Back to California Disability

Isabella Oliveira

Do I need an SDI appeal attorney if my employer overstated wages and my disallowed claim repayment notice came in?

So I'm kind of panicking right now and not sure where to start. I got a notice from EDD saying my disability claim is disallowed, and from what I can piece together it looks like my employer reported my wages wrong, like they overstated what I was making, and now EDD is saying I owe money back. I filed my claim after I had to stop working because of a back injury and I thought everything was fine. I did get a Notice of Computation at some point and saw a weekly amount, then payments started. Now this notice is saying the claim wasn't valid and I have to repay. Does anyone know if I actually need a lawyer for a California EDD SDI appeal in this situation? I don't even fully understand how wages factor into whether a claim gets allowed or disallowed. I have 30 days to respond I think but I'm scared of doing something wrong and making it worse.

The notice EDD sent, the DE 2517, has an Appeal Form attached, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date printed on that notice to get it in. If the form is gone, a detailed letter mailed to the address on the notice works. Lead with the wage error.

0 coins

Found the DE 2517 and the appeal form is attached. So I just fill out the DE 1000A and explain that the wage amount my employer reported was wrong? Do I attach anything?

0 coins

Attach anything that shows the correct wages, pay stubs, W-2s, whatever you have. The more specific you are on the appeal form about what was wrong and why, the better.

0 coins

Got it. Pulling together my stubs now. Thank you for being so clear about this.

0 coins

The 30-day window is on the notice itself, not from when you received it, so check the date it was issued, not the postmark. EDD's appeals page spells this out. A late appeal can still be reviewed if you give reasons for the delay, but an administrative law judge has to sign off on that, and it adds more uncertainty.

0 coins

Wait, so the 30 days starts from the date they printed on the letter, not the day I actually got it in my mailbox? That seems like it could catch people off guard.

0 coins

Exactly, and it does catch people. If the notice was mailed and sat in transit for a few days you might have less time than you think. Open those envelopes right away when anything from EDD comes.

0 coins

Okay now I'm going to be anxious every time something arrives from EDD. I didn't realize the clock starts on their end.

0 coins

DE 2593 came in the mail and I almost missed it. Had a 20-day window to return it. Tried the EDD disability line for three mornings straight and got a recording every time. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got a live agent on the line. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent pulled up my claim and confirmed they had received the form and that my benefits would continue. That was the piece I needed.

0 coins

What exactly is Claimyr? Haven't heard of it before this post.

0 coins

You hand off the hold time to the service, and when an EDD agent actually picks up, your phone rings. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Huh, okay. I've got a question about my waiting period that I'd want to sort out with a real agent. Might actually use that for it.

0 coins

Three mornings is nothing, I tried for two weeks. Anyway good to know there's a way through.

0 coins

An attorney isn't required for an SDI appeal, and many people handle the hearing themselves. Where having legal help becomes more useful is when the wage dispute involves the base period calculations and the employer's records conflict directly with what EDD has on file. If the difference in wages affects whether you even had enough to qualify, that's the kind of thing where a free consultation with a workers' rights clinic might be worth your time before the hearing.

0 coins

That's exactly the situation, the wage difference apparently pushed my qualifying wages in a direction that made EDD say the claim shouldn't have paid. So it's not just the repayment amount, it's whether I qualified at all.

0 coins

Then definitely look into a consultation. Some legal aid organizations handle EDD appeals at no cost, especially wage-related ones.

0 coins

Does the appeal cover both the disallowed claim and the repayment demand, or do you have to file two separate appeals?

0 coins

Usually one appeal addresses both when they come from the same determination, but read the DE 2517 carefully because it will state exactly what is being appealed.

0 coins

Employers misreport wages and workers get the bill. Classic. EDD takes the employer's numbers and suddenly you're the one scrambling. File the appeal, get your own pay records together, and if your employer has a payroll department, get something in writing from them acknowledging the error.

0 coins

Easier said than done getting anything in writing from an employer who caused the mess in the first place.

0 coins

True. But if they made a clerical error and know it, some HR people will correct it without a fight. Some won't. Either way you go into the appeal with what you have.

0 coins

Payroll errors happen constantly. The question is whether the employer will own it or make you prove it at a hearing.

0 coins

I'm confused about something. If EDD already paid her based on the Notice of Computation and then later said the claim was disallowed, does that mean the payments she already got are what they want back? All of them? Because that would be devastating on top of a back injury recovery.

0 coins

The repayment notice would specify the amount they're seeking. It may not be every payment, depending on what period is disputed. The appeal is the right move before assuming the full amount is final.

0 coins

The notice does list a specific amount and yeah it's most of what I received. Filing the appeal is definitely happening.

0 coins

That's such a rough situation. Fighting EDD while recovering from a back injury, lol no one signs up for that.

0 coins

Thirty years working and I've seen payroll mistakes follow people into every kind of claim. When you go into that hearing, bring your original offer letter or any paperwork that shows what your actual pay rate was. W-2s, check stubs, anything dated.

0 coins

This. Paper trail is everything. Don't walk in there with just your word against the employer's numbers.

0 coins

Writing all of this down. I have stubs going back over a year so hopefully that covers the base period they used.

0 coins

wait so the employer just reported the wrong number and edd used that number to decide if youre eligible? thats wild, so its not even like edd checked the actual records independently

0 coins

EDD relies on reported wage data. If the employer submitted incorrect figures that inflated the wages, the base period calculation would be off, and that can flip eligibility. That's why having your own documentation matters for the appeal.

0 coins

so she basically got approved based on wrong numbers and now has to prove what the real numbers were. that is a weird position to be in

0 coins

I'm glad someone else found this confusing because I was also not understanding how the system works here.

0 coins

The base period for a DI claim pulls wages from roughly 5 to 18 months before the claim starts, whichever quarter was highest within the 12-month window. If the employer overstated wages in the quarter EDD used, the weekly benefit amount on the Notice of Computation was based on a number that wasn't real. The appeal needs to show what the actual wages were in that quarter.

0 coins

This is incredibly helpful framing. The notice they sent does reference specific quarters, so I need to match that against my actual pay stubs for those same months.

0 coins

Exactly right. And note that you need at least $300 in wages subject to SDI during the base period to qualify. If the corrected wages still clear that bar, you have a strong argument that the claim was valid, just the benefit amount was calculated wrong.

0 coins

So there's a scenario where fixing the wage number actually helps her case rather than hurting it? Like if the real wages still qualify her?

0 coins

Possibly, yes. If the overstated amount made it look like she earned too much in one category and disqualified her under some threshold, correcting downward might actually show the right eligibility. She'd need to lay that out clearly in the appeal.

0 coins

Notice of Determination landed in my mailbox on a Thursday and I had no idea what it even meant at first. Tried EDD's line maybe seven or eight times over a few days. Used Claimyr and got through to an agent who looked up my claim right then. The agent confirmed the determination related to a specific set of weeks and that I had 30 days from the notice date to appeal it.

0 coins

Got a DE 2525XX submitted by my doctor for an extension and tried to confirm EDD had it. Used Claimyr too and was grateful for it. The agent looked at my claim and told me the extension certification had been received and noted which weeks it covered. Really steadied my nerves.

0 coins

When the agent confirmed the extension was received, did they say anything about how that affects the payment schedule?

0 coins

The agent said the weeks covered by the extension would go through the normal payment process and that I'd get a notice when each payment issued. Didn't go beyond that.

0 coins

Good to know the extension confirmation shows up on their end that quickly.

0 coins

Filing the appeal yourself is absolutely doable. The DE 1000A isn't long. Just be specific about what was wrong, state that your employer's reported wages didn't match your actual earnings, and list the evidence you're attaching. Clear and factual beats emotional every time.

0 coins

Trying to stay calm and document-focused. It's hard not to feel overwhelmed but I know the appeal needs to read clearly.

0 coins

Concise and specific is the way to go. Administrative law judges read a lot of these. If the core error is documented it doesn't need to be long.

0 coins

Not sure if this is a dumb question but, can the employer correct their wage report before the appeal hearing? Like if they admit it was a mistake, does that change anything?

0 coins

An employer correcting the record would be useful evidence for your appeal, but EDD still makes the final determination. Bring the corrected employer record to the hearing along with your own documentation.

0 coins

So even if the employer fixes it, I'd still need to go through the appeal rather than just having EDD update automatically?

0 coins

An appeal in motion stays in motion until EDD resolves it one way or another. Keep the appeal open and use the corrected employer record as part of your evidence.

0 coins

Don't count on the employer correction fixing it on its own anyway. File the appeal and treat the corrected record as a bonus if you get it.

0 coins

Got hit with an overpayment notice once on a different claim, different situation, but the appeals process was the same. Keep copies of everything you mail. Use certified mail if you can so you have proof it got there.

0 coins

Sending it certified mail is a great idea, didn't even think of that. Thank you.

0 coins

Certified mail is the right move on anything time-sensitive with EDD. Never send something important and wonder if it arrived.

0 coins

Worth clarifying something I had wrong for a while: I used to think the Notice of Computation meant you were approved. It doesn't. It just shows what your potential weekly amount would be based on your wages. Actual approval, or in this case the determination that something's off, comes separately.

0 coins

I thought the same thing. Getting the Notice of Computation felt like a green light. Knowing it's just a wage estimate, not an approval, is something I wish was clearer when you first file.

0 coins

The DE 2517 is what actually communicates whether EDD is allowing or disallowing the claim. The Notice of Computation and the DE 2517 serve totally different purposes.

0 coins

That was my confusion exactly. The computation notice came and payments started and I assumed all was settled. Then this hit.

0 coins

Does the appeal hearing happen in person or is it like a phone thing? Asking because if someone's still recovering from a back injury traveling somewhere could be a real issue.

0 coins

Hearings can be conducted by phone. When you file the appeal you can indicate that, and the appeals unit will work with the format. The notice itself may also have information about how to request accommodations.

0 coins

That's a relief. Good to know there are options for people who literally can't get somewhere easily.

0 coins

Receipt number was the sticking point on my own filing. After submitting Part A in SDI Online I almost didn't pass the number along to my provider because I didn't realize they needed it to find the claim. Used Claimyr and got an agent who pulled up my claim and confirmed the receipt number was there and unmatched because my provider hadn't submitted yet. That got me to call the office right away.

0 coins

Sounds like a service that gets you a live person at EDD, which sounds more like marketing to me than something that actually works on that line.

0 coins

Thought the same thing when I first saw it mentioned somewhere. Ended up trying it anyway because I'd been dialing that number for a week with nothing. Agent I reached told me my payment method was still set to the default card and walked me through confirming the direct deposit I'd set up was actually active on the claim. Wouldn't have known to check that otherwise.

0 coins

Alright, that's something I'd actually want to ask about. I'll give it a try and see.

0 coins

Matching the receipt number is such a small thing but it trips everyone up at least once. Anyway, glad you got it sorted.

0 coins

On the repayment side, don't pay anything while the appeal is pending. You're contesting the determination and the repayment flows from that. Paying before the appeal resolves could complicate things.

0 coins

Really important point. I was worried about whether I had to start paying immediately or face some other consequence. Appealing first makes sense.

0 coins

Correct. Appeal first. The repayment demand is tied to the disallowance, and you're contesting both by filing the appeal.

0 coins

been dealing with a wage question on my own claim for weeks. the employer number and what i reported just werent matching and edd never said a word until a notice showed up. now im trying to untangle it.

0 coins

Pull together your base period wages quarter by quarter and compare against what your employer filed. If you can find the discrepancy yourself first you'll know exactly what to put on the appeal form.

0 coins

yeah thats the plan. have my stubs, just have to lay them out by quarter. tedious but i guess thats the job.

0 coins

Laying it out by quarter sounds right. The clearer you make it the easier it is for the administrative law judge to follow.

0 coins

Payment on my claim hit on a Tuesday and I wanted to confirm which weeks it covered before I did anything else. Spent three mornings hitting redial. Tried Claimyr and got to an EDD agent who told me the payment covered specific weeks and that the remaining weeks were still pending.

0 coins

When you got through to the agent, did they say anything about why some weeks were still pending?

0 coins

Agent said the pending weeks were waiting on the medical certification to match up. That was all they'd say about it.

0 coins

Three weeks trying that line myself. Still haven't reached anyone.

0 coins

Pending weeks and no info is the worst. Anyway glad you at least got an answer.

0 coins

if the employer overstated wages would that also mess with how much you paid into sdi on your paystub? like if they said you earned more than you did would your casdi deductions be off too

0 coins

The CASDI deduction on your check comes from actual wages paid to you, not from what the employer separately reported to EDD. So your stubs showing what you actually earned, and what CASDI was actually withheld, are independent evidence of the real wage picture.

0 coins

oh so the stubs could actually show the discrepancy directly. the casdi line would show what you actually earned vs what employer said you earned. that makes sense

0 coins

I keep thinking about whether asking EDD to explain how they got to the disallowed decision before filing the appeal would help or just take up time. Like is there a way to get more info first?

0 coins

The DE 2517 itself should state the reason for the disallowance. If more detail is needed, you can contact EDD through SDI Online using the Request Claim Update option, or through Ask EDD. But don't wait on extra information if it risks the 30-day appeal window.

0 coins

Okay so appeal first, ask questions as a parallel track, don't let the deadline slip trying to get answers. Got it.

0 coins

Exactly. File the appeal to protect the right, then gather more context. The hearing itself is also a place to present and ask questions.

0 coins

Update: I filed the DE 1000A today, certified mail. Included my pay stubs for all four quarters of the base period they referenced and wrote out clearly that the employer's reported wage figure was higher than what I actually received, with the stub totals to back it up. Now I wait for the hearing date I guess. Thank you to everyone here, this thread gave me a real roadmap.

0 coins

Filing with the documentation attached is the right move. Stubs showing quarter-by-quarter actuals are exactly what an administrative law judge needs to see.

0 coins

You handled it correctly. Keep a copy of everything you sent and the certified mail receipt.

0 coins

The hearing notice will come by mail with the date and format details. Read it carefully when it arrives, it will also say whether you can submit additional documents beforehand.

0 coins

You did the work. Good.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure