Back to California Disability

Tasia Synder

Does employer pay first SDI with company disability plan — how does that work in California?

So my HR sent me home after my back thing got bad enough that I can't lift anything at work, and they mentioned something about the company having its own short-term disability plan. I'm totally lost on whether that means my employer pays me first and then state SDI kicks in later, or if it goes the other way around, or if I even file with EDD at all. I've been reading EDD's site for an hour and I still don't know if I need to file on SDI Online or just wait for HR to do something. Has anyone dealt with both a company plan and California SDI at the same time?

Your company plan and state SDI are two different things. File with EDD on SDI Online anyway, don't sit around waiting on HR. The state claim protects you if the company plan doesn't cover everything or runs out.

0 coins

So I file both at the same time, not one after the other?

0 coins

File EDD as soon as you can. Don't let the 49-day window sneak up on you.

0 coins

Filing both at the same time is what most people do. HR handles their side, you handle EDD's side independently.

0 coins

Start date on my claim got messed up and I had no way to fix it through SDI Online. Spent three mornings dialing 1-800-480-3287 and either got a busy signal or the line just cut off after the hold music. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an actual EDD agent, and they pulled up my claim and confirmed the disability start date EDD had on file, which was off by four days from what my doctor's office had submitted. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Four days off on the start date would have cost you a week of benefits. That line thing sounds like a marketing pitch to me, not a real service.

0 coins

Thought the same thing before I tried it. What it does is stay on hold with EDD in your place, then your phone rings when an agent picks up. The agent I spoke with was EDD's own staff, confirmed my start date and said EDD would mail a corrected notice.

0 coins

The start date matters more than people realize because the waiting period counts from it. After my own claim I ran into something similar with the medical certification, and the agent told me EDD hadn't received it yet even though my doctor's office said they submitted it. Took another week to sort out.

0 coins

Alright, the start date fix sounds real enough. I'll see if I can get through myself first and if the line does what it always does to me I'll give that a look.

0 coins

When I was out for my procedure two years ago, HR told me their plan would pay a certain amount for the first few weeks. EDD's benefit ran alongside it. What your employer's plan pays and what EDD pays can overlap, but how they interact is something your HR department and your plan documents will explain, not EDD. EDD only decides what SDI owes you based on your wages.

0 coins

Did EDD know about the company plan or did you just file separately and not mention it?

0 coins

I filed with EDD the same week I went out. EDD's claim is completely separate from whatever your employer offers. EDD calculates your benefit from your wages and the SDI deductions on your paychecks, that's it.

0 coins

Wait so EDD doesn't reduce your benefit if the company is also paying you? I assumed they'd offset it somehow.

0 coins

The SDI benefit calculation uses wages from a base period, the highest-earning quarter in a 12-month window that ends a few months before your claim. The company plan has nothing to do with how EDD figures that number. The Notice of Computation EDD mails you will show the weekly amount and the total maximum. EDD's benefit calculator on their site can give you a rough estimate before the notice arrives.

0 coins

Is that calculator on edd.ca.gov or somewhere else?

0 coins

It's on edd.ca.gov, look for the disability benefits calculator. It asks about your wages and spits out an estimate. The real number is on the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

That's really helpful, I didn't know there was a calculator.

0 coins

My client came in last month talking about this exact thing. Her company had some kind of supplemental plan and she was completely confused about whether to file with EDD. I told her just file with EDD on SDI Online and let HR deal with their side separately, those are two different buckets.

0 coins

Two different buckets is a good way to put it.

0 coins

Right, and EDD doesn't care what your employer is paying. They look at your SDI payroll deductions and your wages, full stop.

0 coins

my old job had something like this and i just filed edd the normal way and got the notice of computation in the mail after like two weeks, company plan paid the first couple weeks on their own schedule, edd paid on its own schedule, they didnt talk to each other at all

0 coins

How long did it take before EDD started paying you after the medical certification went in?

0 coins

maybe like 10 days after my doctor submitted it, then a payment showed up on my money network card

0 coins

Same rough timeline for me. The seven-day waiting period was the part that tripped me up, I kept thinking EDD was late but that first week just isn't paid, anyway.

0 coins

I'm in a similar situation right now and I'm panicking a little. My company said they have a plan but HR hasn't sent me anything about it yet. Do I wait for them to send forms before I file with EDD, or just go ahead and file on SDI Online now?

0 coins

Don't wait on HR. File EDD now. HR can send their forms whenever they want, it doesn't affect your EDD deadline.

0 coins

The 49-day window from when your disability started is EDD's deadline, and it doesn't pause while you wait for HR. File your part on SDI Online and get the receipt number to your doctor right away.

0 coins

Okay filing tonight. Thank you.

0 coins

Company plan pays on their schedule. EDD pays on EDD's schedule. Those two things happening at once doesn't mean you're doing anything wrong. File the state claim.

0 coins

Yep. Two separate systems, two separate checks. File both.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD is going to call your HR department to compare notes.

0 coins

The benefit amount on my Notice of Computation surprised me because it was higher than I expected. Spent a week trying to reach EDD to ask about which wages they used, and the phone line hung up on me every single time. Eventually I went through Claimyr to get an agent on the line, and she told me which quarter of my base period they used and confirmed the weekly amount on the notice was correct.

0 coins

Did the agent say how the quarter gets selected, or just tell you which one it was?

0 coins

She just told me which quarter, not the why behind it. EDD picks the highest-paid quarter in the base period, and she confirmed mine was the second quarter of last year. The notice itself explains the amount but doesn't spell out the quarter by name, so it was helpful to have her confirm it.

0 coins

Have been dialing that number before 8 a.m. for two weeks straight. Some mornings I get a busy tone immediately, other mornings I get through the menu and then it disconnects at the hold music. Knowing there's another way in is useful.

0 coins

The waiting period thing confused me at first too. Thought my doctor hadn't sent in the certification fast enough, but actually that first week just isn't payable no matter what. EDD doesn't pay day one through seven of a new claim, so the first payment covers day eight forward, anyway.

0 coins

So even if EDD gets everything the same day I file, I still don't get paid for that first week?

0 coins

Exactly. It's not a processing delay, it's a built-in unpaid waiting period on every new DI claim.

0 coins

The waiting period is the same regardless of whether you have a company plan too. Neither plan pays that first week unless your employer's own documents say otherwise.

0 coins

My HR actually told me their plan has a waiting period too so they stack up and I basically had two waiting periods at once. EDD's seven-day waiting period still applied separately though!

0 coins

That's pretty common with supplemental plans. They often have their own elimination period before they kick in.

0 coins

Yep and nobody warned me about that upfront. At least EDD's waiting period only happens once per claim.

0 coins

Went back to part-time after my wrist thing healed enough and EDD kept asking me to report my hours. Had a stretch where I wasn't sure which weeks they had already paid versus which ones were still pending. Used Claimyr to get an agent and she went through my claim week by week and told me exactly which weeks had been paid and which were still open.

0 coins

My pending weeks are what I want to ask EDD about too, going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I get on the line?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and your claim ID from SDI Online handy. Also know the specific week ending dates you're asking about so the agent can pull them up fast.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. busy tone every single time before i even get to hold music.

0 coins

Filed on SDI Online on a Tuesday, doctor submitted the medical certification the following Monday, got the Notice of Computation in the mail exactly 11 days after that. The notice showed the weekly amount and the total maximum for the claim period. Company plan paid on its own separate schedule and EDD never asked about it.

0 coins

Eleven days from medical certification to Notice of Computation, that's good to know as a rough timeline.

0 coins

It can vary. EDD says most payments go out within two weeks of a properly completed claim. My doctor submitted everything clean the first time, which probably helped.

0 coins

Filing with EDD is independent of whatever your employer offers. Get your Part A submitted on SDI Online, give the receipt number to your doctor, and let them handle Part B. The company plan runs on its own track.

0 coins

Is Part B the same form for every kind of doctor, or does it change?

0 coins

Same SDI Online process for most licensed providers. Your doctor logs in, finds your claim with the receipt number, and submits the medical certification. Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of who can certify, so if that's your only provider, you'd need an MD or similar.

0 coins

My doctor is an orthopedic surgeon so I think I'm fine.

0 coins

Company plans and EDD are just parallel. File EDD, give your doctor the receipt number, and don't overthink the overlap. EDD's going to pay what they calculate regardless.

0 coins

Pretty much this. The complexity people assume is usually just two separate processes running at the same time.

0 coins

EDD has never once asked me what my employer was paying. Different system, different forms, different payment entirely.

0 coins

An extension question came up on my end later in the same claim. My doctor said I needed more time and I didn't know if I had to file all over again or what. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to EDD and the agent looked at my claim and confirmed they had received the DE 2525XX my doctor submitted, and that EDD would mail a notice about the extended period.

0 coins

The extension piece is exactly where I am right now on my own pregnancy claim. I used Claimyr for that too, actually, and once the agent confirmed the receipt number my doctor had used matched what EDD had on file, I stopped worrying about whether the extension was linked correctly.

0 coins

Have been redialing that line every morning for about a week. Getting through to anyone seems basically impossible.

0 coins

The receipt number matching was the key thing. My extension went through fine once I knew it was tied to the right claim.

0 coins

does the medical certification expire if the doctor submits it too late or does edd just reject the whole claim

0 coins

The medical certification has to be submitted within 49 days of the disability start date. If it comes in after that, EDD can disqualify the claim. Same 49-day window applies to the claimant's own filing.

0 coins

ok so the doctor and me both have the same 49 day deadline, got it

0 coins

Exactly right. That's why getting the receipt number to your doctor quickly matters so they can submit their part well inside that window.

0 coins

Physical therapist tried to certify my buddy's claim and EDD rejected it. Took another week to get his actual MD to submit the right certification. Cost him time on the waiting period clock.

0 coins

Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of authorized certifiers. It has to be a licensed physician, nurse practitioner, physician assistant, chiropractor, psychologist or similar. The waiting period clock doesn't reset because of a provider issue though, it starts from the disability start date either way.

0 coins

Good to know the waiting period didn't reset at least. He was worried about that.

0 coins

That's one of those things worth confirming before your doctor's office just assigns whoever is available.

0 coins

One more thing worth knowing: if you're on automatic payment and your claim goes long, EDD sends a DE 2593 form after 10 weeks asking if you're still unable to work. Return it within 20 days or the payments stop. Easy to miss if you're not expecting it.

0 coins

What happens if you miss the 20-day window on that form?

0 coins

Payments stop until EDD processes the returned form. Send it back as fast as you can if you miss the window and explain the delay.

0 coins

That form caught my neighbor completely off guard. She didn't know it was coming and her payments paused for two weeks.

0 coins

Appeals are worth knowing about too. If EDD denies the claim or issues an overpayment notice, the Notice of Determination comes with an Appeal Form DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal. Miss that and you have to explain the delay to an administrative law judge.

0 coins

Is 30 days from when you receive it or from the date printed on the notice?

0 coins

From the date printed on the notice, not the date you receive it. Open the envelope fast.

0 coins

That date distinction has tripped people up before. The postmark doesn't matter, the notice date does.

0 coins

is there any difference in how edd pays you if your company plan is also paying at the same time, like does it come slower or something

0 coins

No difference in how EDD processes or pays the claim. Payment goes to your Money Network prepaid card or direct deposit if you set that up on SDI Online. Company plan pays separately, however their system works.

0 coins

ok so just two separate payments on separate schedules, neither one slows the other down

0 coins

Correct. EDD doesn't know or care what your company is doing.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure