Back to California Disability

Brooklyn Knight

Can you collect SDI and disability at the same time in California?

So I'm trying to wrap my head around this and maybe I'm overthinking it. I got hurt away from work, nothing job-related, and my HR person mentioned I might have short-term disability through the company AND California SDI. Now I'm wondering if you can collect SDI and disability at the same time, like both running together, or if one cancels out the other. I've been out for about three weeks already and haven't filed anything because I didn't want to mess it up. My wife keeps telling me just file but I genuinely don't know which one to do first or if I can even do both. Anyone been through this?

Base period question nearly tripped me up when I filed last year after my back gave out. Turns out EDD looks at wages from a specific 12-month window, four quarters, and they use whichever single quarter had your highest pay. I ended up calling to find out exactly which quarter they pulled because my hours had been all over the place. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through on the disability line after the regular line just rang and rang. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me which quarter they used and what wages showed in it. That matched my Notice of Computation so it all made sense after that.

0 coins

Quarterly wage thing bit me too on my claim. Had a stretch where my gig income was way higher in one quarter than the others and I had no idea if EDD caught it. Claimyr is how I got through after spending four mornings hitting redial with nothing. Agent confirmed they had the right quarter on file, then I asked about my DE 2593 since I'd had it sitting there, and she told me I had to return it within 20 days or benefits would stop. Sent it in that afternoon.

0 coins

wait so the DE 2593 can actually stop your payments if you dont return it in time? I think I got one of those in the mail and I'm not sure I even opened it yet, that's really scary

0 coins

Yeah open it. 20 days from whatever date is on it. EDD sends it after your first ten weeks on automatic payment, like around the five-payment mark.

0 coins

found it, the date is still okay, sending it tomorrow, thank you

0 coins

To answer the main question here: SDI is the state program, the one run by California EDD with the CASDI deduction on your paystub. When people say 'disability' they almost always mean the same thing. So SDI and state disability are not two separate checks, they are one claim. What you may be thinking of is an employer's private short-term disability plan alongside the state SDI claim, and those are different things entirely.

0 coins

oh okay so I wasn't even asking the right question. it's the same program. so my real question is whether the employer plan and EDD's SDI can both pay at once

0 coins

Exactly right. For the employer plan side, that is between you and your HR. For the state SDI side, file through SDI Online in myEDD. EDD decides the state claim on its own.

0 coins

does filing EDD's claim affect what the employer plan pays or the other way around? I'm in a similar boat and I really don't want to accidentally get overpaid and owe money back

0 coins

The employer plan terms are set by your company, not EDD. Read your plan documents or ask HR what happens when SDI is also in payment. EDD runs the SDI side and decides that claim independently.

0 coins

sdi IS disability lol they're the same thing, state disability insurance is what sdi stands for

0 coins

Right, SDI is literally the abbreviation for State Disability Insurance. The confusion probably comes from people saying 'my disability' meaning the EDD claim and separately 'my disability insurance' meaning a private employer policy, two different things with similar names.

0 coins

yeah exactly, tripped me up too when i first filed, kept thinking i was missing something

0 coins

My salon closed for a bit and I had a client who was out on SDI for a pretty long stretch after a surgery. She was also getting something from her employer, some kind of supplemental plan her union had. She said they ran at the same time but the union plan paid less once SDI kicked in because they coordinated benefits. So it really does depend on what your employer offers and how their plan is written. EDD doesn't care about the other one, it just runs its own calculation.

0 coins

that coordination of benefits piece is what I need to figure out with HR. At least EDD's side sounds straightforward, file and let them calculate it.

0 coins

HR conversation is worth having before you file nothing, some plans have a deadline to report that you filed for SDI and missing it can mess up the supplemental payment

0 coins

HR meeting is on my calendar for tomorrow morning now, good call

0 coins

Three weeks out and nothing filed yet is worth fixing today. You have 49 days from when the disability started to get the claim and the medical certification both in before EDD can disqualify the claim. Clock is running.

0 coins

49 days total, that's tighter than I realized. I'm around 21 days in so I still have time but I need to move.

0 coins

Day 1 to Day 49, that window covers both the claimant's online filing and the doctor's medical certification. Miss it and EDD can deny the whole claim. File your part first through SDI Online, get the receipt number, give it to your doctor same day if you can.

0 coins

your doc needs that receipt number to find your claim in the system and submit their part. dont skip giving it to them

0 coins

49-day deadline surprised me when I first read EDD's filing instructions. The rule is nine days after disability starts before you can file, then no later than 49 days after it starts, and the medical certification also has to be in by that 49-day mark. EDD's SDI Online page spells this out if you search for the how-to-file instructions on edd.ca.gov.

0 coins

so there's a nine-day minimum wait before filing and a 49-day hard cutoff and both apply to the same claim? I want to make sure I'm reading that right

0 coins

Yes, that's exactly it. Wait at least nine days in, file within 49 days of the start date, and have the doctor's certification in by that same 49-day point.

0 coins

okay writing that down. I'm on day 11 so I should file this week and get the receipt number to my doctor right away

0 coins

Payment method threw me off when my check was mailing to an old address. Called EDD after three weeks of nothing showing up. Claimyr got me to an actual agent when I'd been trying the line every day that week. Agent looked up my claim and said payments were going to a Money Network debit card, not a check, and walked me through what address they had on file. Got it sorted from there.

0 coins

Money Network card is news to me, I always thought EDD sent a Bank of America card. Are you sure that's what the agent said?

0 coins

Positive. Agent said it's Money Network now, not Bank of America. The card mails separately from any EDD paperwork so a lot of people miss it.

0 coins

Agent was right! EDD moved to Money Network a while back. I actually got confused by the same thing when my card arrived because the envelope didn't look official. But it was real and it works great!

0 coins

Alright, good to know. Mine's on direct deposit so I never saw a card but I'll pass that along.

0 coins

I told three clients this week that the Bank of America card is gone, everyone still thinks that's the one to watch for

0 coins

wait so workers comp is totally separate from SDI right, like if you got hurt at work you go that route and not EDD disability?

0 coins

Workers' comp is for on-the-job injuries, yes. SDI is for things that happen off the clock, illness, surgery, pregnancy. EDD itself says it's not common to get both at the same time, though they acknowledge there are exceptions. If the injury is work-related, workers' comp is the first stop.

0 coins

my injury was off the clock so SDI is definitely the right lane for me. good clarification though

0 coins

got it, makes sense. my buddy got hurt at his warehouse job and went the workers comp route, different thing entirely lol

0 coins

I keep seeing people mention PFL alongside SDI and I honestly don't know if I need to file for that too. Is PFL the same claim or a second one on top of SDI?

0 coins

PFL is Paid Family Leave and it's a separate program from SDI disability. You'd use SDI when you can't work due to your own medical condition. PFL comes into play for things like bonding with a new baby after pregnancy disability ends, or caring for a seriously ill family member. Two different claims filed separately.

0 coins

okay so for my situation, just out sick and can't work, I only need the SDI disability claim and PFL doesn't apply here. that makes sense now

0 coins

Exact same mix-up I had. The two programs share the SDI payroll deduction but they're filed and tracked separately in SDI Online.

0 coins

the waiting period thing, nobody warned me the first seven days dont pay. i thought my first check would cover day one

0 coins

Seven calendar days from day one of the disability, non-payable, every new claim. First payable day is day eight. It's not a processing delay, it's a built-in unpaid window that EDD calls the waiting period. Your Notice of Computation will show it.

0 coins

yeah i see it now on the notice. wish i'd known before i filed but at least it's clear in writing

0 coins

same surprise here. first claim and that waiting period was not what I expected

0 coins

I'm kind of scared to ask my doctor to certify my claim because what if they say my condition doesn't qualify? Like does the doctor decide or does EDD decide?

0 coins

EDD decides eligibility. The doctor just certifies that you have a medical condition that keeps you from doing your regular work. That's their part. EDD reviews the whole claim and makes the call.

0 coins

that actually helps a lot, I was worried my doctor would refuse and that would be the end of it

0 coins

The doctor certifies the medical facts, EDD handles the rest. If EDD denies the claim they send a Notice of Determination with an appeal form, so you'd have options.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is legitimately broken. Called every morning for two weeks trying to ask about an extension and either got the busy signal loop or it cut me off after the hold music. I finally got through once and the call dropped. No resolution whatsoever.

0 coins

two weeks of that is brutal

0 coins

Extension questions specifically are worth getting to an agent for because the DE 2525XX has to come from your doctor, but EDD can tell you whether they've received it yet. The SDI Online message option is a backup if the phone keeps failing.

0 coins

tried the SDI Online message thing too, waited nine days and got a form response that told me nothing. phone is still the only way to get a real answer

0 coins

Filing part A of the claim online took me maybe 15 minutes through myEDD, the tricky part was making sure my doctor had the receipt number before they tried to submit. Their front desk almost submitted without it and that would have been a mess.

0 coins

I'm going to file tonight and physically walk the receipt number into my doctor's office tomorrow morning so there's no way it gets lost in an email

0 coins

That works. Some offices have a patient portal where you can send it securely too, but walking it in is totally fine.

0 coins

I literally printed mine and faxed it because my doctor's office still uses a fax machine, whatever works

0 coins

The Notice of Computation came in the mail and I was so excited thinking it meant my claim was approved! Then I read it again and realized it just shows the potential weekly amount, not an approval. Had to remind myself payments and approvals are two separate things!

0 coins

Very common mix-up. The Notice of Computation shows your potential weekly and maximum benefit amounts based on your base period wages. It is not approval. Payments starting is when you know the claim is active.

0 coins

Yes! Once I understood that I stopped panicking every time I saw something in the mail from EDD. The notice is actually a helpful preview of what to expect if the claim goes through.

0 coins

genuinely didn't know that either. I thought any paperwork from EDD after filing meant it was approved, good to know the notice is just the estimate

0 coins

Medical certification still showing unmatched on my claim after two weeks was what got me to pick up the phone. Used Claimyr to reach an agent on the disability line since I'd gotten nowhere on my own. Agent checked and said the certification had come in but was filed under a slightly different form receipt number, which was why it hadn't matched to my claim. She noted the correction and told me to watch for a status update in SDI Online within a few days.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I haven't heard of it before.

0 coins

It waits on hold with EDD's disability line so you don't have to, and your phone rings when an agent is on the line. That's really the whole thing.

0 coins

Receipt number mismatch is actually what I was going to ask about for my own claim. My doctor's office submitted and I gave them the number but I'm not 100% sure they entered it right. Sounds like an agent can actually check that.

0 coins

I didn't realize the receipt number mismatch was something the agent could look up and fix on the spot, that's really useful to know if mine ends up stuck

0 coins

For the original question: short answer is SDI is the state disability program, so collecting 'SDI and disability' would be the same stream of money. The real version of your question is probably whether a private employer plan and EDD's SDI can both pay, and the answer is they can run at the same time, but whether they coordinate or offset each other depends entirely on how the employer plan is written.

0 coins

HR confirmed today that my employer plan actually reduces its payment dollar for dollar once SDI kicks in. So I'll get the SDI amount from EDD and just a top-up from the employer plan. Better than nothing.

0 coins

That is a really common setup. Means your total income replacement is capped around the employer plan's level but EDD's piece is covering a chunk of it.

0 coins

good outcome honestly, at least you got it figured out before filing nothing and missing the deadline

0 coins

Unemployment and SDI is a different question from the employer plan thing. Can't collect both for the same days.

0 coins

yeah cause unemployment requires you to be ready and able to work every week, if youre out on disability you cant claim that

0 coins

Exactly. Once you're medically cleared to work again you can file for unemployment if you need to. EDD decides each claim.

0 coins

People try to stack them sometimes. EDD notices.

0 coins

my doctor said she could certify my claim but she's a nurse practitioner, is that okay?

0 coins

Nurse practitioners are on EDD's list of providers who can certify a disability claim. You're fine.

0 coins

okay, relief. I wasn't sure and didn't want to submit and have it rejected for the wrong certifier

0 coins

The list also includes physician assistants, chiropractors, podiatrists, and others depending on the condition. As long as the certification is within their scope of license, EDD accepts it.

0 coins

Heard someone say their physical therapist certified their claim. That doesn't sound right to me.

0 coins

Physical therapists are not on EDD's approved certifier list. The list covers physicians, osteopathic doctors, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, licensed midwives, nurse-midwives, and authorized medical officers of US government facilities, and accredited religious practitioners for certain conditions. A PT would not be a valid certifier and a claim submitted that way could be held up.

0 coins

Figured. Whoever told them that sent them down the wrong path.

0 coins

Someone at my salon tried that because her PT was easier to reach than her regular doctor. Good thing her friend stopped her before she submitted.

0 coins

52-week maximum on a single DI claim is worth knowing going in if the condition is serious. After that point the claim ends even if you're still unable to work. Extensions within the 52 weeks require the physician to submit the DE 2525XX, but nothing extends past 52 weeks on one claim.

0 coins

52 weeks is a lot longer than I'll need thankfully, mine should wrap up in 6 to 8 weeks. but good to know the ceiling exists

0 coins

For shorter claims the main milestone is around week 10, that's when the DE 2593 arrives on automatic payment and you have 20 days to return it.

0 coins

DE 2593 caught me completely off guard on week 10. Almost missed the return window.

0 coins

Pregnancy claims are a separate flavor of this whole thing worth mentioning. You can start SDI about four weeks before your due date even if you're still working, if your provider certifies it. After delivery it's usually six weeks for a regular birth or eight for a C-section, then bonding with the baby is a separate PFL claim after that.

0 coins

the four weeks before the due date part is what I needed to know, I'm due in about 11 weeks and wasn't sure when to file

0 coins

Around 4 weeks out is the typical window to apply, though you can start earlier if there are complications or your provider limits your work. I'd talk to your OB about when they'd certify it.

0 coins

okay so my OB would certify earlier if she restricts my hours before that. I'll ask at my next appointment

0 coins

Filing nothing because you're not sure is how people miss the 49-day cutoff. File your part now, sort out the employer plan question separately. EDD's clock doesn't pause while you research.

0 coins

Filed tonight. Receipt number printed and I'm dropping it at the doctor's office first thing tomorrow.

0 coins

0 coins

Day one through week eight of my own claim and that deadline stress was real. Glad you got it in.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure