Back to California Disability

Oliver Schulz

Can you qualify for SDI if you didn't pay into CASDI?

So I started a new job back in the spring and got hurt about two months in. When I looked at my pay stubs I noticed the CASDI deduction was listed but it looked really small, like I'd only been paying in for maybe eight or nine weeks total before I had to stop working. My HR department told me I probably don't qualify for SDI because I haven't been paying in long enough, but I'm not sure if that's actually true or if they just don't know the rules. I think I've heard that it's based on some kind of base period from before the claim, not just how long you've been at your current job? But I honestly don't know how any of this works. Has anyone filed a disability claim with only a short time paying into CASDI? Did EDD actually look at wages from previous jobs too?

Quarter two of my base period was the one EDD used, which I didn't expect at all given my work history. Spent three mornings in a row getting nowhere on that disability line before I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and ended up talking to an agent. She confirmed exactly which quarter they pulled, what wages were on file from my previous employer, and that my claim had moved past the pending stage. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

What's Claimyr, if you don't mind me asking? I've been in pending for almost two weeks and I want to ask about my receipt number matching up with the doctor's submission.

0 coins

You dial in and EDD picks up on their end, then your phone rings with an agent already there. That's the whole thing. For a receipt number question that's exactly the kind of thing the agent can sort out fast.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense, I'll give it a try. The receipt number situation has been driving me up the wall.

0 coins

HR told me something similar when I first filed, that I hadn't been there long enough. But my previous job was in the same state so I wondered if those wages counted too. Does EDD actually pull from multiple employers in that base period?

0 coins

They look at a twelve-month base period, four quarters, and they use the highest-paid one. It doesn't matter how many jobs those wages came from. What matters is at least three hundred dollars subject to SDI deductions in that whole base period. Previous jobs count as long as the wages fall in those quarters.

0 coins

So if I had two jobs during that period they'd add the wages together from both?

0 coins

Yes, all wages subject to CASDI in the base period go into the calculation. The Notice of Computation will show what they used.

0 coins

That's actually really reassuring. I had a job before this one that I left in March so those wages might still be in the window.

0 coins

I went through almost this exact thing last year. My old salon closed right before my injury so I was only like six weeks into the new place. EDD still approved my claim because my wages from the salon fell in the base period. The Notice of Computation showed wages from both employers, it was kind of a surprise honestly.

0 coins

Did EDD pull those old wages automatically or did you have to send anything in yourself?

0 coins

It was automatic, they had everything on file. I didn't send in any extra wage documents. The notice just showed up with both listed.

0 coins

Good to know they do that automatically, I always assumed you had to submit extra paperwork anyway.

0 coins

The rule as EDD writes it is that the base period is the twelve months ending about five to eighteen months before the claim start date, broken into four quarters. The highest-paid quarter is used to estimate your weekly amount. At least three hundred dollars in wages subject to SDI across the whole base period is the minimum. Where those wages came from across employers doesn't change the threshold.

0 coins

Does the base period ever shift if you were unemployed for part of it?

0 coins

EDD does have an alternative base period option in some situations. That's something worth raising directly with EDD on your specific claim rather than assuming which period applies.

0 coins

That's helpful, I'll ask EDD directly since my situation was a bit patchy employment-wise.

0 coins

HR departments almost always get this wrong. I've heard the 'you haven't been here long enough' line from two different employers over the years. They're thinking of their own company's sick leave policy, not EDD's rules. CASDI is taken from your check by law, it's not something the employer decides whether you qualify for.

0 coins

Yep. HR knows their own benefits. EDD is a whole different thing.

0 coins

Exactly. Two completely separate systems.

0 coins

My direct deposit had never switched over from an old bank account I'd closed, so I had a whole mess to sort out with payment method on my claim. Called EDD using Claimyr and an agent pulled up my file and confirmed the payment was going to the wrong place and told me I could update it through SDI Online right then. Got it fixed that same afternoon! The agent was so clear about it which was such a relief after days of busy signals.

0 coins

Claimyr worked well for me too when I had a question about my DE 2593. The agent confirmed the date mine was due back and what would happen to my benefits if it came in late. Really glad I had it available because that form caught me off guard.

0 coins

Wait how strict is EDD about that DE 2593 deadline?

0 coins

EDD gives you twenty days from when they send it. Miss that window and benefits can stop. Send it back right away when it arrives, don't set it aside.

0 coins

Twenty days goes fast. Good warning.

0 coins

my old roommate had this same situation, new job only had a few weeks of casdi on the stub but edd used wages from his restaurant job before that and he got approved, wasnt even a question

0 coins

How far back did his old restaurant wages go? Like were they from the year before?

0 coins

yeah like eight or nine months before he got hurt so they fell right in the base period window

0 coins

One thing to verify before assuming you don't qualify: check every pay stub from every employer over roughly the last year and a half and confirm the CASDI line is on each one. If a previous employer was exempt for some reason or you did gig work paid as a contractor, those wages may not have had the deduction taken and would not count toward the base period.

0 coins

Does gig work really not count even if you paid self-employment taxes on it?

0 coins

Correct. The CASDI deduction has to have been withheld from wages. Self-employment income without that deduction does not count toward the SDI base period.

0 coins

I did do some delivery driving last fall. I should double-check whether that was set up as contractor pay or W-2.

0 coins

HR at my last job told me i couldn't file either bc i was part time lol. that was completely wrong, filed anyway, got approved. they really shouldn't be advising people on EDD rules at all

0 coins

Part-time, full-time, doesn't matter. As long as the CASDI was coming out of your check.

0 coins

Exactly that. Showed up on every stub even at 20 hours a week.

0 coins

If your stubs show CASDI coming out, you've been paying in. The job being new doesn't erase what you paid somewhere else. File the claim and let EDD figure out the base period, don't let HR talk you out of filing.

0 coins

That's the part I keep second-guessing, whether it's even worth filing or if they'll just deny it outright.

0 coins

File it. A denial tells you something. Not filing tells you nothing.

0 coins

been trying to work this out with two jobs in my history both with casdi taken out, just not sure how to show edd which wages are from which job

0 coins

You don't need to show them separately. EDD gets wage information from employers directly through the state system. The Notice of Computation will reflect what they already have on file.

0 coins

oh good, i was worried i had to gather a bunch of documents

0 coins

My eight weeks at the job before I got hurt had CASDI on every stub but the job before that, I quit in January, that employer never had the deduction. Hoping the eight weeks plus some older part-time work adds up to that three hundred dollar threshold.

0 coins

Add up what CASDI was taken on across all the stubs that show it. The deduction amount on the stub isn't the same as wages, but if you had regular hours and any kind of decent hourly rate those eight weeks plus some part-time before probably hit three hundred in wages pretty easily.

0 coins

Yeah when I actually did the math it looked like it was well over that. I'll file and see what the Notice of Computation says.

0 coins

Medical certification on my claim had sat unmatched for eleven days when I finally reached an agent through Claimyr. The agent found that my provider had submitted it under a slightly different claim ID format, and confirmed EDD had it and was processing the match. That cleared up why my claim had been stuck pending, and the agent noted the status had already updated on their end that morning.

0 coins

Honestly sounds like marketing to me. Some service that finds you a live person at EDD, really? I tried that line forty-five minutes every morning for a week and got the recording every single time.

0 coins

I thought the same thing when I first saw it mentioned somewhere. Tried it anyway when my DE 2525XX extension had been sitting for three weeks with no update. The agent confirmed EDD had received it and told me which date it was logged. That's all I needed to know. Whether the doubter tries it or not is up to them but it got me an actual answer.

0 coins

Alright, I'll look into it. Three weeks of mornings wasted on that line and I'm running low on patience.

0 coins

Many people assume the CASDI deduction only counts at your current employer. When I was out for my own situation I worried the same thing because I'd switched jobs twice in eighteen months. The base period pulled in wages from two of those three jobs and my benefit amount reflected more than just the new job.

0 coins

Did EDD ever contact you to ask for wage information from the previous employer, or did they already have it?

0 coins

They already had it. The state employer records are what EDD works from. I never had to submit anything beyond my own claim form.

0 coins

That's good to know, I assumed there'd be extra forms involved.

0 coins

The bigger trap I see people fall into is waiting too long to file because they're not sure they qualify. You have forty-nine days from when your disability starts and that window closes fast when you're recovering and stressed. File first, worry about eligibility after EDD reviews the base period wages.

0 coins

How strict is that forty-nine-day window? Like is there any way to file late?

0 coins

EDD says late filings can result in disqualification. I wouldn't test it. File as soon as you can, even if you're uncertain.

0 coins

The nine-day waiting period from disability start before you file is real too, but the outer limit is forty-nine days. Those are two separate things. The first seven days of the claim itself are the unpaid waiting period, which is different again.

0 coins

Your HR department doesn't decide EDD eligibility. EDD does. File and find out.

0 coins

Short and right.

0 coins

Yeah I think I've been letting HR's opinion carry too much weight here.

0 coins

Just to add from my own filing, they look at the period starting about five months before you got hurt, not from your hire date at the current job. So wages you earned well before you started this job can absolutely count. File the claim, get the Notice of Computation and see what base period they used anyway.

0 coins

Does the Notice of Computation come before or after the medical certification part gets submitted?

0 coins

In my experience it came pretty early, before everything was fully processed. It shows potential amounts, not final approval.

0 coins

That's right. The Notice of Computation shows potential weekly and maximum benefit amounts. It's not the same as the claim being approved.

0 coins

My provider almost messed this up for me by saying they didn't know how to submit Part B for someone who'd just switched employers. The claim form itself doesn't care about that, the provider just needs your receipt number to find it in SDI Online. Took a quick call to the office to remind them.

0 coins

What is the receipt number and where do you find it?

0 coins

You get it when you finish filing your part of the claim online, the claimant statement. SDI Online gives it to you right there. Write it down and give it to your doctor's office so they can locate your claim to submit the medical certification.

0 coins

I haven't filed yet so this is good to know in advance. I'll save that number the second I see it.

0 coins

The waiting period thing confused me so badly at first because I thought it meant my claim was just sitting in a queue being processed. Nope, it is a flat seven days at the start of every new claim that simply don't get paid, no matter how fast EDD moves. First payable day is day eight.

0 coins

So those seven days don't count toward the total weeks you can be paid?

0 coins

Correct, the unpaid waiting period is at the front of the claim and doesn't reduce your payable weeks. The claim can run up to 52 weeks of actual benefit payments from there.

0 coins

Yes that's what I eventually figured out. The agent I spoke with laid it out clearly once I finally got through.

0 coins

if you had casdi taken out at any job in the right window you should file, dont let anyone tell you otherwise, the system figures out the wages

0 coins

Agreed. File and let EDD sort it.

0 coins

Thank you all, this has actually cleared up a lot. I'm going to look at my old pay stubs tonight from my previous job, add up what I had in wages with the CASDI deduction, and then file the claim. I didn't realize EDD pulls that wage data from prior employers automatically. HR at the new place made it sound like I was just out of luck.

0 coins

File soon, that forty-nine day window is the one to watch.

0 coins

Get the receipt number after you file and give it to your provider right away so the medical certification doesn't lag behind the claimant part.

0 coins

Already planning to call the doctor's office the same day I file.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure