Back to California Disability

Ravi Patel

Can you switch from unemployment to SDI while waiting for surgery?

So I've been on unemployment for about six weeks now and my doctor just told me I need a hip replacement that's been scheduled for three weeks out. I'm definitely not going to be able to work after the surgery, probably for a couple months at least, but here's the thing, I'm already not really able to do much now because of the pain. My unemployment has been going fine but I'm not sure if I should stop claiming it and switch to SDI before the surgery or wait until after. I think SDI pays more but I honestly don't sure how that works. Can you even collect unemployment while you're waiting for a surgery date? Like does the fact that I can't really lift or stand for long mess up my unemployment eligibility? I filed a claim on SDI Online but I don't know if I did it right and I haven't heard anything back yet. Really anxious about having no income while I'm recovering.

The core of your situation is that unemployment requires you to be able to work and available every single week you claim it. If your hip is limiting you to the point where you genuinely can't do your regular work, that week isn't really an unemployment week, it's a disability week. You can't be paid by both programs for the same days, so the switch matters and it matters from the right date.

0 coins

So does that mean I should have already stopped claiming unemployment when the pain got bad? I'm worried I might have been collecting it when I wasn't really supposed to be.

0 coins

Report the situation to EDD honestly, including when your limitations started. EDD decides each claim on its own facts. Stopping unemployment and filing SDI from the date your doctor says you couldn't do your regular work is the right move now.

0 coins

This is the part that scares me too. How does EDD even know when you stopped being able to work? Does your doctor have to give a specific date?

0 coins

Your doctor puts a disability start date on the medical certification. That date is what EDD uses for the SDI claim, and it's what you'd want to match up with when you stopped claiming unemployment.

0 coins

been on that phone line for three mornings straight trying to ask this exact question and all i get is the busy signal or it just hangs up after the hold music. EDD's disability line is basically a myth at this point. DE 2593 sitting in my stack unread until I actually got someone on the phone, used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live agent, and she told me EDD had already issued the questionnaire and I had about a week left in my 20 days to return it. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

The DE 2593 is the continued eligibility form, right? I got one of those after my tenth week and I had no idea it had a deadline. How much time did you have left when the agent told you?

0 coins

she said i had maybe six or seven days on mine. filed it that same afternoon. would have missed it completely if id kept trying the regular line.

0 coins

Genuine question on the Claimyr thing, what does it actually do? I've been dialing the 800 number at 8am and getting a busy signal every single time for two weeks.

0 coins

it basically stays on hold with EDD in your place so you end up talking to a live person there without having to sit on the line yourself. that's the whole thing.

0 coins

Huh, okay. I need to ask about my own extension form, might try that.

0 coins

You need to stop claiming unemployment the day your doctor certifies you can no longer do your regular work. File the SDI claim from that date. The seven-day waiting period starts there, so the first payable day is day eight. Those two programs can't overlap.

0 coins

The seven days, is that just EDD processing time or is it actually seven days I don't get paid no matter what?

0 coins

It's not processing time. It's a real non-payable window built into every new DI claim. Day one through seven, no payment. Day eight is the first day you can be paid.

0 coins

I didn't know that when I filed mine and I kept checking SDI Online wondering why nothing was showing. The waiting period caught me completely off guard.

0 coins

The 49-day rule is worth flagging here. Your doctor has to get the medical certification into SDI Online within 49 days of your disability start date, the same deadline you have to file the claim. If you filed already, give the surgeon's office your receipt number so they can find the claim and submit Part B.

0 coins

I did file it but I'm not sure I gave my doctor's office the receipt number yet. I'll call them today.

0 coins

The receipt number is exactly what the provider's office needs to match their submission to your claim. Without it they're filing blind.

0 coins

Does the doctor's office have to submit it online or can they mail it?

0 coins

They can submit through SDI Online or mail the paper form, but if they submitted online they don't also mail it. Online is faster and EDD usually contacts the claimant within about 14 days after the certification comes in.

0 coins

You cannot get unemployment and disability for the same days. That's the whole rule. Pick a date, stop one, start the other.

0 coins

Got it. So I just stop certifying for unemployment and my SDI claim picks up from there?

0 coins

Roughly, yes. The SDI start date has to match what your doctor puts down. Make sure those line up.

0 coins

My surgery was similar, I was out six weeks and I kept my unemployment going two extra days because I didn't know you had to stop it first. EDD sent me a notice about an overpayment for those two days. Super annoying but it was my own fault for not reading the rules. Just get the dates straight before you stop certifying.

0 coins

Two days turned into an overpayment notice? That's wild. I really need to get this transition right.

0 coins

Yep, they're precise about it. The overlap was tiny but it still triggered a notice. Easy to fix if you catch it early though.

0 coins

EDD is very good at finding the overlap. Less good at answering the phone when you have questions about it.

0 coins

wait so if youre waiting for surgery and cant really work but havent had it yet does the sdi clock start before or after the actual surgery

0 coins

The clock starts when your doctor certifies that you can't do your regular work. If the hip was limiting you before the surgery date, the start date could be before you go in.

0 coins

oh so pre surgery pain can count too thats actually good to know

0 coins

Exactly. The provider documents the onset date based on when you became unable to work, not the surgery date itself. The two can be the same day or weeks apart.

0 coins

my wife went through this last year, hip surgery too weirdly enough. she stopped unemployment on a Thursday, SDI started Friday, waiting period ran through that first week, payment came about two weeks after EDD got her doctor's form in. wasn't perfect timing but it worked anyway.

0 coins

Two weeks after the medical cert came in, that's helpful. Did she have any gaps in income?

0 coins

About ten days between her last unemployment payment and the first SDI payment. We used savings to cover it, nothing huge, anyway it was manageable.

0 coins

Ten days is actually better than I feared. I've been worried about a month-long gap.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in the mail after I tried to switch like you're doing, said my claim wasn't payable. Turned out my medical cert had an error on the start date. Spent three days on the phone getting nowhere, eventually got through to an agent using Claimyr and she pulled up my claim right there. The start date on the cert didn't match what I had filed, that was the whole problem.

0 coins

Sounds like every other service that promises to get you through to EDD. What actually happened, they just had you hold?

0 coins

Thought the same thing when I first saw it mentioned somewhere. Ended up trying it myself when my claim went to a Notice of Determination. The agent told me EDD had me down for direct deposit but my bank account number on file had a digit wrong, so payments were bouncing back. I would not have known that any other way.

0 coins

Okay that's actually useful. I'll give it a look if my denial doesn't get sorted by mail.

0 coins

The agent didn't guess, she read it off the claim. Start date on my cert said one thing, my filed claim said three days earlier. Appeal form came with the notice, 30 days to file it.

0 coins

Can I ask a maybe dumb question here, what does the Notice of Computation actually tell you? I haven't gotten mine yet and I keep seeing it mentioned.

0 coins

Your Notice of Computation shows your potential weekly and maximum benefit amount. It's based on the highest-paid quarter in your base period, roughly the wages from about five to eighteen months before your claim starts. It doesn't mean you're approved, it just tells you what the amount would be if you are.

0 coins

So I might get one before I even know if I'm approved? That's confusing.

0 coins

Exactly. Lots of people think the computation notice is an approval letter. It is not. Approval comes through payments actually issuing or a formal determination.

0 coins

The EDD site has a calculator that estimates your weekly amount before you even get the notice. Worth looking at so you're not surprised by the number.

0 coins

the unemployment to SDI switch is real and it works but timing it is kind of annoying lol. I did it after a knee thing and the main headache was my doctor's office taking forever to submit the medical cert. three weeks they sat on it.

0 coins

Three weeks, did that cause any problems with the 49-day deadline?

0 coins

Cut it close but we made it. I had to call the office like four times. Give them the receipt number, they can't find the claim without it.

0 coins

Doctor offices are slow. Hound them until they confirm it went in.

0 coins

Pregnancy is actually where I saw a lot of people mess this up, they'd still be on unemployment at 36 weeks because they didn't realize the disability for pre-birth restrictions counts. Same idea for surgery, the disability starts when you can't do the job, not when you're literally on the table.

0 coins

I told three coworkers this exact thing when they were pregnant. The doctor can certify it starts early if there are restrictions, reduced hours, any of that.

0 coins

Does that change the weekly benefit amount or just the start date?

0 coins

Just the start date. The weekly benefit amount comes from your base period wages no matter when the disability starts.

0 coins

seven day waiting period also applies to this switch situation right, its not waived just because you were already on unemployment

0 coins

Correct. Every new DI claim has the seven-day waiting period. Prior time on unemployment doesn't count toward it.

0 coins

figured, just wanted to make sure someone didn't slip through without it

0 coins

For the base period question that usually comes up with these switches: SDI uses a 12-month window of wages from about five to eighteen months before your claim starts, the highest-paid quarter sets your weekly amount. If you've been on unemployment with no wages coming in for six weeks, what mattered was the work you did before that. EDD's site has a calculator to estimate it.

0 coins

I worked full time for about two years before getting laid off six weeks ago. So those wages still count even though I haven't been working lately?

0 coins

Yes, the base period looks back before the claim, not at what you're doing right now. Two years of full-time work before a recent layoff means you likely have solid wages in that window.

0 coins

The calculator on EDD's site will walk you through which quarter it would pull from. I ran mine before filing and it was pretty close to what the Notice of Computation actually showed.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim didn't match what the surgeon's office had on file and it held everything up for almost two weeks. Tried the EDD line six mornings without getting past the automated system. Ended up using Claimyr to get through to an agent, and she confirmed the receipt number wasn't matched to any provider submission yet, so the cert was sitting unlinked.

0 coins

How did you sort it out once the agent told you that? Did she do anything on her end?

0 coins

She just told me what was missing. I went back to the surgeon's office with the correct number and they resubmitted that afternoon. Status updated within a few days.

0 coins

I've been trying that line every morning this week, 8am sharp, it's been dead air or a hang-up every single time. Good to know there's another way to get through.

0 coins

The overlap rule for unemployment and SDI is what tripped me up. I thought I could keep claiming unemployment through the last day before surgery and then flip to SDI the morning of. But the medical cert start date my doctor submitted was two weeks before the surgery because of my work restrictions, so I had an overlap I didn't even know about. Got a notice in the mail about it.

0 coins

Two weeks before the surgery date because of restrictions, so the cert started earlier than you expected?

0 coins

Exactly. I didn't realize how early she dated it. The restrictions she documented started when I stopped being able to lift, not on the actual surgery day.

0 coins

This is why getting the disability start date from your provider before filing matters. If you file unemployment through a date that your cert puts inside the DI period, EDD will catch it.

0 coins

Payment date question on a switch like this: on my claim after a knee repair, I stopped unemployment on a Monday, SDI start date was that Tuesday per my doctor, waiting period ran Tuesday through the following Monday, first payable day was that Wednesday. Payment issued about 12 days after EDD received the medical cert. I tracked all of this by logging into SDI Online daily.

0 coins

You kept a log of it, that's smart. I've just been refreshing SDI Online hoping something changes.

0 coins

Daily log was the only thing that kept me from panicking. When status changed I had the exact dates to reference.

0 coins

the two weeks estimate after the cert comes in feels right based on what i saw on mine too

0 coins

Payment date on my own SDI claim after a wrist surgery was what finally pushed me to call. SDI Online said nothing was pending but no payment had hit. Got through to an agent using Claimyr and she read off my claim, told me the payment had been issued four days earlier but was going to a card, not a direct deposit, because I hadn't set up the account properly in SDI Online.

0 coins

My waiting period weeks question is exactly what I want to get answered. Going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready when I call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and your SDI Online claim ID pulled up before you go in. The agent will want to verify identity first, then she can pull up exactly which weeks are showing paid, pending or held.

0 coins

The card vs. direct deposit thing is a real trip-up. EDD's card is through Money Network now, not Bank of America, so if anyone's expecting that old card setup it changed.

0 coins

I didn't know it changed to Money Network. I was looking for the old card in my mail.

0 coins

The switch you're describing works. File SDI, stop unemployment, match the dates to what your doctor puts on the cert. Everything else is just waiting and refreshing SDI Online.

0 coins

Honestly that's the clearest summary I've gotten. Thank you.

0 coins

EDD is not complicated. It just moves slowly.

0 coins

does the surgery itself count as the start date if your doc says you couldnt work before it too or do you get to pick

0 coins

Your doctor picks the date, not you. They certify when you became unable to do your regular work, which could be before the surgery if restrictions or pain were already keeping you from it.

0 coins

ok so i shouldnt try to game the date then, got it

0 coins

EDD doesn't care why you're off, it cares whether you can do your job. If you genuinely can't, that's the date. If you can and you're just waiting for a future procedure, that's trickier.

0 coins

My doctor already told me I'm limited now, not just post-surgery. So I think the date is legitimate either way.

0 coins

Then you're fine. Have the doctor document the current limitations, not just the surgery outcome.

0 coins

Exactly right. The certification covers the whole period you can't work, pre and post surgery, as long as the provider documents it.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure