How to fix false statement penalty week on a California EDD disability claim
Okay so I'm trying to figure out how to fix false statement penalty week that showed up on my SDI claim and I'm kind of panicking. Some background: I was out for about six weeks earlier this year after a back injury kept me from doing my warehouse job. Filed everything through SDI Online, got my medical certification in from my doctor, got the Notice of Computation, all that. Then I went back to work part time for a couple weeks before my doctor cleared me fully, and I reported it — or at least I thought I reported it correctly. Now I've got a notice saying I have a false statement penalty week and I genuinely do not understand what triggered this. I didn't intentionally misrepresent anything. Has anyone dealt with this and actually gotten it resolved? I don't even know if I should be appealing or if there's some other process to go through here.
77 comments

Dyllan Nantx
Paid weeks on my claim went sideways in a similar stretch, and when I couldn't get through on the disability line I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live EDD agent on the phone. Video on reaching someone at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which weeks had been issued and which were still pending, and that one week was flagged because my part-time hours overlapped a week I'd already been paid in full for. That was the week that caused the issue — once I knew which one it was, I could address it in my appeal letter with the right details.
0 coins
TillyCombatwarrior
Knowing the exact week is half the battle honestly. When I filed my appeal I was vague about dates and the whole thing dragged on longer because they had to piece together what I was even disputing.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorWhich number did you call to get through? I've been dialing 1-800-480-3287 and sitting on hold for over an hour each time with nothing.
0 coins
Dyllan Nantx
That's the right number, 1-800-480-3287. Staff are there 8 to 5 Monday through Friday. I'd tried that same number multiple times before I tried the other route.
0 coins
Anna Xian
Penalty weeks on a disability claim and an appeal are two different things worth separating out in your head. If EDD issued a Notice of Determination (the DE 2517) with the penalty, the Appeal Form that comes with it is the DE 1000A and you have 30 days from the date on that notice to file it. That's the window. If you think the penalty was wrong — and it sounds like you do — you write up a detailed explanation of what you actually reported and when, attach anything you have showing you tried to report the part-time work correctly, and send it to the return address on the notice. Don't mail it to some general EDD address.
0 coins
Jungleboo Soletrain
Tried to send my appeal to the wrong address the first time and it caused a delay. The return address printed on the notice is what matters, not anything you find by searching online.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorMine says DE 2517 at the top so at least I have the right form. The date on it is from about two weeks ago so I still have time but I want to move fast.
0 coins
Rajan Walker
Two weeks still leaves room, but write that appeal letter now. Pulling together pay stubs and your SDI Online activity from those part-time weeks before you sit down to write it will make the letter a lot more specific and specific letters do better.
0 coins
Nadia Zaldivar
I assumed for a while that a penalty week just meant a processing delay — like EDD was holding the payment while they looked into something. It's actually a formal determination that you made a false statement, which is why the DE 2517 comes with the appeal form attached. The distinction matters because a processing delay clears on its own, but a penalty week doesn't go away unless you appeal or EDD reverses it.
0 coins
Lukas Fitzgerald
Had that same misunderstanding and waited three weeks thinking it would just resolve. By the time I understood it was a formal determination I had used up most of my 30-day window.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorReading this thread is clarifying things a lot. I had been treating it like a flag that might just drop off.
0 coins
Ev Luca
Filing that appeal as soon as you can, even if your letter isn't perfect yet, is better than missing the deadline. You can send additional documentation after, but the 30-day clock on the DE 1000A is firm.
0 coins
Avery Davis
Part-time work reporting on SDI is one of the most confusing parts of the whole system, and a lot of people end up with these notices not because they were trying to hide anything but because the reporting process for partial weeks isn't intuitive. When you say you thought you reported it correctly — do you know if you reported the gross wages or just the hours? And did you report during the right certification period? Those are the two places where mismatches usually happen in my experience.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorHonestly I'm not 100% sure I reported gross wages versus net. I remember putting in hours but I may have just estimated the dollar amount. That could be the issue right there.
0 coins
Avery Davis
Estimating or using net instead of gross would create a discrepancy between what you reported and what your employer's wage records show when EDD cross-checks. That's often what triggers these. Your appeal letter should address it directly — explain the error was an honest mistake in how you reported, not an intent to get more than you were owed.
0 coins
Collins Angel
Intentional versus unintentional matters a lot in these appeals. The language you use in your letter framing it as a reporting error rather than a deliberate misstatement is worth being careful about.
0 coins
Marcelle Drum
Appeals that go in with nothing attached almost always take longer to resolve than ones with documentation. For a penalty week tied to part-time work, the most useful things to bring are your pay stubs covering the weeks in question, any emails or records of contact with EDD during those weeks, and screenshots or printouts from SDI Online showing what you certified and when. If your employer can give you a letter or payroll records confirming the exact hours and wages, that helps too.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorMy employer does digital pay stubs through an HR portal, so I can pull the exact amounts for every week. That's probably going to be the strongest piece of documentation I have.
0 coins
Marcelle Drum
Exact payroll records are exactly what you want. Cross-reference them against the weeks on your Notice of Computation and your certification records so you can show, week by week, what you earned, what you reported, and what EDD paid. Presenting it that way makes it easy for the reviewer to follow.
0 coins
Tate Jensen
Pay stubs saved me in my appeal. Had a discrepancy because my pay period didn't align with the EDD certification week and the stubs showed that clearly — the overlap wasn't me double-dipping, it was just a calendar mismatch.
0 coins
Adaline Wong
DE 2525XX came into my situation near the end of a long injury claim — my doctor submitted the extension form but I wasn't sure EDD had received it, so I ended up phoning EDD about it. Used Claimyr to get through and the agent confirmed the DE 2525XX was in their system and told me which weeks the extension covered. That detail helped me know exactly when my benefits would continue through, so I didn't have to guess or assume.
0 coins
TillyCombatwarrior
Knowing whether the extension was actually received versus just submitted by the doctor's office is a question I've had too. Those are two different things and SDI Online doesn't always reflect the receipt immediately.
0 coins
Adaline Wong
The agent told me the date it was received, which was a few days after the doctor's office said they'd sent it. So there was a lag, but it did get there. Having that date was useful for my records.
0 coins
Gabriel Ruiz
Appeals after penalty weeks are worth filing even if you're not sure you'll win. The administrative law judge process exists specifically to let you present your side of what happened. If you miss the 30-day window the DE 1000A gives you, you can still appeal late but you'll need to explain in writing why the appeal is late, and a judge has to decide whether that reason is acceptable before they even look at the underlying penalty. It's a much harder road than just filing on time.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorHave not missed the window yet — the notice is dated about two weeks back so I should have around two weeks left. Submitting this week.
0 coins
Gabriel Ruiz
Submitting this week is the right call. Mail it with tracking so you have proof of the date it was sent.
0 coins
Jungleboo Soletrain
Certified mail with return receipt is what I used for my appeal documents. Having the postmark and the delivery confirmation gave me something to point to if there was ever a question about timing.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
Read somewhere that you can get penalty weeks waived by calling EDD and explaining yourself, without having to do a full appeal. That's not accurate. If a DE 2517 has been issued, the formal appeal process through the DE 1000A is the way to contest it. Phone calls to EDD agents don't reverse formal determinations — an appeal to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board is what does.
0 coins
Peyton Clarke
Went down that path myself thinking a call would sort it out. Spent a lot of time on hold and the agent was clear they couldn't change a formal determination over the phone. Had to file the appeal anyway.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorGood to know that now before I spend more hours on hold trying to explain myself verbally.
0 coins
Vince Eh
Notice of Computation on my claim had a base period I didn't recognize, and I wasn't sure which quarter it was drawing from, so I phoned EDD. I'd tried a few times on my own and kept running into busy signals so I used Claimyr to get a live agent. She told me exactly which quarter they'd used as my highest-earning quarter and what wages were on file for it. Turned out one employer's wages hadn't been reported yet so the amount on the notice was lower than it should have been — I hadn't realized until I asked.
0 coins
Rajan Walker
Wages from a job not yet reported to EDD is a real thing that happens, especially if you recently changed employers or had two jobs at once. Getting that corrected before the claim closes matters.
0 coins
Vince Eh
The agent told me to wait for the corrected wages to show up in EDD's system, then contact EDD again to get the Notice of Computation reviewed. It was an extra step but the difference in my weekly amount was significant.
0 coins
Tate Jensen
Always worth checking the base period quarters against your own records. I had a quarter where I'd had a gap in employment and the wages pulled from a different quarter than I expected.
0 coins
Sophia Gabriel
Confusion I had early on was treating the penalty week the same as the seven-day waiting period at the start of a new claim. The waiting period is built into every new claim — the first week is just not payable, and that's normal. A penalty week is something else entirely, it's EDD saying a specific certification had a problem. Two completely different things, same word 'week' but nothing alike.
0 coins
Lukas Fitzgerald
Mixed those up myself at first. Spent time worrying about the waiting period on a new claim thinking I'd done something wrong, when actually it just applies to everyone.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorHad no idea about the waiting period being standard. I went through that on my initial claim and stressed out thinking it was a flag on my account.
0 coins
Sophia Gabriel
The waiting period on your original claim is totally separate from any penalty. It is the first seven days, they're just not payable, and it has nothing to do with your reporting or certifications. The penalty is an entirely different animal.
0 coins
TillyCombatwarrior
Part-time work reporting is confusing because people assume SDI just cuts off if you work any hours. What actually happens is you report what you earned and EDD determines how that week is paid. When the reported amount doesn't match what EDD gets from employer wage records, that's where the discrepancy turns into a problem. The penalty isn't necessarily about working — it's about the mismatch between what you reported and what their records show.
0 coins
Anna Xian
The mismatch is the key thing. Someone could work part time for the whole tail end of their claim and have no issues at all if the reporting matched. It's the gap between the two records that creates the problem.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorThis is basically what I think happened — I reported something but my estimate was off and the actual wage record showed a different number. So the mismatch is there even though I wasn't trying to hide anything.
0 coins
TillyCombatwarrior
That framing — honest reporting error, not intentional misstatement — is exactly what should be in your appeal letter. Explain what you understood about how to report, what you actually put down, and why there's a difference between that and your employer's record.
0 coins
Ev Luca
Went through a penalty week dispute after my surgery recovery ran longer than expected and I had a complicated stretch of partial weeks. The administrative law judge hearing wasn't as scary as I expected. You present your documentation, explain what happened, and they ask questions. It's not a courtroom. What helped me most was having a written timeline with dates and amounts attached to each entry — when I worked, what I earned, what I certified, and what EDD paid each week.
0 coins
Jungleboo Soletrain
Timeline format is underrated for these hearings. Judges deal with a lot of cases and anything that makes yours easy to follow at a glance is going to help.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorAre the hearings in person or by phone? I'm still not fully recovered and can't easily travel.
0 coins
Ev Luca
Hearings can be by phone. When you file the appeal the scheduling process includes options, and you can request a phone hearing. Make sure you're in a quiet place with a good connection.
0 coins
Collins Angel
Something I got wrong before my own penalty dispute was thinking I needed a lawyer before I could file the appeal. The DE 1000A can be filed on your own — you don't need legal representation. If the appeal goes to a hearing and the amount in question is large, some people choose to get help from a worker's rights organization, but representation is optional throughout the process.
0 coins
Peyton Clarke
Filed mine completely on my own and it was resolved without a hearing. The written explanation and documentation were enough for them to reverse it without having to schedule anything.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorKnowing it doesn't require a lawyer upfront is actually a relief. I can get the appeal in now and then figure out next steps.
0 coins
Collins Angel
Get the appeal in first, definitely. You can add documentation and get help later, but the 30-day window is the one thing you absolutely can't get back if you miss it.
0 coins
Tobias Lancaster
Claim start date on my file was different from what I thought I'd put when I filed, and it was affecting which weeks were showing as payable. I'd tried to sort it out through SDI Online messages but wasn't getting a clear answer, so I ended up using Claimyr to reach an EDD agent. The agent confirmed the start date in their system, which was a day off from what I'd entered, and explained that the date as filed was what the claim was built from.
0 coins
Tate Jensen
A one-day difference in start date changes the waiting period and the first payable day. It seems small but it cascades through the whole claim.
0 coins
Tobias Lancaster
Exactly — the first payable day moved, which meant one week that I thought was covered wasn't. Knowing the exact date in their system let me decide whether to address it in an appeal or just move forward.
0 coins
Avery Davis
Worth pointing out that going back to part-time work is not the same as your disability ending. EDD's process for partial weeks is different from just flipping a switch back to employed. If you're still under a doctor's restriction and working reduced hours because of that, the medical certification side of your claim is still relevant. Some people close out their disability claim the moment they go back part time and then realize they should have reported the partial weeks instead.
0 coins
Lukas Fitzgerald
Did exactly that — closed out thinking I had to, then realized I could have been reporting partial weeks the whole time instead. Had to sort out what I was actually owed versus what I'd already received.
0 coins
Anna Xian
Closing the claim early and then trying to reopen it or file a new one creates complications. Reporting partial weeks through the same claim is the cleaner path when you're still under medical restriction.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorMine was still open when I went back part time, I didn't close it. The issue was just in how I reported the wages during those weeks. So hopefully the appeal can address that specific window.
0 coins
Peyton Clarke
Appeal letters that work are really specific about what week is disputed, what the actual hours and wages were, and why the number reported doesn't match the employer's record. Vague letters that just say 'I didn't mean to do anything wrong' don't give the reviewer much to work with. The more precisely you can describe what happened — including the honest mistake in reporting method if that's what it was — the clearer the path to resolution.
0 coins
TillyCombatwarrior
Reviewed a few sample appeal letters through a worker's rights organization before I wrote mine and the difference between a vague one and a specific one was stark. The specific ones read like you actually understand your own claim.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorGoing to build mine around the actual week, the actual pay stub amount, what I entered in SDI Online, and then explain the gross versus net mistake directly. Does the letter need to be a certain length?
0 coins
Peyton Clarke
No required length — the content is what matters. Some effective appeals are a page, some are three. What you want is enough detail that someone reading it can follow exactly what happened without having to guess.
0 coins
Marcelle Drum
Appeals filing mailing — just to be direct about the mechanics — goes to the return address on the DE 2517 itself, not to any EDD field office you happen to know about and not to a general EDD mailing address. The notice prints that address because it routes to the correct appeals unit. If you file online through myEDD, the Request Claim Update path in SDI Online is another way to send written communication to EDD, but for a formal appeal the DE 1000A mailed to that address or submitted as directed on the notice is the proper route.
0 coins
Jungleboo Soletrain
Used myEDD to send a message once thinking it was the same as filing an appeal and the response I got back made it clear that a formal appeal required the DE 1000A. The message route is for questions, not appeals.
0 coins
Gabriel Ruiz
The DE 1000A also has a space for a detailed statement on it. Some people attach a separate letter with more space, which is fine — the form just needs to be included with that additional explanation.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorGoing to print the form and attach a full letter. Sending both together makes sense so there's no ambiguity about what I'm filing.
0 coins
Rajan Walker
Certifications during the period you're appealing are still required if your claim is otherwise active. Some people stop certifying thinking the whole claim is frozen while an appeal is in progress, then end up with a gap they can't recover. If EDD is still sending you forms or you're on automatic payment and the DE 2593 arrives, respond to those on schedule regardless of what's happening with the penalty appeal.
0 coins
Ev Luca
Had a gap in certifications during my appeal period and sorting that out added time to the whole resolution. The penalty dispute and the ongoing certification are parallel tracks — missing one doesn't excuse the other.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorMy claim actually ended before the penalty notice arrived because I went back to full-time work. So there's nothing active to certify right now — this is just about the penalty on the closed period.
0 coins
Rajan Walker
If the claim is fully closed that simplifies it. The appeal is just about those disputed weeks, and you don't have an ongoing certification obligation on top of it.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
For anyone confused about whether a disability false statement penalty week is the same process as an unemployment false statement penalty week — they're separate systems. SDI is not unemployment. Someone receiving disability benefits because they can't work is not eligible to also claim unemployment for the same days, since unemployment requires being able and available to work. The appeal process for a DI penalty goes through the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board but the program and the rules are distinct.
0 coins
Sophia Gabriel
The EDD handles both programs which is why people mix them up. But the requirements are different — disability is because you can't work, unemployment is because you can work but don't have a job. Those are opposite situations.
0 coins
Nadia Zaldivar
Had a coworker who tried to file both at once after a layoff during their recovery. EDD contacted them pretty quickly about it because you can't collect both for the same period.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
The rule is you can't be paid for the same days under both programs. Someone who recovers and then has their job eliminated could move to unemployment once they're able and available to work again — but only after the disability period ends.
0 coins
Tate Jensen
Documentation you put together for this appeal is worth keeping even after the dispute resolves. If EDD ever questions the same period again or you file a future claim and there's a cross-check on the prior claim's wages, having your records organized makes it much easier. I keep a folder for each SDI claim with pay stubs, the Notice of Computation, every DE form that came in, and any correspondence.
0 coins
Marcelle Drum
Organized records saved me when a question came up on a later claim about wages in an overlapping quarter. Had everything pulled and sorted already.
0 coins
Destiny Bryant
AuthorStarting that habit now. I had most of the pieces but not in one place, which is part of why figuring out what happened with those weeks took me so long. Going to build the folder while I'm pulling everything for the appeal letter.
0 coins
Tate Jensen
Building it while everything is fresh is the right time. The Notice of Computation, the DE 2517, the pay stubs for every week in question, and whatever confirmation you get from filing the appeal — all of it in one place.
0 coins