Back to California Disability

Freya Larsen

Pay stub CASDI deduction and what it actually means for your SDI claim

Been staring at my pay stub trying to make sense of my SDI situation and figured someone here might know more than I do. I work in logistics and have been out since late October after a back procedure. Filed my claim through SDI Online and got the receipt number, my surgeon's office submitted the medical certification the following week. All that part seemed okay. But my coworker was looking at his pay stub and pointed out the CASDI deduction line and asked me what it was actually for — like what does paying into it mean for what I can actually collect now. Honestly I didn't have a great answer. I know the deduction funds the program but I'm fuzzy on how the amount I paid in connects to what I'll receive. My Notice of Computation came in the mail and it has a weekly benefit amount on it but I don't totally understand how they arrived at that number or what period of my earnings they looked at. Also wondering if the deduction rate on the stub has anything to do with the max payout. I've seen people throw around specific dollar figures online for the weekly maximum and I have no idea if those numbers are accurate or current. Anyone been through this recently and can explain how the pay stub connects to what SDI actually pays?

CASDI deduction sitting on my stub every two weeks was something I never thought about until my own claim started. Filed for a shoulder injury back in September, got my receipt number, and then the medical certification sat unmatched for almost three weeks before anything moved. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with an EDD agent — the agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the certification had come in but hadn't been linked to my receipt number yet, and told me what I needed my provider to do to fix it. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ On your actual question about the stub and the benefit amount: the CASDI deduction is what funds your eligibility, but the weekly amount you'll collect isn't tied to how much you personally paid in through that deduction. It's based on the wages you earned in a specific period before your claim. Your Notice of Computation is the real answer — whatever weekly figure it shows is what EDD calculated from your earnings history. The numbers floating around online for a weekly maximum are not always current, so I'd go off your notice rather than anything you read in a forum.

0 coins

The receipt number matching issue — did your provider have to refile from scratch or just update something on their end?

0 coins

Provider had to log back into SDI Online with the receipt number I gave them and resubmit. It was their end, not mine, and once they did it the status moved within a few days.

0 coins

Unmatched certifications seem to cause so many delays. Good to know the fix is on the provider's side and doesn't require refiling the whole claim.

0 coins

Your Notice of Computation is doing the work you're trying to do manually. The weekly benefit amount printed on that form is EDD's calculation — you don't need to reverse-engineer it from your stub. What EDD actually looks at is a twelve-month base period made up of four quarters, and your benefit is drawn from whichever of those quarters had your highest wages. If you worked steady in logistics with consistent pay, that number should reflect a solid quarter. The percentage EDD applies sits somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of your average weekly wage from that highest quarter, depending on your income level. EDD's disability benefits calculator on their site lets you plug in your wages and see an estimate, but honestly your notice already has the real figure so just use that.

0 coins

The base period piece is what I was missing. So they're looking back further than just the last few months before I went out?

0 coins

Correct — it's not the most recent months. The base period ends several months before your claim start date, which catches people off guard. If you had a gap in work or a lower-earning quarter in that window it can affect the number. Your notice should spell out the period they used.

0 coins

Worth noting the calculator on EDD's site gives an estimate, not a guarantee. The notice is the binding number.

0 coins

The CASDI line on the stub just means you're covered. Every California worker paying into it is building eligibility. When I went out for a knee surgery last year the thing I didn't understand was why my benefit felt lower than I expected — turns out EDD uses a base period that ends before the last few months, so my recent raise didn't count. The estimate I'd looked at online was based on wages from over a year before I went out.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of surprise I want to avoid. Did your Notice of Computation show you which quarter they pulled from?

0 coins

Yes, the notice listed the quarter and the wage amount EDD used. I'd read it carefully and compare it to your W-2 or paystubs from that period to make sure the wages match what you actually earned.

0 coins

The raise-not-counting situation happened to me too. Frustrating but at least the notice makes it clear so you know what you're working with.

0 coins

people keep sharing specific dollar amounts for the sdi weekly max in facebook groups and half of them are wrong or from a couple years ago, don't trust any number you see posted online. your notice of computation is the only number that matters for your claim, everyone's is different anyway based on their wages

0 coins

Accurate. The benefit amount is personal to your earnings history, not a flat rate everyone gets. Sharing a dollar figure helps nobody because yours will be different.

0 coins

exactly and then people freak out thinking they were shorted when really they just had lower wages in the base period

0 coins

Okay that makes me feel better about my number being different from what I saw posted somewhere. Sounds like I need to focus on my own notice rather than comparing.

0 coins

Waiting period question tripped me up when I was out for an illness earlier this year. The seven days at the start of the claim are a non-payable waiting period — meaning even if everything is filed perfectly and EDD has everything they need, those first seven days pay nothing. I thought my payment was late and kept expecting it to show up, and then I realized the waiting period pushed my first payable day to day eight. I phoned EDD to confirm which weeks were showing as my waiting period weeks versus my paid weeks, and I ended up getting through to an agent using Claimyr. The agent confirmed my waiting period dates and told me which week my first payment had been issued for — helped me stop watching for money that wasn't coming yet.

0 coins

Does the seven-day clock start from the date EDD receives your paperwork or from the date you stopped working?

0 coins

Starts from when your disability began, not when EDD received anything. So if you filed a bit late it still counts back to your actual disability start date.

0 coins

I had no idea the waiting period wasn't tied to processing. I was counting from when my surgeon's office submitted the certification and that was completely the wrong start point.

0 coins

The waiting period confusion is so common. People assume it's a processing delay and then don't understand why the first payment covers fewer days than expected.

0 coins

i thought sdi and paid family leave were the same thing for a while lol. like i thought when my wife was going to take time after our baby i could also use sdi to bond. turns out sdi is only for when you can't work because of your own medical condition, the bonding part after a birth is pfl which is a totally separate claim. embarrassing how long it took me to figure that out

0 coins

Not embarrassing at all, EDD doesn't make it obvious. Pregnancy disability and bonding are two separate claims filed separately. Lots of people find that out late.

0 coins

yeah my wife ended up filing her disability claim for the pregnancy and then had to file a separate pfl claim for bonding. two different processes, two different approvals

0 coins

The two-claim system for pregnancy and bonding catches almost everyone. At least now that the distinction is clear you can plan the timing right.

0 coins

Something about the CASDI deduction that isn't obvious: it only funds eligibility if the wages were actually subject to SDI tax. If someone has a job that's exempt from SDI withholding — certain government positions, for example — those wages don't count toward the base period for a DI claim even if the person worked those jobs for years. For most private-sector workers in California it's automatic, but it's worth checking your stub to confirm the CASDI line is actually there and showing a deduction.

0 coins

Mine definitely shows CASDI withheld every period. So I should be okay on that front.

0 coins

Then you're contributing and those wages count. EDD needs at least $300 in SDI-covered wages in the base period, and steady logistics work almost certainly clears that well above.

0 coins

Good point about the $300 minimum. For most people it's a non-issue but good to know the threshold exists.

0 coins

my doctor submitted the certification and then i got a Notice of Computation in the mail and i panicked because i thought getting that letter meant i was approved and payments were starting. a coworker told me it just means EDD calculated what i might get, not that they approved anything. is that right?

0 coins

Your coworker is right. The Notice of Computation shows the potential weekly and maximum benefit amount EDD calculated, but it isn't an approval. Actual eligibility is determined separately — payments starting or a Notice of Determination are what tell you where you stand.

0 coins

okay that's a relief to know before i assumed money was on the way. so i just wait to see if payments come through or if i get some other notice?

0 coins

Exactly. If the claim is payable you'll see payments. If EDD finds it's not payable, you'll get a Notice of Determination with an appeal option. Keep an eye on SDI Online and your mailbox.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation not being an approval is genuinely confusing the way it's worded. They should make it clearer on the letter.

0 coins

EDD's benefit formula isn't based on what you paid in through CASDI — people always assume higher deductions mean higher benefits, but the deduction is a flat rate on your wages, and what you receive is a percentage of your wages from a specific lookback period. Two people with identical CASDI deductions in the same paycheck could get different weekly benefits if their wages in the base period differed. The deduction is the entry fee, not the payout formula.

0 coins

That's the clearest way I've heard it put. Entry fee makes sense — you've paid in, so you're eligible to file, but what you collect is figured from the wages themselves.

0 coins

Right. And because the base period looks back further than you might expect, your highest-earning quarter in that window is what matters, not what you've been earning most recently.

0 coins

Does anyone know if the CASDI deduction on a pay stub from a part-time job counts the same as a full-time job for the base period calculation? I had two jobs before my injury and I'm wondering if EDD adds both sets of wages together.

0 coins

The honest answer is to check with EDD directly about how wages from multiple employers in the same base period are counted, because I don't want to guess wrong on something that affects your benefit amount. The notice will reflect what EDD calculated, so compare it to your combined wage history once you have it.

0 coins

Makes sense not to assume. I'll wait for the notice and check whether both employers' wages show up in what EDD used.

0 coins

Had a friend who kept saying EDD would just look at her last paycheck to figure out her benefit amount. That's not how it works at all — the base period covers a twelve-month stretch made up of four quarters, ending before the most recent quarter before your claim. So your most recent paycheck isn't even in the picture. I've seen people surprised when their benefit reflects a period where they were working fewer hours or in a lower-paying role.

0 coins

So for me going out in late October, would the base period end sometime before that? Like there's a gap between when it ends and when my claim started?

0 coins

There's a lag, yes. The exact months depend on when your claim started. The best move is to look at your Notice of Computation — it should identify the quarter EDD pulled your highest wages from, and that tells you exactly what period they used.

0 coins

The lag between current earnings and the base period is what gets people. A promotion right before going out won't help because those wages probably fall outside the base period entirely.

0 coins

Base period question came up for me when I was out for a respiratory illness a few months back — the quarter on my notice was not the one I expected because I'd changed jobs partway through that year and my hours were different. Claimyr got me through to an EDD agent and I asked which quarter of the base period they'd actually used. The agent walked me through it and confirmed the quarter by name, and I could match it up against my W-2 to see the wages they had on file lined up with what I'd actually earned that quarter.

0 coins

They were able to tell you exactly which quarter right there on the phone?

0 coins

Yes, the agent pulled it up and read the quarter to me. It was quick once I was actually talking to someone. That was the piece I needed to understand why my weekly amount was what it was.

0 coins

Knowing the specific quarter helps so much for making sense of the notice. I'll keep that question ready if I need to phone EDD.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is worth reading more than once. First time I got one I skimmed it and missed the section that shows your base period wages by quarter. That breakdown is where you can see exactly what EDD has on file for your earnings in each quarter — if a quarter looks wrong compared to your records, that's when you'd want to contact EDD.

0 coins

Where on the notice is that breakdown? Mine seemed short but maybe I didn't look closely enough.

0 coins

It's usually a table or list showing each quarter and the corresponding wage amount EDD has. If your notice doesn't show it clearly, SDI Online sometimes has additional detail on the claim.

0 coins

Going back to look at mine more carefully now. I think I also just skimmed it.

0 coins

the payment method is something nobody talks about but it matters. payments go to a Money Network prepaid debit card unless you pick direct deposit when you file on SDI Online. i didn't realize i could choose direct deposit and ended up with the card, which was fine but would have preferred my bank account

0 coins

Is direct deposit an option only at the time of filing or can you switch to it after the claim starts?

0 coins

My understanding is you select it during the SDI Online filing process. I'm not sure about switching after, that's worth asking EDD directly if you've already filed.

0 coins

Worth noting the card is Money Network now. Some older posts mention a Bank of America card but that changed — it's Money Network issuing the card these days.

0 coins

Certifying properly once you're on claim matters as much as the initial filing. If you're on automatic payment, after ten weeks EDD will send a form called the DE 2593 — the Disability Claim Continued Eligibility Questionnaire. You have to return it within 20 days or benefits can stop. I almost missed mine because I assumed payments would just keep coming.

0 coins

Twenty days feels tight. Does it come by mail or show up in SDI Online?

0 coins

Comes by mail. Keep your mailing address current in myEDD. Missing it can interrupt payments, so watch for it around the ten-week mark if you're on automatic payment.

0 coins

i didn't even know this form existed until week nine. almost missed it

0 coins

Extensions work differently than people assume. If your doctor says you need more time beyond what your current claim covers, you don't refile — your provider submits a Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate, the DE 2525XX. EDD typically sends that form out with the final payment notice. The claimant doesn't initiate it, the provider does, so give your doctor's office a heads up when you're getting close to the end of your certified period.

0 coins

Does EDD send the DE 2525XX form to the patient or directly to the doctor's office?

0 coins

It goes out with the final payment notice, so it comes to the claimant. You'd then bring it to your provider or let the office know to look for it on their SDI Online provider portal. Confirm with your doctor's office what they prefer.

0 coins

Knowing the form name makes it easier to ask the office specifically for it rather than just saying 'extension paperwork.

0 coins

Appeals are worth knowing about even before you need them. If EDD sends a Notice of Determination saying your claim isn't payable, you have 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal. The notice comes with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You fill it out with your explanation and mail it to the return address on the notice. If you've misplaced the form you can write a detailed letter instead, but send it to the right address. Late appeals can still be considered if you explain why it was late, but don't count on that.

0 coins

What counts as a good explanation in the appeal? Like how much detail do you need to include?

0 coins

Be specific — your dates, what your doctor certified, what EDD's notice says versus what you believe is accurate, and any supporting documents like the medical certification timeline. Vague appeals don't give the administrative law judge much to work with.

0 coins

The 30-day deadline is real. I've seen people post about missing it by a few days and having to explain the delay, which adds a whole extra step.

0 coins

The SDI funding side is worth understanding as a worker even outside of an active claim. The CASDI deduction is the employee contribution — employers in California don't contribute to DI. The rate on your stub comes out of your wages, not the employer's pocket. When people ask why the benefit doesn't equal their full salary, that's part of the answer: the program is funded by employees alone and designed to replace a portion of wages, not all of them.

0 coins

The portion-of-wages point is key. EDD's formula produces a number between 70 and 90 percent depending on income, so expecting full salary replacement leads to disappointment.

0 coins

Exactly. The 70 to 90 percent range is based on where your earnings fall — lower earners get closer to 90 percent as a share of their wages, higher earners trend toward 70 percent. The calculator on EDD's site gives a clearer picture than trying to do it yourself.

0 coins

Going back to work part time is something I had to navigate near the end of my last claim. EDD needs to know when you return even partially — you report it, and EDD determines how a partial week gets paid. I'd assumed I'd keep getting the same weekly amount and just add my part-time pay on top, which isn't how it works. Report accurately and let EDD calculate it.

0 coins

Good to know going in. I'm not close to returning yet but I want to understand the rules before I assume I can just go back a few days a week without it affecting anything.

0 coins

Report any work, every week, accurately. The overpayment headache from not reporting is much worse than any short-term benefit from staying quiet about partial hours.

0 coins

Overpayment notices are brutal. Way easier to just report and let EDD sort the math.

0 coins

EDD's disability line does get through eventually if you keep trying. I've had sessions where I dialed before 8 a.m. and waited for the line to open and that worked better than calling mid-morning. No magic time, just persistence.

0 coins

Early morning worked for me once too. The hold situation varies week to week, honestly.

0 coins

Yeah there's no guaranteed window. The 1-800-480-3287 line is what it is — some days faster, some days you're waiting a long time.

0 coins

spanish line is 1-866-658-8846 for anyone who needs it

0 coins

Really appreciate all of this. To pull together what I've learned: the CASDI deduction on my stub is what funds my eligibility, but the actual weekly benefit on my Notice of Computation is based on my wages from a base period that looks back further than I realized — specifically my highest-earning quarter in a twelve-month window that ends before the most recent quarter. The notice shows the period they used. The deduction rate and amount I paid in don't directly set what I collect. Still have one open question: I've been on claim for a few weeks now and payments have come in correctly so far. But I want to understand better — if I think EDD used the wrong quarter or the wages on file don't match my actual W-2 from that period, is that something I can dispute or just have to accept?

0 coins

Disputing wage records is a real option — it's not just accept-and-move-on. Contact EDD through SDI Online's Request Claim Update or by phone and explain the discrepancy with your documentation. Have your W-2 or paystubs from that quarter ready to support what you're saying.

0 coins

Knowing there's an actual path to correct it if the wages are wrong is reassuring. I'll pull my W-2 and line it up against what the notice says before I assume there's a problem.

0 coins

Wage records can have errors, especially if an employer filed late or misreported a quarter. It's worth checking before the claim closes rather than after.

0 coins

If there is a discrepancy and you don't get it resolved through a request update, the appeal process exists for a reason. Document everything — the notice, your earnings records, and any communication with EDD.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure