Back to California Disability

StardustSeeker

Can you appeal a denial of workers comp benefits when SDI is also involved?

So I got hurt at work about six weeks ago, bad enough that I couldn't go back and needed surgery on my shoulder. I filed for workers' comp through my employer and also put in a California EDD disability (SDI) claim because I wasn't sure which one was going to come through first and I needed income. Workers' comp ended up denying me — apparently there's a dispute about whether the injury actually happened on the job — and now I'm trying to figure out what my options are on both fronts. I did get a Notice of Computation from EDD showing my potential weekly amount on the SDI side, which was reassuring, but then I got a denial notice from EDD too, I think because they saw I had a workers' comp claim open. I'm confused about how these two things interact and whether I can fight the denial on the SDI side while the workers' comp dispute is still going. Has anyone navigated both of these at the same time?

The SDI denial notice — does it have a form number on it? If EDD sent a Notice of Determination, that's the one that also comes with an appeal form attached, the DE 1000A. The 30-day clock to appeal runs from the date printed on the notice itself, not from when it showed up in your mailbox, so check that date first.

0 coins

Looked it up and yes, it says DE 2517 and there's a form at the bottom that says DE 1000A. The date on it is about 12 days ago so I still have time to get the appeal in.

0 coins

DE 2517 is exactly what you're looking for. Keep that original notice with everything — the return address on it is where the appeal goes, not EDD's general address.

0 coins

Missed this for a second — does the 30-day deadline extend at all if you can prove you got it late? Not sure the appeal form has room for that.

0 coins

Workers' comp and SDI are genuinely two separate things and EDD's own language on this is that it's not common to get paid by both for the same days, but there are exceptions. The tricky part in your situation is that your workers' comp claim is still disputed — it hasn't been paid. So whether EDD treated the denial of workers' comp the same as being paid by workers' comp is something worth asking them directly, because those aren't the same situation.

0 coins

That distinction is exactly what I was unclear on — a denied claim vs. an active payment. My workers' comp was denied, never paid, so I didn't think EDD should treat it the same way.

0 coins

EDD's answer to that probably depends on what they put in the denial notice as the reason. The notice usually spells it out and that's what you'd address in the appeal.

0 coins

The reason code on the DE 2517 matters a lot here. If it cites workers' comp, that's your hook for the appeal argument.

0 coins

Payment on my own SDI claim went missing for about two weeks and I could not get anyone at EDD to pick up. DE 2500A was submitted, everything looked fine in SDI Online, and no payment showed. Ended up reaching a live agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) — the agent pulled up my claim and saw that the payment had been issued but to a card address that hadn't updated when I moved. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. They told me to update the address in my profile and confirmed the payment date so I knew exactly what to watch for.

0 coins

Address mismatch is such a common one and nobody warns you about it when you file. Glad the agent was able to pull the actual payment date off the claim.

0 coins

Getting through to a live agent sounds like exactly what I need once I sort out which appeal argument to make. I've been unable to get anyone on the phone.

0 coins

The Money Network card can also cause confusion if you've moved — the card itself goes to whatever address EDD has on file, so updating it early matters.

0 coins

On the appeal itself: if you lost the DE 1000A or the form feels too small to explain everything, EDD says you can send a detailed letter instead to the address on the notice. The letter needs to lay out why you think the denial was wrong, so being specific about the workers' comp situation — that it was denied and never paid — is the kind of detail that belongs in there.

0 coins

A letter with the full explanation might actually be better in my case since the DE 1000A doesn't have much space. I'll attach a copy of the workers' comp denial too.

0 coins

Attaching the workers' comp denial is a solid move. It shows the dispute is real and unresolved, not that you've been receiving those benefits.

0 coins

Keep copies of everything you mail — the appeal letter, the attachments, and ideally send it in a way you can confirm was received.

0 coins

My sister went through something kind of similar and she was told by her HR that SDI and workers' comp just cancel each other out automatically. That doesn't sound right to me based on what people are saying here — is that actually EDD's rule or is it more complicated?

0 coins

HR's framing isn't quite right. EDD says it's not common to get both for the same days but there are exceptions, and a denied workers' comp claim is a different situation from an active one. HR isn't the authority on how EDD decides — that's EDD's call.

0 coins

That makes more sense. She probably got an oversimplified answer from someone who wasn't actually looking at the EDD rules.

0 coins

Worth noting that an employer's HR department also doesn't usually know the specifics of how EDD handles disputed claims. The notice and the appeal are where the real answer comes out.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window is firm enough that it's worth flagging. A late appeal can still be reviewed but only if the administrative law judge finds your reasons for being late acceptable — it's not automatic. With 18 days left, filing something rough and amending it isn't how it works; file your best version on time.

0 coins

Understood — not going to wait on this. Plan is to get the letter written this week with all the supporting documents.

0 coins

Filing late even by a day puts you in a harder position. The 30-day window is from the notice date, not from when you read it.

0 coins

DE 2593 landed in my mailbox after my tenth week on SDI and I almost missed the 20-day return window because I was still recovering and not checking mail carefully. Called EDD through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the form had been received and logged the date it came in, which settled my nerves about the deadline.

0 coins

Twenty days to return the DE 2593 is tight when you're not well enough to be dealing with paperwork. Good to know the agent could confirm receipt.

0 coins

The DE 2593 is the continued eligibility form — EDD sends it out around week ten and you have to return it or payments stop. Easy to miss if you're in the middle of recovery.

0 coins

Automatic payments only run for the first five payments before that form goes out. After that, EDD needs to know you're still unable to work before it keeps going.

0 coins

Quick sanity check on the base period thing — my denial said something about insufficient wages in the base period, not about workers' comp at all. Does everyone who files SDI get a Notice of Computation first and then possibly a denial? Those seem like contradictory things to receive.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation and a denial aren't contradictory — the computation notice shows what your weekly amount would be if you're found eligible, but it's not an approval. EDD can still deny the claim for other reasons after sending it. At least $300 in wages subject to SDI during the base period is what's needed just to get past that threshold.

0 coins

Ah, so the computation notice is kind of a preview, not a green light. That explains why I was confused when both showed up.

0 coins

Exactly — the computation notice just means EDD ran the math. Eligibility is a separate determination, and the denial notice is where they explain the reason.

0 coins

Shoulder surgery puts you out for a while, so the 52-week maximum on DI benefits probably isn't your immediate worry, but it's worth knowing your SDI claim doesn't go indefinitely. If your recovery extends, your surgeon's office would need to submit a supplementary certificate to keep the claim going past the original end date — they don't file a new claim for you.

0 coins

Surgeon's office already mentioned they'd need to extend the certification. Didn't know the form had its own name but that's good to have.

0 coins

The form for the extension is the DE 2525XX and EDD actually sends that form with the notice about your final payment, so the doctor's office should receive it as part of the process.

0 coins

Right — EDD triggers that form with the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification near the end of the claim period, so the timing is built in.

0 coins

Filed SDI after a back injury and had a workers' comp claim running at the same time. Mine wasn't denied — it was just slow to process — and EDD did eventually ask questions about it. The resolution in my case came down to making sure EDD had documentation of what workers' comp was actually paying, if anything, for each week. If yours was denied outright, that documentation would look different.

0 coins

Workers' comp denial letter exists in writing so I can include that with the SDI appeal to show nothing was actually paid.

0 coins

Documentation that nothing was paid is the strongest thing to include. A denial letter is cleaner than a pending situation because it's definitive.

0 coins

Something worth double-checking: the medical certification on your SDI claim — did your surgeon's office submit it, and did they use the receipt number from when you filed? A claim can sit pending because those two things don't match, which would add another layer to what you're already dealing with.

0 coins

Surgeon's office said they submitted it online, and I gave them the receipt number I got after filing Part A. SDI Online showed pending for a while and then the denial came, so I think the certification did get matched.

0 coins

If the denial notice cites workers' comp and not a missing certification, then yes, the certification was likely matched and the issue is the reason in the notice.

0 coins

The receipt number matching is easy to overlook. Good that you gave it to them directly.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came on my SDI claim and I genuinely could not parse whether it was a full denial or a partial one. Phoned EDD through Claimyr and the agent walked me through what the notice meant for my specific weeks — which weeks were being denied and which were still pending — so I knew whether to appeal the whole thing or just part of it.

0 coins

Knowing whether it's a full or partial denial changes the appeal strategy. That's exactly the kind of thing an agent can clarify from the claim file.

0 coins

Parsing the notice language is harder than it should be. If I hit a wall reading mine, that approach sounds useful.

0 coins

Waiting period confusion comes up a lot with these situations — the first seven days of a DI claim are always non-payable, no matter what. That's not EDD holding your money, it's just how the program is structured. If the denial is about something other than those first seven days, the appeal is about the reason in the notice, not the waiting period.

0 coins

Couldn't agree more that people mix up the waiting period with processing delays. They're completely separate things.

0 coins

Didn't realize the seven-day waiting period was baked into every claim. Thought it was just how long they took to start processing.

0 coins

Nope — it's a built-in non-payable stretch at the start of every claim, not a timing thing. The eighth day is when payable benefits can begin.

0 coins

The appeal form asks for a detailed explanation, so vague language like 'I disagree with the denial' won't carry weight. For your situation, spelling out that workers' comp was disputed, that your injury was not found compensable by workers' comp, and that no workers' comp payment was ever made for any week gives the administrative law judge something concrete to work with.

0 coins

Concrete and specific is right. The more the appeal reads like a timeline of what happened — when you filed, when workers' comp was denied, what the SDI denial says — the clearer the case.

0 coins

Timeline format makes sense. I'll lay it out chronologically: injury date, SDI filing date, workers' comp denial date, then why EDD's reason doesn't hold given that nothing was actually paid.

0 coins

Went back to light duty at my job partway through my SDI claim and had to report that to EDD. Didn't realize reporting partial work was my job — assumed my employer would update EDD somehow. Worth mentioning since your situation might eventually get to a partial return.

0 coins

Reporting partial work is entirely on the claimant, not the employer. EDD doesn't pull that information from anywhere else.

0 coins

Found that out the hard way, fortunately before it turned into an overpayment situation.

0 coins

An unreported partial return can create an overpayment, which then comes with its own notice and its own appeal window. Much easier to report at the time.

0 coins

EDD's disability line is 1-800-480-3287 and hours are 8 to 5 Monday through Friday, closed on state holidays. Getting through early in the week tends to be what people say, though there's no guarantee.

0 coins

I've tried a few times in the morning and gotten the too-busy recording. Will keep at it, especially once the appeal is in.

0 coins

Mornings definitely aren't a guaranteed fix. It seems like volume is just high across all hours right now.

0 coins

Appeals go to the return address on the denial notice — just want to make sure that's clear since some people assume it goes to the same place they mailed their original claim or to EDD's general address. Those are different.

0 coins

Correct, and if you send it somewhere else, there's a risk of it not being routed in time. The notice address is the right one.

0 coins

Mailing to the wrong address and having it arrive late would be a painful way to miss the deadline. Worth double-checking the envelope before it goes out.

0 coins

Direct deposit is worth setting up if you haven't already — SDI Online lets you do that for claims filed online. Avoids the card and address complications some people run into.

0 coins

Direct deposit is cleaner than the Money Network card if you file online. Payments land faster too in most cases.

0 coins

Set up direct deposit when I filed, so at least that part is handled. The denial is the main thing to resolve now.

0 coins

Direct deposit also makes it easier to track exactly when a payment was issued versus when it hits your account, which can matter for record-keeping.

0 coins

Whether California taxes SDI benefits is a question that comes up with shoulder injuries and surgeries because you're often out long enough that it starts to matter at tax time. California doesn't tax them, but the federal side can depend on specifics of your situation. Worth checking EDD's tax information page or asking a tax professional rather than going by what someone in a forum says.

0 coins

Didn't even think about taxes yet — still trying to get the appeal sorted. Good to know that's something to look at later.

0 coins

Probably not urgent right now, but file away for January when the tax documents show up.

0 coins

If you've filed your appeal and are waiting on a hearing date, keep certifying or responding to any EDD correspondence that comes in during the appeal period. A missed form in the middle of an appeal can complicate things separately from the appeal itself.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about that — staying on top of any EDD mail during the appeal makes sense. Don't want a secondary issue popping up while the main one is being reviewed.

0 coins

Any DE 2500A or other certification form that comes in during the appeal window still needs to be handled on its regular timeline. The appeal doesn't pause those requirements.

0 coins

Administrative process and ongoing eligibility are running in parallel. Missing a certification while appealing a denial can create a second problem that's separate from the first.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure