Back to California Disability

LunarLegend

Does permanent disability affect SDI approval for full year

So I've been out of work since late October because of a back condition that my doctor says is permanent. She's already submitted the paperwork classifying it as a permanent disability, and now I filed my SDI claim through SDI Online. What I can't figure out is whether having it labeled permanent is going to cause problems with EDD approving the full 52 weeks, or if EDD treats it differently than a temporary condition. My doctor said I genuinely cannot do my regular job anymore, and she certified that in the medical certification she submitted. I've tried reading EDD's website but I keep going in circles. Has anyone had a permanent condition and still gotten the full year of DI benefits?

Payment method on my claim was showing something weird in SDI Online, and after a week of getting nowhere on the phone I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and actually ended up talking to an EDD agent. Video on reaching someone at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed my direct deposit info hadn't been saved correctly from when I filed, so she walked me through what to do to get it updated. On your actual question, from what the agent mentioned, EDD looks at whether you can do your regular work right now, not whether the condition will ever fully resolve.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came weeks ago but I still haven't seen the first payment land anywhere. Want to ask about which weeks are actually pending. Have my claim ID and everything ready to go if Claimyr works the way you're saying.

0 coins

Claim ID, your Social Security number, and the last four of your debit card or your bank account info if you switched to direct deposit. Those are the things the agent asked me for right at the start.

0 coins

been trying that number three tuesday mornings in a row and it just cuts out around the five minute mark every time, so good to hear something actually got through

0 coins

The part about EDD looking at whether you can work right now, not whether it'll ever get better, that's actually really reassuring. That's exactly what my doctor certified.

0 coins

The question worth putting to EDD directly is whether the medical certification your doctor submitted covers the full period you're claiming, because that's what determines how far out payments can go. DI pays up to 52 weeks on a single claim, and the certification your provider filed is what EDD uses to establish the period you're unable to do your regular work. A permanent diagnosis doesn't cap the benefit or change the 52-week limit, but the certification has to reflect the actual dates.

0 coins

My doctor certified through the end of April, so does that mean I'd need her to submit another form after that even if the condition is permanent?

0 coins

After the initial period your doctor certified, the physician/practitioner submits a Supplementary Certificate, the DE 2525XX. EDD typically sends that form with the final payment notice. Your doctor files it on their end, not you.

0 coins

EDD sent me the DE 2525XX with my final payment notice and my doctor filed it within the week. Worth flagging to your doctor's office now so they're not caught off guard when it shows up.

0 coins

Okay so the DE 2525XX is the extension form and EDD sends it automatically. I didn't know that. I'll mention it to my doctor's office at my next appointment.

0 coins

Permanent just means your condition doesn't go away. EDD cares if you can't work right now. That's what the certification covers. You're fine as long as the doctor keeps filing the right forms.

0 coins

Makes sense. My doctor said the same kind of thing when I asked her about it.

0 coins

Yep. EDD's not in the business of predicting the future. Can you work this week or not, that's the question.

0 coins

medical certification my provider submitted got flagged somehow and my payments stopped for two weeks before I even knew there was a problem. I tried phoning EDD four different times that week. Used Claimyr on the fifth try and an agent actually answered. She checked and told me the certification was in their system but hadn't been matched to my claim yet because the receipt number on file didn't match what I submitted. Got that sorted the same day. For anyone with a permanent condition, make sure your doctor used the exact receipt number you got when you filed.

0 coins

The unmatched receipt number issue is what held my claim up too. I've used Claimyr on my own claim, and after the agent confirmed the medical certification mismatch on mine, I sent my doctor's office a secure message through the patient portal with the correct number. They resubmitted and the pending status cleared two days later. That Notice of Determination I'd been dreading never came after that.

0 coins

how do you even find the receipt number after you already filed, is it in sdi online somewhere

0 coins

It's in the confirmation screen right after you submit your claim in SDI Online, and EDD also emails it to the address on your myEDD account. If you didn't save it, check that email first.

0 coins

ok checking now thanks

0 coins

Had no idea the receipt number was that important for the doctor's side of it.

0 coins

EDD does not care what label your doctor puts on the condition. What they're looking at is the certification period. If the certification says you can't work from date X to date Y, that's the window. After that your doctor extends it. The word permanent is a medical term, not an EDD term.

0 coins

So the certification period my doctor chose is basically the claim period, and permanent versus temporary doesn't change how EDD reads it?

0 coins

Exactly. The certification period is what drives the payment period. Permanent, chronic, whatever your doctor calls it doesn't factor into the EDD calculation.

0 coins

This is right. I went through almost this exact thing last year with a degenerative condition. The word permanent in the chart notes made no difference to how EDD processed the claim.

0 coins

The 52-week limit is on the total benefits paid out, not on the duration of the disability itself. So if your condition is permanent but you can keep getting your doctor to certify each period, you can use up to 52 weeks of DI on that claim. After 52 weeks, it ends regardless.

0 coins

Does that 52-week clock restart if you go back to work for a bit and then have to stop again?

0 coins

A new claim would need to meet its own eligibility requirements. Whether prior weeks affect anything on a new claim is something EDD would determine based on your specific work history and wages. I wouldn't assume one way or the other without asking EDD directly.

0 coins

52 weeks total on the claim, got it. I hadn't realized it was capped at a year from the start, I thought maybe it was open-ended for permanent conditions.

0 coins

Not open-ended, no. A year is the max no matter what.

0 coins

Worth knowing that the base period EDD uses to figure your weekly benefit amount is the 12 months ending about 5 to 18 months before your claim started, specifically your highest-paid quarter in that window. A permanent condition doesn't change how that's calculated, your wages are your wages.

0 coins

My wages were pretty consistent, so I guess the highest quarter isn't going to vary much. I already got the Notice of Computation and the amount looks reasonable.

0 coins

If the amount on the Notice of Computation seems off, there's a calculator on EDD's site you can use to cross-check the estimate. But the notice itself is what EDD will use.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation isn't an approval, by the way. It just shows the potential amount. Approval comes later, reflected in actual payments or a denial notice.

0 coins

You mentioned going in circles on EDD's website. The clearest thing I found was that DI covers you when you can't do your regular job, up to 52 weeks. That's really the whole answer. Permanent or not doesn't come into it.

0 coins

My regular job involves lifting and my doctor said I can't lift anything over five pounds right now. So that should be clear enough for the certification.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of thing the certification should capture. Your doctor knows what to write.

0 coins

My doctor was pretty specific about functional limits in mine and EDD didn't push back at all.

0 coins

I confused SDI and workers comp at first because my injury happened over time and I wasn't sure which one applied. SDI ended up being the right one since it wasn't a single work incident. Just making sure you're on the right track since you said back condition.

0 coins

Mine is definitely not a work injury, it's a degenerative thing my doctor has been monitoring for a couple years. So SDI is the right program.

0 coins

Good, just wanted to flag it. EDD's pretty clear that work injuries go through workers comp, not SDI, so sounds like you're on the right path.

0 coins

EDD themselves say it's not common to get both SDI and workers comp at the same time. You're right to sort that out early.

0 coins

Waiting period question came up for me in a confusing way with my own claim, so I want to make sure it's clear here. The first seven days of a DI claim are a non-payable waiting period. That's not processing time, it's just seven days EDD doesn't pay, no matter how fast everything else goes. I actually phoned EDD about it because my SDI Online showed no payment for those days and I thought something was wrong. Used Claimyr to get through, and the agent confirmed my waiting period was days one through seven of my claim, and that the eighth day was my first payable day.

0 coins

Seven calls to that line in the past two weeks and I've gotten through maybe twice, both times on hold so long I had to hang up. Not sure I believe any service actually cracks that line consistently.

0 coins

My own experience before that call was similar, two mornings of nothing before I tried Claimyr. The agent I reached was an actual EDD employee who pulled up my claim right there. That waiting period confusion would have dragged on another week otherwise.

0 coins

I went through the same waiting period mix-up! Thought EDD had lost my first week entirely. Turns out those seven days just don't pay, end of story. The agent I reached confirmed my claim's start date was correct and that the waiting period counted from there.

0 coins

Alright, might be worth a shot. The number I keep hitting is 1-800-480-3287 and it's a wall every time.

0 coins

I didn't know the waiting period was literally seven non-payable days, not just slow processing. That explains why my first payment was smaller than I expected from the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Your doctor certifying a permanent condition is not the same as EDD denying or limiting a claim. The only thing EDD cares about is whether the certification covers the period claimed. Period.

0 coins

That's the most direct answer I've seen on this. Thank you. I've been worried EDD would read permanent as somehow different.

0 coins

EDD doesn't adjudicate whether something is curable. They adjudicate whether you can work. Two different things.

0 coins

base period on my claim was something I never thought to check until the agent walked me through it. Hadn't even realized which quarter EDD picked as the highest, and mine turned out to be a quarter where I'd worked a ton of overtime. Used Claimyr for that call, and the agent told me exactly which quarter they were using and what the wage figure was. For a permanent disability situation like the OP's, the base period math is the same, the condition's classification doesn't touch it.

0 coins

What does Claimyr do exactly, never heard of it.

0 coins

You let it sit on the line to EDD while you go about your day, and when an agent picks up it rings you so you're the one talking to them. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Huh. My Notice of Computation looks off to me and I want to ask an agent which quarter they actually pulled. Might try that.

0 coins

been trying mornings for six days straight, that line just doesn't answer

0 coins

There's a bit of a myth worth clearing up about the full 52 weeks. Some people think a permanent condition automatically gets you the full year. It doesn't. You get paid for the weeks your doctor certifies you can't work, up to the 52-week cap. If your doctor only certifies 20 weeks, you get 20 weeks unless she extends it.

0 coins

So I should be talking to my doctor now about how long she plans to certify, and making sure she knows about the DE 2525XX when the time comes?

0 coins

Exactly. Loop her in now. The extension form comes from EDD with your final payment notice, and your doctor files it. But if she doesn't know to expect it, it might sit in her inbox.

0 coins

My doctor's office had no idea about the DE 2525XX until I told them. It was in a stack of other EDD mail they hadn't opened yet.

0 coins

my coworker had something permanent and got the full year no problem, doctor just kept filing extensions every few months

0 coins

The extensions your coworker's doctor filed are the DE 2525XX forms. That's exactly how it works. Each one covers another period, as long as the total doesn't go past 52 weeks.

0 coins

ok yeah that tracks, she had a stack of paperwork from her doctor every couple months

0 coins

From an organization standpoint, keep a log of every date your doctor submits anything to EDD, the receipt number you gave them, and when you see your status update in SDI Online. If something goes wrong, you'll have a timeline to work from.

0 coins

That's a really practical idea. I've been keeping emails but not actual dates of submissions.

0 coins

The submission date matters a lot if EDD ever says they didn't get something. Your doctor's office can usually pull the confirmation from SDI Online on their end too.

0 coins

Ask your doctor's office to send you the confirmation number when they submit. Most offices will do it if you ask.

0 coins

My claim is for a chronic condition and I honestly stressed so much about the word chronic meaning EDD would deny me. It doesn't. The certification period is what matters and my payments have been going fine for months!

0 coins

Chronic, permanent, it's all the same in terms of how EDD treats it. That's really good to hear from someone who's actually in it.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me. Worried for nothing once the payments started.

0 coins

Automatic payments run for ten weeks and then EDD sends a questionnaire called the DE 2593. You have 20 days to return it or benefits can stop. Mark it on your calendar the moment it arrives.

0 coins

Is that the form they send in the mail or is it in SDI Online?

0 coins

EDD mails it. Keep an eye on your physical mailbox around that ten-week mark.

0 coins

I nearly missed mine. It looked like junk mail because the envelope wasn't labeled obviously. Open everything from EDD during your claim.

0 coins

EDD not knowing what permanent means is actually in your favor here. They process it like any other claim. The certification is in, the form is correct, you wait.

0 coins

That's weirdly reassuring. I kept thinking the word permanent was going to trigger some special review or something.

0 coins

No special review for that. Special reviews happen when certifications are missing or the numbers don't add up.

0 coins

been following this thread because im dealing with similar thing. doctor said lifelong condition, still filed, still pending, waiting to see what happens

0 coins

Pending just means EDD is still processing it. Fourteen days is the usual window after the medical certification is in. If it goes longer, check SDI Online first.

0 coins

yeah its been twelve days so i guess still in the window

0 coins

If you hit 14 days without a notice or a payment, try the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online before calling. Sometimes it moves things along.

0 coins

One thing I got wrong early on was thinking the Notice of Computation meant I was approved. It doesn't. It's just showing the potential weekly amount. Approval shows up as an actual payment or a Notice of Determination if there's a problem.

0 coins

Someone else mentioned this above and I'm glad it came up twice because I definitely thought the Notice of Computation was an approval letter.

0 coins

Super common mix-up. The notice is EDD saying here's what you'd get if approved, not that you are approved.

0 coins

The Notice of Determination is what comes if EDD says no. It has an Appeal Form with it and you have 30 days from the date on that notice to file the appeal.

0 coins

Paperwork is paperwork. Keep copies of everything you send and everything EDD sends you. If there's ever a dispute, you need a paper trail.

0 coins

Doing this from now on. I have most things saved in email but not the actual SDI Online submissions.

0 coins

Screenshots too. SDI Online doesn't always let you go back and see what was submitted.

0 coins

To directly answer the original question here: permanent disability as a medical classification does not block SDI approval and does not reduce the 52-week maximum. The question EDD is answering is whether you are currently unable to perform your regular or customary work, and your doctor's certification is what answers that for them. The condition's prognosis beyond that period is a medical question EDD isn't weighing in on.

0 coins

This is the clearest summary of everything in this thread. That's exactly what I needed to know.

0 coins

Agreed. The whole thread kind of circles back to that one point.

0 coins

Wish someone had told me that before I spent three days trying to find it on EDD's site.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure