Back to California Disability

Mei-Ling Chen

How to pay off SDI overpayment over 24 months — has anyone done this?

So I got hit with an overpayment notice from EDD for my disability claim and the amount is not small. I went back to work part time toward the end of my claim and I thought I reported everything correctly through SDI Online, but apparently EDD thinks I was paid too much for a few weeks. The notice came in the mail and my stomach just dropped. I know you can appeal within 30 days of the date on it, but honestly I'm not sure I have a great case since the weeks they listed do roughly line up with when I went back part time. What I really want to know is whether EDD lets you stretch out repayment. I've heard something about being able to pay it off over 24 months but I have no idea how to actually set that up or whether it's automatic. Has anyone dealt with paying back an SDI overpayment and gotten some kind of payment plan? What did you have to do to get it?

DE 2517 in hand, October 3rd, the amount EDD said I owed on my own claim was more than I expected after returning to light duty. Spent three mornings dialing 1-800-480-3287 and landing on a recording. Tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up on the phone with an EDD disability agent that same afternoon. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my file and confirmed EDD had received the medical certification from my provider and matched it to the right claim ID. That was the piece I'd been unsure about. For anyone watching an overpayment balance, the agent said to contact EDD directly to discuss repayment options, because the terms aren't set by SDI Online.

0 coins

My extension form is what I'm not sure about, whether the DE 2525XX my doctor sent in actually got attached to the right claim. I think I'm going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready before the call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the date your doctor submitted the form. The agent can look up what EDD has on file by claim ID.

0 coins

DE 2517 is the denial or overpayment notice, right? I keep mixing up which form is which and I want to make sure I'm reading mine correctly before I do anything.

0 coins

The DE 2517 is the Notice of Determination, yes. It's the document EDD sends when they've made a decision on your claim, whether that's a denial or an overpayment finding. The appeal form, DE 1000A, comes with it.

0 coins

From what I've read on EDD's site, the appeal window is 30 days from the date printed on the notice, not the date you received it. So if it sat in the mail a few days, that counts against you. Worth double-checking that date right now if you're close to the line.

0 coins

The notice came Saturday and I looked it up that same day, so I still have about three weeks. I'm leaning toward not appealing since I honestly did work those weeks, I'm more trying to figure out the repayment side.

0 coins

That's reasonable. If the weeks they flagged are the weeks you worked, disputing the amount owed is harder than just figuring out how to pay it back in a way that doesn't wreck you financially.

0 coins

Appealing when you know you're in the wrong is usually just delaying the inevitable and sometimes adds complications.

0 coins

Repayment arrangements for an SDI overpayment are handled by contacting EDD directly. The notice itself should have information or a contact point for overpayment recovery. If you want to ask about spreading the balance over a longer period, that conversation happens with EDD's overpayment unit, not through SDI Online.

0 coins

The notice has a phone number on it that's different from the main disability line. Has anyone actually reached someone at that number, or is it just as bad as 1-800-480-3287?

0 coins

Every EDD phone number I've tried is a 45-minute wait followed by a disconnect. I'd call whichever number is on your notice first since it may route differently, but don't expect a quick answer.

0 coins

Use the number on the notice. That's the right place to start. If it doesn't go through, try SDI Online's Request Claim Update to send a written message.

0 coins

Whether you can stretch repayment to 24 months specifically, or some other term, depends on what EDD's overpayment recovery unit agrees to for your case. No standard schedule is published as far as I've found on edd.ca.gov. The practical step is calling them, having the notice and the overpayment amount in front of you, and asking what terms are available.

0 coins

Is there paperwork involved for a payment plan, or is it just a verbal agreement over the phone?

0 coins

EDD typically sends written confirmation of a repayment agreement. I'd ask the agent to confirm what gets mailed and keep that document once it arrives.

0 coins

Got a letter after I set up a plan on a different EDD matter. Took about two weeks to arrive but it laid out the terms clearly.

0 coins

Waiting period on my own claim was the thing I couldn't get a straight answer on from SDI Online. Called the disability line through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the seven-day waiting period started on the first day I was off, and that the first payable day was day eight. Cleared up two weeks of confusion in about five minutes.

0 coins

My receipt number situation was almost the same kind of stuck-in-limbo feeling. Used Claimyr too on my injury claim. Once I had the agent on the line I read off the receipt number my provider used, and the agent confirmed EDD had matched it to my claim ID. After that I just waited for the Notice of Computation, which showed up about a week later.

0 coins

ive been trying that line since monday and it just cuts out every time, what time did you call

0 coins

Staff are there 8 to 5 Monday through Friday is what it says on EDD's site. I'd just keep trying different mornings.

0 coins

Monday mornings are the worst in my experience, anyway. I've had slightly better luck mid-week but nothing is guaranteed.

0 coins

I went back part time too on my last claim and reported my hours every week. EDD still sent me an overpayment notice three months after the claim closed. Ended up calling and they told me the partial weeks were recalculated and I owed back part of two payments. No fun at all.

0 coins

That's exactly what happened here. I reported every week I worked through SDI Online but the notice showed up long after. Did you end up setting up a payment plan or just paying it in one shot?

0 coins

Paid it in full because I didn't want it hanging over me. But my amount was manageable. If yours is bigger, definitely ask about spreading it out.

0 coins

Partial week pay is calculated by EDD and honestly their math sometimes surprises you even when you think you reported everything right. Not saying you did anything wrong, the formula just isn't obvious.

0 coins

The 24-month figure you heard about isn't something EDD advertises openly, as far as I can tell. Some people report setting up plans over that length, some shorter. It seems to be case by case. You have to ask and negotiate rather than assume any specific term is available.

0 coins

That tracks with how most government overpayment recovery works. The agency has discretion on terms, so the more you can demonstrate hardship, the better your negotiating position tends to be.

0 coins

That's good to know. I was worried they'd just demand payment in full within 30 days. If there's room to negotiate I'll go into that call prepared to explain my situation.

0 coins

Be straightforward when you call. Tell them what you can realistically afford per month. They've heard it before and it's better than agreeing to something you can't keep up.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. If you appeal, does the repayment get paused while EDD reviews it? Or do they still want money during the appeal?

0 coins

The appeal form DE 1000A goes to the address on the notice, and EDD's overpayment recovery unit is separate from the appeals process. I'd ask EDD directly when you call whether the balance is held during a pending appeal, because that varies and I wouldn't want to give you a wrong answer on that piece.

0 coins

Good question to put to the agent when you call. Write it down so you don't forget to ask it in the moment.

0 coins

DE 1000A goes to the address on the notice, got it. I'll add the hold question to my list.

0 coins

Base period quarter on my own injury claim was something I wanted to verify before my Notice of Computation arrived. After four mornings of getting cut off on 1-800-480-3287, I tried Claimyr and reached an EDD agent. The agent pulled up my claim and told me which quarter EDD had used as my highest-paid quarter for the base period calculation, so I could check it against my own wage records before the notice came.

0 coins

Four mornings and nothing. That's about where I gave up last time too. How is Claimyr actually supposed to help with that, it doesn't sound real to me.

0 coins

I had the same doubt, but what happened was I ended up talking to an EDD disability agent who had my actual claim on the screen. The quarter she named matched what I'd calculated myself from my pay stubs, so I knew the Notice of Computation would be in the right ballpark.

0 coins

I've used it too on my own claim! The agent I spoke with confirmed the Notice of Computation had been generated and told me the weekly amount on it. I was so relieved to actually know the number before the envelope showed up.

0 coins

Okay, that part about the agent reading off the actual number on the notice is useful. That's something SDI Online doesn't just show you while you're waiting.

0 coins

When you call EDD to talk about repayment, have the notice number, the overpayment amount, and a rough idea of what monthly payment you can handle. They need that to put anything in writing for you.

0 coins

Notice number, overpayment amount, monthly figure I can swing. Writing all three down right now.

0 coins

Also keep notes from the call, the agent's ID if they give one, the date, what they said. That way if the written confirmation doesn't match, you have something to refer to.

0 coins

my coworker had an overpayment and just paid the whole thing on edd's site, didnt even call anyone. not sure if that works for a big amount but its an option

0 coins

Paying through EDD's site is fine for a lump sum, but if the goal is to pay off SDI overpayment over 24 months, you'd need a formal arrangement first. You can't just start sending partial payments and assume EDD has agreed to a plan.

0 coins

oh that makes sense, didnt think about the plan part

0 coins

Does getting a payment plan affect your ability to file a new disability claim later? Like does EDD flag your account or something?

0 coins

An open overpayment balance can affect future payments in that EDD may offset future benefits to recover what's owed. Ask EDD how that works for your specific situation when you call.

0 coins

Offset meaning they'd take money out of a future claim automatically? That's something I need to understand before I decide anything.

0 coins

Worth asking EDD directly when you call about the repayment plan. That's the kind of case-specific answer they can give you.

0 coins

My situation was different but my overpayment ended up smaller than the notice first said because I sent in the pay stubs for the weeks they flagged and EDD adjusted the amount. If you have documentation of what you actually earned those partial weeks, it might be worth submitting it even if you're not formally appealing.

0 coins

I do have all my pay stubs from those weeks saved in my email. So even without filing a full appeal I could send those in and ask EDD to verify the calculation?

0 coins

That's what I did. I sent them through SDI Online's message function, referenced the notice number, and asked them to review the partial week earnings. Took a few weeks to hear back but the amount changed.

0 coins

Document everything before you send it. Keep copies of the stubs and a record of when and how you submitted them. If the amount changes you want a paper trail.

0 coins

the 24 month thing, did someone in this thread actually confirm that's a real option EDD offers or is it just something people have heard

0 coins

Nothing published as a guaranteed option from what I can find. Seems to depend on what you owe and what you can show about your finances. EDD has discretion.

0 coins

okay so its worth asking but not guaranteed, that's what I figured

0 coins

Before calling EDD about a repayment plan, write out your monthly income and expenses so you have a real number to offer. If you propose a monthly amount and EDD agrees to it, that becomes the basis for the written plan.

0 coins

Budget worksheet first, then the call. That's a good way to go in organized instead of just asking them to pick a number for me.

0 coins

Exactly. If you let them set the number without input from you it may be higher than you can manage.

0 coins

One thing that helped a friend of mine on a similar situation was asking EDD in writing through SDI Online first, before calling, just to get something on record. The response came through the portal and had more detail than she expected.

0 coins

I didn't know you could ask overpayment questions through SDI Online's message function. I assumed it was only for claim status stuff.

0 coins

Request Claim Update in SDI Online, pick the type closest to your question, and type it in. It goes to EDD and they respond in the portal. Not instant but it's documented.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update route is good for things you want in writing. For something as important as a repayment agreement, having written confirmation from EDD matters a lot.

0 coins

Is the 30-day appeal window totally firm or is there any leeway if you missed it, asking for my own situation where the notice sat unopened for a bit anyway

0 coins

A late appeal needs a written explanation of why it's late, which an administrative law judge reviews. It's not automatic, but it's not automatically denied either. You'd include that explanation with the DE 1000A and mail it to the address on the notice.

0 coins

Okay so there's a path even if I'm past 30 days, it's just harder. Good to know.

0 coins

The explanation needs to be specific, not just 'I didn't see it in time.' Something that shows why the delay was reasonable helps your case with the judge.

0 coins

Has anyone looked into whether the overpayment amount is correct before agreeing to pay it? I feel like sometimes EDD's math is off and claimants just accept the number.

0 coins

The poster above who mentioned submitting pay stubs had the right idea. If you have records for those weeks, compare them to what EDD says the overpayment is based on. The Notice of Determination should explain which weeks and amounts are in dispute.

0 coins

EDD's math was off on mine by about two weeks of wages. The pay stubs fixed it. Never just accept the number without checking it against your own records.

0 coins

Pulling out every pay stub from those weeks tonight. I want to verify the amount before I agree to anything, let alone set up a plan to pay it off.

0 coins

Asking EDD to explain the calculation in writing, through SDI Online's message function, is worth doing before you agree to any repayment amount. Get the breakdown first.

0 coins

Agreed. A written breakdown protects you if the amount turns out to be wrong. You have something concrete to point to when you dispute it.

0 coins

Request Claim Update for overpayment questions, choose whichever type fits, and type your question out clearly. EDD responds in the portal.

0 coins

EDD will not just forget about an overpayment if you ignore it. Respond to the notice, ask about the plan, and get it in writing. That's the whole job here.

0 coins

No plan to ignore it. Just wanted to understand my options before calling so I didn't go in blind. This thread helped a lot.

0 coins

Then you're ahead of most people who get one of those notices.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure