Back to California Disability

Zoe Papadakis

How does California EDD calculate SDI benefits when returning to disability after Paid Family Leave

So I'm really confused and hoping someone has been through this before. I took bonding leave through PFL right after my delivery, and now my doctor is saying I have a postpartum complication that means I need to go back on disability. I already used my DI for the childbirth recovery period before the PFL started. Does EDD open a brand new claim for the return to disability, or does it attach to the original one somehow? And the thing I'm most anxious about is the benefit amount. When they calculate SDI benefits for this new disability period, do they go back to the same wages they used the first time, or do they look at a different set of quarters? I'm trying to figure out if the weekly amount would be the same as before or could come out different. I filed the original DI claim through SDI Online and that part went fine, but I have no idea how EDD handles this situation. Any help appreciated.

SDI Online showed which weeks got paid on my own injury claim, so I know exactly what I'm dealing with. EDD's disability line is another story, four mornings of trying before I got a live person by going through Claimyr (claimyr.com). Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed which weeks had actually been issued payments versus which ones were still showing open, which cleared up a discrepancy I'd been staring at for days.

0 coins

My extension request is sitting out there and I haven't been able to get anyone on the line to confirm they even got it. Planning to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I make the call?

0 coins

Receipt number from when you filed, your Social Security number, and the dates you're asking about. Agent can pull the claim right up with those.

0 coins

Three mornings here too, line just cuts off. Good to know there's another way to get through.

0 coins

The question to put to EDD is whether the postpartum disability is treated as a new claim or a continuation, and the answer matters because a new claim uses a new base period. EDD calculates the weekly benefit using the highest-paid quarter from a 12-month base period that looks back roughly 5 to 18 months before the new claim's start date. So if your PFL period lasted several weeks, the base period for a new DI claim could include wages from quarters the original claim didn't touch, which might push the amount up or down depending on what you earned in that window. The calculator on EDD's site can give you a rough estimate once you know which quarters would apply.

0 coins

So it really could be a completely different amount than the first claim? That's kind of stressful to not know in advance. Does the Notice of Computation come before the first payment so I'd at least know what to expect?

0 coins

Yes, EDD sends the Notice of Computation before the first payment on a new claim. It shows the weekly benefit and the maximum. That's your first real look at the number.

0 coins

The base period question is exactly what had me confused on my own claim. I ended up with a higher quarter than I expected because my wages shifted over that 5 to 18 month window.

0 coins

Wait, so after PFL ends you can go back on disability if your doctor certifies you still can't work? I thought once you switched to PFL the disability part was just done.

0 coins

If a new medical condition arises, or the original one continues after bonding, the provider can certify a new DI claim. PFL and DI are separate programs. PFL doesn't use up your DI entitlement.

0 coins

Oh wow I genuinely didn't know that. Good to know for my clients who go through this.

0 coins

Same, I had no idea that was an option.

0 coins

I'm kind of in a similar spot and this thread is helping but I'm still nervous. My PFL bonding period ends in about three weeks and my doctor already told me she's going to certify that I can't go back yet. Do I need to file a whole new claim in SDI Online before she can submit anything, or does she certify against the old claim? I don't want to mess up the timing.

0 coins

File a new claim for the new disability period. After you file and get a receipt number, give it to your provider so she can submit the medical certification. The certification has to match the new claim, not the old one.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. And the nine-day wait before filing still applies to this new claim too, right? Or does it not count because I was just on PFL?

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period is for each new claim. It's not processing time, it's just the first seven days that aren't payable. File when you can and let the timeline work itself out.

0 coins

Thank you. At least I know to start a new claim and get my doctor the receipt number right away.

0 coins

EDD's going to look at whatever quarter pays out highest in the new base period. Same formula, different window. That's really all there is to it.

0 coins

Does that mean my benefit amount could actually be higher on the new claim than the first one? My wages went up a little before I went out.

0 coins

Could be. Depends which quarters fall in the new window. The Notice of Computation will tell you.

0 coins

For reference on mine, the base period ran from roughly Q3 of the prior year through Q2 of the claim year. EDD used my highest single quarter from that range. So if your pay went up recently it might land in a better quarter than the first claim used.

0 coins

wait so pfl doesnt have a waiting period but new disability does? thats kinda rough when youre already dealing with a postpartum thing

0 coins

Correct. PFL has no waiting period. A new DI claim has the standard seven-day non-payable period at the start. Worth knowing going in.

0 coins

ugh okay at least its only a week not longer

0 coins

Yeah it stings but it's baked into every new claim, nothing specific to this situation. At least the payment formula still looks at your best quarter.

0 coins

My provider submitted the DE 2525XX for my extension and I wasn't sure EDD had actually received it. Spent almost two weeks trying to get through on the phone. Ended up reaching an agent through Claimyr, and she confirmed the extension form was in and told me which weeks it covered. That was the clearest answer I'd gotten on my claim in a month.

0 coins

The extension piece is exactly where my own claim is right now. I used Claimyr for a different question a few weeks back and the agent confirmed which quarter of my base period EDD had used to set my benefit. That was actually really useful because I'd been reading my Notice of Computation wrong. Now I need to figure out the extension side.

0 coins

How many times had you tried the line before that? I've been at it since Tuesday.

0 coins

Tried six mornings over two weeks before the Claimyr call. After that I just had the answer and moved on.

0 coins

Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday for me, keeps ringing out. Anyway, good to hear extensions actually do show up in the system once they're in.

0 coins

My question on the original post thing is whether you even qualify for a second DI claim if you haven't gone back to work at all. Like does EDD require you to return to work between claims or is a new medical reason enough?

0 coins

A new or continuing medical condition that your provider certifies is enough to file a new DI claim. There's no requirement to return to work between a PFL period and a new DI claim. EDD evaluates each claim on its own merits.

0 coins

Okay that actually clears that up. I was thinking there was some rule about working in between.

0 coins

Makes sense. The two programs are separate so there shouldn't be a crossover work requirement.

0 coins

The timing on filing matters more than people realize. File the new DI claim within 49 days of the new disability start date or you risk disqualification. If your PFL ends and you go straight back to disability, start the clock from when the new medical condition actually prevents you from working.

0 coins

49 days from the new disability start, not from when PFL ended? Those could be different dates if the condition started before PFL was even over.

0 coins

Exactly right. The disability start date is whatever date the provider certifies you couldn't work, not the date PFL ended. Keep those separate in your head.

0 coins

I had to re-read that twice but it makes sense now. The medical condition drives the date, not the PFL end date.

0 coins

Filing in SDI Online is the fastest path for the new claim. Log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and open SDI Online from there. You'll get the receipt number right away and can hand it to your provider the same day.

0 coins

That's what I did for the first claim and it was pretty smooth. Good to know the process is the same for the second one.

0 coins

myEDD really is easier than people expect. I always tell my clients who are going out on leave to just do it online.

0 coins

Something worth checking before you file: pull your pay stubs from roughly 5 to 18 months before your expected new claim start date and see which quarter had your highest earnings. That gives you a reasonable preview of where EDD might land on the weekly amount before the Notice of Computation arrives.

0 coins

That's a really practical idea. I can actually do that now while I'm waiting for the PFL to wrap up.

0 coins

EDD's disability benefits calculator on their site can help too if you punch in the quarterly amounts. It's not exact but it gets you close.

0 coins

The calculator helped me set a budget before my first check came in. Much better than guessing.

0 coins

My claim's start date had been entered wrong in the system, which pushed my first payable day out by almost a week. Couldn't get anyone on the disability line, tried every morning for about nine days. Used Claimyr and got through to an agent who confirmed the actual start date EDD had on file and what it should have been. Ended up with a discrepancy that needed a fix but at least I knew what I was dealing with.

0 coins

Nine days of trying and nothing, I'm having the same problem right now. I find it hard to believe anything actually gets you through to a live person on that line, I've sat there mornings hitting redial until it disconnects.

0 coins

I had the same feeling after all those failed mornings. When I actually got someone on the line through Claimyr I checked twice that it was really an EDD agent. It was. She had my claim on screen, read me the start date, and told me to watch for a notice in the mail about the correction.

0 coins

been stuck in the same loop. glad the start date thing got sorted for you at least.

0 coins

okay maybe ill give it a shot then. nothing else is working.

0 coins

For the medical certification side, make sure the provider knows they're certifying a new claim, not extending the old one. The DE 2525XX is for extensions on an existing claim. A new DI claim after PFL needs the provider to certify through SDI Online against the new receipt number you get when you file.

0 coins

So the extension form and the new claim certification are two different things? I want to make sure I tell my doctor the right one.

0 coins

Different forms, different purpose. Extension form goes to an existing open claim. New claim certification uses the new receipt number from the new filing. Tell your provider which one applies to your situation.

0 coins

My provider's office mixed these up once and it caused a two-week delay. Worth being very specific with them upfront.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came about five days after EDD received the medical certification on my new claim. The weekly amount was higher than my first claim because my highest quarter had shifted into a better earnings period. Reached an agent through Claimyr to ask about the computation itself, and she walked me through which quarter EDD had used and confirmed the figures matched what was on the notice. That was reassuring after all the uncertainty.

0 coins

What is Claimyr? I keep seeing it mentioned and I haven't heard of it before.

0 coins

It's a service that handles holding the line with EDD in your place and your phone rings once a live agent picks up. That's really all it is.

0 coins

Oh interesting. I have a client who's been trying to reach EDD about her payment amount for weeks. That might be worth passing along.

0 coins

Honestly the simplest answer to the original question is that EDD treats the return to disability as a fresh claim with a fresh base period. Same formula, new window. Everything else flows from that.

0 coins

That's actually the clearest way anyone has put it in this whole thread. Fresh claim, fresh base period, same formula.

0 coins

Yep. All the complexity people stress about comes down to that one fact.

0 coins

Does the seven-day waiting period apply even if you were literally just on disability two months ago and then PFL and now back to disability? Feels like you should get some credit for already having served one waiting period, anyway.

0 coins

Each new claim has its own waiting period. There's no carryover from a prior claim. It's just how the program works.

0 coins

Figures. Worth asking though.

0 coins

yeah i asked about this once and got the same answer, its just part of it

0 coins

The provider also needs to certify within 49 days of the new disability start date, same as the original filing rule. If the office is slow about submitting, that deadline can sneak up. Worth reminding them when you hand over the receipt number.

0 coins

49 days for me to file and 49 days for the provider to certify, both from the new disability start date?

0 coins

That's the rule. Both clocks start from the same date. File your part early so your provider has as much of that window as possible to submit.

0 coins

The 49-day window is in EDD's filing instructions. Easy to miss but it's there.

0 coins

been following this thread because i might be in the same situation in a few weeks. my pfl is winding down and my doctor hasnt cleared me yet. glad i know to file a new claim and not wait for edd to do something automatically.

0 coins

That was my exact worry too, that there was some automatic process and I'd mess it up by filing separately. Sounds like filing new is the right move.

0 coins

Nothing automatic here. EDD needs you to initiate the new claim. Don't wait for them to reach out.

0 coins

This helped me understand something I've been confused about for weeks. Filed the new claim yesterday after my PFL ended. Receipt number is in my provider's hands already.

0 coins

Good to hear you got it moving. Hope the certification comes in quickly and EDD processes it fast.

0 coins

Me too. At least now I know what to watch for.

0 coins

For anyone still unsure, the main takeaway I got from this thread: PFL ending and going back on disability means a new DI claim, a new base period calculation, a new waiting period, and a new medical certification. Not a continuation of anything that came before.

0 coins

That's an accurate summary. The only connection to the prior claim is that it might inform which quarters you look at when estimating the new benefit, but EDD runs the numbers fresh.

0 coins

Clean break between programs. That's what trips most people up.

0 coins

Okay I think I finally have a full picture of this. File new, give provider the receipt number, wait for the Notice of Computation, and don't assume any numbers carry over from before. Thank you all.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure