Back to California Disability

Ella Harper

How does SDI work with workers comp claim when accepted — California EDD

So I hurt my back pretty bad at work, forklift incident, and workers comp got accepted pretty quickly which I was relieved about. But now I'm trying to figure out if I can also file for SDI through California EDD at the same time. My buddy said I'd get paid by both but that honestly sounds too good to be true and I want to make sure I'm not doing something wrong. Can anyone explain how does SDI work with workers comp claim when accepted? I don't want to mess up either claim by filing something I shouldn't, anyway.

Workers comp and SDI aren't meant to run together for the same injury. EDD says it's not common to get both at the same time, though there are exceptions. What those exceptions look like depends on your specific situation, so you'd want to ask EDD directly how your case counts.

0 coins

So my buddy was just wrong about getting both? I figured it sounded off. What kind of exceptions are even possible?

0 coins

Honestly the exceptions aren't something I can spell out here, that's really EDD's call on a case-by-case basis. Best to ask them.

0 coins

Start date on my own SDI claim got confusing after a work injury situation. I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone at EDD on the phone. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the date EDD had recorded as my disability start date, which wasn't matching what I'd put in SDI Online. Got that corrected before anything else moved forward.

0 coins

Never heard of Claimyr before, what does it actually do? I've been sitting on a question about my own claim dates too.

0 coins

You set it up and it handles holding on the EDD line for you, then your phone rings when an actual EDD person is on the other end. If your start date is off, that's exactly what you'd want to raise with the agent.

0 coins

That makes sense. My disability start date in SDI Online looks different from what my doctor's office wrote on the paperwork and I was not sure how to get that fixed without spending my whole morning redialing.

0 coins

The EDD line for disability is basically a wall. I tried something like forty times over three mornings and got nothing but a recording that cut me off. For a work injury situation where workers comp is already accepted, you really do need to talk to someone before filing SDI.

0 coins

Forty times isn't even an exaggeration. I hit that same wall when my claim was pending.

0 coins

Exact same recording every time too. Not even a queue, just done.

0 coins

I had the same question when my workers comp came through for a shoulder thing earlier this year. What I found out from researching EDD's own site is that SDI is specifically for non-work-related illness or injury. A work injury goes through workers comp. The two programs aren't designed to stack on the same days.

0 coins

Wait so the whole point of SDI is injuries that AREN'T at work? I think I completely had that backwards.

0 coins

Yeah that's the core thing. Work injury means workers comp. SDI fills in for stuff that happens off the job, like getting sick or having surgery that wasn't from work, or pregnancy.

0 coins

Does that mean if workers comp denies part of the claim down the road I could file SDI then? Or is it too late because the injury was at work?

0 coins

That I genuinely don't know. EDD decides how each case counts, so I'd ask them rather than guess.

0 coins

Worked construction for 22 years and seen guys try to run both. EDD's position is pretty clear, those two don't pay the same days. If workers comp is covering you, that's your program for that injury.

0 coins

That tracks. Workers comp is on the employer's dime, SDI is a different system entirely.

0 coins

Exactly. SDI comes out of your own paycheck deductions, the CASDI line. Workers comp is the employer's insurance.

0 coins

My coworker at the salon tried to file both after she slipped on a wet floor and workers comp picked it up. EDD flagged it pretty fast. She ended up having to sort out a whole mess. So just be careful.

0 coins

That sounds like a headache, did she have to pay anything back?

0 coins

She did get an overpayment notice yeah. Took forever to sort out. The appeal process, the forms, all of it.

0 coins

An overpayment notice even if she didn't know the two couldn't overlap? That feels harsh.

0 coins

Whether someone knew or not, EDD still issues the overpayment notice if they paid out when they shouldn't have. The appeal form is included in the notice and you have 30 days from the notice date to send it in.

0 coins

I'm kind of in a gray area and not sure if it applies here. I was hurt at work but workers comp only covered part of my time off. For the weeks they didn't cover, could SDI pick those up? Or is the whole claim still considered a workers comp claim because the injury happened at work?

0 coins

That kind of partial coverage situation is exactly what you'd need to ask EDD about directly. I wouldn't want to guess how they'd classify those uncovered weeks.

0 coins

Yeah I figured. I've been nervous to file anything without knowing for sure.

0 coins

The CASDI deduction on your pay stub is what funds SDI! So technically you've been paying into it, but that doesn't mean you can claim it at the same time as workers comp. The programs serve different purposes.

0 coins

yeah i always wondered what that casdi line was, never really looked it up

0 coins

It's your State Disability Insurance contribution, taken out of every paycheck. So you've been building eligibility for years probably!

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in last spring for a non-work claim and the weekly amount on it surprised me. I phoned EDD to understand how it was calculated and ended up using Claimyr to actually reach someone. The agent walked me through which quarter of my base period they'd used, and it matched the highest-earning quarter which is exactly what EDD says they look at.

0 coins

Claimyr worked out for me too on a different question. Had a missing medical certification and the agent confirmed right on the call that EDD hadn't matched it to my claim yet, which explained why everything was stuck. Saved me weeks of wondering.

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about how to get the certification matched up faster once you knew it was missing?

0 coins

She said the provider needed to submit it through SDI Online using the receipt number from my original filing. Once that happened it moved along.

0 coins

The base period calculation is one of those things that's hard to follow without seeing your own numbers. EDD's disability benefits calculator on their site can give you an estimate before the notice arrives.

0 coins

Worth knowing: the waiting period on SDI is seven days, non-payable, and it's not processing time. Some people think those first seven days are just EDD being slow. They're not. That's built into the program. Workers comp has its own waiting period rules, completely separate.

0 coins

I think I actually thought the waiting period WAS just them being slow. So day eight is the first day they'd actually pay?

0 coins

First payable day is day eight, yes.

0 coins

Does the waiting period apply even if you've had a previous SDI claim before?

0 coins

Every new claim has its own seven-day waiting period. That's how it works.

0 coins

For anyone tracking this by dates: EDD says most payments go out within two weeks of receiving a fully completed claim, meaning both your part and the medical certification from your provider. Missing either one and the clock doesn't really start.

0 coins

so both parts have to be in before anything gets processed, good to know

0 coins

Exactly. Your claimant statement is Part A, the doctor completes Part B. Both need to be in SDI Online before EDD can move on it.

0 coins

Genuine question: if someone gets workers comp and it ends, like the case settles, can they then file SDI? Or is that also not allowed because the original injury was work-related?

0 coins

If you're able to work again when the comp case settles, that's really more of an unemployment situation than SDI. SDI requires that you still can't do your regular work due to the disability. EDD sorts out which applies.

0 coins

Makes sense. So SDI is specifically for when you're still unable to work, not just when workers comp stops.

0 coins

My crew filed for SDI when we weren't injured, things like back surgery unrelated to work, illness, that kind of stuff. That's what it's designed for. Workers comp handles the on-the-job stuff. Tried to keep those two straight for years on the jobsite.

0 coins

That's a helpful way to think about it. Work injury = workers comp, everything else = SDI.

0 coins

Yep. Simple as that in most cases. Edge cases you gotta ask EDD.

0 coins

The SDI filing window is also worth knowing: you file no earlier than nine days after disability starts and no later than 49 days in, or you risk disqualification. If you're trying to figure out whether SDI even applies, don't wait too long to ask.

0 coins

49 days goes fast. Good to know that clock.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came up when I needed more time off than my original claim covered. Getting any answer out of EDD by phone took ages on its own. Used Claimyr to get through eventually, and the agent told me EDD had received the extension form from my provider but hadn't yet linked it to my active claim. Knowing that it was received at least told me what to wait on.

0 coins

Did the agent say whether you needed to do anything from your side, or just wait for EDD to link it?

0 coins

Just wait. EDD links it on their end when they process it. Nothing for me to submit again.

0 coins

been trying that disability line for about two weeks myself, every morning before my shift. never got past the recording once.

0 coins

Two weeks of that would exhaust anyone.

0 coins

Extensions are something a lot of people don't know about until they're in a panic. Your doctor submits the DE 2525XX, you don't file a new claim. EDD sends that form with the final payment notice when your original approval period is ending.

0 coins

I didn't know the extension form came with the final payment notice! I thought I'd have to track it down myself.

0 coins

EDD sends it as part of the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification when your benefits are wrapping up. So keep an eye on your mail around that time.

0 coins

Can I ask something kind of basic: if someone files SDI and then workers comp gets approved after, what happens? Does EDD want money back?

0 coins

That could result in an overpayment situation, yes. EDD would likely issue a notice. You have 30 days from the notice date to appeal if you disagree with how they calculated it.

0 coins

So better to know upfront which one applies before filing, got it, lol.

0 coins

Filing through SDI Online in myEDD is usually the fastest way to get the claim started on the SDI side, if SDI does end up applying to your situation. The system gives you a receipt number right away and your doctor needs it to submit their part.

0 coins

I lost my receipt number and had to track it down from the confirmation email. Don't delete that email is my advice.

0 coins

The receipt number is in SDI Online too if you log into myEDD, so you can always pull it back up there.

0 coins

The 49-day window for the medical certification matters as much as the 49-day filing window. EDD says the provider must submit their certification within 49 days of when the disability began. Miss that and the claim is at risk.

0 coins

Is that 49 days from when I stopped working or from when I actually filed?

0 coins

From when the disability began, which is when you first couldn't do your regular work. Not the filing date, not the date you saw the doctor for the first time.

0 coins

That is a really important distinction, I had it backward.

0 coins

I'd been thinking the Notice of Computation meant my claim was approved. I was wrong. EDD sends that notice to show the potential weekly amount, but it doesn't mean EDD has decided you're eligible. Approval comes through payments actually being issued, or through a determination notice.

0 coins

I made that exact mistake, saw the notice and thought I was all set.

0 coins

A lot of people do. The Notice of Computation is just about the amount, not the eligibility decision.

0 coins

If the claim isn't going to be paid, EDD sends a Notice of Determination instead, and that one comes with the Appeal Form DE 1000A. The appeal window is 30 days from the date on that notice.

0 coins

so basically for a workers comp situation youre covered by that and sdi is for like getting sick or hurt outside of work, is that the short version

0 coins

That's the short version. Work injury stays in workers comp. SDI is for off-the-job stuff.

0 coins

ok that actually clears it up, was confused for a while

0 coins

Okay after reading all this I think I had it completely wrong. Workers comp handles my forklift injury, SDI wasn't meant to stack on top of it. I'll talk to EDD before doing anything else just to be sure about the edge cases people mentioned. Thanks everyone.

0 coins

You can also send EDD a message through SDI Online using Request Claim Update if you have a claim open, or use Ask EDD on their site. Gets your question in writing which is sometimes easier than the phone.

0 coins

Ask EDD might be the move. I'll try that first.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure