Back to California Disability

Nia Davis

Los Angeles disability claim denied — what do I do next with California EDD?

Filed my SDI claim about six weeks ago after I had to stop working due to a back injury that's been getting progressively worse. I'm in Los Angeles and my employer actually has nothing to do with this process which I know, but I mention it because I initially thought they had to submit something and wasted a week waiting on them. My doctor submitted the medical certification and everything looked like it was moving along. Then last week I got a notice in the mail saying my disability claim was denied. No phone call, nothing in SDI Online warning me, just a letter. I'm pretty blindsided because my doctor clearly stated I can't do my job right now and I've been paying into SDI my whole career. The notice mentioned something about an Appeal Form DE 1000A and a 30-day window but honestly the letter is confusing and I don't know if I missed something procedurally or if EDD just got something wrong on their end. Has anyone in LA gone through a denial and appealed it? What am I actually looking at here?

DE 1000A is the form you need and the clock is already running from the date printed on that denial notice, not the day you got it in the mail. Pull that notice out right now and check the date at the top. If you're within 30 days of that date you can still appeal. If you've already passed 30 days you can still submit the appeal but you'll need to explain why it was late, and an administrative law judge will decide whether to hear it anyway. Either way, you fill out the DE 1000A with a detailed explanation of why you think the denial is wrong, and you mail it to the return address on the notice itself, not to some general EDD address. If you lost the form you can write a detailed letter instead, same address. What did the denial notice say as the reason?

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

The date on it is from about two and a half weeks ago so I'm still within the window. The reason it listed was something about not meeting base period wage requirements, which I do not understand at all because I've been working full time for three years.

0 coins

Wages eligible for SDI are only the ones where CASDI was deducted from your paycheck. Check your pay stubs from roughly five to eighteen months before your claim started and look for that CASDI line. If you were ever paid as a contractor, had any period of self-employment, or worked for an employer who wasn't withholding SDI, those wages wouldn't count toward the base period. Also the base period is a specific 12-month window of four quarters, not just any recent 12 months, and you need at least $300 in SDI-covered wages in that window. Your Notice of Computation should show which quarter EDD used.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

Every job I've had deducted CASDI and I have the stubs. I'll pull my Notice of Computation and double-check the quarters they used. That might be where something went wrong.

0 coins

EDD denied my claim twice before it finally got approved, both times in the LA area. First denial was because my doctor submitted the certification late, second was a base period issue similar to what you're describing. The appeals process is real and it does work if you have documentation. Gather every pay stub you have from the base period on your Notice of Computation, any letter from your employer confirming your start date and wages, and your doctor's certification if you have a copy. Write a clear explanation on the DE 1000A of what the denial says versus what your records show. Keep a copy of everything before you mail it.

0 coins

Two denials before approval sounds exhausting. Did EDD ever explain what specifically was miscalculated on the base period the second time?

0 coins

The quarters they pulled didn't include my highest-earning period because I had changed jobs partway through the base period window. Once I sent in stubs showing the full picture it got sorted out on appeal.

0 coins

Changing jobs mid-base-period trips so many people up. The 12-month window is fixed by when your disability started, not by when you felt like you were earning the most.

0 coins

Payment date on my own claim was completely invisible to me for weeks and I finally got an answer by using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD disability agent. The hold situation on 1-800-480-3287 had been impossible every time I tried on my own. The agent told me the specific date my payment had been issued and which weeks it covered, so I stopped panicking about whether it had gotten lost. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. For your denial situation specifically, an agent can at least confirm what triggered it on their end so you know exactly what to address in the appeal.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

Appreciate this. The 1-800-480-3287 line has been a wall of hold music every time I've tried. I'll look into this before I mail the appeal so I actually know what I'm disputing.

0 coins

EDD's disability line is genuinely brutal in terms of wait times. Good to have another way in.

0 coins

Knowing the specific trigger before you write the appeal letter is a smart move. You don't want to argue the wrong point.

0 coins

Before you write one word on that appeal form, pull up your SDI Online account and look at whatever it shows for your claim status. Sometimes the denial is because EDD flagged a mismatch between what your doctor submitted and the dates you put in Part A of your claim. If the disability start date your doctor used doesn't match what you filed, that alone can generate a denial. Fixing a date discrepancy in an appeal is straightforward if you have documentation from your doctor confirming the actual date you became unable to work.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

Good point, I'll check whether the dates line up. My doctor's office submitted everything online so there could be a mismatch I didn't catch.

0 coins

Date mismatches are more common than people realize. The doctor fills in the start date from their records, the patient fills it in from memory, and they can end up a day or two apart which creates a problem.

0 coins

The 30-day deadline is from the date on the notice, as the person above already said. Something people miss: the appeal form asks for a detailed explanation, and 'I disagree with this decision' by itself is not enough. You want to lay out specifically which facts EDD got wrong and attach copies of whatever proves it. If the issue is wages, that means pay stubs with CASDI clearly showing. If it's about whether you're actually disabled, that means your doctor's written statement. The more specific you are, the better position you're in at the hearing.

0 coins

Does the appeal go straight to a hearing or is there a review stage first?

0 coins

There's a hearing before an administrative law judge. EDD sends a Notice of Determination DE 2517 when a claim isn't payable, and that notice has the appeal form attached. The hearing is where you present your documentation and explain your side.

0 coins

Got it, so the DE 2517 is the denial notice itself. I always see people refer to it differently and it confused me.

0 coins

Three years of CASDI deductions and a legitimate medical condition should be a strong appeal. The key is making it documentary, not just verbal. Your employer can write a letter confirming your employment dates and that CASDI was withheld. Your doctor can write a supplemental statement. All of it goes in the envelope with the DE 1000A.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

Worth noting, my HR department is actually very responsive so getting an employer letter should be quick. Didn't know that was something I could include.

0 coins

Absolutely include it. The more corroborating documentation you send, the cleaner the appeal record is for the judge.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my mailbox about ten weeks into my own claim and I almost missed the deadline to send it back. Called EDD to make sure they'd received it and ended up speaking to an agent through Claimyr because the regular line kept dropping me before anyone answered. The agent confirmed the form had been received and told me my claim was on automatic payment, which I hadn't been sure about. The 20-day return window on that form is strict, so worth knowing before you get there.

0 coins

20 days goes fast when you're dealing with a recovery and also trying to track down paperwork. What happens if you send it back but they say they never got it?

0 coins

The agent told me to keep a copy every time I send anything to EDD. If there's ever a question about receipt, having a copy with a mailing date is your documentation. For something that important I'd send it certified.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

Good to know there's even a form like that coming down the line. I didn't know about the DE 2593 at all before reading this thread.

0 coins

Workers' comp is different from SDI and I want to flag that because a few people I know in similar situations mixed them up. If your back injury happened at work, the right claim is workers' compensation through your employer, not SDI. If it's non-work-related, SDI is correct. EDD's own language says it's not common to receive both at the same time, with some exceptions. Worth being clear on which one applies to your situation before the appeal.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

Mine is not a work injury, it's a condition that developed outside of work. So SDI is the right path.

0 coins

Then you're in the right place. Just wanted to make sure because I've seen people go months appealing the wrong program.

0 coins

Read the denial notice one more time and look for any language about which quarter they're using for the base period. The base period is four quarters from roughly five to seventeen months before your claim start date. If you had a gap in employment or a period where SDI wasn't deducted anywhere in that window, it can drop your covered wages below the threshold. Your Notice of Computation spells this out quarter by quarter. If the numbers on the notice don't reflect what your pay stubs show, that discrepancy is the core of your appeal.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

My Notice of Computation is in the same pile of EDD mail. I'll go through both documents side by side today.

0 coins

Compare each quarter on the notice to the stubs from that same quarter. If EDD missed a quarter entirely or used a lower number than your stubs show, that's what you're correcting in the appeal.

0 coins

My sister tried to tell me SDI and unemployment were basically the same thing when I first filed and I almost listened to her. They are completely different. SDI is for when you physically or mentally cannot work. Unemployment is for when you're able to work but don't have a job. You can't get both for the same days. Sounds like you're correctly on SDI for a medical condition, just wanted to put this out there because that confusion is everywhere.

0 coins

The SDI versus unemployment mix-up is so common. The rule is clean though: if you can't work because of a health condition, that's SDI. If you're able and available but just out of a job, that's unemployment.

0 coins

Exactly. And if you're on SDI and then recover and your job is gone, that's when you'd look at unemployment, once you're actually able to work again.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in on my own claim with a denial I genuinely didn't expect. Ended up talking to an EDD agent about it after reaching the disability line through Claimyr because I'd been trying the regular number for days without getting through. The agent confirmed which Notice of Determination was on file and the date it was issued, so I knew exactly when my 30 days started. That date on the notice matters more than the day it arrives in your mailbox.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

That's the exact thing I need to nail down. Knowing when the 30 days actually started from the notice date, not the day I opened it.

0 coins

The notice date versus the receipt date is a distinction that catches people off guard. The clock runs from the notice date, full stop.

0 coins

Glad you got clarity on the timeline. Appeals that land even one day late have a much harder path.

0 coins

If the base period wage issue turns out to be a miscalculation on EDD's end, include a cover letter that walks them through the math. Quarter by quarter, stubs attached, total covered wages, and a clear statement of how that meets the minimum. Make it easy for whoever reviews the appeal to see the error without having to do work themselves.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

Cover letter framing the math explicitly, that's a great idea. I'll structure it that way.

0 coins

Agreed on the organized approach. Appeals that come in as a pile of loose documents without explanation are harder for the reviewer. A one-page summary up front makes a real difference.

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period is not the same as a denial, worth saying clearly because I've seen people panic when they get the first notice and think their claim got denied when really they're just in the non-payable waiting period. Sounds like yours is an actual denial but I wanted to put it out there for anyone reading this thread who might be confusing the two things.

0 coins

This is worth clarifying. The waiting period is the first seven days of any new claim, they don't pay benefits for those days at all, it's built into the system not an error.

0 coins

Right, the eighth day is when payable benefits start. Entirely different from a denial, which is what a DE 2517 Notice of Determination is.

0 coins

I confused these two myself when I first filed. Got the Notice of Computation and thought it meant I was approved, then panicked when no payment showed up for the first week.

0 coins

If your doctor is willing, have them write a brief supplemental letter for your appeal specifically addressing the base period issue. Not medical details but a statement confirming when you became their patient, when they certified you as unable to work, and that the medical certification they submitted was accurate. It reinforces the medical side of the record.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

My doctor's office has been cooperative throughout this. I'll ask them when I go in next week.

0 coins

Bring a copy of the denial notice to that appointment so they can see exactly what EDD questioned. It helps them know what to address.

0 coins

CASDI deductions show up as 'CA SDI' or 'CASDI' on most pay stubs, sometimes the formatting varies by payroll system but it's always there if SDI was withheld. If yours shows something you're not sure is SDI withholding, you can call your payroll department and ask them to confirm which line corresponds to State Disability Insurance. Having that confirmed in writing is better than guessing.

0 coins

Payroll departments can usually pull old pay stubs too if you need records from prior years. Worth asking if you're missing any stubs from the base period window.

0 coins

Yes, HR or payroll can usually generate a wage history that shows SDI contributions by quarter. That document alone could be what you submit with the appeal.

0 coins

Appeals that go to hearing are heard by an administrative law judge who is separate from EDD. The hearing is your chance to present documentation and explain what happened. You'll get a notice of when and where the hearing is scheduled. If you can't make the scheduled date you can request a continuance, but do it early. Showing up prepared with organized documents matters more than being a perfect speaker.

0 coins

Is the hearing in person or can it be done by phone?

0 coins

Both options have been available in California. The notice scheduling your hearing should give you information on how to request a phone hearing if that works better for your situation.

0 coins

That's helpful, good to know you don't necessarily have to be physically there.

0 coins

Went through a denial in a different county but the appeals process is statewide, same forms, same rules. The thing that made the difference in my case was sending the appeal certified mail with a tracking number. EDD claimed they hadn't received my first attempt, which I couldn't prove because I'd just dropped it in a mailbox. Second time I sent it certified and kept the receipt. Got scheduled for a hearing about six weeks later.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

Certified mail noted. I would not have thought of that but it makes sense to have proof of delivery.

0 coins

EDD's appeals address is on the return address of the notice. Send it there certified and keep the receipt with your copies of everything you sent.

0 coins

Something that might help: SDI Online lets you send a message to EDD through the Request Claim Update option on your claim. Pick the request type, write your question, and you'll get a response in the system. It's not instant but for non-urgent questions about what your denial was based on it's worth trying alongside the appeal process.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

I've been avoiding SDI Online because I felt like it never showed me anything useful, but I'll try the Request Claim Update path specifically.

0 coins

The request update feature is different from just reading the status screen. It actually sends a message to someone. Response times vary but it's documented in writing, which is useful.

0 coins

PFL is not what you want here and I say that because someone above mentioned bonding leave in a different context. PFL is for bonding with a new child or caring for a seriously ill family member. What you're dealing with is a DI claim for your own medical condition, which is entirely separate. Just want to make sure no one sends you toward the wrong program.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

Understood, I know my situation is DI not PFL. The two programs get conflated a lot online.

0 coins

The PFL versus DI confusion is everywhere. They're both under the SDI umbrella but completely different claims with different purposes and different rules.

0 coins

Mailing the appeal to the wrong address is a silent killer for these cases. The return address on the denial notice is the correct one for that specific appeal. Not EDD's general mailing address, not SDI Online, not a local office unless the notice says so. Read that return address carefully and use it exactly.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

I would have just Googled an EDD mailing address. Really glad I know to use the one on the notice itself.

0 coins

EDD has multiple processing locations and the appeals section is specific. The notice routes to the right place, general EDD addresses do not.

0 coins

This is one of the most practically important things in the thread. Wrong address means your appeal potentially never reaches the right department, and you've lost your window.

0 coins

The base period your Notice of Computation shows is typically the 12-month period that ended about five months before your disability began. So if you became disabled in, say, October, the base period would look at four quarters that ended the previous June. Walk that back on your own calendar and match it to your stubs to see which earnings window they're evaluating.

0 coins

Nia Davis

Author

Walking it back on a calendar makes it much clearer. I had the right stubs but wasn't sure which months to focus on.

0 coins

Once you map it to actual calendar quarters you'll probably see quickly whether EDD's calculation matches your records or not. It usually becomes obvious fast.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure