Back to California Disability

Luca Romano

Employer never deducted SDI, can I still collect pregnancy disability benefits?

So I just found out I'm pregnant and started looking into what disability benefits I might get through California EDD when it's time to take leave. When I pulled up my pay stubs going back a couple years I noticed there's no CASDI deduction anywhere on them. Not a single one. I asked HR and they kind of brushed me off and said I'd have to look into it myself. Now I'm panicking because I'm due in about five months and I have no idea if I even qualify for SDI or if my employer not taking out that deduction means I'm just out of luck. Has anyone dealt with this before? Do I even have a claim if the deduction was never made?

Pay stubs with no CASDI line is worth looking into before you assume the worst. Some employers run a Voluntary Plan instead of the state SDI program, which is a private plan that covers the same thing. HR might have been vague because they don't know you're asking about their plan specifically. Ask them directly whether the company has a Voluntary Plan for disability.

0 coins

I didn't even know Voluntary Plans existed. I'm going to go back to HR and ask exactly that. If there's a plan through the company, would I still file through SDI Online or somewhere else?

0 coins

A Voluntary Plan is administered by the employer or their insurer, not through EDD. HR would tell you how to file under their plan. If there's no Voluntary Plan, then the missing deduction is a payroll issue and EDD still has options.

0 coins

My old salon had a Voluntary Plan and nobody told us for like two years. You really do have to ask HR the exact right question or they just stare at you.

0 coins

Weeks 14 through 20 of my claim showed as paid in SDI Online but I couldn't tell if the two weeks before that had gone through. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the line at EDD. Video on reaching a live person on EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed those two earlier weeks had been issued and when. Helped a lot to actually hear it said out loud instead of staring at a screen.

0 coins

Claimyr worked for my base period question too. The agent told me which quarter of the four in my base period had the highest wages and was being used to calculate my weekly amount. I'd been guessing from my own records and had the wrong quarter.

0 coins

Which quarter did they end up using, and was it the one you expected?

0 coins

It was the second quarter of the base period, not the most recent one like I assumed. My hours had been cut late last year so the earlier quarter actually had more in it. The agent just read it off the claim.

0 coins

Okay so if I do end up having a valid claim, calling EDD directly can actually get me real answers about what's on my account? Good to know that's even possible.

0 coins

Talked to someone in payroll at my last company when I had a similar question. Turned out they were misclassifying some of us and EDD had a process for it. File your claim and let EDD sort out the employer side.

0 coins

EDD sorting out the employer side took forever for a guy I know. File early don't wait.

0 coins

Agreed. File as early as EDD lets you, which for pregnancy is about four weeks before the due date, and don't sit on it hoping HR figures itself out.

0 coins

Filing four weeks out means I should be starting to put this together now then. I had no idea it was that close.

0 coins

The whole payroll deduction thing is on the employer, not you. EDD's own site says the SDI deduction is the employer's job to withhold. If they didn't, that's their problem to fix, not a reason to deny your claim.

0 coins

Is that actually EDD's position, that a missed deduction by the employer doesn't disqualify the employee?

0 coins

That's how it works. The employee doesn't control what gets withheld. You earned wages, the employer was supposed to take the SDI contribution out, they didn't, that's between them and EDD.

0 coins

To be precise about it, EDD can go after the employer for the unpaid contributions. The claimant who had wages in the base period and meets the other requirements can still file. It's not the worker's fault the employer dropped the ball.

0 coins

Wait I might be misunderstanding but doesn't the CASDI deduction on your check prove you paid into the system? Like if it was never taken out does that mean there's no record of contributions and EDD has nothing to base a claim on? I'm not sure I'm reading this right.

0 coins

The record EDD looks at is the wage report the employer files, not the deduction line on your stub. Even if the employer never withheld CASDI from you, they should have been reporting your wages to EDD. That wage report is what creates your base period record.

0 coins

Oh okay so EDD might actually have my wages on file even though my stubs don't show the deduction. That's actually kind of reassuring.

0 coins

Right, and if the employer also failed to report wages, that's a bigger issue, but EDD has a process for disputing wage records. You'd have to show your W-2s or pay stubs as evidence.

0 coins

my employer never took out sdi either and i just filed last month for my own thing, edd didnt reject me right away so fingers crossed i guess

0 coins

Did you have any issues when you submitted the claim? Like did SDI Online flag anything or was it just normal?

0 coins

totally normal to file, just went through the same screens as anyone else. nothing asked about whether my employer deducted it or not

0 coins

The DE 2525XX my midwife submitted after my original claim ended showed up in SDI Online within a few days. I'd been nervous about the gap between the first claim ending and the extension starting, so I ended up using Claimyr to get through to someone at EDD's disability line. The agent confirmed the extension had been received and told me which weeks it covered so I knew there wouldn't be a break in payments.

0 coins

EDD's disability line has chewed up half my mornings over the past few months. Marketing is usually what I call a service that promises to do what I've been failing at for free. What actually happened when you used it?

0 coins

I had the same doubt, then spent three weeks hitting the same busy signal every time and tried it anyway. The agent told me my DE 2593 had been received and confirmed the 20-day return window I had, which was about to close. I would have missed that without that call.

0 coins

If it got you a real EDD agent and not just a recording, fine. I'll give it a shot before I lose another morning.

0 coins

The DE 2525XX is the form for extensions? My provider would submit that, not me, right?

0 coins

For what it's worth on the base period question, EDD's site has a disability benefits calculator. If you put in your wages by quarter it'll estimate your weekly benefit amount. That's also how you can check whether you even hit the minimum needed for a claim.

0 coins

I found the calculator on EDD's site and tried it. My wages are definitely in there for the right quarters, which makes me think my employer was at least reporting even if they weren't deducting. That's something, right?

0 coins

Yes, that's actually the more important part. If your wages are in EDD's system, you have a base period record. The deduction question is a payroll compliance issue between your employer and EDD, not a barrier to filing.

0 coins

Just to put some structure on it, the base period covers wages in four quarters, and EDD uses the highest-paid quarter to calculate your weekly amount. If your wages show up in the calculator, your employer was filing their reports correctly even if the CASDI line is missing from your stubs.

0 coins

HR told you to look into it yourself? That's just bad. Put whatever they said to you in an email so there's a record.

0 coins

Honestly that's a good call. Right now it was all verbal and I wish I'd gotten something in writing.

0 coins

Ask them again by email. Something like, can you confirm whether the company has a Voluntary Plan and whether my wages were reported to EDD. Gets them on record either way.

0 coins

Five months out means you're probably looking at filing around four weeks before your due date for the pregnancy disability part. After that there's a separate bonding claim through Paid Family Leave which is a whole other thing, but you'd cross that bridge after the birth.

0 coins

Is PFL also through EDD? I've seen it mentioned but didn't know if it was the same program as SDI.

0 coins

Paid Family Leave is a separate EDD program from DI. Your pregnancy disability claim is through SDI. After you've recovered from the birth, if you want to bond with your baby, that's a PFL claim, filed separately. Different form, different benefit period.

0 coins

And just so you know, PFL doesn't have a waiting period like the DI claim does. The first week of disability is unpaid waiting, then it kicks in on day eight.

0 coins

Claim start date on mine got recorded wrong and I didn't catch it for three weeks. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and the agent pulled up the claim and confirmed the actual start date they had on file versus what I thought it was. Turned out the date had been entered correctly after all, I'd just misread my own paperwork.

0 coins

What did you even say to the agent to get them to look at the start date specifically?

0 coins

Just told them the date I stopped working and asked them to confirm what date the claim showed. They read it back, matched my last day, done.

0 coins

been trying that line for two weeks now. every time it just cuts off. maybe i should just accept i'm not getting through.

0 coins

There's another angle here worth considering. If the employer never enrolled in SDI at all and never reported wages, the claimant can contact EDD about a wage dispute and submit evidence like pay stubs and a W-2. It's more work but it's not a dead end.

0 coins

If I end up needing to do a wage dispute, what evidence should I be pulling together?

0 coins

W-2s for the base period years, all of your pay stubs, and any employment contract or offer letter showing your hire date and wages. The more documentation the better.

0 coins

Pay stubs with dates and amounts matter more than you'd think in those situations. Keep every one you have from the past two years at minimum.

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period trips a lot of people up. The first week of your disability claim is unpaid no matter what, then benefits start on day eight. It's not EDD processing slowly, it's just how the program works.

0 coins

So even if everything goes perfectly, there's a full week at the start where nothing gets paid?

0 coins

Exactly, that first week is just not covered by design. It's not a glitch or a delay.

0 coins

Okay that I did not know. I was under the impression payments started from day one. Good to know before I plan my finances around it.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim came about two weeks after I filed and had my weekly benefit amount on it. Called EDD through Claimyr to double check the numbers before I banked on them. Agent read back the weekly figure and the max benefit on the claim, matched the notice exactly.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation is pending and I need to know if the weekly amount they're calculating is based on my wages from the right quarters. I'll try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I get through?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and your Notice of Computation in front of you if you have it. Know the quarters you worked and the rough wages each quarter so you can follow what the agent says.

0 coins

So the Notice of Computation shows up before EDD actually approves the claim? I thought it was the approval letter.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation tells you the potential weekly and maximum amount they calculated. It's not an approval, it just shows what the benefit would be if the claim is paid. An actual denial would come as a Notice of Determination.

0 coins

my manager went through something similar last year, her employer had messed up withholding, she still filed and edd worked it out on the back end, never affected her getting paid as far as she told me

0 coins

That's really reassuring to hear. Did she have to do anything extra when she filed or just go through the normal process?

0 coins

she just filed normally through SDI Online, nothing extra on her end, edd handled whatever the employer issue was separately

0 coins

just want to flag the medical certification piece because nobody's mentioned it yet, your doctor or midwife has to submit their part through SDI Online too using your receipt number, make sure they have it because without that the claim just sits there anyway

0 coins

The receipt number is what I get after I submit my part online, right? And then I have to give it to my provider so they can find the claim and submit the medical certification?

0 coins

yes exactly, you file your part first, get the receipt number, give it to whoever is certifying for you, they go into SDI Online and complete their section, missing that step is probably the number one reason claims stay pending forever

0 coins

For a pregnancy claim a licensed midwife or nurse-midwife can submit the certification, not just an OB. Worth knowing if that's who your care is with.

0 coins

For what it's worth, I called the EDD disability number at 1-800-480-3287 and actually got through on a Tuesday morning! Took a while but I got to ask my question. Just putting that out there in case someone hasn't tried recently.

0 coins

I tried that number for four straight days at opening time and got a recording that ended the call every single time. Glad it worked for you.

0 coins

I really was surprised! Might have just been lucky timing on that particular day.

0 coins

The practical step right now is to file even without full certainty about the employer side. Filing opens the process and EDD will request what they need. Waiting to file risks missing the 49-day deadline from when your disability starts.

0 coins

49 days from when the disability starts, not from the due date. I want to make sure I have that right. So once I stop being able to do my regular work, the clock starts then?

0 coins

Correct. The disability start date is when your condition means you can't do your regular work, which for pregnancy can be before the birth if your provider certifies that. The deadline to file runs from that date.

0 coins

EDD also says to file no earlier than nine days after the disability start date but no later than 49 days from it. Those are the two ends of the filing window.

0 coins

Has anyone actually had EDD deny a claim specifically because the employer didn't withhold? I've heard this fear come up but never heard of it actually happening.

0 coins

Not in anything I've read or anyone I know. The employee doesn't control payroll. EDD's issue would be with the employer.

0 coins

The denial reasons EDD lists are about the claimant's own eligibility, the medical certification, the base period wages. Missing CASDI deduction by the employer isn't on that list.

0 coins

That's what I figured. The anxiety about it makes sense but it's probably not the actual problem here.

0 coins

You mentioned your due date is about five months out. If your provider says you have pregnancy-related restrictions before the birth, like reduced hours or certain duties you can't do, that can be when disability starts, not just right before delivery. Worth asking at your next appointment.

0 coins

I didn't realize the disability start could be earlier than the four weeks before the due date. My job involves being on my feet all day so that might actually matter.

0 coins

Exactly, if your job has physical demands and your provider documents that you can't safely do it, benefits can start earlier. That would be in the medical certification.

0 coins

just found out the payment method defaulted to a prepaid debit card and i thought it was going to be a direct deposit. is that the standard?

0 coins

EDD's default is the Money Network prepaid debit card. If you filed through SDI Online, you can choose direct deposit instead. It's not automatic, you have to select it.

0 coins

didnt realize i had to pick it. going to log into myedd now and see if i can still switch it

0 coins

You can update the payment method in SDI Online before payments begin. Log in at myedd.edd.ca.gov, open SDI Online and find your claim. The option to change to direct deposit should be there.

0 coins

Thank you all for this. I went back to HR with a direct question about the Voluntary Plan and they finally confirmed there is no Voluntary Plan. They also confirmed my wages were being reported to EDD, they just never set up the CASDI withholding correctly. The payroll manager is apparently panicking now. I'm going to file my claim through SDI Online and let EDD sort out the employer side. I feel a lot less like I'm just out of luck.

0 coins

Filing and letting EDD deal with the employer piece is the right call. You did the work of getting the answer out of HR, now the claim process can move.

0 coins

Good outcome. File soon, don't let the HR drama slow you down.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure