Back to California Disability

Fatima Al-Hashemi

Disability claim paused after filing unemployment, should I file new claim?

So my back went out in late September and I filed for SDI, got the medical cert from my doctor within the first week. Everything seemed fine, claim was processing. Then HR told me I'd been laid off while I was out, and I panicked and filed for unemployment too because I didn't know what else to do. Now my disability claim just stopped and I don't know if I screwed myself up. Do I need to file a whole new SDI claim? Or can I undo the unemployment part somehow? I have bills stacking up and I still can't work, anyway.

Filing unemployment while your disability claim is active is exactly what froze things. EDD won't pay both for the same days, it's one or the other. You can't get unemployment while you're still unable to work anyway, because unemployment requires you to be able and available to work every week you claim it. Since your back is keeping you out, the SDI claim is the right one. You don't file a new disability claim, the original one should still be there.

0 coins

So I just stop certifying unemployment and go back to the SDI side? Or do I have to call someone?

0 coins

Stop certifying for unemployment, then check SDI Online to see if there's a Notice of Determination or anything EDD sent you. If EDD paused it because of the overlap, there may be something to respond to.

0 coins

Okay I found a notice in SDI Online. It says I need to appeal within 30 days. That's cutting it close, I filed unemployment almost three weeks ago.

0 coins

You can still appeal. The form is the DE 1000A, it comes with the determination notice. Write a clear explanation that you were laid off while on disability, that you are still unable to work, and mail it to the address on the notice before the 30 days run out.

0 coins

Is there any chance they'll just reinstate it without the appeal?

0 coins

Don't count on it. File the appeal now and let EDD sort it out from there.

0 coins

Wait, the DE 1000A is just for appeals? I thought that form was for something else, not sure where I got that from.

0 coins

It's the Appeal Form, yes, that's its only purpose. If you've misplaced it, a detailed letter works too, mailed to the return address on the notice.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my mail during my own claim and I nearly missed the 20-day window to send it back. Ended up talking to a live EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to confirm they had received it. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent told me my form had come in and was matched to my claim, so payments resumed the week after.

0 coins

Claimyr showing up here feels like a planted comment, honestly. I've seen the name in a few forums and it always reads like someone pushing it. What actually happened when you called?

0 coins

Tried the EDD disability line myself for four mornings straight before that. Each time I got the recording that there was too much volume and it ended the call. Then I tried the other way. The agent I reached was EDD staff, confirmed my form was in, nothing else to it.

0 coins

I actually had the same doubt at first, but I tried it when my extension paperwork was hanging. The agent told me my DE 2525XX had come in and was being processed. After that I just waited for the payment to show, and it did.

0 coins

Alright, that's fair enough. I might give it a go because I've been getting nowhere on my own.

0 coins

EDD's phone line after a layoff-plus-disability situation is a nightmare. You will not get a straight answer fast. Keep copies of absolutely everything, the notice, any letters, your unemployment claim confirmation, your original SDI filing date. All of it.

0 coins

I do have screenshots of both filings at least. Good reminder to keep those somewhere better than my camera roll.

0 coins

Print them out too. Screenshots disappear, paper doesn't.

0 coins

Does the layoff actually cancel the SDI claim or just pause it? I'm kind of in a similar boat, got let go while on disability and I'm terrified my whole claim disappears.

0 coins

The disability claim covers the days you can't work because of the medical condition, and a layoff doesn't erase those days. DI is for when you're physically unable to work, unemployment is for when you are able and available. They're separate things.

0 coins

So I should not file for unemployment until my doctor clears me to go back?

0 coins

That's the right order. File for unemployment once you're cleared and available, not while you're still on disability.

0 coins

You didn't screw yourself permanently. EDD sorts through these overlaps, it just takes time and paperwork. File that appeal and be clear about the timeline, when the back injury started, when the layoff happened, when you filed unemployment.

0 coins

Timeline is a good idea. Mine is a little tangled but I can write it out clearly.

0 coins

Bullet points. Dates. Keep it short and factual.

0 coins

my coworker had a similar thing happen and she just waited it out without appealing and edd eventually fixed it. not sure if she was just lucky tho

0 coins

Waiting without appealing is risky because the 30-day window to appeal a determination notice is a real deadline. If the window closes, the determination stands. Don't count on it fixing itself.

0 coins

yeah ok fair point she might have just gotten lucky

0 coins

To clarify the original question directly: you do not file a new SDI claim. The original claim stays. What needs to happen is stopping the unemployment certification and dealing with whatever notice EDD issued. If there's a Notice of Determination, appeal it with the DE 1000A and explain the overlap clearly.

0 coins

This confirms what I'm hearing from others. I'm going to write up the appeal today.

0 coins

Include the date your back injury started, your SDI claim date, your layoff date, and the unemployment filing date. Keeps EDD from guessing.

0 coins

ugh this whole situation sounds exhausting. edd really does not make it easy when life throws two things at you at once lol

0 coins

For real. My back is already a problem and now I'm doing paperwork research at midnight.

0 coins

hang in there, the appeal process is annoying but people do get through it

0 coins

Notice of Determination came through on my claim after I had a confusing overlap too, and I honestly had no idea what it meant at first. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the phone, and she walked me through which weeks EDD had flagged and confirmed the determination had gone out on a specific date. That detail mattered for my appeal timeline.

0 coins

Did the agent say anything about whether you needed to submit additional documents with the appeal, or just the form?

0 coins

She said the DE 1000A plus my written explanation of the timeline was sufficient and to mail it to the address on the notice. She didn't say anything beyond that.

0 coins

Been trying to get through on that line for about two weeks now. Good to know there's another way.

0 coins

Wait, I might be confused about something. If someone is on SDI and gets laid off, can they still keep getting paid through the end of the SDI claim even without a job to go back to? I thought SDI was connected to your employer.

0 coins

SDI isn't tied to your job continuing. It's insurance you paid into through the CASDI deduction on your paychecks. The benefit covers the days you're medically unable to work, regardless of whether you still have that job.

0 coins

Oh that's actually a relief. I was worried the layoff would void the whole thing.

0 coins

The benefit is based on your base period wages, which are from before the claim started. The layoff happening mid-claim doesn't change those quarters.

0 coins

Don't overthink it. File the appeal, stop the unemployment, let EDD do their thing. I went through something close to this and it got resolved. Takes a while but it moves.

0 coins

How long did yours take to resolve?

0 coins

About six weeks from when I mailed the appeal to when payments started again. No promises on your end but it wasn't forever.

0 coins

Receipt number on my original claim never matched the medical certification my doctor submitted, and it took me forever to figure out why payments weren't moving. Got through to an EDD agent through Claimyr and she confirmed the receipt numbers were different and that my provider needed to refile with the correct one.

0 coins

That's the exact thing I need to check on my claim. Receipt number question is what I'd want answered. Might try Claimyr for that.

0 coins

Have your receipt number from when you first filed ready, and your provider's contact information. The agent will look up what number is on file on their end.

0 coins

Didn't even know the receipt number was something to track. Good to know for anyone else reading this.

0 coins

Can I jump in here? I had my claim pause too but mine was because I didn't return the DE 2593 fast enough. The 20-day window is no joke. If you get that questionnaire, fill it out the day it arrives.

0 coins

Is the DE 2593 the same as the form your doctor fills out, or is that a different thing?

0 coins

Different form entirely. The DE 2593 is a continued eligibility questionnaire that EDD sends to the claimant after about 10 weeks of automatic payments. The doctor handles the medical certification, which is Part B of the original filing or the extension form later.

0 coins

Exactly. I confused them at first too. The 2593 is EDD checking in with you, not your doctor.

0 coins

Paused on the payment side is not the same as the claim being gone. I had a week where nothing showed and I panicked, turned out EDD had just mailed something I hadn't answered. Keep an eye on SDI Online and your physical mail.

0 coins

I do check SDI Online but I've been bad about checking mail. Going right now actually.

0 coins

Honestly that's where a lot of people miss stuff. EDD still mails a lot of things.

0 coins

Payment date on my claim was showing as issued but nothing had hit my account. Called EDD about it through Claimyr and the agent confirmed it had been issued on a specific date and that my payment method had a mailing address attached, not direct deposit. Switched to direct deposit through SDI Online after that.

0 coins

Payment method sitting as mail instead of direct deposit is exactly what happened to mine too. Used Claimyr as well, and once the agent confirmed the same thing I went into SDI Online and updated it right there. Next payment came through faster.

0 coins

How many times did you try the EDD line before that? I've dialed at least a dozen times over three weeks.

0 coins

More than I want to admit. Some days the line just ended the call before I even got to hold.

0 coins

For anyone reading this later: EDD's own site says you cannot receive unemployment and disability benefits for the same days. That's the rule that caused the original pause here. The SDI claim is for days you're medically unable to work. Unemployment is for days you're able and available. The two don't overlap.

0 coins

Is that written somewhere specific on EDD's site, or just in the FAQs?

0 coins

It's in the DI FAQs on edd.ca.gov. Worth reading through before you file anything else so you know exactly where the lines are.

0 coins

appeals take time but they do happen. filed mine in october, resolution came before the holidays. not saying that's typical just what i saw

0 coins

That's about the range someone else mentioned too. Hoping mine lands in that ballpark.

0 coins

just keep the notice and your mailing receipt from the appeal, in case they say they didn't get it

0 coins

One procedural note on the appeal: mail it with some form of tracking or at minimum get a post office receipt. The 30-day deadline is from the date on the notice, not the date you receive it. Those days go fast.

0 coins

Mailing it today with certified mail. Notice is dated 18 days ago so I have no room left to wait.

0 coins

Good. Keep the tracking number with the other paperwork.

0 coins

Certified mail is the only way to go with EDD documents. Regular mail and hoping for the best is a bad plan.

0 coins

Circling back to the original question one more time: no new claim. Appeal the Notice of Determination, stop the unemployment filing, and your original SDI claim is what picks back up if the appeal goes through. That's the path.

0 coins

Appeal is in the mail as of this afternoon. Stopping unemployment today. Thanks everyone, this thread helped me get it straight.

0 coins

Good luck. Check SDI Online in a couple weeks and watch the mail.

0 coins

You handled it. That's the main thing.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure