Back to California Disability

GalacticGladiator

PFL appeal start date denied after SDI — how long does it take?

So I'm in this weird situation where my SDI ended and I tried to file for PFL right after to bond with my baby, but EDD denied it saying the start date I put was wrong. I thought the PFL just picks up where the SDI leaves off, but apparently EDD has a problem with the date I listed. I filed the appeal using the DE 1000A and sent it in, but now I have no idea how long I'm supposed to wait or what happens next. Has anyone gone through this? My SDI covered my recovery and now the bonding claim is just stuck. I don't know if I should be doing anything else while the appeal is sitting there or if I just wait. Any idea how long these appeals take or what I should have ready?

Payment card situation came up on my own claim that made me finally break down and phone EDD. No matter how many mornings I tried that number, the line just ended the call on me. I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an actual EDD agent, and she confirmed my payment was set to go to the old Money Network card I'd never activated. Got that sorted out. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. For your appeal situation, the Notice of Denial you got should have the DE 1000A attached, and your 30 days to appeal runs from the date printed on that notice, not the date you received it.

0 coins

Wait what is Claimyr exactly? I've been redialing that disability line since Monday and can't get anywhere. Got a pending question about my own claim I really need answered anyway.

0 coins

You phone EDD but Claimyr is what stays on the line with them until a real person picks up, then your phone rings. What's the question on your claim?

0 coins

Oh that makes sense. Mine is about whether my doctor's certification even came through, been stressing about it for days. Might give that a try.

0 coins

The 30-day window on an appeal is something I had wrong for a long time. I assumed it started when the letter arrived in my mailbox. The date printed at the top of the Notice of Determination is what starts the clock, so if it took several days to reach you, that time is already spent. If your 30 days have passed, you can still submit the DE 1000A with a written explanation for why it was late, and an administrative law judge looks at whether the delay was reasonable.

0 coins

I sent mine in well within the 30 days, so I should be okay on that. Good to know about the late appeal option though, that wasn't clear to me at all.

0 coins

Does the administrative law judge actually read the late explanation or is it basically automatic denial? Not sure how strict they are about that.

0 coins

They review the reason you give, so being specific helps. What you can't do is just ignore the deadline without explaining why.

0 coins

Just to make sure I understand the PFL piece here: the bonding claim after pregnancy disability is a completely separate filing from your SDI, right? Like EDD doesn't automatically roll one into the other?

0 coins

Correct. SDI covers your recovery. PFL for bonding is its own claim you file separately, and PFL has no waiting period, which is different from the SDI side.

0 coins

That was actually part of my confusion. I thought it was one continuous thing. So the start date EDD rejected was probably because I entered the date wrong on the separate PFL filing.

0 coins

Yeah if you put a start date that overlapped with SDI days or was before the birth that would explain the denial.

0 coins

EDD's disability phone line is a joke. I've tried before 8, right at 8, mid-morning, all of it. Either rings forever or just disconnects. For your appeal though, make sure the date you're claiming for PFL bonding is after the SDI period ends, not overlapping it.

0 coins

Yep. Can't collect both for the same days. That's probably exactly the issue with the start date.

0 coins

Looking at what I submitted, I think I may have put a start date that was still inside my SDI period. That would explain the denial completely.

0 coins

If that's the case your appeal letter should spell that out, that you're correcting the start date to the day after SDI ended.

0 coins

Appeals don't move fast. File it, keep a copy of everything you send, and document the date you mailed it. After that it's waiting.

0 coins

Keeping a copy of that appeal form is the move. EDD loses paperwork.

0 coins

Mailing it certified helps too so you have proof it arrived.

0 coins

Yep. Certified mail, copy in a folder, done.

0 coins

Medical certification on my claim was a whole ordeal. After five mornings of that disability line cutting me off mid-hold, I tried Claimyr and got a live agent who pulled up my claim right there. She said the certification came in but the receipt number my doctor's office used didn't match the one from my filing, so it was sitting unmatched. Had them fix it that same week. For the appeal here, the Notice of Determination should spell out exactly which date EDD is objecting to.

0 coins

Used Claimyr on a Notice of Determination question on my own claim. Glad I did. Agent confirmed the notice was issued and told me the 30-day appeal window from the date on it, which I had mis-read as a later date than it actually was. Mailed the DE 1000A the next morning.

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about where to mail the appeal form? I always second-guess whether it goes to the return address on the notice or somewhere else.

0 coins

Return address on the notice. That's where it goes, not EDD's general address.

0 coins

The receipt number matching thing tripped me up too when I first filed! Make sure your doctor has the exact one you got when you submitted your claim in SDI Online. Such a small thing but it can hold everything up.

0 coins

yeah the receipt number is the thing nobody tells you about until your claim is stuck

0 coins

Exactly! I wish it was more prominent in the instructions.

0 coins

I'm kind of in a related spot, not PFL but I had my SDI denied and I'm not totally clear on what the denial means. Does denied mean I can never get it, or just that this particular claim got rejected?

0 coins

A denial means that specific claim as filed didn't qualify. You can appeal within 30 days of the date on the notice. It doesn't bar you from future claims.

0 coins

Okay that's less scary than I thought. I'll check the date on my notice today.

0 coins

Pull out the actual notice and look at the date at the top, not the envelope postmark. That's your starting point.

0 coins

The overlap thing with dates is probably what got you. I did the same thing when I transitioned, put the PFL start the same day SDI ended instead of the day after. EDD flagged it. Had to resubmit.

0 coins

Did you have to do a full new appeal or could you just correct the date on the same filing?

0 coins

In my case I appealed and explained the correct date in the letter. Didn't file a whole new claim.

0 coins

That's what I'm planning to do. Explain that the right start date is the day after my SDI ended and ask them to review with that date.

0 coins

For documentation on the appeal, I'd pull the Notice of Computation from the SDI side that shows when that claim ended, and attach it to your appeal letter so the date is right there in front of whoever reviews it.

0 coins

That's a good practical step. Having the SDI end date documented in writing avoids any ambiguity about where the gap is.

0 coins

I didn't think to attach the Notice of Computation. Pulling it out of my SDI Online inbox now to include with everything.

0 coins

Exactly, the more the reviewer can see at a glance without having to dig into separate records, the better.

0 coins

wait so pfl actually has no waiting period? i thought it was the same 7 days as sdi

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period. The seven unpaid days at the start apply to DI claims, not to PFL bonding claims.

0 coins

ok that actually makes pfl start date way more important then because every day counts

0 coins

Yep, so getting the right start date on the PFL appeal matters even more than it might with SDI.

0 coins

Something worth including in the appeal explanation: be specific about what the correct date should be, not just that the denial was wrong. 'The correct start date is X' is more useful to the reviewer than a general complaint.

0 coins

That's actually the kind of concrete advice I needed. I was going to write a general explanation but I'll make sure to state the exact corrected date clearly.

0 coins

Short and clear beats long and vague every time with these appeals.

0 coins

Waiting period on my claim had me completely confused for weeks. I kept thinking the seven days was EDD processing time, not an actual non-payable period built into the claim. Used Claimyr to get through to a disability agent and she confirmed the first payable day on my claim was day eight. That cleared up why my payment was less than I expected that first cycle. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line, which helped me understand what I was getting into: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Genuinely skeptical about this. Reads like a paid placement whenever someone drops a service name and a link in the same comment. What am I missing here?

0 coins

thought the same thing the first time i saw it mentioned. tried it anyway after two weeks of that line going dead on me. agent confirmed my claim start date, which i had wrong by one day, so my whole payment schedule was off. pretty mundane call but it answered what i needed.

0 coins

Okay, the start date thing is exactly what I'd need to sort out on my own claim. Maybe I'll give it a shot.

0 coins

The waiting period confusion is real. I kept thinking those seven days would just show up as late payments, not that they'd never be paid at all.

0 coins

For the appeal letter itself, is there a specific format EDD wants or can you just write a plain explanation of what happened?

0 coins

The DE 1000A has space for your explanation. If you've misplaced it, the instructions on EDD's site say a detailed letter works too. Mail it to the address on the notice.

0 coins

Good, because my handwriting on the form ended up kind of cramped. Might type a letter and attach it.

0 coins

Attaching a typed letter to the form is fine and often easier to read.

0 coins

Base period question on my claim had me turned around for a while. EDD was looking at a quarter where I'd barely worked because I'd had some slow months. Used Claimyr and talked to an agent who told me which specific quarter they pulled from, and it matched my lightest earnings period. She pointed me to the wage calculator on EDD's site to see how that affected my weekly amount on my own Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about whether you could ask EDD to look at a different quarter, or is the base period fixed once the claim is filed?

0 coins

She said the base period uses the highest-paid quarter in the 12-month window before the claim. It's calculated from that, not something you pick. If my numbers looked different on the notice I'd have to figure out why from the notice itself.

0 coins

Been at that disability number most mornings this week and haven't reached a person once. Might look into that.

0 coins

the appeal timeline thing nobody says outright: there's no published number for how long it takes. you file and wait. checking sdionline doesn't show you appeal status, so it's just mail from edd when they have something.

0 coins

That's frustrating but at least I know not to expect an online update. Just watching the mailbox then.

0 coins

Pretty much. EDD's online stuff doesn't reflect every stage of a claim, let alone an appeal.

0 coins

Make sure your mailing address in myEDD is current before the appeal decision comes out. Stale address means the notice goes somewhere you don't live and your 30 days on any next step starts running anyway.

0 coins

Logged into myEDD to double-check my address just now. It was right but I wouldn't have thought to verify it without this.

0 coins

Good catch. I updated mine after a move and even then the first piece of mail after went to the old place.

0 coins

Curious whether the PFL bonding period clock matters here, as in does the appeal decision need to come back before a certain date or does the PFL window stay open while the appeal is pending?

0 coins

That's worth asking EDD directly because individual claim timelines vary. Generally file the appeal as soon as possible rather than waiting to see what the window looks like.

0 coins

Makes sense. Getting it in early is better than trying to calculate the boundary.

0 coins

The SDI to PFL transition trips a lot of people up because EDD treats them as completely separate claims with separate filing requirements. Getting the SDI end date documented and using it as the anchor for the PFL start date is the clearest path through the appeal explanation.

0 coins

Writing my appeal letter with the SDI end date as the anchor point, like you said. Feel like I finally have a concrete way to frame it.

0 coins

That framing makes the error easy to see for whoever reviews it. The dates either line up or they don't.

0 coins

Exactly. Keep the letter short, state the correct date, attach proof of the SDI end date. Done.

0 coins

Hang in there! The appeal process feels opaque but people do get through it. Getting your dates lined up clearly in the letter is the main thing.

0 coins

Sent the appeal out today with the corrected date and the Notice of Computation attached. Now just waiting on mail from EDD.

0 coins

Fingers crossed it goes smoothly for you.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure