Back to California Disability

Lily Young

Private disability employee — does California EDD SDI still apply to me?

Okay so I work for a company that offers its own private disability coverage through our benefits package, and I've been trying to figure out whether California EDD's SDI program even covers me or if I'm supposed to go through the company's private plan instead. I had a procedure done a few weeks ago and I'm going to be out for at least six weeks total. HR gave me paperwork for the company disability plan but I also see CASDI deductions on every single paycheck, so I know I've been paying into the state program too. Now I'm confused about which one I'm actually supposed to file with, or if both are even an option. Has anyone dealt with this when their employer has their own coverage? I don't want to file with the wrong one and mess up my payments while I'm already dealing with recovery.

The CASDI deduction on your stub is what matters first — if that's there, you've been contributing to California's SDI program and you're generally covered under it. Some employers run what's called a Voluntary Plan, which is a state-approved private alternative to the EDD program, and in those cases your CASDI line might look different or your HR would have specifically told you that SDI is handled through the private insurer. If your stub still shows CASDI going to the state, your best starting point is filing with EDD directly on SDI Online. Talk to HR and ask them point blank whether you're under EDD or a Voluntary Plan — that one question will clear up everything.

0 coins

HR actually confirmed it's a Voluntary Plan, which I hadn't heard of before. So does that mean I skip EDD entirely and just deal with the private insurer?

0 coins

With a Voluntary Plan your employer's carrier handles the claim, not EDD. Your employer is required to give you the same level of benefits as the state program at minimum. The private insurer runs its own process so you'd follow whatever forms and timelines they give you. If you have problems with how the carrier handles your claim, that's where it gets complicated and you'd want to look into your rights separately — EDD's site has some information on Voluntary Plans but the actual claim goes through the carrier, not SDI Online.

0 coins

wait so the state deductions on the paycheck dont automatically mean EDD is handling your claim? I always assumed the CASDI line just went straight to EDD no matter what

0 coins

Not always. Under a Voluntary Plan the deductions still appear on your stub and the funds go to the approved private carrier rather than EDD directly. It's a state-authorized swap, not an extra layer on top of EDD.

0 coins

Went through something similar last year when I was out after my back surgery. Had been paying CASDI for years and just assumed EDD would handle everything, but my company was also pushing me toward their short-term disability product. I called HR and asked which system my specific deductions were enrolled in and that was the fastest way to get a straight answer. For what it's worth, being under straight EDD SDI meant I filed on SDI Online, got a receipt number, gave it to my doctor's office, and they submitted the medical certification from their end. Everything ran through EDD after that.

0 coins

My HR confirmed Voluntary Plan after I asked the direct question. But my doctor already knows about SDI Online from another patient's claim — does that process change for a Voluntary Plan or does the doctor do something different?

0 coins

For a Voluntary Plan the carrier usually has its own certification form or portal, so your doctor would submit to them, not through SDI Online. Worth calling the carrier's number and asking what they need from the treating provider before the doctor's office submits anything.

0 coins

My company had a voluntary plan too and the doctor had to fill out a totally different form. The carrier mailed it to me and I brought it to the office myself. Definitely don't assume SDI Online works the same way.

0 coins

DE 2500E came in with what I thought was my final notice, but the actual deposit date shown in SDI Online was three days later than the letter said it would arrive. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get to someone on EDD's disability line after the hold music cut out on me twice — their video on reaching a live person at the EDD disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the payment had issued on the date SDI Online showed, and that the letter date and the deposit date don't always land the same day. Got the deposit sorted out the same afternoon.

0 coins

The phone line cutting out is exactly what I was afraid of if I ended up needing to call EDD. Good to know that option exists before I hit a wall.

0 coins

Payment method question on my end too — went to EDD's site and confirmed the card is now Money Network, not Bank of America, in case anyone still has the old one floating around.

0 coins

The Money Network card thing tripped me up at first too. My payment info all showed correctly once the deposit actually posted.

0 coins

The piece about CASDI deductions that tripped me up — I always thought I was paying into EDD and that was that. Never knew there was a Voluntary Plan setup some employers use. My current company is straight EDD and I had a claim last spring for a wrist issue. Filed on SDI Online, got my receipt number right on the confirmation screen, and the medical certification from my doctor came in within a week. The notice showing my potential weekly amount came in the mail shortly after. The waiting period was something I misread at first — I thought those seven days were EDD processing time, not an actual non-payable stretch built into every new claim.

0 coins

The waiting period confusion is so real. I thought my claim was stuck in review during those first seven days and was about to call EDD. Turns out EDD was just doing what it's supposed to.

0 coins

Exactly. The first payable day is the eighth day of disability, which is spelled out in the SDI rules. Those seven days aren't a glitch or a delay, they're just not covered under a new claim.

0 coins

Does the waiting period apply to Voluntary Plans too or is that just an EDD thing?

0 coins

For EDD SDI the waiting period is baked into how the program works — Voluntary Plans have to meet at least the same standard as EDD, but the specific terms can vary. Best to check your carrier's summary of benefits for that one.

0 coins

Probably worth flagging that if your Voluntary Plan carrier denies your claim or handles it in a way that feels off, the appeals path is different from EDD's. With EDD you have a Notice of Determination and an Appeal Form with a 30-day window. With a carrier, the dispute process is on them and would depend on how the plan is set up. HR should have a summary plan document that explains the process.

0 coins

Hadn't even thought about what happens if the carrier denies it. So with EDD the appeal window is 30 days from the notice date?

0 coins

Thirty days from the date on the notice itself, yes. The notice comes with an Appeal Form attached. If you lose the form you can write a detailed letter instead, but you'd need to send it to the return address on that notice. Missing that window makes things harder — you'd have to explain the delay to a judge.

0 coins

The 30-day window goes fast. When I got my denial notice I almost missed it because I thought I had 30 days from when I received it, not from the date printed on the form.

0 coins

Slight correction to something mentioned earlier — a physical therapist can't certify a disability claim for EDD. Had a friend assume their PT could do it and they almost missed the 49-day window waiting for a form that couldn't count. EDD's list of who can certify is physicians, osteopathic doctors, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and licensed midwives for pregnancy-related stuff. The claim needs to come from someone on that list.

0 coins

Genuinely did not know that about PTs. My PT knows my injury better than anyone at this point.

0 coins

PTs are great for the actual treatment side but EDD needs the certification from someone whose license is on their approved list. Your treating physician can certify even if the PT is running the day-to-day recovery sessions.

0 coins

Worth double-checking if your doctor already submitted — SDI Online would show whether EDD received it. If the certification hasn't come in, the receipt number your doctor needs is the one you got when you filed your claim.

0 coins

DE 2593 landed in my mailbox after my tenth week on automatic payments and I almost didn't send it back in time. Had three days left in the 20-day window when I finally opened the envelope. Used the EDD disability line through Claimyr after the form confused me on one of the questions — the agent looked at my claim and confirmed which weeks were still pending and what the form was asking me to certify. Sent it back the next day.

0 coins

Twenty days is not a lot of time if you're dealing with a recovery and not checking your mail every day. Good heads-up on that form.

0 coins

The form comes around the five-month mark if you're on automatic payments — EDD sends it after every five two-week payment cycles. Missing the 20-day return window apparently stops benefits, so it's worth watching for.

0 coins

Does that form go out for everyone on disability after a certain point or just some people?

0 coins

Automatic payments trigger it after those ten weeks. If you're not on automatic payment you'd already be certifying every two weeks with a different form, so the DE 2593 is specifically the automatic-payment check-in.

0 coins

One thing that happened on my own claim that might be useful here — I filed SDI Online and my surgeon's office said they submitted the medical certification, but EDD showed no record of it for over a week. Turned out the office had the wrong receipt number. The receipt number you get right after filing is what the doctor's office needs to find your claim in SDI Online; without it matching up, their submission goes nowhere.

0 coins

SDI Online shows that receipt number after you submit Part A, right? I want to make sure I'm saving the right thing if I end up needing to file directly with EDD someday.

0 coins

Yes, it shows up on the confirmation screen right after you submit. Screenshot it or write it down before you close the page. That number is how your provider locates your specific claim to attach the certification.

0 coins

My doctor's office lost mine the first time and I had to log back into SDI Online to find it again. It's visible in your claim details after you file so you can always retrieve it.

0 coins

The pregnancy side of this is a little different and might be relevant if that ever comes up in this thread — with SDI you can typically start your claim about four weeks before your due date even before the birth. After delivery it's usually six weeks for a regular birth or eight for a cesarean. The bonding after that is Paid Family Leave, which is a completely separate claim from SDI. PFL doesn't have a waiting period the way DI does.

0 coins

PFL and SDI kept blending together in my head when my wife was going through her claim. The pregnancy disability part goes through SDI, then bonding goes through PFL after that.

0 coins

Exactly right. The disability claim for the pregnancy itself closes out and then a separate PFL claim picks up for bonding. Two separate filings.

0 coins

Is the PFL bonding always eight weeks? I thought I heard it was more than that now.

0 coins

The bonding period under PFL is typically up to eight weeks — the EDD site has the current numbers and they can vary based on your situation. Check there rather than taking a fixed number from a forum.

0 coins

Can I ask about the base period and how the weekly amount gets calculated? I looked at the Notice of Computation when I got mine and I couldn't figure out how they picked which quarter my wages came from. My highest earning quarter was actually the most recent one but EDD didn't use it.

0 coins

The base period looks at a 12-month stretch that ended about five to eighteen months before your claim started — it's not the most recent quarter you worked. So if you just started a claim, the last few months before it might not be in your base period at all. That's why higher recent earnings sometimes don't show up.

0 coins

That explains it. My pay went up in the last two quarters and neither of them counted. So the number on my Notice of Computation is based on older wages.

0 coins

The benefit amount is estimated from the highest-paid quarter inside that base period, then EDD applies a percentage based on how much you earned. The calculator on EDD's site will give you a rough picture before your notice comes in.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in and the denial reason made no sense to me based on what I'd submitted. Had a question about whether the agent could tell me anything specific, so I got through to EDD's disability line using Claimyr. The agent confirmed the notice date and told me the Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, was already attached — thirty days from that notice date was my window, and they noted it was still open. Filed the appeal with the form and a detailed letter the same week.

0 coins

DE 1000A attached to the denial notice — I didn't realize EDD sends the form with the denial itself. Had a panic moment thinking I'd need to track down a separate form.

0 coins

It comes attached. If you can't find it, EDD says you can write a detailed letter instead and mail it to the address on the notice. Same 30-day clock applies either way.

0 coins

What counts as detailed enough in the letter? I'm in that situation now and trying to figure out how much to write.

0 coins

Explain what happened with your claim, why you believe the denial was wrong, and reference anything you submitted that supports your position — dates, the medical certification, any forms you sent back. The more specific the better. An administrative law judge reviews late appeals too if you miss the window and have a reason for the delay, but staying inside the 30 days is much simpler.

0 coins

Something that helped me sort out the SDI vs. unemployment confusion early on — if you're still unable to do your regular work, unemployment isn't the right claim. Unemployment requires you to be able and available to work every week you certify. DI is the right track when you're physically out and can't work yet. The two don't overlap for the same days.

0 coins

Tried to figure out if I could file unemployment after getting laid off while still on DI. Ended up being told that DI covers the days I can't work and unemployment would apply once I'm able and available again.

0 coins

That's the right read. File for unemployment when you're actually cleared to return — EDD handles each claim separately and decides based on your situation.

0 coins

Workers' comp is a whole other thing too right? Heard someone say SDI and workers comp can run at the same time.

0 coins

Workers' comp is for injuries on the job. EDD itself says it's not common to get both SDI and workers' comp simultaneously, though there can be exceptions. If you have a work injury, the starting point is your employer's workers' comp process, not SDI.

0 coins

Filing timeline got me anxious when I first read about it — the 49-day window from when your disability starts is the outer limit to file your claim and also the deadline for the doctor to get the medical certification in. If the certification is late it can affect your claim. Nine days after disability starts is the earliest you can file. It's worth getting that doctor's office moving quickly on their end.

0 coins

My doctor's office said they'd handle it and then didn't for two weeks. I had to go back in person and confirm they'd actually submitted through SDI Online with the correct receipt number.

0 coins

Offices that deal with this regularly are usually faster but it's still on you to follow up. After the certification is received, EDD typically contacts you about your claim status within about two weeks.

0 coins

Does EDD send something to confirm they received the certification or do you just check SDI Online?

0 coins

SDI Online updates when the certification is received. Watching the status there is the easiest way to know it went through, and EDD will also follow up about your claim status once everything is in.

0 coins

My claim was sitting pending for about three weeks longer than expected and I kept checking SDI Online every day. Eventually got a Notice of Computation in the mail which showed the potential weekly amount but not an actual approval — I had to look that up because I thought the notice meant I was approved.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is not an approval, it just shows what your weekly benefit could be if the claim is approved. Actual payment is a separate step.

0 coins

Wish someone had told me that upfront. I stopped worrying when I got the notice and then wondered why no payment came.

0 coins

The pending status had me spiraling too. Mine flipped one day without warning and the first payment just appeared.

0 coins

Extensions came up in my claim when my recovery took longer than the doctor originally estimated. My doctor submitted the Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate to extend the period — I didn't file a new claim. EDD sent the extension form with the final payment notice, and my doctor filled it out from there.

0 coins

DE 2525XX is that form, right? My doctor's office had never heard of it.

0 coins

That's the one. If the office hasn't dealt with it before, it helps to let them know EDD sends it with the final payment notice — the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification — and that the provider needs to complete and submit it.

0 coins

Good to know extensions work this way in case my recovery runs longer than my doctor initially estimated. So no second claim, just the same claim extended through the doctor's form.

0 coins

Exactly. Same claim, same claim ID in SDI Online, just the treating provider extending the certified period with that form.

0 coins

Payment method was something I had to sort out before my first deposit hit. Direct deposit is available on SDI Online claims — you set it up there. Otherwise EDD sends a Money Network prepaid debit card. Had heard rumors about a Bank of America card but that's not EDD's card anymore.

0 coins

Saw someone at my office confused about the Bank of America thing. The Money Network card is what EDD sends now.

0 coins

Payment info can also be checked through the automated line, 1-800-480-3287, without needing to reach a live agent if you just want to verify what posted.

0 coins

Part-time return to work is something nobody explained to me until I was already doing it — reported my hours to EDD and my payment that week was adjusted. How exactly a partial week gets calculated is EDD's call and can vary by what you earned, so just report accurately and don't try to predict the amount yourself.

0 coins

Good reminder. I tried to do the math myself and was completely wrong. Just report and let EDD determine the amount.

0 coins

Accurate reporting is the main thing — EDD handles the calculation and an overpayment notice later is a lot worse than a smaller payment now.

0 coins

Got an overpayment notice after going back to part-time and panicked. Had all my pay stubs and what I'd reported, and the notice itself. Appealed within the 30-day window and had everything documented.

0 coins

California doesn't tax SDI benefits at the state level — that one I'm pretty sure about. Federal is different and depends on your situation. EDD has tax information on its site and a tax professional is the right person to ask if your specific situation is complicated.

0 coins

State side is straightforward. Federal side has more nuance and EDD's tax info page covers the basics, but yeah, a tax professional for anything specific.

0 coins

Just wanted to flag it because someone earlier was asking about what they'd actually take home and I didn't want them thinking the state was going to cut into it.

0 coins

SDI Online is in myEDD — worth mentioning because I spent an embarrassing amount of time looking for a separate SDI website when I first filed. You log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and open SDI Online from there. If you need to send a message to EDD outside of a phone call, there's also the Request Claim Update option inside SDI Online and the Ask EDD contact form on EDD's site.

0 coins

Ask EDD being a thing surprised me. I'd always assumed it was phone or nothing.

0 coins

Ask EDD, Request Claim Update in SDI Online, and the Office Locator on EDD's site for in-person help are all options. Phone is fastest for something urgent but the online options exist.

0 coins

EDD's disability phone number is 1-800-480-3287 for English and 1-866-658-8846 for Spanish in case anyone needs it. Staff are there 8 to 5 weekdays, and closed on state holidays.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure