Can you pay into SDI retroactively if employer withheld wrong taxes
Filing date on my DI claim is about six weeks back now, and something that came up when I was pulling my pay stubs together stopped me cold. Looking at the last 18 months of stubs, my employer never took out CASDI. Not one deduction. I only noticed because I was trying to figure out my base period wages for the Notice of Computation estimate. I've been in this job almost two years, so we're talking a significant chunk of wages with zero SDI contributions on record. My question is whether there's any way to pay in retroactively so the base period wages actually count, or if I'm just stuck with whatever quarters did have proper withholding. Has anyone run into this? The HR person I spoke with basically shrugged and said it was 'probably a payroll error' but didn't offer anything beyond that.
76 comments

Brooklyn Knight
Payroll errors like that are more common than people realize, and the short answer is that the burden is on the employer, not on you. When an employer fails to withhold CASDI from wages that should have been subject to it, the employer owes the contributions to EDD, not the employee. You would not make a separate retroactive payment yourself. What matters for your claim is whether those wages were subject to SDI withholding, which most California wages are. EDD can assess the employer for unpaid contributions. I'd put that in writing to HR so there's a paper trail.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorSo my wages still count toward the base period even if the deduction never showed up on my stubs? That's the part I wasn't clear on.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
Wages subject to SDI withholding count whether or not the employer actually took the money out. The error is theirs to fix with EDD, not yours to absorb on your claim.
0 coins
Owen Devar
Wait, so EDD could still approve the claim even with the withholding missing? I always assumed if the deduction wasn't there the wages just didn't count. That's a relief to hear, I think.
0 coins
Daniel Rivera
HR shrugging at a payroll error that affects your DI claim is infuriating. I'd go above them to whoever handles payroll directly and get something in writing about what happened and what they're doing to correct it with EDD. Vague verbal answers don't help you if EDD questions the base period.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorYeah the shrug answer was not it. I'm going back with a written request this week.
0 coins
Sophie Footman
Get the response in writing, full stop. Verbal stuff disappears.
0 coins
Connor Rupert
EDD can audit an employer's payroll records. If the wages were there and no CASDI came out, that's on the employer to make right, not on you.
0 coins
Molly Hansen
Notice of Determination landed in my mailbox on a claim that had a similar payroll mess behind it, so I ended up needing to actually talk to someone at EDD to sort out what they were seeing on their end. Tried that disability line a few mornings in a row and it just kept dumping me. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through, and when an agent finally picked up she told me the determination had flagged my claim because the wages in one quarter weren't showing SDI contributions. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. She pulled up my specific claim and confirmed the quarter in question, so I knew exactly what to bring to HR.
0 coins
Brady Clean
Every time someone mentions a service like that for a government phone line it reads like marketing to me. What actually happened when you tried it, and did you end up talking to an actual EDD employee?
0 coins
Molly Hansen
I get the skepticism, I'd have said the same thing two weeks ago. The person who answered was EDD's own agent, she had my claim number pulled up and read me the quarter that was showing no contributions. That's not something a marketing script could fabricate.
0 coins
Skylar Neal
Had the same suspicion when I first came across it. Tried it because I'd burned a week trying to reach EDD on my own claim's start date, the line either cut off or rang forever. Agent I spoke with confirmed the start date EDD had on file matched what I'd entered when I filed, so at least I knew that piece was right. The doubter angle made sense to me before I had my own result.
0 coins
Brady Clean
Alright, that's a more grounded answer than I expected. I still have questions about whether a service sitting on hold with a government line is something I'd want, but I'm not going to just dismiss it now.
0 coins
Skylar Neal
The rule EDD works from is that SDI covers wages paid for employment in California. If the wages were paid and should have had CASDI withheld, EDD treats them as covered wages for the base period calculation even when the deduction was missed. The employer's obligation to remit those contributions to EDD is separate from your entitlement to have those wages counted. EDD's site has a benefits calculator that lets you estimate using your actual wages if you want to check where you stand before the Notice of Computation arrives.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorThat's the clearest explanation I've seen on this. I'll run the calculator with my actual quarterly wages and see what it spits out.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
Is the calculator on the main EDD site or somewhere inside SDI Online? I keep looking and can't find it, sorry.
0 coins
Skylar Neal
It's on edd.ca.gov, the main EDD site. Search 'disability insurance calculator' and it should come right up.
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
My cousin went through something kind of like this last year, employer had been misclassifying her as a 1099 contractor for two years even though she should've been W-2, so no CASDI ever came out. When she filed her DI claim it was a whole situation. EDD got involved with the employer separately on the classification issue. Her wages ended up counting once EDD sorted out that she'd been misclassified. Yours sounds different but the underlying idea, that the employer's mistake doesn't necessarily wipe out your base period wages, seems to be the same.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorMisclassification sounds like a whole other layer of trouble. Mine is a straight W-2 job, just a payroll deduction that never got set up right.
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
Oh that's actually simpler then. If you're W-2 and the wages are on record, the employer just has to fix the withholding side with EDD.
0 coins
Norah Quay
Similar thing happened at my job. Payroll fixed it with EDD and my wages counted fine.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
wait so if your employer just forgot to take out the sdi deduction your claim is still ok? asking bc my stubs look weird too and im freaking out a little
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
If your wages were subject to SDI and the employer just didn't withhold, your base period wages should still count. Check with HR, and if something looks off on your Notice of Computation, that's the time to raise it with EDD.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
ok good bc i genuinely did not understand what that casdi line was supposed to show and now im going to look at my stubs properly
0 coins
Jessica Nolan
Employer owes EDD the contributions. You don't. That's been the rule for as long as I can remember dealing with this system.
0 coins
Connor Rupert
Concise and correct. The employee doesn't eat the employer's mistake.
0 coins
Owen Devar
How does EDD even know to go after the employer if the employee doesn't report it somewhere? Or does the claim itself trigger a review?
0 coins
Jessica Nolan
EDD cross-checks payroll records. The claim starts the process. You're not responsible for chasing it down yourself, though a written complaint to EDD's employer division doesn't hurt.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
Filing my own DI claim right now and this thread is making me panic a little. How do I even check whether my employer withheld CASDI correctly? Is it just the CASDI line on each pay stub?
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
Yes, look for the CASDI deduction on each stub. It should be there every pay period. If a pay period is missing it, flag it with HR right away and keep copies of the stubs.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
Mine all show it but now I'm going to triple check every single one, lol. Thank you.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorI wish I'd checked sooner. Worth the ten minutes to go through the whole stack.
0 coins
Angelina Farar
Receipt number situation on my own claim led me to EDD as well. The number my provider used didn't match what I had saved from when I filed, and SDI Online just sat there. Tried phoning for a couple of mornings, got nowhere. Claimyr got me to an agent and she confirmed the receipt number on file for my claim and told me which one the provider needed to use. Straightened out in a day once I had the right number to give the office.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
Can I ask, did the agent have the corrected receipt number on the spot or did you have to do anything else before she could give it to you?
0 coins
Angelina Farar
She pulled it up from my claim record as soon as I gave her my Social and claim ID. No extra steps, she just read me what was on file.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
been dialing that line myself for four mornings now. good to know there are other ways to get through.
0 coins
Sophie Footman
Talked to my employer's payroll rep years back about an SDI withholding gap, and the advice I got was the same: EDD goes after the employer for the missed contributions. The employee files the claim, the employer fixes their end. You just need to make sure your base period wages are showing up right on your Notice of Computation, and if they're off, that's when you get EDD on the phone.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorMy Notice of Computation hasn't shown up yet, I'm still waiting. I'll compare it against my actual wage records when it does.
0 coins
Sophie Footman
That's the right move. Notice will show the quarterly wages EDD is using. If a quarter looks wrong, you've got your stubs to dispute it.
0 coins
KingKongZilla
The CASDI deduction on a stub is usually a pretty small number each check, easy to miss for years if you're not watching for it. I noticed mine was gone for about three pay periods once and HR said it was a software update that reset the withholding settings for a batch of employees. Employer filed a correction with EDD and that was it.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorThree pay periods is one thing. I'm looking at close to two years. Hoping the correction process scales up.
0 coins
KingKongZilla
Yikes, two years is a different scale. Definitely get HR to loop in whoever handles their EDD employer account and get a status in writing.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
Two years of missing withholding would show up pretty clearly in an EDD payroll audit. The employer is going to have to reconcile all of it.
0 coins
Owen Devar
Not sure if this is a dumb question but, if EDD looks at my employer and finds the missed CASDI contributions, could that slow down my actual DI claim while they sort it out? Or do those happen separately?
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
They're separate processes. Your DI claim moves on its own timeline based on whether EDD has what it needs from you and your doctor. The employer's contribution audit is a tax matter on EDD's employer side.
0 coins
Owen Devar
That's really good to hear. I was worried fixing the employer's error would put my payments on hold while everything got reconciled.
0 coins
Skylar Neal
The DI claim side and the employer contribution side run in separate lanes at EDD. Your payments shouldn't be delayed because of the employer's correction.
0 coins
Nathan Dell
Payment date on my own claim was a mystery for longer than I wanted! The SDI Online screen wasn't giving me anything useful and the phone line was a dead end for days. Claimyr got me talking to an agent who looked up exactly which week had been issued and what date it went out. Turned out the payment had already processed and was sitting on my Money Network card, I just hadn't activated it yet. Easy fix once I knew where to look.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
My claim has a question about the base period wages EDD is using, and I've been meaning to get that clarified properly. I'll try Claimyr for that one. What's worth having ready when you get through?
0 coins
Nathan Dell
Have your Social, your claim ID from SDI Online, and any notices EDD has sent you. The agent can find everything else from those.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorThe Money Network card activation thing catches a lot of people. I didn't know the card came separately until someone mentioned it.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
Two years of missing withholding is a significant payroll failure, and HR's shrug response concerns me more than the missing deductions themselves. If they don't take this seriously, EDD has an employer division you can contact directly to flag that an employer may not be remitting SDI contributions properly. You don't have to wait for HR to get around to it.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorI didn't know I could contact EDD's employer division directly. That's useful to have as a backup if HR drags their feet.
0 coins
Daniel Rivera
HR 'shrugging' at a payroll error on a government withholding is not a small thing. Put everything in an email, send it today.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
Exactly. An email trail with a date on it protects you if this comes up later during your claim.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
Worth noting that the minimum to even qualify for DI is $300 in wages subject to SDI during the base period. If the missing withholding somehow meant your wages weren't showing as SDI-covered at all, you'd want to confirm with EDD that the base period wages they have on record meet that threshold before your claim gets too far along.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorMy wages are well above that number but I didn't know there was a minimum. Good flag for anyone in a shorter employment situation.
0 coins
Vincent Bimbach
What counts as the base period exactly? I've seen different explanations and I'm still confused.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
It's the highest-earning quarter out of a 12-month window that runs from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim start date. EDD shows the exact quarters on your Notice of Computation.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
four weeks into waiting and my notice still hasn't shown. reading all this about base period wages and im hoping the employer stuff doesnt make mine take even longer
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
Fourteen days after EDD receives your complete claim, with both your part and the medical certification, is the usual window for them to contact you about status. If it's been longer, the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online is worth using.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
the medical cert went in week two i think. maybe i should use that request update thing now.
0 coins
Maya Jackson
Patients sometimes don't realize the SDI deduction question matters until they're already filing. The base period wages are what EDD uses to set your weekly amount, so a missing deduction that affects those quarters is worth resolving quickly. Contact HR in writing, keep your stubs, and check your Notice of Computation line by line when it arrives.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorThe 'check line by line' advice is exactly what I'll do. I'm building a spreadsheet now with my quarterly wages so I have a comparison ready.
0 coins
Maya Jackson
That's exactly the right preparation. Discrepancies are easier to dispute when you have your own wage records organized alongside the notice.
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
Can I ask a sideways question here? If someone did get a Notice of Determination saying their claim wasn't payable, partly because of a wage question, what's the window to appeal it?
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
Thirty days from the date on the notice. The notice itself comes with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. If you've misplaced the form, a detailed letter works too, mailed to the return address on the notice.
0 coins
Kelsey Chin
Got it, 30 days from the notice date. That's tighter than I would have guessed.
0 coins
Jessica Nolan
Don't sit on it. Thirty days goes fast.
0 coins
Connor Rupert
Bottom line for anyone reading: missing CASDI on your stubs is the employer's problem to fix with EDD, not a reason your claim automatically fails. Document everything and follow up in writing.
0 coins
Norah Quay
Short and correct. This should be the first reply anyone reads on this topic.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorAgreed. When I first saw those stubs I thought I was completely sunk. Much clearer picture now.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
ok so to summarize what ive learned here: casdi missing from stubs = employers fault, wages still count, get it in writing from hr, check the notice of computation when it shows up. did i get that right
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
You've got it right. The employer owes the missed contributions to EDD. Your wages should count toward the base period. Put everything in writing, and compare your quarterly wages carefully against whatever EDD shows on your Notice of Computation.
0 coins
Leo McDonald
ok cool. still going to panic a little but at least i know what to actually do now
0 coins
PrinceJoe
AuthorSame. That's exactly where I landed after this whole thread. Now I just have to wait for the notice and see what EDD actually has on file for my wages.
0 coins