Back to California Disability

Hunter Hampton

Is SDI federally taxable? Confused after seeing my 1099-G

Okay so I've been going back and forth on this for weeks now and I need someone to help me make sense of it. Got a 1099-G from EDD after my SDI claim last year and my tax person asked me whether the disability payments are federally taxable. I had no idea what to say. California I've heard doesn't tax it, but federal is a whole different story and nobody seems to give a straight answer. Has anyone dealt with this? Did you end up paying federal tax on your SDI payments or not?

California does not tax SDI benefits, that part is settled. The federal side is the one where it depends on your situation, and EDD's tax information page lays it out more clearly than most people expect. A tax professional is really the right person to say how it applies to your specific case, because the answer genuinely does vary.

0 coins

So there's no flat yes or no for the federal part? My tax person sort of implied it might be taxable and I didn't know enough to push back.

0 coins

Federal taxability of SDI is not a simple rule that covers everyone the same way. Your tax professional is the right one to work through your particulars with, and EDD's own tax page is worth pulling up together.

0 coins

Does the 1099-G tell you which part is state and which is federal? Mine just had a number on it and I didn't know how to read it.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came back from my doctor's office three weeks after my final payment notice, so the extension question was hanging in the air while I was also trying to sort out what I owed at tax time. Spent four mornings trying 1-800-480-3287 and it either rang out or cut me off before I reached anyone. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally talked to an EDD agent. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent confirmed they had received the DE 2525XX and that the extension weeks were on the claim. I went back to my tax person with that date information and we worked out the federal question from there.

0 coins

Claimyr showing up in a tax thread feels like marketing to me. How does anyone know it's a real call to EDD and not just someone pretending to be an agent?

0 coins

The agent I spoke with knew the exact date my DE 2525XX was received and read back the specific weeks added to the claim. That's not something a person pretending to be EDD could pull up. They were EDD's own staff, same as if I'd reached them myself after two hours of redialing.

0 coins

Had the same doubt honestly! Tried it anyway when my payment method was showing wrong in SDI Online. The agent confirmed the card on my claim was still the Money Network card and walked me through how to update it. Totally real EDD agent. Made me feel so much better about the tax stuff too because at least I knew what had been paid and when!

0 coins

Okay. I might give it a go. My phone just rings forever on that line and I still have questions about my own claim.

0 coins

Nobody at that phone line is going to tell you your federal tax answer anyway. The EDD agent can tell you what was paid and when, but federal taxability is for your accountant. I've wasted enough mornings on that line to know what they will and won't say.

0 coins

Fair point. So basically get the payment info from EDD and take that to the tax person?

0 coins

Exactly. EDD tells you the numbers, your tax person tells you what to do with them.

0 coins

That's actually a really useful way to split it. EDD's job is the what, your CPA's job is the so what.

0 coins

EDD's own site says California does not tax SDI benefits. Federal is a separate question and EDD's tax information page points people to a tax professional for that reason. Worth finding that page on edd.ca.gov rather than relying on forum answers for something that varies by person.

0 coins

Where exactly on edd.ca.gov is that page? I've looked around and keep ending up in the wrong section.

0 coins

Search 'EDD tax information disability' and it usually comes up near the top. It's under the DI section of the site.

0 coins

Thank you, I'll do that. I think I was just looking in the wrong spots.

0 coins

my coworker told me sdi is totally tax free across the board but i looked it up and that's only california not federal so wanted to flag that in case anyone else heard the same thing

0 coins

You're right to flag it. The state exemption is clear, the federal side isn't the same rule, and mixing them up is very common.

0 coins

yeah had to unlearn that one myself

0 coins

Claim start date was the thing the agent sorted for me, which mattered a lot once I was figuring out which tax year the payments fell into. Called through Claimyr when the line was doing its usual thing. Agent read back the exact start date EDD had on the claim, different from the date I had in my head, so at least my tax person and I were working from the right figure after that.

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about which weeks specifically showed as paid, or just the start date?

0 coins

Just the start date was what I asked about. Could have asked about individual weeks too but I had what I needed.

0 coins

Been trying that line myself every morning for going on two weeks now, anyway.

0 coins

California SDI is not subject to state income tax. Federal treatment depends on individual circumstances, so point your tax professional to EDD's tax information page and let them work through it with your actual numbers.

0 coins

Is there a form EDD sends that shows the total paid, or do I have to add it up from each payment?

0 coins

The 1099-G covers what EDD reported for the year. Take that to your tax person.

0 coins

This is what I got too, the 1099-G. Glad to know that's the right document to bring.

0 coins

Tax questions on a disability forum are going to get you halfway there at best. California side is settled, federal side needs a professional. That's the whole answer.

0 coins

Blunt but accurate. California no, federal it depends, see a CPA.

0 coins

Appreciate someone just saying it plainly.

0 coins

Now I'm worried I might have already filed wrong. I didn't report my SDI at all on my federal return because I thought it was all non-taxable. Should I be panicking?

0 coins

Whether your filing needs amending is exactly what your tax professional is there to help you figure out. EDD's tax information page is a good starting point for the conversation.

0 coins

Don't panic. Take your 1099-G and your return to your tax person and ask them to look at it.

0 coins

Okay. I'll make an appointment. I just didn't realize the federal question was even a question.

0 coins

Notice of Computation had my weekly benefit amount on it, which came in handy when I was reconciling what EDD paid versus what the 1099-G showed. The numbers didn't quite line up at first because my claim crossed into a second quarter. Used Claimyr to reach an agent and get the base period quarter EDD had on file. Agent told me which quarter was used and confirmed the weekly amount matched what was on the Notice of Computation. That cleared up the gap in my numbers.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation showed an amount that doesn't match what I expected from my wages. I want to ask EDD which quarter they pulled. I'll try Claimyr for that.

0 coins

Have the Notice of Computation in front of you and your SDI Online claim ID. The agent will need the claim to pull the quarter information.

0 coins

Good to know. I've been trying to figure out that same mismatch on mine for a couple weeks.

0 coins

The confusion here makes sense because 'non-taxable' gets used loosely. California really does exempt SDI from state income tax. Federal is a different code, different rules, and whether it applies depends on things specific to your situation that nobody on a forum can fully answer.

0 coins

That explains why I kept getting different answers when I searched. People were mixing the two up.

0 coins

Exactly. Someone says 'SDI is tax free' and they mean California, but someone else reads it and applies it to federal. The state exemption is real and clear, the federal answer just isn't the same for everyone.

0 coins

My sister told me SDI counts as PFL for tax purposes and I was totally confused for a while. They're separate programs, different claims. SDI is disability, PFL is for bonding or caregiving. Tax treatment may also differ so don't mix up advice meant for one with the other lol.

0 coins

You're right that they're separate programs. Someone's PFL experience won't necessarily apply to a DI claim, and mixing the two up at tax time can cause real headaches.

0 coins

This is a really common mix-up. Disability Insurance and Paid Family Leave are both under SDI but they're not the same thing.

0 coins

just got my 1099-g and wasnt expecting a number on there for disability. thought it was all going to be zero. guess i have more research to do

0 coins

Your tax professional can walk through what that figure means for your federal return. EDD's tax information page is worth reading first so you go in with some context.

0 coins

yeah probably should have looked into this before filing season snuck up on me

0 coins

Went through this last year with my own claim after a surgery kept me out for about nine weeks. Brought the 1099-G to my tax person and we went through EDD's tax information page together. California wasn't an issue. Federal required a bit more back and forth but we got through it.

0 coins

Good to hear someone got it sorted. Did your tax person seem familiar with SDI or did you have to explain what it was?

0 coins

Had to explain a little bit what SDI was and how the claim worked, but once we had the 1099-G and the Notice of Computation in front of us it went pretty smoothly.

0 coins

This is reassuring. I was scared no one would know how to handle it.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation and the 1099-G together give your tax professional what they need for the federal question. Keep both. EDD's tax information page on edd.ca.gov should be the starting point for any factual questions about what EDD itself says.

0 coins

Agreed. The Notice of Computation is worth holding onto all year, not just at filing time.

0 coins

I didn't know I should be keeping the Notice of Computation. Good to know for next year.

0 coins

Dealt with this after a back injury kept me out six months. EDD's disability line finally got me someone who confirmed what was paid, and the tax question went from there. Phone line is rough but eventually someone picks up.

0 coins

Six months is a long claim. Did you have to do an extension or did the original cert cover it?

0 coins

Doctor submitted a DE 2525XX around week eight. Covered the rest of it.

0 coins

Good to know extensions work for longer injuries like that.

0 coins

If the 1099-G shows an amount, does that automatically mean you owe federal tax on it? Or is getting the form itself not the same as owing something?

0 coins

Receiving a 1099-G means EDD reported that amount to the IRS. Whether you owe anything on it federally depends on your specific situation, which is why a tax professional is the right resource here, not a forum.

0 coins

The form is for reporting purposes. What it means for your tax bill is a question for your preparer.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense. I thought getting the form automatically meant I'd owe something.

0 coins

been asking around at work and nobody has the same answer on this, one person says pay it one person says don't, anyway my wife's claim is still pending so we're just trying to get our bearings here

0 coins

The inconsistent answers make sense because the federal side genuinely varies. EDD's own tax page plus a tax professional is the clearest path.

0 coins

yeah we'll probably end up paying someone to sort it out anyway

0 coins

EDD disability doesn't get taxed by California. Federal is a separate matter and I can't tell you what it means for yours specifically. That's what tax people are for.

0 coins

You put that more cleanly than I've been able to for weeks. Thank you.

0 coins

Not complicated once you separate the two questions.

0 coins

Had a moment of total panic when I saw the 1099-G because I thought I'd done something wrong by not setting aside money for taxes during my claim. EDD's tax information page actually calmed me down quite a bit because it was clear about the California part at least. Federal I'm still working through with my preparer but at least I know what I do and don't know now!

0 coins

This is exactly where I am. The California part being clear actually helps a lot even if the federal side still needs sorting.

0 coins

Right! And knowing what questions to even bring to your tax person makes the whole appointment go faster.

0 coins

yeah going in knowing the california part is handled is way less stressful

0 coins

EDD pays the disability, doesn't file your taxes. The 1099-G gives your preparer the number. Everything after that is between you and the IRS.

0 coins

Pretty much. EDD's job ends when they hand you the form.

0 coins

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure