Back to California Disability

Diego Chavez

How much will I get from disability — trying to figure out what California EDD actually pays

So I've been out of work for about three weeks now after a pretty rough back injury and I finally got around to filing my SDI claim last week. My surgeon signed off on everything and I think the medical certification went through but now I'm sitting here trying to figure out what my actual check is going to look like. Like is there a formula? Is it based on what I was making most recently or does EDD look at some older period of my earnings? I work in a warehouse so my pay varies a lot depending on overtime some weeks and slower weeks, so I have no idea if they're taking an average or what. I got a Notice of Computation in the mail yesterday and there's a weekly benefit amount on it but I don't totally understand how they arrived at that number. It's less than I was hoping for and I want to know if it's right before I just accept it. Anyone been through this and can explain how the math works?

The Notice of Computation is basically EDD's answer to that exact question — it lays out your potential weekly amount and your maximum for the whole claim. What I'd do first is look at which quarter of wages they used for your calculation, because EDD pulls from your highest-paid quarter inside a 12-month base period that ended several months before your claim started. If your overtime was spread across multiple quarters, the number on that notice might feel lower than you'd expect based on your recent paychecks. The percentage they apply sits somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of those wages depending on your income level, and EDD's disability calculator on their site can help you check whether the number on your notice makes sense.

0 coins

So they're not looking at what I made right before I got hurt, they're looking at some earlier window? That's what threw me off. I had a really strong stretch of overtime in the spring and I'm wondering if that quarter is what they're basing it on.

0 coins

Exactly, it's not your most recent pay. The base period they look at ends a few months before your claim date, so spring overtime could absolutely be the quarter they used if it falls in that window. Pull up the calculator on EDD's site and plug in your quarterly wages and it should get you close to what the notice shows.

0 coins

The base period thing confused me too when I filed after my knee surgery. I kept thinking they'd use my last paycheck and the number came out totally different than I expected. Once I found the calculator it made more sense.

0 coins

Before anything else I'd double-check that the wages on your Notice of Computation actually match what your employer reported. I had a situation where one quarter was listed lower than what I actually earned and it brought the weekly amount down. If the numbers on the notice don't line up with your W-2 or pay stubs, you can contact EDD to get it sorted before the claim goes further.

0 coins

I didn't even think about checking the actual wage figures, I just assumed EDD had the right numbers. I'll pull out my pay stubs and compare.

0 coins

Definitely worth doing. My employer had reported my wages wrong one quarter and EDD was using the lower number. Took a few weeks to get it corrected but the weekly benefit amount went up after they fixed it.

0 coins

How do you even tell EDD the wages are wrong? Do you call or is there something in SDI Online?

0 coins

You can send a message through SDI Online under Request Claim Update, or call the disability line at 1-800-480-3287. If you have your pay stubs showing the correct amount, have those ready when you reach someone.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim and the medical certification not matching up was the thing that held my payment back for two weeks after I filed. I had my doctor's office submit the certification but they used a different reference number than what SDI Online gave me after I completed Part A. Tried the phone line for days and it just rang endlessly. Eventually I got through to an EDD agent using Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with EDD so you end up talking to an actual person — and the agent looked at my claim and confirmed the receipt number the provider used didn't match the one tied to my filing. Had my doctor's office resubmit with the right number and the pending status cleared within a few days after that. Video on how to reach a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Wait so the receipt number has to match exactly? My surgeon's office said they submitted it but I never gave them any kind of reference number. I'm going to check with them tomorrow.

0 coins

Yes, the receipt number is what EDD uses to match your doctor's certification to your Part A filing. SDI Online gives it to you right when you submit your claimant's statement — it's on the confirmation screen. If your provider filed without it the systems might not link them up.

0 coins

Had the same exact issue after my appendix surgery. Office submitted the certification but without that number and it sat unmatched for almost three weeks. Would have been helpful to know this before filing.

0 coins

The 70 to 90 percent range that people keep mentioning isn't a flat rate — where you land in that range depends on your wages in that highest quarter. Lower earners get the higher percentage and higher earners get closer to 70. EDD's calculator on their site will show you the specific percentage for your income level, and once you see it you can verify whether the weekly amount on your Notice of Computation is in the right ballpark.

0 coins

That actually makes the number on my notice make more sense. I was assuming it would be closer to 90 percent and it's not, but if higher earners get a lower percentage that tracks with what I saw.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me — I assumed 90 percent and was surprised when my notice came in lower. The calculator helped me understand it wasn't an error, just where my wages put me in the range.

0 coins

Exactly, most people filing for the first time expect the highest percentage and the calculator is really the fastest way to understand what your specific number should be.

0 coins

Something to keep in mind with the warehouse work and variable pay — overtime counts toward your wages for SDI purposes as far as EDD is concerned when they look at your quarterly earnings. So if you had a quarter with a lot of overtime in that base period window, it's already baked into whatever number they're using. The issue is just making sure it falls in the right quarter inside the base period, which is what the person earlier was describing.

0 coins

Good to know. My overtime was pretty concentrated in a couple of months so it probably all lands in one quarter, which might actually help if that ends up being my highest one.

0 coins

Overtime being included was something I had to ask about specifically when I filed. My work schedule is similar and I was worried they'd strip it out somehow but it all counted when they ran the quarterly figure.

0 coins

Just to add to the waiting period question before it comes up — a lot of people assume the first week of payments gets delayed because EDD is processing things slowly, but the first seven days of a new DI claim are actually a non-payable waiting period by rule, not a processing delay. The eighth day is the first day that can generate a payment. So whatever your weekly amount turns out to be, factor in that first week being unpaid when you're planning your finances.

0 coins

Nobody told me this. I assumed all the days from when I filed would eventually be paid. So that first week is just gone no matter what?

0 coins

Right, it's not processing time, it's a built-in unpaid week at the start of every new DI claim. Your surgeon's certification still needs to cover those days for the rest of the claim to be payable, but you won't see money for that first week.

0 coins

Took me reading my denial paperwork three times to figure out why I was short a week. The notice doesn't explain it super clearly. Knowing this upfront would have saved a lot of confusion.

0 coins

I thought the waiting period was like a deductible and I'd get it back eventually. Nope, it's just gone. Important to know when you're trying to figure out how long your savings need to stretch.

0 coins

To go back to the Notice of Computation for a second — it's worth understanding that the notice shows your potential benefit, not a confirmed approval. EDD still has to process the full claim with the medical certification and determine eligibility. The amount on the notice is what you'd get per week if everything checks out, but a separate determination about eligibility comes later. Treated mine like an approval letter and was confused when more paperwork showed up.

0 coins

So the notice isn't confirmation that I'm actually approved, just what I'd get if I am? That's an important distinction I completely missed.

0 coins

Exactly. If EDD finds something that makes you ineligible they'd send a Notice of Determination with an appeal form. If everything is fine the payments just start, usually within a couple weeks of them receiving the full claim.

0 coins

I made the same mistake. I thought receiving the Notice of Computation meant everything was settled and I could relax. The actual payment showing up is what confirmed it for me.

0 coins

Payment date on my claim took longer than the two-week window I kept reading about, and I could not figure out why from SDI Online alone. Phoned EDD's disability line early one morning and landed with an agent through Claimyr — that one for me was figuring out which week the payment had actually been issued versus which weeks were still pending. The agent pulled up my claim and told me one payment had gone out already and three weeks were still showing as pending because my doctor hadn't updated my certification to cover the full period. Had the office submit the update that afternoon.

0 coins

Two-week window felt like a myth when my first payment took almost four weeks. Turned out my employer verification was the holdup but I had no way to know that from SDI Online.

0 coins

This is making me realize there are a lot of different things that could be holding up a payment that you'd never know about just staring at the pending screen.

0 coins

SDI Online really only shows you a status, not what's causing it. Having someone actually read the claim notes out loud to me made all the difference.

0 coins

For the warehouse workers with inconsistent pay wondering how to estimate their benefit before the notice arrives — go into myEDD, open SDI Online, and look at whether there's a wage statement section, or use the disability benefits calculator on EDD's site. You'll need to know roughly what you earned in each quarter of the last couple of years. Your pay stubs by quarter are the fastest way to put that together. Plug in your four highest quarters and the calculator will give you a ballpark.

0 coins

I don't have my old pay stubs organized by quarter but I can probably pull them from my company's HR portal. Good to know what to gather.

0 coins

HR portal or your W-2s from the last two years will have what you need. The base period usually goes back 5 to 18 months before your claim start date so older pay records are more relevant than you'd think.

0 coins

Came here because I'm trying to estimate mine before I even file. Work in construction so my pay varies a ton. This calculator approach sounds like the right move before I go expecting a number that's way off.

0 coins

The 52-week cap is something worth knowing upfront if you're dealing with a serious injury. DI benefits max out at 52 weeks per claim. After that there's nothing more from SDI unless it's a new, separate disability. For shorter claims like a surgery recovery it won't come up, but longer rehab situations it matters.

0 coins

My surgeon said 10 to 12 weeks for recovery so 52 weeks isn't my concern right now, but good to file away.

0 coins

Someone I work with burned through almost the whole 52 weeks after a complicated fracture. Things like extension requests from the doctor matter a lot at that point because without them payments stop.

0 coins

Extensions are the doctor submitting the DE 2525XX form — EDD actually sends it out with your final payment notice so you should get it automatically, but following up with your doctor to make sure they submit it promptly is smart.

0 coins

Nobody seemed to mention what happens to the benefit calculation if you go back to work part time partway through your claim. If you return part time, you're supposed to report those earnings to EDD. EDD then determines how a partial week is paid. It's not dollar for dollar but the actual formula is EDD's to calculate — if you end up working a few warehouse shifts while still recovering, don't just assume you can keep accepting the full weekly amount without reporting it or you could end up with an overpayment notice later.

0 coins

My surgeon hasn't cleared me for even light duty so this isn't my situation right now but I'll remember it if that changes.

0 coins

Got an overpayment notice exactly because of this. Went back a couple of shifts, thought it was fine since I was still mostly out, didn't report right away. Reporting the minute you go back even one day is the move.

0 coins

Overpayment notices can be appealed if you think something was calculated wrong — you get 30 days from the date on the notice to file the appeal form DE 1000A. But the cleaner path is reporting immediately so it doesn't come up.

0 coins

My pay was deposited on a Money Network prepaid debit card automatically, which caught me off guard because I'd vaguely heard something about an EDD debit card and assumed it was a Bank of America card like some people still mention. EDD moved to Money Network, so if you're setting up payment options and wondering which card program it is, it's Money Network now. Direct deposit is also an option if you chose it in SDI Online when you filed.

0 coins

I didn't set up direct deposit when I filed. Can I change it after the fact?

0 coins

You can switch to direct deposit through SDI Online — log into myEDD, open your claim and there should be an option to update your payment method. Worth doing sooner rather than later if you prefer the money going straight to your bank account.

0 coins

The Money Network card took longer to show up in my mailbox than I expected. If your payment processes but you haven't gotten the card yet, you can check the Money Network site or call their line to track the card separately.

0 coins

Coming at this from the other side — I finished my SDI claim three months ago after a hernia repair and looking back the number that showed up on my Notice of Computation was actually accurate, it just felt low because I'd been mentally spending my full paycheck in my head. The reality is any SDI payment is replacing a portion of wages, not all of them. Figuring out that gap before you go out is the best planning you can do.

0 coins

That's a good reality check. I've been treating the SDI amount like it'll cover everything and it probably won't quite. Need to be more honest with myself about the gap.

0 coins

Went through this exact mental adjustment when my claim started. Having a realistic number early makes the budgeting easier than constantly hoping it'll be higher than it is.

0 coins

DE 2593 landed in my mail about ten weeks into my claim and I had no idea what it was at first. It's the form EDD sends when you've been on automatic payments for about five months — they want to confirm you're still unable to work. If you don't send it back within 20 days your benefits stop. I'd set everything up and forgotten EDD might reach out mid-claim. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD's disability line because I wasn't sure if the form had already hit the 20-day window — the agent looked at when my claim payment cycle was and confirmed I still had time to return it.

0 coins

So EDD can pause your claim mid-stream if you don't respond to that form? That's something I would have completely missed if no one mentioned it.

0 coins

Exactly, and 20 days goes faster than it sounds when you're in recovery mode and not checking your mail every day. Set a reminder the moment it shows up.

0 coins

20 days from when EDD issues it, not from when it arrives in your mailbox, so read the date on the form itself carefully.

0 coins

That 20-day window is firm. If you miss it you can try to get benefits reinstated but that creates more paperwork and more phone calls you don't want to deal with when you're trying to recover.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in the mail for me after what I thought was a straightforward claim — said there was a question about my eligibility and gave me 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal. Had a lot of questions about what exactly was being disputed. Called EDD through Claimyr and the agent walked through what was noted on my claim and confirmed EDD would mail a follow-up. Filed the DE 1000A appeal form with a detailed explanation of my situation and kept my copies of everything. Still waiting on the administrative law judge hearing date.

0 coins

30 days sounds like a lot until you're trying to put together a coherent appeal while you're recovering from an injury. Good reminder to treat it like a real deadline.

0 coins

The appeal form is DE 1000A, and if you lose that form you can write a detailed letter instead and mail it to the return address on the notice. The key is getting something in before that 30-day window closes, not waiting until you have a perfect response.

0 coins

Appealing feels really intimidating but knowing the form has a name and an address to send it to makes it slightly less scary. Bookmar— I mean, writing that down.

0 coins

For anyone wondering whether SDI income gets taxed — California doesn't tax SDI disability benefits. Federal tax treatment depends on your situation and there are specifics that go beyond what anyone here should be guessing at. EDD has a tax information page worth reading and a tax professional is the right resource if you're trying to figure out what your federal picture looks like.

0 coins

This is actually really useful because I was worried about setting aside money from the benefit for taxes. Good to know California at least doesn't take a cut.

0 coins

The federal side tripped me up — ended up talking to a tax professional about it rather than guessing. Definitely worth a conversation if you're out for more than a few weeks.

0 coins

Something I didn't see in the thread yet — if your condition stretches longer than your doctor originally certified, you don't file a whole new DI claim. Your doctor submits the DE 2525XX form, which is an extension of the existing claim. EDD sends that form to you with your final payment notice, so watch for it. The key is getting your doctor to submit it before benefits actually stop, not after.

0 coins

So the extension goes through the same claim, not a new filing. That makes sense. I'll mention it to my surgeon at my next appointment so we're both on the same page.

0 coins

Exactly right, same claim, same weekly amount, your doctor just extends the certification period. Mention it at your next appointment and ask them to submit it through SDI Online when the time comes.

0 coins

The earlier the doctor submits it the better. I had a gap of about a week between when my benefits technically ended and when the extension was processed and that week had to be sorted out separately.

0 coins

Can I ask a related question since people here seem to know the system well — does SDI look at all my jobs or just my main one? I work a warehouse day shift and pick up a couple of side shifts at a different place on weekends. I've been paying CASDI on both paychecks so I assume both count?

0 coins

Wages with CASDI deducted from any job should count toward your base period earnings. The key is that the wages were subject to SDI contributions — if both employers were deducting CASDI, both sets of wages would factor in. EDD's disability benefits calculator on their site can help you check by entering your total quarterly wages from both.

0 coins

Both paychecks definitely have the CASDI deduction line. I'll total them up by quarter and plug it into the calculator. Thanks for the clarification.

0 coins

EDD looks at all wages subject to SDI contributions, not just one job. You'll want to have both employers' wage information when you file so your base period earnings are as accurate as possible.

0 coins

Unemployment versus disability question keeps coming up with people I know — if you're still medically unable to work you're on DI, not unemployment, because unemployment requires being able and available to work every week you claim it. If your injury heals and you lose the job or get laid off after that, then you'd file for unemployment when you're able to return. You can't collect both at the same time for the same days.

0 coins

My company still has my job protected while I'm out but I know someone who got laid off mid-claim and panicked about this. Good to have it explained clearly.

0 coins

Losing the job while on DI doesn't automatically change the DI claim — but the two programs can't overlap on the same days. When a person is well enough to work again, that's when unemployment comes into the picture if they need it.

0 coins

My coworker mixed these two up and thought she had to pick one upfront. DI is specifically for the period you can't work, unemployment is for after, when you're available to work again. Different programs for different situations.

0 coins

Quick sanity check from someone who just finished a 14-week shoulder surgery recovery on SDI — the whole process felt more manageable once I stopped trying to predict the exact dollar amount before the Notice of Computation arrived. File on time, make sure your doctor submits the medical certification with your receipt number, watch your mail for forms EDD sends mid-claim, report any work immediately if you go back part time, and the system mostly runs the way it's supposed to. Stressful, yes, but it does work.

0 coins

This is a good note to end on honestly. I've been anxiety-spiraling about the amount and whether everything is set up right and maybe I need to just trust the process a bit and watch my mail.

0 coins

That anxiety is real and completely normal when your income is suddenly dependent on a government system you've never used before. The main things in your control are filing on time, keeping in touch with your doctor's office about the certification, and responding to anything EDD sends you. The rest is waiting.

0 coins

14 weeks and it was smooth is reassuring to hear. Mine was similar after a knee repair — the most stressful part was the first two weeks before anything confirmed, and then once payments started it became routine.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure