Back to California Disability

Sunny Wang

How to apply for both SDI and SSA disability with leg condition — California EDD side explained

So I messed up my leg pretty bad, been off work for going on six weeks now and my doctor says I'm looking at a few more months minimum before I can even think about getting back on my feet. Someone at my physical therapy place mentioned I should look into filing for state disability AND Social Security disability at the same time since it's a longer-term thing. I already filed the SDI Online claim through myEDD and my orthopedic surgeon submitted the medical certification, so that part's moving. But I'm totally lost on whether the two programs overlap, conflict, cancel each other out, whatever. Has anyone dealt with both at once? Mostly asking about the California EDD side since that's what I need to sort out first anyway.

Filing the SDI claim first was the right call. For the California EDD side, the medical certification from your orthopedic surgeon covers the SDI piece as long as it went in within 49 days of when your disability started. SDI pays for up to 52 weeks of benefits, so a few months of recovery fits well within that window. The Social Security side is an entirely separate federal process and has nothing to do with EDD's rules, so the two applications don't interfere with each other procedurally. EDD decides the SDI claim on its own.

0 coins

So EDD doesn't even ask about a Social Security application when you file SDI? I was worried they'd put the claim on hold or something if they saw I was pursuing both.

0 coins

They don't ask, and one doesn't hold up the other. Your SDI benefit amount comes from your own wages and base period, nothing else.

0 coins

Worth noting: EDD's own site says SDI is for non-work-related illness or injury, which a leg condition qualifies as. The 52-week maximum is written right on the disability benefits page if you want to confirm it yourself.

0 coins

EDD's disability line is a nightmare to get through if you have questions about your specific claim status. I've been redialing since 8 a.m. and it just dumps you after a few minutes every single time. Spent three mornings on this last week alone.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me. Called at opening time four days straight and got nowhere. It's like they designed it to wear you out.

0 coins

Does using SDI Online's message feature help at all? I sent a Request Claim Update two days ago and haven't heard anything, not sure if that actually goes to a person.

0 coins

The online message thing eventually gets a response but it can take a while. For anything urgent about your claim status I'd say the phone is still the only real option, which is exactly the problem.

0 coins

DE 2593 landed in my mailbox while my leg claim was still active, right around the ten-week mark. Had questions about it so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on EDD's disability line. Video on reaching someone there: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the form was due back within 20 days of its date or my payments would stop. Got it in that week.

0 coins

Used Claimyr for my own extension question, actually glad I did. The agent found my DE 2525XX request in the system and told me EDD had already sent it out with my final payment notice, so I just needed to have my doctor complete it and return it. Hadn't expected that part to be automated like that.

0 coins

Wait, the extension form gets sent automatically? So you don't have to call and ask EDD to send it to you?

0 coins

Right, EDD sends the DE 2525XX along with the notice that your benefits are ending. Your doctor fills it in, and once EDD gets it back, benefits can continue. I'd still confirm with EDD if the form doesn't show up when expected.

0 coins

Didn't know that about the extension form. Good to know before I get to that point.

0 coins

Leg injuries are rough for SDI timing because recovery can drag on and you sometimes need to extend the claim. My client went through this with a knee replacement and by the time she needed more weeks the form situation was confusing her. The main thing is your doctor stays in the loop the whole time so the certification keeps matching what EDD has on file.

0 coins

My surgeon's office seems pretty on top of it, they've done SDI certifications before. I guess I just need to make sure they know to submit the extension paperwork when we get there.

0 coins

Exactly, give them a heads-up now so it's not a scramble at the end. Some offices don't realize they have to submit the supplementary certificate and not just call in.

0 coins

Physical therapists can't certify a claim though right? I thought only the treating doctor could.

0 coins

Correct. EDD's list of who can certify doesn't include physical therapists. It needs to be a physician, surgeon, nurse practitioner, or another licensed provider on EDD's approved list. A PT can treat you but not sign off on the SDI certification.

0 coins

For anyone trying to understand how the SDI benefit amount gets calculated, it's based on your highest-earning quarter in a base period that goes back about 5 to 18 months before your claim start date. EDD's site has a calculator that estimates it, and the actual number shows up on your Notice of Computation once EDD processes everything.

0 coins

I got the Notice of Computation already, it came pretty fast. Trying to figure out if that means I'm approved or if it's just showing what I might get.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation isn't an approval, it just shows the potential weekly amount. Approval comes when payments actually start, or EDD sends a Notice of Determination if something's denied.

0 coins

This tripped me up too. I thought the notice meant I was good to go and then spent a week wondering where my first payment was.

0 coins

The notice explicitly says 'potential' benefit amount. It's worth reading the whole thing carefully because it also shows which quarter of your base period EDD used.

0 coins

You mentioned your doctor is an orthopedic surgeon. As long as that surgeon is the one who submitted the certification in SDI Online, you're fine. Where I see guys get stuck is when they think any doctor who's seen them can submit it, but it has to be the one treating you for this specific condition.

0 coins

Does it matter if you have more than one provider? Like if the surgeon does the cert but a physical therapist is also treating you?

0 coins

PT can't certify it, as someone said above. Keep the surgeon as your certifying provider for the SDI claim.

0 coins

Got it. My surgeon's office confirmed they already submitted it, so I think we're good on that front.

0 coins

the waiting period thing catches everyone off guard, those first 7 days are just gone no matter what, they dont pay those weeks ever

0 coins

Seven days feels like a long time when you're not getting paid. Is it calendar days or business days?

0 coins

Calendar days. The first seven days of the claim are non-payable regardless of anything, and the eighth day is the first day benefits can actually be paid. It's not related to processing time, it's a fixed waiting period built into every new claim.

0 coins

yeah exactly its not EDD being slow its just the rule, day 8 is when it actually starts counting

0 coins

Not sure if this matters but I keep second-guessing whether my claim receipt number got to my doctor's office correctly. I gave it to the front desk person but I didn't confirm they actually entered it into SDI Online. If the numbers don't match does the whole certification get rejected?

0 coins

The receipt number is how EDD links your doctor's submission to your claim. If it doesn't match, EDD may not connect the two. Worth calling your surgeon's office to verify they used the exact number you gave them.

0 coins

I'll do that today. I've been in this weird limbo where SDI Online shows the claim and the medical certification as both received but it's still showing pending.

0 coins

Pending for a week or two after both parts are in is pretty normal. EDD typically contacts you about status within 14 days of receiving a completed claim.

0 coins

Two weeks feels long when you're stressing about it but yeah that's about right.

0 coins

My coworker had a leg fracture last year and did the SDI claim. She said the part that helped most was staying on top of the continued eligibility form EDD sends around week 10. Missing it almost stopped her payments.

0 coins

Is that the DE 2593? I saw someone mention that form above and now I'm putting a note in my calendar.

0 coins

Yeah that's the one. EDD gives you 20 days to return it. Easy to miss if you're not expecting it.

0 coins

The DE 2593 is only sent if you're on automatic payment. If you're getting the bi-weekly form instead, that's the DE 2500A and you send that in every two weeks to keep payments going.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in and mine was denied because EDD said the medical certification hadn't been matched to my claim. I'd been trying that disability line every morning for days. Ended up reaching a live agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) and they confirmed the cert was in the system but the receipt number was off by one digit. Got it corrected and resubmitted.

0 coins

Claimyr sounds like it might be a marketing thing, honestly. How would a third-party service actually get you on the line with EDD any better than calling yourself?

0 coins

thought the same thing before i tried it after my own denial. the agent i reached told me my claim's start date in the system didnt match what i had on the form, corrected it right there. different from what you had but same idea.

0 coins

Alright, that's more specific than I expected. I might look into it. The receipt number issue you described sounds exactly like what someone earlier in this thread was worried about.

0 coins

A one-digit error on the receipt number causing a denial is frustrating but at least it's fixable. Good that the agent could see it right away.

0 coins

The SDI online message system is better than nothing but calling is still the only way to get real-time answers about what EDD actually has on your claim. Wish they'd just let you see more in SDI Online itself.

0 coins

SDI Online does show claim status but it doesn't tell you exactly why something is pending. That's the gap.

0 coins

EDD does have the automated line at 1-800-480-3287 for payment info. Doesn't answer every question but it can at least confirm whether a payment has been issued without waiting for a live person.

0 coins

Automated line told me a payment was issued when I hadn't received anything. So I still had to get a live person to look at it properly.

0 coins

Can you file SDI if you're still technically employed, like on a leave of absence? I'm in a similar situation with a knee issue and I'm worried that being on leave means I don't qualify.

0 coins

Being on a leave of absence doesn't disqualify you from SDI. The claim is about whether you can do your regular work, not your employment status. The SDI deduction on your paystub is what funds it.

0 coins

Okay that actually helps a lot. I've been putting off filing because I thought I had to be terminated or something.

0 coins

File right away if you haven't yet. You have 49 days from when the disability started before it disqualifies you. Don't wait on that one.

0 coins

Filing today. Thank you for that.

0 coins

Something nobody tells you is that going back to work part time affects your payment. EDD needs to know when you start picking up hours again, even if it's light duty.

0 coins

How does that work exactly? Do payments just stop or do they adjust?

0 coins

You report it and EDD figures out what a partial week pays. I wouldn't just quietly go back without saying anything.

0 coins

Reporting it promptly is important. EDD decides how partial weeks are paid, but not reporting it can lead to an overpayment notice later, which is a bigger headache.

0 coins

The Money Network debit card thing threw me off when I first got it. I was expecting the Bank of America card I'd heard about and then this different card showed up.

0 coins

EDD switched from Bank of America to Money Network a while back. If you set up direct deposit when you filed on SDI Online you skip the card entirely though.

0 coins

Wish I'd known that before. The card works fine but setting up direct deposit sounds way easier.

0 coins

Direct deposit is available for SDI Online claims. Worth selecting it at the start so payments go straight to your account.

0 coins

Receipt number my surgeon's office gave back to me didn't match what SDI Online had. Spent two weeks thinking the cert was submitted when it wasn't matched at all. I got a live person at EDD using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and they checked the claim right there, confirmed the cert was sitting unmatched because the number was off.

0 coins

When the agent found the mismatch, did they fix it on the spot or did your doctor's office have to resubmit the whole certification?

0 coins

The agent told me the cert had to be resubmitted with the correct receipt number. So I went back to my surgeon's office with the exact number from my SDI Online confirmation screen and they redid it that day.

0 coins

been dialing that line for two weeks straight and cant get through. been calling right when they open at eight and still nothing past the recording.

0 coins

That is a rough run. Hope you get through soon.

0 coins

If SDI only pays up to 52 weeks, what happens if someone still can't work after that? Do they just fall off a cliff?

0 coins

SDI's 52-week limit is a hard cap for DI benefits. After that, if someone is still unable to work, they'd need to look at other options outside of EDD's disability program. That's where things like Social Security disability become relevant, which is exactly what the person in this thread is already exploring.

0 coins

That's also why filing for Social Security disability early makes sense for longer-term conditions. The SSA process takes a long time, so starting it while SDI is still paying means you're not in a gap.

0 coins

That actually makes the two-track approach make a lot more sense to me now.

0 coins

my buddy had a leg thing and his sdi ran out before he could get back to work, it was rough. wish he'd known about the other options sooner

0 coins

That gap is real. The SDI extension through the DE 2525XX can add more time if a doctor certifies it, but that still has limits and it's within the 52-week total.

0 coins

yeah he didnt even know the extension existed until it was basically too late to do anything about it

0 coins

Payment date on mine was showing one thing in SDI Online and the deposit hit three days later. Called the disability line finally and the agent confirmed the date I saw was the issue date, not when it would actually land in my account. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through after trying every morning for a week.

0 coins

My claim has a question about which weeks got paid that I need answered. Going to try Claimyr for it. Any advice on what to have ready when you get through?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the specific weeks or dates you're asking about. The agent pulled mine up fast once I had those ready.

0 coins

The issue date vs. deposit date thing is confusing. Good to know there's a difference.

0 coins

Payment timing questions like this are exactly what I'll probably have in a few weeks. Good to know you can get real answers when you reach someone.

0 coins

For the original question about applying for both programs at the same time: on the California EDD side, the key dates are the 49-day filing window and the 49-day deadline for the medical certification. Both are measured from when the disability began, not from when you filed. Missing either one can disqualify the claim.

0 coins

Both the filing and the cert submission have the same 49-day deadline? I didn't realize the cert had its own deadline separate from when I filed.

0 coins

They share the same 49-day clock from the disability start date. If your surgeon already submitted it you're likely fine, but confirm the submission date with the office just to be sure.

0 coins

Exactly right. EDD's rules say the medical certification must be submitted no later than 49 days after the disability begins. It's not based on when the claimant filed, it's based on the onset date.

0 coins

Unemployment doesn't apply here while you're unable to work. EDD's rule is you can't collect unemployment and disability for the same days, and unemployment requires being able to work every week you claim it. If someone is out with a leg condition, SDI is the right program, not unemployment.

0 coins

Someone at work told me I should file unemployment since I'm technically still employed and on leave. That's wrong then?

0 coins

Wrong for your situation. If you can't do your job because of your condition, unemployment isn't for you right now. SDI is. Unemployment is for when you're recovered, available to work, and your employer has no position for you.

0 coins

Unemployment also requires you to look for work every week. Not exactly something you're doing from a hospital bed.

0 coins

Workers' comp comes up sometimes with leg injuries when it happened on the job. If this was a non-work injury though, SDI is the right path and workers' comp isn't in play.

0 coins

Definitely not work-related, happened on a weekend. So SDI is the right one and I'm good there.

0 coins

Then you're on the right track. Workers' comp is for on-the-job injuries, SDI is for everything outside of that.

0 coins

EDD themselves say it's not common to get both SDI and workers' comp at the same time anyway. Good that yours is clearly SDI territory.

0 coins

If EDD sends a Notice of Determination that denies the claim, the appeal window is 30 days from the date on the notice. A lot of people miss that deadline because they think they have 30 days from when they receive it. The date on the form is what counts.

0 coins

What if you miss the 30 days? Is the claim just over?

0 coins

A late appeal can still be submitted with an explanation of why it was late, and an administrative law judge looks at whether the reason was valid. It's not automatic but it's not automatically over either.

0 coins

The appeal is filed on the DE 1000A form that comes with the denial notice, or a detailed letter if you no longer have the form. Mailed to the address printed on the notice itself.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure