Back to California Disability

Natasha Orlova

How to dispute SDI not enough wages Notice of Computation

Got my Notice of Computation last week and the weekly benefit amount is way lower than I expected. After some digging I think EDD pulled wages from a quarter where I had barely worked because I'd just started a new job, instead of the quarter where I actually earned most of my income. I'm a grad student who also works part time at a university lab, and my hours fluctuate a lot by semester. The notice shows a potential weekly benefit that doesn't come close to reflecting my actual earnings from earlier this year. I know there's an appeal form somewhere on the notice itself but I have no idea what grounds I'd use, whether 'not enough wages' is even something I can push back on, or whether I'm misreading how they pick the base period quarters in the first place. Has anyone actually disputed a Notice of Computation and gotten it recalculated?

The appeal form is the DE 1000A and it comes attached to your Notice of Computation. You have 30 days from the date printed on the notice to mail it back, so check that date first. When I went through something similar I wrote a detailed letter explaining which quarter I believed should have been used and why, attached my pay stubs for the quarters in question, and mailed everything to the return address on the notice. The letter doesn't need to be formal, just specific about which wages you think were missed or miscounted.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice, not the date I received it. I've had it sitting here for five days already, so I need to move quickly. Thank you for the detail about attaching the pay stubs.

0 coins

Does the DE 1000A have a space to explain everything or is it just a checkbox form? I got a low Notice of Computation too and I don't know if one page is enough to say what happened.

0 coins

The form has a section for your explanation but it's small. I'd recommend writing a separate letter and treating the form as the cover page. Keep a copy of everything you mail.

0 coins

Claim start date on mine was entered wrong and that threw off the whole base period, so I ended up with a low figure too. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the line with an EDD agent who pulled up my claim and confirmed the start date they had on file was off by almost two weeks, which pushed me into a lighter earning quarter. Here's a short video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Filed the DE 1000A the same afternoon with the corrected date as the basis for the dispute. Anyway, worth checking your own start date before you assume it's just the base period math.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? Never heard of it.

0 coins

You hand EDD's hold time off to it, and your phone rings when an actual EDD staffer picks up. That's really the whole thing. Anyway.

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense. I'd want to ask an agent whether the wages from my second job even showed up in the system, been trying that line for days.

0 coins

The base period EDD uses is a fixed 12-month window made up of four quarters, and they look at the highest-paid single quarter within it to estimate your weekly benefit. The window runs from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim's start date, so wages you earned in the last few months before you filed usually don't count. That part trips a lot of people up. The calculator on EDD's site will let you plug in your own quarterly wages so you can see what it should come out to before you appeal.

0 coins

That 5-to-18-month window is exactly the piece I was missing. My heaviest earning quarter is probably just inside that range, which means EDD might actually have it right. Going to run the numbers on their calculator first.

0 coins

Wait so the most recent months I worked don't count at all? That seems backwards, I earned the most in the last quarter before my injury.

0 coins

Yes, that recent quarter is excluded from the base period. It's a common frustration. The intent is to use a stable completed period, but it does hurt people whose income was rising. If you think there's a calculation error even within the correct window, that's still worth appealing.

0 coins

So if the calculator matches what's on my notice, does that mean there's no point appealing? Or can I still argue the wages they used were wrong amounts?

0 coins

If the calculator matches and the quarterly wages in it match your pay stubs, the math is probably right. You can still appeal if you believe the wage figures EDD has on file don't match what your employer actually reported, but you'd need pay stubs or W-2 information to back that up.

0 coins

Check whether your employer reported your wages correctly to the state. Had a buddy whose Notice of Computation was low because his employer had been filing the SDI deductions under the wrong quarter. EDD was doing the math right, the input was just wrong.

0 coins

That's a scenario I hadn't considered. I'll ask the payroll office at the lab to confirm what they reported and for which quarters.

0 coins

Payroll errors happen more than people think. Get it in writing from them.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a nightmare. Called nine mornings in a row and either got the busy signal or sat on hold until the line dropped. Eventually got through and the agent confirmed my employer's reported wages matched my pay stubs, so the base period itself was the problem for me, not a reporting error. If you do manage to reach someone, have your Notice of Computation in front of you with the quarterly amounts circled.

0 coins

nine mornings is brutal man

0 coins

Not exaggerating. Some mornings I tried before 8 and got nothing.

0 coins

Same experience here, week of trying.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came through and I genuinely thought it was for someone else's claim because the amount was so far off. Turned out one of my employers hadn't submitted the SDI withholding correctly so only about half my wages showed up. I appealed with my last three pay stubs from that job and a note from their HR. EDD adjusted it. So don't assume the notice is final, it really can get corrected.

0 coins

HR writing a note, is that something they're obligated to do or were they just being cooperative?

0 coins

They were cooperative, honestly. I explained I was out on disability and needed documentation. I think most HR departments will help if you just ask and explain why you need it.

0 coins

This is reassuring. My payroll office has always been responsive so I'll reach out and see if they can confirm what was submitted.

0 coins

Appeal anyway. Worst they do is deny it. Notice is not an approval and it's not a final wage determination either.

0 coins

Yep. No downside to filing the DE 1000A and finding out.

0 coins

Agreed, took me too long to realize that.

0 coins

Before mailing the DE 1000A, build a simple table: list each quarter in the base period, the wages your pay stubs show, and the wages on the Notice of Computation. Any quarter where those numbers differ is your argument. Attach the stubs for those quarters only. Keeps the packet focused.

0 coins

That's exactly the format I used. An administrative law judge doesn't have time to hunt through a pile of paper, so the clearer you make it the better.

0 coins

Building that table now. There are two quarters where my stubs show more than the notice does, so I have something concrete to point to.

0 coins

Good practical approach. I did something similar and it made the whole thing feel less overwhelming.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim had a quarterly wage figure that didn't match anything I could trace back to my own records. Spent a few days trying to phone EDD about it and kept getting cut off. Ended up using Claimyr to reach an agent, who read me the exact quarter and wage amount EDD had on file. Turned out the figure was lower than my actual earnings, so I filed the appeal with the corrected stubs right after.

0 coins

Used Claimyr on my own claim after the medical certification sat unmatched for over a week. The agent found it had been received but not yet linked to my claim, and told me to give it a few more days. That was the piece I needed to stop worrying.

0 coins

The certification being unmatched is something I hadn't thought about. Good to know an agent can actually see that detail.

0 coins

They could on mine. The agent was straightforward about what was showing in the system.

0 coins

I'm going through something kind of similar and I'm not sure if I even filed correctly. Does the appeal go to a different office than where the claim was filed? I'm scared of sending it to the wrong place and missing the 30-day window.

0 coins

The return address on your Notice of Computation is where the appeal goes. Don't use a general EDD mailing address, use the one printed on that specific notice.

0 coins

Okay. The notice has an address in the lower left, I'll use that one. Thank you.

0 coins

Also consider sending it via certified mail so you have proof of the postmark date. The 30-day clock runs from the date on the notice, not when it arrives, so having that postmark documented protects you.

0 coins

my notice was low too and i just figured it was what it was, didnt know you could fight it. do you have to file the appeal before or after your claim is actually approved

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is separate from your claim approval. Appeal the notice for the wages question. Your claim can still be processing at the same time.

0 coins

oh okay so they run at the same time got it

0 coins

Went through this last year. My error was assuming the SDI deduction line on my pay stub meant all those wages were automatically in EDD's system. They weren't, at least not in the right quarter. The appeal process was slower than I wanted but it did work.

0 coins

How long did the appeal take to get resolved?

0 coins

About six weeks from when I mailed the DE 1000A to when I got a written decision. No promises it's the same for everyone.

0 coins

Six weeks is a long time when you're already out of work and counting on those payments.

0 coins

Don't overthink the appeal letter. State the quarter, state the wages you believe are correct, attach the stubs. That's it. I've seen guys write three pages and it doesn't help.

0 coins

Appreciated. I was about to write a long narrative. Will keep it to the facts.

0 coins

Agreed, specificity matters more than length. One page with the numbers laid out clearly beats four pages of explanation.

0 coins

When I filed my appeal I included a letter from my employer confirming the SDI withholdings by quarter and the administrative law judge referenced it specifically in the decision. Definitely worth asking your payroll department for something in writing if you think wages were misreported on their end!

0 coins

That's a good point about the judge referencing it. Having employer documentation clearly swayed the outcome for you.

0 coins

It seemed like it. And my employer was actually relieved I caught it because they had a reporting error they needed to fix anyway.

0 coins

waited three weeks to open my notice. thought it was junk mail. was not junk mail.

0 coins

That's a painful way to find out about the 30-day window.

0 coins

yeah. managed to still appeal in time but barely.

0 coins

Payments on my claim had a week that showed as unpaid that I couldn't account for. Tried phoning EDD for a few mornings but could never get through. Tried Claimyr and got an agent who went through which weeks were paid and found that one week fell inside my waiting period, which explained why it showed nothing. Hadn't realized the first seven days of a new claim are just non-payable, not a processing delay.

0 coins

That whole Claimyr thing reads like a marketing post to me, honestly.

0 coins

I thought the same thing at first. But I'd been trying the line myself for four days and kept getting cut off, so I tried it. The agent I ended up talking to confirmed EDD had my receipt number on file and that my provider's certification had been received. Having that confirmed was the only reason I stopped worrying. Anyway.

0 coins

Fair enough. I may try it myself just to get a straight answer on my base period quarters before I mail the appeal.

0 coins

The waiting period being seven non-payable days, not processing time, is something I had wrong too. Good clarification.

0 coins

Is there a way to check the quarterly wages EDD has on file for you before the Notice of Computation even arrives? I'm still waiting on mine and already stressed it'll be low.

0 coins

EDD gets wage data from employers after the fact, so there's no real-time view available to claimants in SDI Online. Once the notice arrives, that's your first look at what they're working with. Use the calculator on EDD's site with your own pay stubs in the meantime to get a rough sense.

0 coins

Okay. So I should gather my pay stubs now so I'm ready to compare the moment the notice shows up. That I can do.

0 coins

Extension paperwork on my claim was sitting somewhere and nobody could tell me what was happening. DE 2525XX had to come from my doctor but I had no confirmation it was received. Used Claimyr to reach an agent and they checked whether the extension form was in the system. It wasn't yet. That at least told me to follow up with the doctor's office rather than just waiting.

0 coins

What did you say when the agent picked up? Did you need anything specific to have them check on the DE 2525XX?

0 coins

Had my claim ID and the date I'd asked the doctor to submit it. Agent looked up the claim and confirmed the extension hadn't come through yet. Straightforward once I actually had a person.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying that line before I found another way through. At some point you stop thinking the problem is the time you're calling.

0 coins

For what it's worth, the Notice of Computation itself says on it that it's not an eligibility decision. People treating it like a final answer is what causes all the panic. It's an estimate of what you'd get if approved.

0 coins

That framing actually helps. The number matters but it's not the same as a denial.

0 coins

Exactly right. A Notice of Determination, the DE 2517, is what you'd get if the claim itself is denied or reduced. The Notice of Computation is specifically about the wage calculation. Two different documents, two different issues.

0 coins

Appeal if the numbers don't match your records. Gather your stubs, write clearly, mail by the date on the notice. That's the whole process.

0 coins

Sending the appeal tomorrow. Stubs are organized, table is built, letter is one page. Thank you to everyone who helped piece this together.

0 coins

Good. Keep copies of everything you mail.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure