Back to California Disability

NebulaNinja

Can u collect disability and unemployment at the same time in California?

okay so i got laid off about three weeks into being out on disability and now im completely lost about what i can even file for. my SDI claim was already approved and payments were coming in, then my employer let me go while i was still out recovering from my back procedure. a friend told me i should file for unemployment too since i lost my job, but another friend said i can't get both at the same time and now im getting conflicting info from everyone. like do i just keep getting my SDI payments and ignore unemployment for now? or do i need to do something to protect my job claim? i don't want to mess up the disability payments i already have coming in and i also don't want to leave money on the table if i'm supposed to be getting both. has anyone actually dealt with losing their job while on an active SDI claim?

Two different programs doing two different things, which is why you can't double-dip on the same days. The way i'd think about it in your situation: while you literally cannot do your job because of the back thing, that's your SDI days. Unemployment is for when you're ready, able, and actually looking for work. EDD won't let the same days count for both. So right now while you're still recovering, your SDI keeps going. When a doctor clears you to work again, that's when unemployment comes into play — you can file then. The problem comes if you try to claim UI for the days you're already getting SDI. EDD will catch it and you'd be looking at an overpayment.

0 coins

so i shouldn't even touch the unemployment filing until my doctor releases me? i've been panicking thinking i need to do both at once

0 coins

Yep that's how i understood it too. My physical therapist actually said i should file both and i almost did before someone here set me straight. SDI first while you can't work, then unemployment when you can.

0 coins

Physical therapist probably just meant well but that's not how EDD sees it. The two programs can't cover the same stretch of days, full stop. When you're cleared and available to work, file for UI then.

0 coins

Lost my retail job while i was on SDI last year for a shoulder thing and went through exactly this. Kept my SDI going because i still couldn't lift anything, then filed unemployment the week my doctor said i was cleared. What helped me was keeping the two timelines completely separate in my head: disability days for when i can't work, unemployment days for when i can but don't have a job. Don't file UI while you're still certifying with your doctor for SDI.

0 coins

the timeline thing actually makes it click for me. i've been thinking of them as competing but they're more like back to back

0 coins

back to back is exactly the right way to put it. i did the same sequence after a knee surgery — SDI until cleared, then straight to unemployment. worked out fine

0 coins

wait so you file a brand new unemployment claim after SDI ends? i thought maybe you had to file before your SDI ran out or something

0 coins

Notice of Determination landed in my mailbox about ten days after i filed my own SDI claim, and something on it didn't match what i expected, so i needed to actually talk to someone at EDD. Spent a full morning trying to reach the disability line at 1-800-480-3287 and kept hitting the busy signal loop. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the line for me and ended up talking to an EDD agent inside of that call. She pulled up my claim and confirmed the determination was based on the right base period and told me what the notice meant. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability if you're stuck: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

i got a Notice of Computation a few days after my claim went active but haven't gotten a determination notice. do those come separately?

0 coins

They're different documents. The computation notice shows your potential weekly amount. A determination notice only comes if EDD decides something about your eligibility — like a denial or a partial approval. If your payments are coming in you probably just have the computation one, which is normal.

0 coins

the determination notice is the one with the appeal form attached. if you haven't gotten one and payments are flowing, you're in good shape

0 coins

the question people always get tangled up on is whether SDI affects what you can collect in unemployment. short answer is they don't pay you for the same days. where i see people get in trouble is filing UI while still on a doctor's restriction because UI requires you to certify every week that you were able to work and available. if you can't do that honestly, you shouldn't be certifying for UI.

0 coins

my neighbor told me to just file for both and 'see what happens' and i almost did that. glad i asked around first because that could have created a real mess

0 coins

See what' happens with EDD is usually how people end up with overpayment notices. Not worthit.

0 coins

yeah i'm not trying to guess on this one. the overpayment thing genuinely scares me

0 coins

Workers comp question that comes up alongside this: if the back procedure was related to something that happened at work, that's a totally different lane from SDI. EDD themselves say it's not common to get workers comp and SDI at the same time, though there are exceptions. Just flagging it since you mentioned a back procedure — if it was a work injury, the path is different and you'd want to look into that separately.

0 coins

it was not work related, just something that finally needed to get fixed. so SDI is the right program for me

0 coins

Good, that makes it cleaner. SDI for the recovery, then UI when you're back on your feet and job hunting.

0 coins

good point to raise though. i've seen people go down the SDI road for months when it was actually a work injury and they had a whole comp case they didn't know about

0 coins

To answer the person who asked about filing UI before SDI ends — you don't have to wait until your very last SDI payment clears. You can file for unemployment once your doctor releases you to work, even if you're still technically in the tail end of your SDI period as long as you're not claiming UI for the same days SDI is covering. The key is that you have to be genuinely able and available to work when you certify for UI.

0 coins

okay that makes sense. so as long as i'm cleared by my doctor and not double-counting the same days, i can get UI started

0 coins

Exactly. The day your doctor clears you is effectively the dividing line. SDI covers up through that point, UI covers what comes after, assuming you meet UI's other eligibility requirements.

0 coins

i would add: file UI pretty quickly once you're cleared, don't wait around. UI has its own filing window and delays can cost you weeks of benefits

0 coins

can i ask a dumb question — if someone is on SDI and their employer lays them off, does the layoff change the SDI claim at all? like does EDD stop the disability payments when they find out you got laid off?

0 coins

DI is about whether you can work, not whether you have a job. Getting laid off while on SDI doesn't automatically stop disability payments. SDI is covering your inability to work due to the medical condition, not your employment status.

0 coins

that's actually reassuring. i was worried that losing the job would somehow cut off the SDI

0 coins

Same concern i had honestly. The payments kept coming after my layoff until my doctor cleared me. Then i transitioned to UI.

0 coins

i got tangled up on this exact thing because i confused SDI with PFL in my head for weeks. thought i'd need to file a whole new PFL claim when my SDI ended for a bonding situation. turns out PFL is completely separate — if someone is on disability for pregnancy and then wants bonding time after, that transition does involve a new PFL claim. But for a plain disability claim with no baby involved, PFL doesn't come into it at all.

0 coins

mine is definitely not pregnancy related so i think i'm in the simpler bucket

0 coins

Yeah you're in the simpler situation. No PFL overlap, just SDI then UI once you're cleared. The PFL thing tripped me up because i was reading everything i could find and kept mixing the programs together.

0 coins

the SDI vs PFL confusion is so common. they're both under the SDI umbrella but they're separate claims with different rules

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim form wasn't matching what my doctor's office had on file, and it held up the whole certification for almost two weeks. Got through to an EDD disability agent through Claimyr and she confirmed which number was correct — the one from my SDI Online confirmation screen after i submitted Part A. Office had been using the wrong reference entirely.

0 coins

i didn't even realize the receipt number could cause a holdup like that. i gave mine to my doctor's office but i should double check they have the right one

0 coins

Worth a quick check. My office had four different numbers written down from various forms and picked the wrong one. The right one is specifically the receipt number SDI Online shows you right after you submit your claim.

0 coins

the receipt number thing tripped me up too. my surgeon's office was using my EDD customer account number instead. had to go back and correct it in person

0 coins

something worth knowing about the waiting period that people sometimes confuse with processing time: the first seven days of an SDI claim are just not payable, period. it's not EDD taking seven days to process anything, it's a mandatory non-payable window built into every new claim. so when your first payment comes in, it covers starting from day eight. i see people thinking they're owed those first seven days and they're not.

0 coins

i think i was one of those people. i kept waiting for a payment that covered the first week and wondering why it wasn't there

0 coins

Super common misread. The Notice of Computation helps clarify it but even that document isn't the clearest on the waiting period. Day eight is your first payable day on any new DI claim.

0 coins

i thought the waiting period was just for certain kinds of claims, not all of them. good to know it's across the board

0 coins

jumped on here because i was wondering about the same double-collecting question from the other side — my situation is i'm currently collecting unemployment and just got diagnosed with something that means i'll probably be out for a few months. so do i switch to SDI now?

0 coins

UI requires you to certify every two weeks that you were able and available for work. If you genuinely can't work anymore because of a health situation, you can't honestly certify for UI. At that point you'd file for DI. Same rule — the two programs don't cover the same days.

0 coins

so i'd file the SDI claim and stop certifying for UI once i'm actually unable to work?

0 coins

That's the right sequence. Talk to your doctor about when the disability starts, file the SDI claim from that date, and stop UI certifications from then. Keep your documentation clean so the timelines don't overlap.

0 coins

one correction to something mentioned earlier in the thread — the person who said their physical therapist certified their SDI claim. a PT isn't on EDD's list of providers who can certify a disability claim. the list includes physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, authorized medical officers, licensed midwives, and accredited religious practitioners. if someone only has a PT certifying their claim, EDD may not accept it and they'd need to get a different provider to sign off.

0 coins

genuinely did not know PT wasn't on the list. my PT has been acting like the main person handling my recovery and i assumed that counted. guess i need to get my actual physician to certify

0 coins

Definitely get your physician on it. The PT is great for the actual recovery work but EDD needs someone from that approved list to certify the medical part.

0 coins

good catch on this. the PT thing comes up and people assume any healthcare professional counts. they don't — has to be someone from that specific list.

0 coins

the appeals process question came up indirectly here so i'll mention: if EDD sends you a Notice of Determination that says they're not paying you, don't just sit on it. you've got 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal using the form that comes attached (DE 1000A). miss that window and you're asking an administrative law judge to excuse the late filing, which is a harder road. the notice itself tells you what the appeal deadline is.

0 coins

what if someone lost the form that came with the notice? is there another way to appeal?

0 coins

If you can't find the form, write a detailed letter instead and mail it to the address on the notice. Include your claim number, what you're appealing and why, and get it in before that 30-day deadline.

0 coins

didn't know a letter worked as a substitute for the form. that's useful to have in the back pocket

0 coins

i want to flag something that hasn't come up yet — when you do eventually file UI after your SDI ends, make sure you report any weeks where you got SDI payments when certifying for UI. EDD cross-references this stuff and you don't want any overlap on the same days looking like you tried to collect both.

0 coins

is there a specific place on the UI certification where you report that or does it just come up in the weekly questions?

0 coins

the UI weekly certification asks about any other income or benefits you received that week. that's where you'd note it if there was any overlap period. keep it honest and you'll be fine.

0 coins

Keeping the timelines clean is the whole game here. SDI days on the SDI side, UI days on the UI side, no same-day overlap, and report everything accurately when certifying.

0 coins

My SDI payment showed as issued in SDI Online but nothing had hit my Money Network card after several days, so i phoned EDD at 1-800-480-3287 on a Tuesday morning. Got through to an agent through Claimyr and she looked up the specific payment date and confirmed it was processed on a particular date and told me which day it was sent to the card network. Card showed the deposit the next morning.

0 coins

the Money Network card thing is a whole other thing i need to figure out. i set up direct deposit but want to make sure it went through correctly

0 coins

Direct deposit is the cleaner option honestly. If you set it up through SDI Online it should be tied to your bank account directly. The Money Network card is the default if you didn't choose direct deposit.

0 coins

i didn't know you could switch to direct deposit. i've been dealing with the card for two claims now and it's annoying

0 coins

DE 2593 landed in my mailbox about ten weeks into my claim and i almost ignored it thinking it was junk mail. it's the continuing eligibility questionnaire EDD sends out after five automatic payments. you've got 20 days to return it or they cut off your benefits. opened it the same day and sent it back that week.

0 coins

the DE 2593 caught me off guard on my first claim too. did not expect a form showing up mid-claim asking if i was still disabled. almost missed the 20-day window

0 coins

the envelope really doesn't look important from the outside. i only opened it because i was paranoid about missing something. 20 days goes fast.

0 coins

i'm on automatic payment so i guess i'll be watching for that form around week ten. good to know in advance so i don't panic when it shows up

0 coins

going back to the original question about collecting both — there's a version of this that actually can work in sequence without any gap: some people on SDI near the end of their claim ask their doctor to extend if they still can't work, using the extension process. the doctor submits a supplemental certificate and EDD can extend the claim. that's separate from unemployment. then when you ARE cleared you go to UI. it's not collecting both, it's making sure you don't leave SDI money on the table before you switch.

0 coins

my doctor mentioned the possibility of a longer recovery period so this is actually really relevant. i didn't know there was a formal extension process

0 coins

EDD sends a form with the final payment notice and the doctor fills it out. You don't start a whole new SDI claim. The doctor submits the supplemental certificate and EDD reviews it. Worth asking your doctor about if recovery is dragging.

0 coins

the extension option is underused. a lot of people assume SDI just ends and they're on their own. if the doc says you still can't work, the extension path exists.

0 coins

to wrap up the whole picture for anyone reading this later: SDI covers days you medically can't work, UI covers days you're able and looking for work, and EDD won't pay both for the same days. lose your job while on SDI — keep the SDI going. get cleared by your doctor — file UI then. those are literally the only two rules you need to hold onto.

0 coins

this is the clearest summary of everything in this thread. doctor clears me, i file UI. SDI handles now, UI handles after. got it.

0 coins

Accurate and clean. The only thing i'd add is to certify honestly for whichever program you're on and don't try to claim both for the same stretch. EDD's systems catch overlaps.

0 coins

came in confused and leaving with an actual plan. thanks to everyone who explained this in plain terms

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure