was in their system but the receipt number on the form didn't match what I'd filed under. Gave the office the correct number and they resubmitted.
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
I used Claimyr too and was relieved to actually talk to someone. The DE 2593 was sitting on my list of things to ask about and the agent told me I had 20 days from when EDD sent it to return it or I'd lose benefits. Sent it out the same day I got off the phone.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorDE 2593, what is that form for?
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
EDD sends it after about five automatic payments, ten weeks in. It asks whether you're still unable to work. The agent told me to return it within 20 days.
0 coins
Landon Morgan
49 days from the disability start date is the deadline to file, and also the deadline for the medical certification to be submitted. If wages turn out to be covered and you do have a path to file, don't let the clock run past that point.
0 coins
Daniel White
Author49 days total from when the disability started, not from when I file my part?
0 coins
Landon Morgan
Both deadlines run from the disability start date. Your part and your doctor's certification each have to be in within 49 days of that date. File your part first, then give the receipt number to your provider so they can submit the medical certification.
0 coins
Bruno Simmons
The receipt number piece is easy to miss. SDI Online gives it to you after you file, and your doctor's office needs it to find your claim and submit their part.
0 coins
Haley Stokes
Payment method question on my claim kept me going in circles until I called EDD directly. Getting through on my own took forever so I tried Claimyr and an agent picked up. Told me my payments were set to go to a Money Network card and explained I could switch to direct deposit through SDI Online since I'd filed online. Switched it right then.
0 coins
Zane Gray
What exactly is Claimyr? Haven't heard of it.
0 coins
Haley Stokes
You hand off the hold time, and when a live EDD agent picks up the line, your phone rings so you're the one actually in the conversation. That's the whole thing.
0 coins
Zane Gray
Useful to know. I've got a question about my base period quarter that I keep putting off because the hold times scare me. Might be worth trying for that.
0 coins
Asher Levin
worth checking if your employer has an accountant who mislabeled your work state at setup. happens more than people think with remote hires.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorHR told me they set me up in my home state from day one because I never lived in California. So it was intentional, just maybe wrong for my situation.
0 coins
Asher Levin
if the job is fully remote and always has been, their tax person probably made a judgment call. a payroll attorney might be worth a consult to see if california had any claim on those wages.
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
Wrote HR a pretty direct email yesterday asking why no CASDI on two years of stubs, anyway they said it was set up correctly for my home state. Still waiting to hear if that was actually the right call for a CA-based employer.
0 coins
Selena Bautista
Get their response in writing and ask them to point to the specific guidance they relied on. That paper trail matters if you later need to dispute it.
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
Good call, I followed up and asked them to send me the documentation they used to make that determination.
0 coins
Aileen Rodriguez
Had a similar payroll gap discovered during a claim. EDD's answer was to contact the employer and sort out the coverage question before filing.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorDid EDD ever end up recognizing the wages for you, or did it just fall through?
0 coins
Aileen Rodriguez
In my case the employer confirmed it was their error and corrected the records. EDD processed the claim after that. Took extra time but it worked out.
0 coins
Bruno Simmons
That's good to know. So it isn't necessarily a dead end if the employer is willing to correct the classification.
0 coins
Natalia Stone
If EDD does review your claim and find no qualifying wages, you'll get a Notice of Determination with the reason spelled out. Appeal within 30 days of the date on that notice using the DE 1000A that comes with it. Keep a copy of everything you send.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorIs there a different form if I lost the DE 1000A?
0 coins
Natalia Stone
EDD says you can send a detailed letter instead of the form if the form is lost, mailed to the return address on the notice. Explain why you're appealing and include your claim information.
0 coins
Landon Morgan
Also note the date on the notice itself, not the date you receive it. The 30-day window runs from that printed date.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
Worth filing through SDI Online anyway if you think there's any chance your wages were subject to CASDI. At least nine days after the disability starts and before 49 days are up. You need to file your part first, get the receipt number, give it to your doctor, and they submit the medical certification within that same 49-day window. If EDD finds no qualifying wages they'll send the determination and you can respond then.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorSo filing doesn't hurt me if it turns out I don't qualify? It won't create some penalty?
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
Filing and not qualifying gets you a determination you can appeal. It doesn't penalize you for trying. The worst case is a denial.
0 coins
Ellie Perry
Don't wait around while you sort out the employer question. File before the 49 days are up and let EDD make the call.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Has anyone had EDD actually find that wages should have been covered when CASDI wasn't withheld? Curious whether that's a real outcome or just theoretical.
0 coins
Aileen Rodriguez
Real outcome in at least one case I know of firsthand, mine. Employer acknowledged the deduction should have been taken and EDD processed from there.
0 coins
Zane Gray
EDD has an employer compliance process for exactly that situation. It's not automatic, but it's not purely theoretical either.
0 coins
Nolan Carter
Employer acknowledging the error is the key step. Without that, it stalls.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
One more thing worth knowing: unemployment and disability can't cover the same days. If you're unable to work you'd be on disability, not unemployment, and EDD decides which applies. Don't file for both for the same period.
0 coins
Daniel White
AuthorI wasn't going to file for unemployment since I'm actually hurt and can't work. Just wanted to make sure I understood the difference.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
Makes sense. Unemployment requires being able and available to work every week you claim it, so if your doctor has you off work, disability is the right lane.
0 coins
Mohamed Anderson
I mixed those two up at first too. Took me a while to understand they're completely separate programs with different requirements.
0 coins