Back to California Disability

Zara Khan

Is CASDI the same as SDI on my California paycheck?

Every time I look at my pay stub there's a deduction labeled CASDI and I've been trying to figure out if that's the same thing as what people call SDI when they talk about disability claims. I've been out of work for a few weeks after a procedure and someone in my family mentioned I should file for SDI but honestly I wasn't even sure I had it because I'd never seen that label anywhere. Then I noticed the CASDI line on my stub and started wondering if that's the same program. Can anyone clear this up? Also if it is the same thing, does what I've been paying into it actually affect how much I'd get if I filed a claim right now?

Waiting period question is actually what landed me on the phone with EDD a few months back, and that call is what I want to share here. Seven days at the start of my own DI claim showed as not payable, and I genuinely didn't know if something was wrong or if that's just how it works. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me to a live EDD agent after I'd spent two mornings getting nowhere on my own. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed those first seven days are a non-payable waiting period on every new DI claim — day eight is the first day a payment can actually cover. Knowing that, I stopped stressing about the gap and just waited for the first real payment to post.

0 coins

Is the waiting period seven calendar days or seven days you would have worked? I keep reading different things and I want to make sure I'm counting right for my own claim.

0 coins

Calendar days is how the agent described it on my claim — the first seven days from the start date, regardless of whether they're weekdays or weekend days. Day eight is when the payable period begins.

0 coins

Does that waiting period reset if you have to extend your claim or is it just the one time at the very beginning?

0 coins

Pretty sure it's just at the start of the claim, not every time you extend. Extensions are on the same claim so you're not starting fresh.

0 coins

CASDI and SDI are the same program — the deduction on your stub is labeled California State Disability Insurance, shortened to CASDI, and the benefit people talk about filing for is State Disability Insurance, SDI. Same fund, same program, just two ways the abbreviation shows up depending on who's printing your paperwork. The wages subject to that deduction are what build your base period, which is what EDD uses to figure out your weekly benefit amount if you file a claim.

0 coins

Zara Khan

Author

That actually makes so much sense — I was going around in circles thinking they might be two separate things. So the fact that I see CASDI deducted every pay period means I'm already contributing and would be eligible to file?

0 coins

Having the deduction is a good sign but eligibility also depends on earning at least $300 in wages subject to SDI during your base period and being unable to do your regular work because of the medical situation. EDD makes the final call, but yes, the deduction showing on your stub means your employer is withholding for the program.

0 coins

Worth knowing your base period is a 12-month window, four quarters, and EDD picks the highest-earning quarter to calculate your weekly amount. The Notice of Computation they send you will spell out what number they used for your specific claim.

0 coins

Are you sure the deduction isn't from a Paid Family Leave thing instead of disability? My coworker said they're separate lines and I want to make sure I'm reading mine right too.

0 coins

PFL and DI are both part of the SDI program and they're funded by the same CASDI payroll deduction — there isn't a separate PFL line and a separate DI line on your stub. The deduction covers both programs, so when someone says they have CASDI deducted, that's the one line that funds both.

0 coins

Oh I had no idea they were funded by the same deduction. I thought they were totally separate. Good to know.

0 coins

PFL is a separate type of claim though — like you file a PFL claim for bonding with a new baby, and a DI claim if you're actually sick or recovering. Same deduction funds both but you'd file them differently and they're not the same benefit.

0 coins

You mentioned being out for a few weeks — did you already file a DI claim or are you still figuring that out? Because there's a 49-day window from when your disability started to get the claim in and also to have your doctor submit their part, and that clock doesn't pause while you're researching.

0 coins

Zara Khan

Author

No I haven't filed yet, honestly I didn't even know there was a deadline. So I need to file within 49 days of when I stopped working?

0 coins

49 days from when the disability began, not necessarily when you stopped working, though those are often the same date. You also need to wait at least nine days after the disability start date before filing. File your part first through SDI Online in myEDD, then give the receipt number to your doctor so they can submit the medical certification, also within that 49 days.

0 coins

The receipt number part is important — the doctor needs that specific number to find your claim in the system and attach their certification to it. If they submit without it or use a wrong number the claim can sit pending for a long time.

0 coins

Does the amount of CASDI that shows up on each paycheck affect your benefit or is it just the actual wages that matter? Like would someone with a bigger deduction get more?

0 coins

The deduction amount is just a percentage of your wages, so a bigger deduction means higher wages, which means a higher benefit — but it's the underlying wages EDD uses to calculate, not the deduction line itself. EDD looks at the wages from your base period and estimates your weekly benefit as somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of your highest quarter's weekly average, depending on where your income falls. The calculator on EDD's site can give you an estimate before you even file.

0 coins

That makes sense. I was overthinking it. So basically higher pay equals higher benefit, up to whatever the max is.

0 coins

Exactly right. Your Notice of Computation after you file will show the exact amount EDD determined for your claim.

0 coins

Can someone who is self-employed file for SDI or is this only for people whose employers take out the CASDI deduction?

0 coins

If you're self-employed and haven't opted into SDI through the elective coverage program, you can't file a DI claim. Regular employees who have CASDI withheld automatically are covered. If you're not sure whether you're covered, the best question to bring to EDD is whether your wages in the base period were subject to SDI withholding.

0 coins

Got it, so not being an employee is the reason self-employed people usually can't file, unless they separately signed up. That's a situation I'll have to look into for my own work arrangement.

0 coins

My doctor's office said they already submitted the medical certification but SDI Online still shows my claim as pending. Is that normal or should I be worried that the CASDI I paid in isn't going to cover me?

0 coins

Pending after the certification goes in is pretty common, especially in the first week or two. EDD typically contacts you within 14 days after getting a properly completed claim. The thing to double-check is whether your doctor used the receipt number you got when you filed — if they submitted without it, the certification might not have matched to your claim.

0 coins

They said they submitted through SDI Online but I'm not sure if I ever gave them the receipt number. I'll call the office and ask which number they used when they filed it.

0 coins

Also worth using the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online to ask EDD directly whether the medical certification has been received and matched. That way you have a record of the question and don't have to wait by the phone.

0 coins

Base period question came up for me in a confusing way — I had a quarter where I worked a lot of overtime and I wasn't sure if EDD would use that quarter or a quieter one. The agent I reached after trying Claimyr for my own claim looked up which quarter was actually pulled for my base period calculation and read me the wage figure from that quarter. It matched my highest-earning quarter, which was the overtime one, so that settled it. I stopped guessing and just waited for the Notice of Computation to arrive with the official number.

0 coins

Did EDD give you any sense of how much your weekly amount would be before the Notice arrived, or did you just have to wait for the paper?

0 coins

The agent told me which quarter was used and what the wage figure was, but said the Notice of Computation is what confirms the actual weekly benefit amount. I used EDD's online calculator to get a rough estimate in the meantime.

0 coins

Zara Khan

Author

How long did the Notice of Computation take to arrive after you filed? I'm trying to figure out what to expect on my own claim.

0 coins

Mine showed up in SDI Online before the paper copy came in the mail, maybe 10 days or so after I filed. But it doesn't mean you're approved — the notice just shows the potential benefit amount based on your wages.

0 coins

Is there any difference in how much CASDI you need to have paid in before you can get benefits? Like is there a minimum number of paychecks or months contributing?

0 coins

The requirement EDD uses is wages in the base period — you need at least $300 in wages that were subject to SDI withholding during that 12-month base period window. It's not about the number of paychecks or how long you've been with an employer, just whether the wages in those four quarters hit that floor.

0 coins

So theoretically someone could have just started a job a few months ago and still qualify as long as they hit that $300 threshold in the base period?

0 coins

The base period looks back 5 to 18 months before your claim start date, so a brand-new employee might not have wages in those quarters yet depending on when they started. Definitely worth checking EDD's calculator or calling to ask which quarters would apply to your specific claim start date.

0 coins

Wait, I thought SDI and workers' comp were the same thing. If I got hurt at work can I file for CASDI benefits?

0 coins

Workers' comp and SDI are different programs. SDI through your CASDI deduction covers non-work-related illnesses, injuries, pregnancy and childbirth — stuff that happens away from the job. A work injury goes through workers' compensation. EDD actually says it's not common to receive both at the same time, though there are exceptions. If your injury happened on the job, workers' comp is the right starting point.

0 coins

Oh wow I completely had that backwards. I thought CASDI was just the umbrella and workers' comp was under it. They're totally separate programs.

0 coins

Yeah the CASDI deduction is just for the SDI program — disability and PFL. Workers' comp comes from a completely different place, usually funded by the employer not the employee.

0 coins

Does filing for SDI affect unemployment at all? I'm asking because I might be getting laid off right around when I'm planning to go back to work and I want to know if the two would overlap.

0 coins

You can't collect both for the same days — EDD is explicit about that. DI is for the days you can't work because of a medical reason. Unemployment requires being able to work and available for work every week you claim it. If you're still unable to work, you're on DI. When you recover and can work again, that's when unemployment would apply if you've been laid off by then.

0 coins

So basically once my doctor clears me and I'm able to work, that's when I could switch over to unemployment if the layoff has already happened?

0 coins

That's the general idea — DI ends when you can work, and unemployment starts when you're able and available but don't have a job. EDD handles each claim separately so you'd file for unemployment when you reach that point.

0 coins

Just want to add that EDD decides each one based on your specific situation. The timing matters and so does how your last day of disability and the layoff line up. Definitely ask EDD directly when you get to that point rather than assuming how it'll play out.

0 coins

My claim has been in for three weeks and I still haven't gotten a Notice of Computation or any payment. I called the EDD disability line a few times and couldn't get through. Is this how it always goes or is something actually wrong?

0 coins

Three weeks without a Notice of Computation is worth following up on. Did your doctor get the medical certification submitted? If EDD doesn't have both your part and the doctor's certification, the claim just sits. Check SDI Online under your claim to see if there's any status showing what's missing.

0 coins

I checked and it says the certification was submitted but I still haven't heard anything. The pending status has just been sitting there.

0 coins

At that point I'd use the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online to send EDD a direct message on the claim. Explain that it's been three weeks since the certification was submitted and ask what the status is. That creates a written record and sometimes moves things faster than just waiting.

0 coins

I didn't know about the Request Claim Update option. I'll try that today before I attempt the phone again.

0 coins

Is the CASDI deduction supposed to show on a W-2 at the end of the year? Mine showed all year on my stubs but I don't remember seeing it on the W-2 and now I'm second-guessing whether it was really being withheld.

0 coins

CASDI typically shows in box 14 of a W-2 as a state tax or as SDI, depending on how your employer's payroll system labels it. If you're not seeing it, it might be listed under a different label in that box, or it's possible your employer's W-2 uses a different notation. Your pay stubs are the clearest record of what was actually deducted each period — if CASDI appears there consistently, it was being withheld.

0 coins

Mine does say SDI in box 14 actually, I just didn't connect that to CASDI. So same thing, different label again.

0 coins

Exactly — SDI in box 14 is the same withholding. The inconsistency in labels between stubs and W-2s trips a lot of people up but it's the same deduction.

0 coins

Payment method ended up being something I had to phone EDD about on my own claim. The claim was approved and I was expecting a direct deposit but nothing showed up in my bank. Used Claimyr to get a live EDD agent on the line, who checked my payment method on file and told me direct deposit had not been selected — the payment had gone to a Money Network prepaid debit card instead. The agent walked me through confirming the card was mailed and I ended up activating it to access the funds.

0 coins

Wait, it's not Bank of America anymore? I thought EDD sent payments to a BofA card — when did that change?

0 coins

The card is Money Network now, not Bank of America. If you're expecting a card it'll come from Money Network. Direct deposit is an option too if you set it up in SDI Online before or during your claim.

0 coins

Zara Khan

Author

So if I want direct deposit I need to choose that in SDI Online when I file, not just assume it'll go to my bank?

0 coins

You set it up in SDI Online — there's a payment method option in your claim settings. If you don't choose direct deposit it defaults to the Money Network card. Worth checking before your first payment is issued so you're not hunting for a card you weren't expecting.

0 coins

What happens to your CASDI coverage if you switch jobs in the middle of a claim? Like if I filed, got approved, and then my employer ended my job while I was out — does the SDI just stop?

0 coins

The right question to ask EDD in that situation is what happens to the DI benefit for the days you're still unable to work. What these facts say is that DI covers days you can't do your regular work because of a medical reason, and unemployment is for when you're able and available to work again. How EDD treats a job ending during an active claim is specific to each case — ask EDD directly rather than counting on a general answer here.

0 coins

That's fair. I figured the answer might depend on specifics. I'll ask EDD when it comes up rather than assume.

0 coins

Medical certification was the step that held up my claim the longest, and I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr to find out what was actually happening. The agent checked and said the certification had come in but was matched to a different receipt number — my doctor's office had used an old number from a previous claim I had filed two years earlier. The agent told me to have the provider resubmit using the receipt number from this new claim. My doctor's office resubmitted that same day and the pending status cleared within about a week.

0 coins

This is exactly what I'm worried about with my own claim. How do I make sure the receipt number my doctor has is the right one for this claim and not an old one?

0 coins

When you filed, SDI Online gave you a receipt number on the confirmation screen — that's the one for this claim. Give it to your doctor's office in writing, not just verbally, so they can double-check it against what they have on file before they submit anything.

0 coins

Also worth confirming with the office that they're submitting through SDI Online for this claim specifically and not using a paper DE 2501 leftover from a previous submission. Mixing paper and online on the same claim can cause the certification not to match.

0 coins

The mixing of paper and online is a real issue — the agent mentioned that too. Once you file online, the certification should come in online as well. Having the office confirm which method they're using is a good call.

0 coins

Completely lost on where to even start filing. I looked up SDI Online and it seems like I need a myEDD account first — is that right or is there a faster way to just get the claim going?

0 coins

myEDD is the entry point — you create an account there and then access SDI Online through it. It's the fastest way EDD has set up for filing. The alternative is a paper DE 2501 mailed in, but that's slower. If you go through myEDD you can file your part, get your receipt number, and hand it to your doctor all in one session.

0 coins

Is the myEDD account the same one people use for unemployment, or is it a separate login?

0 coins

Same account — myEDD is the umbrella login EDD uses for different programs including unemployment and SDI. If you already have one from a past UI claim you can use it to access SDI Online without creating a new account.

0 coins

My physical therapist said she can submit the medical certification for my SDI claim — is that actually allowed or do I need to go back to my regular doctor?

0 coins

Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of providers who can certify a DI claim. The list includes licensed physicians and osteopathic doctors, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, licensed midwives, nurse-midwives, and certain government facility medical officers and accredited religious practitioners — but not physical therapists. You'd need to get the certification from one of those listed providers, so your prescribing physician or a qualifying provider who is overseeing your treatment would be the right person to ask.

0 coins

My PT seemed pretty confident she could do it — are you sure about this? She's a licensed provider.

0 coins

The EDD list is specific about which license types qualify, and physical therapists aren't included regardless of their license level. If your PT submits it, EDD likely won't accept it and your claim could sit without a valid certification. Worth double-checking with EDD directly, but don't rely on the PT's understanding of EDD's rules here.

0 coins

Okay that's concerning. I'll go back to my orthopedic surgeon's office and ask them to submit it instead. I don't want to lose time on this.

0 coins

Are there situations where someone would have CASDI on their stubs but still not qualify for SDI benefits? Like is there a gap between paying in and being covered?

0 coins

If the wages in your base period — that 12-month window EDD looks back at — total less than $300 subject to SDI withholding, EDD could find you ineligible even if you have CASDI on recent stubs. The base period looks back 5 to 18 months before your claim starts, so very recent wages might not count. Someone who just started contributing in the last few months might not have enough in the base period yet depending on the timing.

0 coins

So theoretically my CASDI from last month might not even count toward eligibility if I filed today?

0 coins

Depending on when in the quarter you are, the most recent wages might fall in a quarter that isn't part of the base period yet. EDD's online calculator can show you which quarters they'd use if you enter your claim start date, which is the clearest way to check your own situation.

0 coins

This is why it's worth filing as soon as you're eligible rather than waiting — the base period shifts based on your claim start date, so the timing actually matters for which wages count.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure