Back to California Disability

Mateo Warren

Does SDI exclude pre-existing conditions for disability claim in California?

Trying to figure something out before I actually file. I had a back issue that flared up about two years ago, got some treatment, and thought it was behind me. Last month it came back way worse and my doctor says I genuinely can't work right now. The job is research and I'm at a desk all day, and even that's off the table right now. What I keep running into online is vague stuff about pre-existing conditions. Does SDI exclude pre-existing conditions for disability claim purposes the way some private health plans used to? Like, is EDD going to look at my history and say this was already a thing so they won't cover it? Or does it work differently than that? My doctor says she'll certify me, I just want to know if the history is going to be a problem before I go through the whole filing process.

Payment method on my claim took forever to sort out, and while I was dealing with that I ended up calling EDD through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because the regular line just dropped me every single time. Actually got a live agent that way. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ Agent pulled up my account and confirmed the direct deposit I'd set up in SDI Online hadn't saved correctly, which is why the payment was sitting there. Had to redo it through myEDD. Anyway on the pre-existing question, agent didn't weigh in on that specifically, but nothing in my file flagged my prior knee stuff as a problem.

0 coins

What even is Claimyr, hadn't heard of it before this.

0 coins

It waits on hold with EDD's disability line so you don't have to, then your phone rings when an agent picks up. That's basically the whole thing.

0 coins

Got it. I'd want to ask EDD whether my doctor submitted the medical certification yet, that's the piece I'm missing right now.

0 coins

The idea that SDI works like old private insurance with pre-existing condition exclusions is something I believed myself until I actually read through the EDD materials. SDI looks at whether you're currently unable to do your regular work because of a medical condition, and your licensed physician certifies that. EDD's standard is about your capacity right now, not your medical history.

0 coins

That's actually really reassuring. So the medical certification from my doctor is what carries the weight, not some review of my prior treatment records?

0 coins

Exactly. Your physician certifies that you can't perform your regular or customary work currently. EDD evaluates that certification, not a history of the same condition.

0 coins

But what if EDD sees the same diagnosis as before and decides it's not really disabling this time? Do they compare your past claims to new ones?

0 coins

Filed twice in my life for the same shoulder. Second time went through fine. The certification is what matters, your doc says you can't work, EDD goes from there.

0 coins

Two claims on the same shoulder and no issue either time, that's good to know.

0 coins

Yep. Different injury event, same body part. Went through both times without a problem.

0 coins

What EDD needs from your provider is confirmation you can't do your current job right now. A prior episode of the same condition doesn't disqualify you. Your doctor documents the current functional limitation and that's what gets certified.

0 coins

Does the doctor have to explain that it's a flare-up versus a brand new condition, or does that not matter to EDD?

0 coins

The certification covers current inability to work. Whether it's new or recurring isn't a separate category on the form.

0 coins

I keep wondering if EDD ever contacts your old providers or requests old records. That part makes me nervous, not sure how deep they look.

0 coins

Went through something similar with a wrist thing that I'd had a minor surgery on two years before. My hand specialist certified me and EDD didn't bring up the prior surgery at all. The notice of computation came and payments started, nothing about the history.

0 coins

A prior surgery on the same wrist and it wasn't flagged, that's exactly the kind of situation I was worried about.

0 coins

Honestly I was bracing for a fight and there was none. The certification was submitted and that was what EDD was focused on.

0 coins

Same kind of thing happened with me. Prior issue, same area, still approved.

0 coins

Medical certification on my claim sat unmatched for 11 days and I could not get through on that line no matter what I tried. Used Claimyr to reach an agent and she found the certification had been submitted but was sitting under a slightly different name spelling than my claim had. Got it corrected on the call. The pre-existing angle: she didn't mention anything like that being a flag in the system.

0 coins

Claimyr worked for me too on a totally different issue. Got through to an agent who saw I had a Notice of Determination sitting on my claim from a week earlier that I hadn't even received in the mail yet. So I knew to look for it and was able to get the appeal window on my radar. Glad I called when I did.

0 coins

What did the agent tell you about the Notice of Determination specifically, like what it said?

0 coins

She read me the determination date and told me I had 30 days from that date to file an appeal using the DE 1000A if I disagreed. Didn't tell me whether to appeal, just what the window was.

0 coins

The name spelling mismatch causing a delay is wild, hadn't thought about that as a possible snag.

0 coins

EDD's own FAQ and the DI program description don't have any exclusion language for pre-existing conditions. The eligibility question is whether you're unable to perform your regular or customary work for at least eight consecutive days, and whether a licensed health professional certifies that. That's the threshold, not a diagnosis history review.

0 coins

Where does the eight consecutive days part fit in? Is that the waiting period or something else?

0 coins

The eight days is the minimum duration to qualify for DI at all. The first seven of those are the waiting period, which is unpaid. The first payable day is day eight. So you need to be out at least eight days before any payment is possible, and your doctor certifies the full period including those first seven.

0 coins

I had it completely backwards, I thought the waiting period was the time EDD takes to process, not actual days I don't get paid. So those seven days are just gone no matter what?

0 coins

They are. It's not processing time, it's a non-payable period built into every new DI claim. No way around it.

0 coins

What about if the flare-up is from something chronic, like it's not a one-time injury but an ongoing condition that gets bad sometimes? Does EDD treat that differently than a sudden injury? Not sure how they categorize it.

0 coins

EDD's focus stays on current work capacity. A chronic condition that periodically disables you can still qualify if you can't do your job right now and your provider certifies it.

0 coins

Okay so the category of condition doesn't create a separate rule. That's less scary than I thought.

0 coins

Filed in October for a hip issue I'd had injections for the previous spring. The base period they pulled for my claim was the four quarters ending before the claim start date, and the Notice of Computation came about a week after the medical certification went in. Nothing in that notice mentioned the prior treatment.

0 coins

October filing, NOC about a week after certification, no mention of prior treatment. That timeline is helpful to have as a data point.

0 coins

The notice shows your potential weekly and maximum benefit amounts. Prior history wasn't a field or factor anywhere on mine.

0 coins

Waiting period question kept tripping me up on my own claim, so I ended up reaching an agent through Claimyr and asked her to walk through what weeks were actually in the waiting period versus what was payable. She confirmed day one through seven were the non-payable waiting period and day eight was the first day that could be paid. No ambiguity once someone actually looked at my claim dates.

0 coins

Reads like a marketing comment to me, the whole Claimyr thing.

0 coins

Felt the same way when I first saw it mentioned somewhere! But I tried it because I'd been at that phone line for three mornings and kept getting the busy signal or disconnected. Agent I reached told me my claim's start date had been entered one day off from what I filed, which was holding up my first payment. Got that corrected.

0 coins

Hm. Alright, might give it a shot then.

0 coins

The agent was an EDD employee, same as if you got through any other way. That part's just normal once you're on with someone.

0 coins

my coworker had this same worry about a pre-existing thing and her claim went through just fine, doctor certified her and edd didnt ask about history at all

0 coins

Good to hear it held up in a real case and not just in the program description.

0 coins

Filing timeline matters a lot here too. You have 49 days from when your disability starts to file and get the medical certification in. If the history issue had been a reason to wait and think about it, the window could slip.

0 coins

I actually didn't realize there was a 49-day deadline. I've been sitting on this for about two weeks already, so I need to move.

0 coins

Two weeks is fine, you've got room, but don't sit on it much longer. File your part in SDI Online first, get the receipt number, give it to your doctor so she can submit the medical certification.

0 coins

The receipt number your doctor needs comes up right after you submit your claim. Write it down and get it to the office the same day if you can.

0 coins

Base period question on my claim was confusing, so I used Claimyr to get an agent who pulled up exactly which quarter of my wages EDD used. Turned out they used my highest-earning quarter from that 12-month window, which I hadn't tracked carefully. The number on my Notice of Computation made more sense after that call.

0 coins

What did you have ready when you made that call, like did you need your claim ID or anything specific?

0 coins

Had my claim ID and the Notice of Computation in front of me. Agent could see everything on the account but having the notice made it easier to follow along.

0 coins

been trying that line most mornings for two weeks, still haven't gotten through to anyone

0 coins

The doctor submitting the certification late is what I'd actually worry about, not the pre-existing angle. Had a buddy whose provider waited until day 45 and EDD still matched it. Cut it close but worked out.

0 coins

The 49-day window applies to the claimant's filing and to the medical certification. Both need to be in within that period from the disability start date.

0 coins

Right, so both sides have the same 49-day clock. Good to flag that.

0 coins

my wife kept calling me asking if her pregnancy claim would be denied because she'd had a complication the year before and it was going to show up in her records. turns out edd just needed her midwife to certify her current condition, and the prior complication never came up

0 coins

Pregnancy claims work the same way on that front. The certification covers what's happening now, not a history review.

0 coins

Is a midwife allowed to certify a pregnancy disability claim? I didn't know that was an option.

0 coins

Licensed midwives, nurse-midwives and nurse practitioners are specifically listed by EDD as providers who may certify for pregnancy, childbirth or postpartum conditions. So yes, a midwife can do it.

0 coins

People confuse SDI with their old employer's short-term disability plan a lot. Those plans set their own exclusion rules. SDI doesn't follow that model.

0 coins

That's probably exactly where my confusion came from, mixing up how private short-term disability worked at an old job with how SDI works.

0 coins

Pretty common. The CASDI deduction on your paystub funds SDI, not a private plan. Different rules.

0 coins

Also wanted to flag for anyone confused about the payment card, it's Money Network now, not Bank of America. Spent two days looking for a Bank of America card that was never coming!

0 coins

Nobody told me that either when my first payment went out. The Money Network card shows up and you have no idea what it is at first.

0 coins

Exactly! The card looks nothing like what I expected. If you chose direct deposit in SDI Online you won't see it, but if you're on the default, that's the card that arrives.

0 coins

PFL is a separate claim for bonding with a baby after the pregnancy disability period ends. Some people think it's the same as SDI disability and try to file it the same way. The pregnancy disability part is DI, the bonding part after is PFL, different claim.

0 coins

I've been mixing those up this whole time. So the disability part ends when the doctor says she's able to work again, and then if she wants bonding time she files a separate PFL claim?

0 coins

Correct. The physician or midwife certifies the disability period, typically six weeks for a standard birth or eight for a Caesarean section, and after that a PFL bonding claim is a separate filing.

0 coins

We went through this sequence. The DI claim closed, then the PFL bonding claim opened separately. Two different claims in SDI Online.

0 coins

been sitting at pending for three weeks now and the pre-existing thing isn't even my issue, just the certification my provider says she submitted but edd doesn't seem to have

0 coins

Get the receipt number from your original filing confirmation and have your provider check that's what they used when they submitted. A mismatch there is what held mine up.

0 coins

she submitted through the provider side of sdi online but i have no way to see what name or number she used on her end

0 coins

You can send a message through SDI Online using Request Claim Update to ask EDD whether the medical certification has been received and matched to your claim. That's the official route if you can't get through by phone.

0 coins

If EDD denies a claim after the doctor certifies it, is there any way to push back? Someone told me denial means it's just over.

0 coins

A denial comes with a Notice of Determination and an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date on that notice to file the appeal. It's not over at denial, the appeals process exists specifically for that.

0 coins

So the appeal deadline runs from the date on the notice, not the date I receive it in the mail?

0 coins

From the date it was issued, yes. So if it sat in the mail for a few days, that time still counts. Open those notices the day they arrive.

0 coins

That 30-day clock caught someone I know completely off guard. They thought they had 30 days from when they read it.

0 coins

To answer the original question directly: nothing in SDI's rules excludes a condition because you've had it before. The only question is whether you're unable to work right now and whether a licensed provider certifies that.

0 coins

Filing today. My doctor already said she's ready to submit the medical certification as soon as she has the receipt number, so I'll get that to her this afternoon.

0 coins

That's the right sequence. File, grab the receipt number, pass it to your doctor same day.

0 coins

Also use EDD's benefit calculator on their site before you file if you want a rough sense of what your weekly amount might be. The Notice of Computation will have the real figure but the calculator can give you a ballpark.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure