Back to California Disability

Zoe Papanikolaou

Overpayment after switching from unemployment to SDI and back error — what happened to my claim

Okay so this is kind of a mess and I'm trying to figure out what I actually owe and why. Back in the spring I was on unemployment, then I had a pretty bad back thing and my doctor said I needed to be out, so I filed for SDI while I was still getting unemployment payments. I didn't realize you absolutely cannot collect both at the same time for the same days — nobody told me that clearly. Now I got an overpayment notice from EDD and I'm panicking a bit. The notice says I was overpaid on the SDI side for the weeks where both were going. I want to appeal because I genuinely didn't understand the rules, but I also don't want to make it worse. Has anyone dealt with an overpayment that came from switching between unemployment and disability and back? What did you pull together to appeal it?

The notice itself is the first thing to find. It has the date it was issued and the appeal deadline printed on it, usually 30 days from that date. Pull your bank records or Money Network card history for the weeks in question and line them up against the weeks the notice says were overpaid. The DE 1000A appeal form came with the notice — fill it out, attach anything showing what you reported and when, and mail it to the return address on the notice, not to a general EDD address.

0 coins

The notice came about two weeks ago so I still have time. I didn't even notice the return address being different — I would have mailed it wrong. Thank you.

0 coins

Keep a copy of everything before you mail it.

0 coins

Does the DE 1000A ask you to explain why you didn't know, or is it just checking boxes? I'm asking because I might be in a similar boat soon.

0 coins

There's a section for a detailed explanation. Write out what you understood at the time and when you first learned the rule. Be specific about dates.

0 coins

DE 2525XX sitting in my stack from EDD was what started my own headache with timing. My doctor submitted the extension late and I wasn't sure which weeks were even covered, so I ended up on the phone with a live EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com). Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the DE 2525XX had been received but not yet matched to the right weeks. That at least told me which weeks to list in my own paperwork.

0 coins

What did the agent actually do with that information — did they flag anything or just read you the status?

0 coins

Just read the status, told me the form was in but pending a match, and said to watch for a notice. So I knew to wait for the mail rather than keep guessing.

0 coins

been trying that line for three mornings straight, never got past the automated part. might give that a shot.

0 coins

The extension timing thing is so stressful, I totally feel that. My claim had a gap too because my doctor's office sent in the wrong form number.

0 coins

The rule that bites people here is simpler than it sounds: EDD says you cannot receive unemployment and disability benefits covering the same days. Doesn't matter which one came first or whether you reported the other — if the days overlap, one of them is an overpayment. The SDI side usually catches it because the systems eventually cross-reference. That's why the overpayment landed on the disability claim rather than the unemployment claim.

0 coins

That explains why it was the SDI side flagged and not unemployment. I assumed since I filed SDI after I got hurt it would just replace the unemployment automatically.

0 coins

Does EDD ever issue the overpayment on the unemployment side instead, or is it always the SDI claim that gets dinged?

0 coins

It can go either way depending on which program issued payment for the overlapping days. Worth reading the notice carefully — it'll say which claim and which weeks.

0 coins

Don't assume the notice is right either. Check every week they listed against what you actually got paid.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a joke. Called nine times one week, got the automated system every time and it hung up on me. If you need to actually talk to someone about an overpayment calculation, you're in for a fight just getting through.

0 coins

This is exactly what I'm dreading. I need to understand the specific weeks they're claiming before I write my appeal.

0 coins

Ask EDD through SDI Online first. Sometimes a written message gets you a straight answer faster than the phone.

0 coins

SDI Online message thing is hit or miss. I waited 11 days for a reply once and the answer was basically 'check your notice.

0 coins

Had a client go through almost this exact thing — she switched from unemployment to SDI mid-month and thought EDD would sort out the overlap automatically. They don't. You have to report it yourself and the moment you don't, the overlap becomes an overpayment the second their systems sync up.

0 coins

Wait, so you're supposed to tell EDD on the unemployment side AND the SDI side when you switch? Or just one of them?

0 coins

You report the change to whichever program you're currently certified with. When you stop being able to work, you stop certifying for unemployment and file SDI instead. The issue is when someone keeps certifying for unemployment after the disability starts.

0 coins

Or when SDI pays the same weeks unemployment already covered. Either direction causes the same mess.

0 coins

yeah this happened to me too, thought the SDI filing would auto-cancel the unemployment weeks. it really doesn't lol

0 coins

Claim start date was the thing I had to nail down when I was sorting out my own overlap issue. The agent I reached — I went through Claimyr for it — looked up my claim and told me the recorded start date was two days later than what I had in my head, which explained why there was a gap week showing as uncovered. Knowing that exact date let me line up all my weeks correctly on the appeal.

0 coins

The start date question is the same one I need answered on my claim. I'll try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready before I make that call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the specific weeks you're asking about. The agent can pull the exact dates off your claim right there.

0 coins

Does the start date affect which base period they use to calculate the weekly amount?

0 coins

The base period is tied to the start date, yes. Even a few days' difference can shift which quarter of wages they look at, which is why getting the exact date confirmed matters.

0 coins

Thirty days from the date on the notice. That's your window to appeal. Miss it and you need to explain the delay to a judge. Don't sit on it.

0 coins

Got it. Working on the explanation now. What level of detail does the judge actually want — paragraph or more like a full timeline?

0 coins

Full timeline. Date you filed SDI, date unemployment paid those weeks, what you understood the rules to be at the time. More detail is better.

0 coins

Agree. Vague explanations don't help in appeals.

0 coins

ugh this is why the system is so confusing, nobody explains that you cant have both at the same time until they send you a bill for it

0 coins

Exactly, found out the hard way.

0 coins

should be in big letters when you file sdi honestly

0 coins

For the appeal letter — if you've lost the DE 1000A or it got mangled — EDD says you can write a detailed letter instead and mail it to the return address on the notice. The letter just has to explain your position and ask for an appeal. Probably still better to use the form if you have it, but the letter works.

0 coins

Still have the form, just wanted to know I had a backup option. Good to know.

0 coins

Mailing it with some proof of delivery is wise too, so you have a record it arrived before the deadline.

0 coins

Certified mail is what I'd use for anything going to EDD appeal.

0 coins

I'm confused about something — if unemployment requires you to be able and available to work every week, and you got hurt and couldn't work, weren't those unemployment weeks already invalid even before the SDI overlap? Can they go back and ding you for those too separately?

0 coins

That's a separate question from the SDI overpayment, and honestly one to put directly to EDD about the specific weeks, since the two programs are run separately. The SDI notice only covers the SDI side.

0 coins

Don't conflate the two notices. If you get a separate unemployment overpayment notice, appeal that one separately with its own form and deadline.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense — treat each notice on its own.

0 coins

Appeal letters that just say 'I didn't know' rarely move the needle on their own. What helps is showing what you did do — that you filed SDI as soon as you knew you couldn't work, that you stopped certifying for unemployment when you filed, whatever actions you took. Facts over feelings.

0 coins

Honestly I did stop certifying for unemployment when my doctor told me to file SDI. The overlap was only the transition week. That's worth laying out clearly.

0 coins

That detail could matter. Write down the exact dates you last certified for unemployment and the exact date you filed SDI, and attach anything that shows them.

0 coins

Even a screenshot of when you filed SDI in the portal can help. Timestamps are your friend here.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came with a potential weekly benefit amount that looked much lower than I expected, and I wasn't sure which quarter they had used for the base period calculation. The agent I spoke with after going through Claimyr (claimyr.com) confirmed the exact quarter and told me the weekly amount on my notice was correct based on that period. If your overpayment calculation seems off, checking which quarter they used could explain a discrepancy.

0 coins

The weekly amount on my own Notice of Computation had me wondering too. I went through Claimyr to ask about my payment method and ended up on the phone with an EDD agent who confirmed my direct deposit was on file — then I asked about the amount while I had her and she pointed me to the calculator on EDD's site to verify it myself. Anyway, three weeks of trying that 1-800 number before that.

0 coins

How many times total did you try before you got through on your own?

0 coins

More than I'd like to count. Stopped trying the number directly after day four.

0 coins

EDD's calculator is at least useful for sanity-checking the number before you go in with a question.

0 coins

The Money Network card history is actually pretty detailed — you can see exactly which dates EDD pushed payments and for how many days! That's what I used to map out my own weeks when I had a discrepancy.

0 coins

Didn't even think to check the card history that way. Going to do that tonight.

0 coins

Filter by EDD deposits and each one will show the payment date. Then match that to the weeks on the overpayment notice.

0 coins

Export or screenshot it before the statement rolls over. Some card portals only show 90 days of history.

0 coins

SDI Online has a Request Claim Update option under the claim ID. Use it to send EDD a written message asking for the exact weeks listed as overpaid and the reason code on the account. Getting that in writing gives you something concrete to respond to in the appeal.

0 coins

Is that the same as Ask EDD, or a different thing?

0 coins

Different. Ask EDD is EDD's general contact form on their site. Request Claim Update is inside SDI Online, under your specific claim. The claim-specific one is better for this situation.

0 coins

The written reply from EDD through that channel can also serve as documentation for your appeal if they confirm the weeks and amounts.

0 coins

One thing that tripped me up early — the waiting period on the SDI claim is the first seven days, and those days don't get paid. If EDD counted the overlap weeks starting from day one of your SDI claim, some of those days might actually fall in the waiting period, which means EDD shouldn't have issued SDI payment for them anyway. Worth checking whether the overpaid weeks include any waiting period days.

0 coins

Wait, so if the first seven days aren't paid anyway, how could there be an overlap for those days?

0 coins

Exactly — if the SDI claim's waiting period covers days one through seven and unemployment paid those same days, technically EDD collected from unemployment for days when SDI never paid. The overpayment should only be the SDI payments that actually went out for days eight and beyond that also overlap with unemployment days.

0 coins

That's a reasonable point to raise in the appeal explanation. If only specific weeks generated actual SDI payments, the overpayment amount should reflect that, not every day since the claim started.

0 coins

The notice should break it down by week. If it doesn't match that logic, that's exactly what to flag in the appeal.

0 coins

Bring a clear week-by-week table to your appeal if you can make one. Date range, what you got from unemployment that week, what you got from SDI that week, whether there was actual overlap. It makes it easier for the judge to see where the real double payment was versus where it wasn't.

0 coins

That's really practical. I can build that from the card history and my bank statements.

0 coins

Keep it simple — four columns, no explanations in the table itself. Put the narrative in the letter above it.

0 coins

my coworker had an overpayment notice for like two hundred dollars from something similar and she just paid it because she thought appealing was more trouble than it was worth. don't do that if the amount is wrong, appeal it

0 coins

The amount on mine doesn't feel right for the overlap I had. That's part of why I want to actually appeal rather than just pay it.

0 coins

Pay it only if you agree with it. If you don't agree, appeal first. Paying it doesn't stop you from appealing but it muddies the water.

0 coins

yeah that's what I told her but she was just done with the whole thing by that point lol

0 coins

the overlap thing confused me too when I went from disability back to unemployment after I recovered. had to make sure I wasn't certifying for unemployment until I was actually cleared to work again and had filed to close out the sdi claim

0 coins

That transition back is the part I'm least sure about too. How did you make sure EDD knew you were done with the SDI side?

0 coins

just stopped certifying and went back to unemployment when my doctor cleared me. never got an overlap notice for that direction, so I think it worked out.

0 coins

Technically you should report your return-to-work date on the SDI side as well, not just stop certifying for disability. Worth confirming that step was done.

0 coins

good point, I honestly wasn't sure I did that formally. nothing came back at me but I got lucky maybe.

0 coins

EDD catching the overlap months later is annoying but it happens. Their systems aren't real-time — the cross-reference between programs takes a while. That's why people are blindsided when the notice arrives.

0 coins

Is there any way to proactively check whether an overlap is showing before you get the notice?

0 coins

Not really. You can message EDD through SDI Online asking if any overlap has been flagged, but you won't get a heads-up before they issue the notice.

0 coins

Keeping your own records current is the best defense. If you know exactly which weeks each program paid you, you can spot a discrepancy before EDD does and address it.

0 coins

For anyone still figuring out the transition: when you can't work anymore, stop certifying for unemployment, file your SDI claim as soon as nine days after the disability starts, and get your doctor's certification in. When you're ready to go back, report the return date on your SDI claim. Each step clearly separated in time is what prevents the overlap.

0 coins

Does the nine-day wait before filing SDI mean there's automatically a gap week where neither program should be paying, or can unemployment cover those nine days?

0 coins

The nine days is when you're allowed to file — your disability start date is what matters for the SDI claim, and the first seven of those days are the waiting period. For those same days you should not be certifying for unemployment either, since unemployment requires you to be able to work.

0 coins

That gap is exactly where people get into trouble. Some people keep certifying for unemployment during those nine days because the SDI hasn't started yet, and that's what creates the overlap.

0 coins

That's precisely what happened to me. I didn't stop unemployment certification immediately because I thought I had to wait for SDI to be active first. Now I know.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure