Back to California Disability

Benjamin Kim

How hard is it for doctor to certify SDI for mental health — what actually happened with my claim

So I finally decided to file for SDI after my therapist and my doctor both said I genuinely need to step away from work for a while. I'm dealing with something serious enough that my employer agreed I shouldn't be in the office right now. I filed my Part A on SDI Online last week and gave my psychiatrist the receipt number, but she seemed a little unsure about the certification process for mental health specifically. She said she's done these before but it's been a while and she wasn't sure if EDD treats mental health claims differently. I don't want to mess this up because I really need these benefits. Does EDD make it harder for a psychiatrist to certify a mental health disability claim? Is there anything I should tell her or make sure she does? I can't afford for this to sit pending forever because of a certification issue on her end.

Start date on my claim got flagged and I couldn't figure out why the dates looked off in SDI Online. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach EDD's disability line and actually talked to an agent. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the start date they had on file was two days later than what I entered, which explained why the first week looked wrong. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Once I had the right date confirmed I asked my doctor's office to recheck their submission.

0 coins

Reads like an ad to me, honestly. Every time I see something like this posted it turns out to be a promo thing. What actually happened when you called, did a real EDD employee pick up?

0 coins

The 'ad' suspicion is fair, I had it too. Tried it myself after three mornings of that hold music cutting off. The agent I spoke with checked whether my medical certification had been received and matched to my claim. It had been sitting unmatched because my doctor's office used a slightly different spelling. That was real EDD information I could not have gotten any other way that week.

0 coins

Okay that's more useful than I expected. I've been hitting a busy signal every single morning so I might actually give it a try.

0 coins

Psychiatrists are on EDD's list of providers who can certify a DI claim, same as any physician. The process for them is the same: they log into SDI Online with the receipt number you gave her, fill out the medical certification, and submit. The fact that it's a mental health condition doesn't add extra steps for her.

0 coins

That's a relief to hear. So she just needs the receipt number I gave her and she submits through SDI Online like any other doctor?

0 coins

Exactly. Receipt number, SDI Online, done. Make sure she doesn't also mail a paper form if she submitted online, that can confuse things.

0 coins

Wait, they can double-submit? I did not know that was even a problem. My therapist mentioned mailing something, should I tell her not to?

0 coins

If your therapist submitted online already, yes, tell her not to also mail the paper Part B. One submission is what EDD needs.

0 coins

EDD's phone line for disability is a nightmare regardless of what kind of claim you have. Mental health, broken leg, doesn't matter, you're stuck listening to that recording loop the same amount of time either way.

0 coins

facts, called at 8am and it still just ended the call on me after like 10 minutes of nothing

0 coins

Twelve days of that before I tried anything different.

0 coins

Worth noting from EDD's own site: a licensed psychologist can certify a DI claim, and a psychiatrist is a physician, so she's well within the allowed provider types. The list also includes nurse practitioners and physician assistants, so your options aren't as narrow as people sometimes think.

0 coins

Good to know there are other options if for some reason my psychiatrist runs into issues. I didn't realize a nurse practitioner could do it too.

0 coins

My NP certified mine and it went through fine. No issues at all with EDD treating it differently.

0 coins

I honestly thought only an MD could certify. Learned something today.

0 coins

Tell your doctor to get that certification in well before 49 days from when your disability started. That's the cutoff. Miss it and you lose the benefits. Don't wait around.

0 coins

49 days from when I actually stopped working, right? Not from when I filed?

0 coins

From when the disability started, not the filing date. Same thing usually, but worth knowing.

0 coins

To add to that, the claimant's part also has to be in by 49 days after the disability starts, and you're supposed to wait nine days after it starts before filing. So the window for the doctor is tight if you filed late.

0 coins

My cousin went through this for anxiety last year and her psychiatrist was totally fine with the SDI Online process. The certification form asks the provider about the medical condition and how it limits the claimant from doing their regular work. That's it, really. No extra hoops for mental health from what she described.

0 coins

That's really helpful, thank you. My psychiatrist's hesitation seemed to be about how to describe the limitation rather than the technical process.

0 coins

Yeah the 'unable to do your regular or customary work' framing is basically what EDD cares about. She should be able to describe that pretty easily.

0 coins

My doctor said the same thing, it comes down to whether she can document the work limitation.

0 coins

Does EDD ever ask for more documentation if it's a mental health claim, like do they send a letter asking for more details? I'm in a similar situation and I'm scared they'll question it more than a physical injury.

0 coins

EDD may send a Notice of Determination if they can't approve the claim, and there's an appeal process. But the standard isn't different for mental health vs. physical. The provider certifies that the person can't do their regular work, and EDD goes from there.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation comes first and shows your potential weekly amount. If EDD can't pay the claim you get a Notice of Determination with an appeal form. Neither one is specific to mental health claims.

0 coins

Okay that helps. I keep reading things that make me think mental health claims get denied more but maybe that's just not true for SDI specifically.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim had a weekly amount that looked way lower than I expected. Tried the EDD disability line for a week straight and kept getting cut off. Eventually used Claimyr and got through to an agent who looked up which quarter they used for my base period. Turned out EDD was using the right quarter, the number was just lower than I thought it would be because of a slow quarter I had two years back.

0 coins

Which quarter did they end up using? Mine showed up and I had no idea how they picked the period.

0 coins

The highest-paid quarter in the base period, whatever that works out to for your wages. The agent just confirmed that's what they had and that the calculator on EDD's site would match.

0 coins

been trying that line since monday, four days now and nothing gets through

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period trips a lot of people up. That first week isn't paid no matter what, it's not a processing delay, just a mandatory non-payable stretch at the start of every new claim. After that the payments usually come within a couple weeks of EDD getting both parts of the claim.

0 coins

So even after my psychiatrist certifies, I won't get paid for the first week I was out?

0 coins

Right, the first seven days of the claim are always unpaid. Day eight is when the payable period starts. It catches everyone off guard the first time.

0 coins

Seems pointless but that's how it works.

0 coins

The base period for the weekly benefit amount is the highest-paid quarter out of a 12-month stretch covering four quarters, roughly 5 to 18 months before the claim starts. If you've had any gaps or low-income periods recently it can affect the number. The Notice of Computation will show the figure EDD landed on.

0 coins

Mine should be okay since I've been working full time consistently, but good to know what goes into it.

0 coins

The EDD calculator on their site can give you a ballpark before the notice shows up, which is handy!

0 coins

Yes, the calculator at edd.ca.gov is worth running before the notice arrives so you're not surprised.

0 coins

my therapist tried to certify mine and edd said she couldnt because shes not on the allowed list, only my actual psychiatrist could do it

0 coins

A licensed psychologist is on EDD's list, but a therapist's credential matters. An LCSW or MFT is not on EDD's list of providers who can certify a DI claim. It has to be a physician, psychologist, nurse practitioner, physician assistant, or one of the other specific types EDD names.

0 coins

yeah that was it, she was an lcsw. had to go back to my psychiatrist which added like another week

0 coins

That's a really important distinction. A lot of people assume any mental health provider can certify but EDD's list is specific about license type.

0 coins

Glad I read this, my provider is a psychiatrist so I should be fine, but I would not have thought to check that.

0 coins

Which weeks were paid on mine was a whole mess. SDI Online wasn't showing anything clearly and I ended up using Claimyr to get through to an agent. She told me the first three weeks processed fine and the fourth was still pending because the DE 2593 form hadn't come back yet. I didn't even know I was supposed to return that.

0 coins

The DE 2593 is the form they send around week ten to check if you're still unable to work, right? That's exactly the kind of thing I'd miss. I think I'd try Claimyr just to ask whether my own medical certification was received yet.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and Social Security number ready when you call. The agent pulled up everything right away once I gave those.

0 coins

Payments go onto a Money Network prepaid debit card unless you set up direct deposit in SDI Online when you filed. Not Bank of America, that card changed a while back. Worth checking your payment method in SDI Online now rather than wondering later why a card you expected didn't arrive.

0 coins

I didn't set up direct deposit when I filed. Can I change it now?

0 coins

Log into SDI Online through myEDD and check your payment method in the claim. Direct deposit is available on SDI Online claims.

0 coins

Yes you can update it! I changed mine about a week after I filed and it worked fine.

0 coins

After both parts of the claim are in, EDD typically reaches out about the status within 14 days. It doesn't always feel that fast, but that's their general window. If the psychiatric certification is submitted through SDI Online your claim should move along like any other.

0 coins

14 days feels like forever when you're waiting and stressing, but I guess that's the process.

0 coins

It really does drag when you're watching for it. Keep an eye on SDI Online for updates and check that your contact info is current in myEDD so you don't miss a notice.

0 coins

Nobody ever mentions that if EDD can't approve the claim they send a Notice of Determination with an appeal form. You have 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal. If you get one of those, don't wait.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice, not from when I receive it?

0 coins

Date on the notice. So open it the second it arrives and don't sit on it.

0 coins

If you file late you can still appeal, but you'd need to explain the delay to an administrative law judge. Better to get it in on time.

0 coins

The DE 2525XX had already been sent to my psychiatrist's office but she hadn't opened it yet. Asked her to submit the extension before the deadline. Used Claimyr to reach an agent who confirmed EDD had sent the extension form with my final payment notice and that nothing had come back yet. That was the confirmation I needed to push the office to act.

0 coins

Final payment notice triggering the extension form was the same point I hit. Used Claimyr myself and the agent walked me through which receipt number on my account matched the open claim, because I had two from different periods and wasn't sure which one my new doctor should use. Went straight to the office with that number.

0 coins

been calling since the beginning of the month and still haven't gotten through once

0 coins

Physical therapists can't certify DI claims by the way. I've seen that come up a few times. Someone will finish a surgery and their PT is the one they see most, and they assume the PT can sign off. EDD's list doesn't include physical therapists.

0 coins

wait really, i told my buddy his pt could do it, gonna have to tell him that was wrong

0 coins

Correct. The list covers physicians, osteopathic physicians, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, midwives, and authorized medical officers. Physical therapists aren't on it.

0 coins

Exactly. Your buddy needs to get to whichever doctor ordered the PT and have that person certify.

0 coins

The hardest part for me was my provider being unfamiliar with SDI Online's provider portal. She kept saying she couldn't find my claim. Turned out she was searching by my name instead of the receipt number.

0 coins

Receipt number is everything. My doctor's office lost mine and we had to go back and forth twice before they found the claim.

0 coins

I'm going to text my psychiatrist's office right now and confirm they have the receipt number written down correctly. Not taking any chances.

0 coins

Unemployment and SDI are not the same thing and you can't be on both at the same time for the same days. I see people mix those up a lot on these threads. If you're out because of a medical condition you're on SDI, not unemployment.

0 coins

What if you got laid off while you're on SDI? Does the SDI stop?

0 coins

SDI pays for the days you can't work because of the medical condition. When you're able and available to work again, that's when unemployment comes into the picture. EDD handles each claim separately.

0 coins

Okay so the SDI doesn't automatically stop just because of a layoff, got it.

0 coins

My psychiatrist submitted on a Friday and by the following Tuesday EDD had both parts! The SDI Online system can move pretty fast once the provider gets in there and completes it. Really hope yours goes as smoothly!

0 coins

That's encouraging to hear. I'm going to follow up with her office tomorrow morning and make sure she knows the receipt number and the SDI Online portal.

0 coins

Following up early is the right move. Some provider offices batch their certifications and it can sit a few extra days if nobody nudges them.

0 coins

PFL is not the same as SDI, just to flag it since the original question is about mental health. If you are out because of your own condition, that's SDI. PFL is for bonding with a new child or caring for a seriously ill family member. Different claim, different form, no waiting period on the PFL side.

0 coins

Yes, I know mine is the SDI disability claim, not PFL. My situation is my own health condition. But good to put that out there for anyone reading.

0 coins

I mixed those two up completely when I first filed. Asked my doctor to certify a PFL when I needed SDI. Wasted almost two weeks before I caught it.

0 coins

EDD doesn't tell you in writing that you're approved, they just start paying. The Notice of Computation shows what your potential benefit could be, but seeing payments hit is the actual confirmation.

0 coins

So I shouldn't read too much into the Notice of Computation? It just shows what I could get if everything goes through?

0 coins

Exactly. Notice of Computation is not an approval letter. Payments showing up, or a Notice of Determination if they can't pay, are what actually tell you where you stand.

0 coins

Well put. A lot of people celebrate when the Notice of Computation arrives and then get confused when they still have to wait. It's a potential amount, not a green light.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure