Got a notice from California EDD's overpayment department — what do I do now?
So I got a letter in the mail last week that honestly made my stomach drop. I've been on SDI since the end of summer after a pretty rough back injury that kept me off my feet for weeks, and I thought everything was squared away. I reported my hours when I went back part time in October, did everything through SDI Online, and figured I was good. Then this letter shows up saying I was overpaid and I owe money back. I genuinely don't understand how this happened. I reported every single week I worked, logged the hours, the whole thing. The letter mentions an overpayment amount for a few specific weeks but I can't figure out how they calculated it differently than I did. It also mentions I have the right to appeal but I'm not sure what that even means or how long I have. Has anyone else gotten one of these out of the blue after going back to work part time? Did you fight it or just pay it? I really want to understand my options before I do anything because honestly I can't just hand over money I don't have right now.
80 comments

Mateo Gonzalez
Part-time return situations can get messy with EDD and overpayment notices are more common than people realize. The key thing with what you're describing is the appeal window — it's 30 days from the date printed on the letter, not from when you got it. So count from that date, not today. You'd file the appeal using the DE 1000A form, which should have come with the letter, or you can write a detailed letter if you've misplaced it. Mail it to the return address on the notice itself. When you write your explanation, lay out exactly which weeks you reported, what you reported, and when you submitted it in SDI Online. Keep it factual and specific.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorThe date on the letter is from about two weeks ago so I still have time, that's a relief. The DE 1000A is in the envelope, I see it now. Should I include copies of my pay stubs for those weeks too?
0 coins
Mateo Gonzalez
Pay stubs, any SDI Online confirmation screens or receipts you saved, and anything that shows the dates and hours you reported — all of it. The more documentation you have showing what you told EDD and when, the clearer your appeal case will be.
0 coins
Nia Williams
Agree with this, I went through almost the same situation last spring. I'd also write a short timeline of when you went back part time, what your schedule was, and when you submitted each certification. Having it laid out chronologically made my appeal letter easier to write and easier for the judge to follow.
0 coins
Luca Ricci
Before the appeal thing — it might be worth going back into SDI Online and pulling up each of those specific weeks the notice flags. Under your claim history you can see what was submitted and whether EDD recorded it the same way you did. Sometimes the issue is a data entry mismatch or a timing thing where your reported earnings landed in a different benefit week than you expected. If you spot a discrepancy between what you submitted and what EDD shows, that's exactly the kind of thing to put in your appeal letter.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorI hadn't thought to check claim history that carefully. I went back and looked just now — the weeks they're flagging do show my part-time hours, but the amounts look different than what my pay stubs say. Not sure if that's the error or if EDD calculated it differently.
0 coins
Luca Ricci
That difference is worth documenting specifically. Write down what your stubs show versus what SDI Online shows for each week, side by side. That comparison is the core of your argument.
0 coins
Aisha Mohammed
Pulling that claim history is smart move. When I had a discrepancy it turned out my employer had reported my wages separately and EDD had two different numbers for the same week. The comparison between what I submitted and what EDD recorded is what actually got my case looked at seriously.
0 coins
Ethan Campbell
Notice of Determination I got back in September nearly sent me into full panic mode — it denied a chunk of my claim and I had no idea why. Claimyr (claimyr.com) was how I got an actual person at EDD on the phone that week. The agent looked up the notice and told me EDD had flagged weeks 4 through 7 of my claim as a Notice of Determination issue because the medical certification hadn't been matched to my claim ID in their system yet. She confirmed the certification was actually there, just unmatched. I filed my appeal with that detail in the letter and it changed everything. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorThe unmatched certification thing is wild — that kind of internal mismatch would never show up if you just looked at SDI Online yourself. Did the agent say anything about how to prevent it next time, like double-checking the receipt number?
0 coins
Ethan Campbell
She confirmed the receipt number I'd given the doctor's office was the right one, it just hadn't processed through yet at the time EDD generated the notice. The fix was filing the appeal before the 30 days expired and including the certification receipt number in my letter.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
The 30-day window is unforgiving. Had a family member go through an overpayment dispute and the hardest part was just making sure the letter got postmarked in time. If you're close to the edge, some people hand-deliver it to their local SDI office so there's no question about the date.
0 coins
Carmen Sanchez
An overpayment notice doesn't automatically mean you owe it — it means EDD thinks you do based on what their records show. You have every right to show them a different picture. The appeal process exists exactly for cases where the claimant believes their reporting was correct. What you described, reporting hours each week through SDI Online, is exactly the kind of paper trail that makes an appeal worth filing. Don't pay anything while your appeal is pending if you can help it, and definitely don't ignore the letter.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorThat's actually really good to know. I was afraid ignoring it would make things worse but I also didn't want to pay something I might not owe.
0 coins
Carmen Sanchez
Responding by the deadline is the critical part, not necessarily paying immediately. The appeal is your formal way of saying 'I disagree and here's why.' That stops the clock on the demand while EDD reviews it.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
There's also the possibility EDD recalculates and reduces the overpayment amount during the appeal process. I've seen that happen when someone had good documentation showing they reported accurately. Worth knowing going in.
0 coins
Zoe Papadakis
Went back to work part time after my shoulder surgery this past spring and got hit with a similar notice about six weeks after my final payment. The weeks they flagged were ones where I'd worked a few hours on a Friday and my pay didn't land until the following Monday, so my paycheck dates straddled different benefit weeks. That timing mismatch is what caused the overpayment calculation to look wrong on EDD's end. My pay stubs with the actual workday dates versus the pay dates were the evidence that made the difference in my appeal.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorThe paycheck timing thing hadn't occurred to me at all. My pay period runs biweekly so there's a real chance the same thing happened with my dates. I'm going to compare my actual workdays against the benefit week calendar right now.
0 coins
Zoe Papadakis
The benefit weeks run Sunday through Saturday for SDI purposes. Map your actual work dates against that calendar and see where your hours actually fell versus when you got paid. That might be exactly where the discrepancy is.
0 coins
ThunderBolt7
This is a super common source of confusion with partial week reporting. The benefit week boundary versus the pay period boundary are almost never aligned and it trips people up constantly.
0 coins
Jamal Edwards
My cousin went through an SDI overpayment and she just paid it because she thought appealing was like going to court and she was scared. She didn't have to do any of that — the appeal process is administrative, not a courtroom. It's paperwork and an administrative law judge reviews it. No lawyer required.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorHonestly I think I had the same fear, like I'd have to show up somewhere and argue in front of a judge in person. Knowing it's paperwork-based makes it much less intimidating.
0 coins
Carmen Sanchez
The hearing is an option, not a requirement. A lot of appeals are resolved on the written record alone. You submit your documentation, your explanation, and EDD has to respond to it. The administrative law judge makes a decision from there.
0 coins
Jamal Edwards
Telling her that after the fact was painful because she definitely could have won — she had all her reporting confirmations saved from SDI Online. The documentation was sitting right there.
0 coins
Mei Chen
Something I want to flag about payment while appealing: I've seen a few people assume that if they just pay the overpayment amount right away it closes the matter and they can't get back anything if the appeal succeeds. Talk to EDD about your specific situation before making any payment while an appeal is pending. The appeal and any payment are handled separately but the sequencing matters.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorSo if I did pay it and then won the appeal, would I get it refunded? Or is it just gone?
0 coins
Mei Chen
That's a question to put directly to EDD — how they handle that depends on the specific circumstances of a claim and I don't want to give you a wrong answer on something that consequential. It's exactly the kind of thing worth getting answered by an actual EDD rep before you do anything.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
Agree that this is not one to guess on. The sequence of appeal versus payment is something EDD needs to tell you about your own case. Don't assume either way.
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
The DE 1000A form is straightforward once you read it through. There's a section where you write your explanation — don't rush it. I took about an hour drafting mine for an overpayment dispute last year, made sure every sentence was about a specific week, a specific amount, or a specific thing I submitted. No vague 'I reported everything correctly' statements. Every claim got tied to a document.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorAn hour feels right, I'd probably rush it otherwise and leave out something important. Did you hear anything back before the actual decision?
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
EDD sent a notice acknowledging receipt of the appeal, then nothing for a while, then the decision letter. No way to know the timeline from mine since it probably varies a lot. Just make sure to keep copies of everything you send.
0 coins
Giovanni Marino
The acknowledgment notice came about two weeks after I mailed mine. Then the actual appeal went to the Office of Appeals so the timeline shifted. Keeping copies of your mailed appeal and the envelope with the postmark matters if there's ever a question about whether it arrived in time.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Sayed
Receipt number on my claim had been entered wrong by my doctor's office at the initial filing stage, and I didn't catch it for three weeks because SDI Online just said pending without giving me a reason. Used Claimyr to get through to EDD's disability line, and the agent pulled up my account and confirmed the receipt number on file didn't match the one I had. She told me to have the provider resubmit using the correct number. That was the whole hold-up.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorThree weeks on pending because of one wrong digit sounds like a nightmare. I'm glad there's a way to get an actual person to look at the account rather than just reading whatever SDI Online shows.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Sayed
The SDI Online view just said pending — there was nothing on the claimant side that pointed to the number mismatch. The only way to find out was to have someone look at the actual account.
0 coins
Dylan Hughes
The receipt number thing is so important and nobody tells you about it at the filing stage. I had my surgeon's office confirm in writing that they used the exact receipt number I gave them, just to have a record if something like this came up.
0 coins
NightOwl42
Had a question about the SDI process when I was out for a knee procedure earlier this year — wanted to track when each payment actually posted. EDD's automated disability payment line is 1-800-480-3287 and it gives you payment info without needing a live agent most of the time. That said, there was one week where the automated line showed issued but nothing had arrived on my Money Network card and I needed to know if EDD had actually released it. Ended up getting an agent on the line, who confirmed the payment date and told me the deposit had been initiated on a specific date that matched what eventually posted.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorWait — EDD's card is Money Network now? I thought it was still the Bank of America card from a few years ago.
0 coins
NightOwl42
EDD switched from Bank of America to Money Network for the debit card. If you're still seeing Bank of America on something, it might be old paperwork or a card that hasn't been reissued yet. Any new payments go through Money Network.
0 coins
Sofia Rodriguez
Confirmed on the Money Network card — I enrolled in direct deposit when I filed so I dodged the whole card situation, but a coworker asked me about the Bank of America card recently and I had to tell her that it's Money Network now. Worth spreading the word.
0 coins
Nia Williams
Overpayment disputes are genuinely one of the more winnable EDD appeals if you have your documentation in order. The cases that tend to go poorly are ones where someone reported late, inconsistently, or didn't save any confirmation from SDI Online. From everything described here, it sounds like there's a solid paper trail to work with.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorThat's reassuring. I do have SDI Online confirmations for each week and I saved screenshots at the time, which I know sounds paranoid but I had a feeling.
0 coins
Nia Williams
Screenshots are not paranoid, they're exactly right. Especially if the submission date is visible in the screenshot — that's evidence of when you reported, not just what you reported.
0 coins
Luca Ricci
Timestamps on those screenshots matter. If you can show that you submitted your hours within the benefit week itself, that's much stronger than just showing the amounts.
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
Something weird that happened with my SDI claim that might be relevant — I went back to work part time about three weeks before my claim officially ended, and EDD sent me a DE 2593 form asking about my continued eligibility around the same time. I returned it within the 20-day window but I wonder if the timing of that plus the part-time reporting created some crossed wires on their end. Never got an overpayment notice but I always thought the overlap seemed like it could cause issues.
0 coins
Carmen Sanchez
The DE 2593 and the partial wage reporting happening at the same time could definitely create a confusing picture if the dates overlap in a way EDD reads as inconsistent. Worth checking if any of the flagged weeks in your overpayment notice line up with when you returned the DE 2593.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorMine was during the last stretch of my claim too so now I'm wondering if the same thing happened. I did get a DE 2593 around the same time I went back part time.
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
Look at the dates on both — the weeks on the overpayment notice and the period the DE 2593 covers. If there's an overlap, that's another thing to put in your appeal letter explaining the timeline.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
The 30-day clock is one of the few truly hard deadlines in the whole SDI process. Extensions for a late appeal are possible but the administrative law judge has to decide the late filing was for a good reason, and that's not guaranteed. File on time even if your appeal letter isn't perfect yet. You can supplement it later but you can't get back a missed deadline.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorSo it's better to file a less polished appeal on time than a perfect one a day late?
0 coins
Andre Dupont
Every time, yes. An on-time appeal that's thin gets reviewed. A late appeal might not get reviewed at all without the judge finding a valid reason for the delay.
0 coins
Mateo Gonzalez
You can also note in the original filing that you're submitting to meet the deadline and may provide additional documentation. That's not unusual and gives you a little more time to gather everything while still protecting the appeal.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
EDD's overpayment department isn't necessarily trying to squeeze you — the notices are often generated pretty mechanically when their records show a discrepancy. The human review is what actually sorts it out, which is why the appeal exists. The system sends the notice; people fix the system's mistakes.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorThat reframe actually helps. I was treating the letter like an accusation but it's more like a flag that needs correcting.
0 coins
Yuki Watanabe
Exactly. EDD doesn't know what's in your pay stubs or what your actual work schedule looked like. The notice is based on what their system recorded. Your appeal is how you show them what actually happened.
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
This is the right way to think about it. The appeal isn't adversarial, it's informational. You're giving them data their system didn't have.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
While you're gathering everything — make sure you can account for how you got paid for the partial weeks. Some people get a straight hourly rate, some get a weekly salary regardless of hours, and EDD may calculate the wage offset differently depending on how your employer actually paid you for those partial weeks. Your pay stubs need to show what you actually earned each week, not just your hourly rate.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorMine are hourly so the pay stubs should be clear about what I actually earned each week. Good to know that's what matters rather than just my rate.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
Hourly is actually easier to document because the stub shows hours times rate equals what you got paid. Weekly salary situations get messier if someone took days off mid-week and their pay didn't reflect it cleanly.
0 coins
Zoe Papadakis
Even with hourly, check that the stub lists the actual workdays or the pay period dates because that's what the benefit week comparison turns on, not just the gross amount.
0 coins
NightOwl42
Payment date question from my own claim got resolved pretty quickly once I had an agent on the phone — Claimyr is what got me there after I'd been trying the disability line for two mornings without getting through. The agent confirmed that one payment had issued on a Tuesday but wouldn't post to Money Network until the following business day due to the deposit processing window. Knowing that stopped me from filing an unnecessary inquiry.
0 coins
Sofia Rodriguez
The processing window between EDD releasing a payment and it showing on the card is something I wish I'd known about earlier. I called in a panic the first time it happened and the rep just told me to wait until the next business day.
0 coins
NightOwl42
The automated line shows the issue date, not the posting date, which is where the confusion usually comes from. The agent explained it was a normal deposit timing situation and there was nothing to do except wait for it to clear.
0 coins
Mei Chen
Using the automated line first to get the issue date and then checking the card the next business day is a good routine to build. Saves you from having to reach anyone unless something genuinely doesn't match.
0 coins
ThunderBolt7
For anyone still unsure about the appeal form itself — the DE 1000A has a small section asking for your reason for disagreeing. Keep it concise but specific. Administrative law judges review a lot of these; a clear, well-organized statement with evidence attached gets read more carefully than a long emotional narrative. Lead with the factual discrepancy, then attach the documentation.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorSo open with the specific weeks, the specific amounts that are different, and then attach the stubs and screenshots?
0 coins
ThunderBolt7
That's the structure. Week, what you reported, what your stub shows, what EDD has on file — if you can do that for each disputed week in a table or a list, it's much easier to follow than prose paragraphs.
0 coins
Giovanni Marino
Sending the appeal via certified mail is worth the few dollars too. You get a tracking number and a delivery confirmation, which makes the postmark question moot if there's ever a dispute about timing.
0 coins
Aisha Mohammed
Partial return to work is one of those situations where the SDI rules interact with real paycheck timing in ways that are genuinely confusing even when you're trying to do everything right. EDD's going to look at what their records show, your job is to show them what actually happened. That's all an appeal is.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorIt's weirdly reassuring that this is a known pattern and not just something weird that happened to me. Makes it feel less random.
0 coins
Aisha Mohammed
More common than it should be, honestly. The benefit week boundary doesn't line up with how most employers run payroll, so the same hours can land in different benefit weeks depending on how your pay cycle falls. EDD's system isn't built around your employer's pay schedule.
0 coins
Andre Dupont
And EDD isn't going to know about the mismatch unless you show them. That's the whole point of the appeal — bridging the gap between what their system recorded and what actually happened.
0 coins
Sofia Rodriguez
Went through my own SDI claim for a pretty serious wrist injury last year and the thing nobody told me was to screenshot SDI Online confirmations every single time I submitted anything. By the time I got a confusing notice about one of my weeks I had to reconstruct some things from memory instead of having a clean record. Keeping a folder with dated screenshots of every SDI Online submission is advice I give everyone I know who's on a claim.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorI did save screenshots but only starting from about week three — the first two weeks I didn't know I should. Those happen to be two of the weeks flagged. That's going to be a problem.
0 coins
Sofia Rodriguez
Check if you got any email confirmations from SDI Online around those weeks, or if there are any submission timestamps still visible in your claim history. It's not the same as a screenshot but it might give you something for those early weeks.
0 coins
Luca Ricci
Even partial documentation for those weeks is better than nothing. If you have the later weeks fully covered and can explain what you remember about the earlier ones, include both. A judge can see that your documentation got better over time, which actually supports that you were trying to report correctly.
0 coins
Giovanni Marino
Appeals for overpayment can sometimes result in EDD revising the amount downward rather than a full reversal — meaning they agree with part of your reporting but not all of it. That's still a win if the revised number is lower. Going in expecting either a full win or a full loss might set the wrong expectations; a partial correction is a real outcome.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
AuthorThat's something I hadn't thought about. Even if they don't reverse it entirely, a reduced amount that I actually owe would be a lot more manageable than the original notice.
0 coins
Giovanni Marino
And a reduced amount on appeal is documented, which matters if you ever need to show that the original notice was at least partially incorrect. Keep copies of every notice you receive, including the appeal decision.
0 coins
Carmen Sanchez
Partial corrections happen because the administrative law judge can look at each disputed week independently. If you have strong documentation for some weeks and weaker documentation for others, you might win on the well-documented ones even if the others are harder to dispute.
0 coins