Back to California Disability

Eloise Kendrick

Can they take all SDI benefits to repay overpayment and can I appeal?

So I got this notice in the mail saying I have an overpayment on my SDI claim and they want the money back. The amount is not small and I honestly panicked when I opened it. What I don't understand is whether California EDD can just take every single one of my future disability payments to cover it, like can they wipe out the whole check, or do they have to leave me something? And then the bigger question is whether I even have the right to fight this because I genuinely don't think I was paid anything I wasn't supposed to get. I reported my hours when I went back part time, I did everything right as far as I can tell. The notice doesn't really explain what I did wrong. Has anyone actually appealed an SDI overpayment and what happened? I don't even know where to start.

The claim start date on mine was listed wrong, which held everything up and created a whole mess with my payment schedule. I ended up talking to an EDD agent after trying Claimyr (claimyr.com) and the agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the date they had on file was off by almost two weeks from when my doctor actually certified my disability. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ The agent said a corrected notice would go out and to watch for it and appeal within 30 days if anything still looked wrong.

0 coins

Can I ask, did you have your medical certification receipt number handy when you called? I always wonder if the agent can even pull anything up without it.

0 coins

Yes I had it right there, the receipt number and the claim ID both. The agent found everything pretty fast once I read those off.

0 coins

I have been dialing that disability line since Tuesday. Busy signal every single time, doesn't even ring through. Good to know there's another way.

0 coins

To answer the main question here: EDD cannot simply take everything. The overpayment notice should tell you what percentage of each payment they intend to withhold. You still receive a portion while the rest goes toward the balance, unless you have fully recovered from your disability and no longer have an active claim, in which case they would pursue collection differently. Either way, you have the right to appeal within 30 days of the date printed on that notice.

0 coins

Logged into SDI Online just now and the notice date is showing. So the 30 days runs from that printed date, not from when it arrived in my mailbox?

0 coins

Correct, from the date printed on the notice itself. If mail delay ate into your time, note that in your appeal and explain; an administrative law judge can consider reasons for a late filing.

0 coins

What if the notice is already two weeks old? Is there still time to appeal or is it basically too late?

0 coins

Two weeks in still leaves roughly two weeks before the deadline. File the appeal now and don't wait on anything else.

0 coins

Got hit with one of these last year. I appealed it. EDD sends you an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, with the notice. Fill that out, write a detailed explanation of why you think the overpayment is wrong, and mail it to the return address on the notice. Keep a copy of everything you send.

0 coins

Checked the envelope again and yes, the DE 1000A is in there. I didn't even notice it the first time I was so stressed.

0 coins

Yeah it's easy to miss when you're panicking. That form is what you need.

0 coins

Does the explanation need to be formal or can it just be a plain letter?

0 coins

Plain is fine. The instructions say a detailed letter works if you don't use the form. Use the form if you have it.

0 coins

The 30-day clock starts on the notice date, not the day you receive it. I'd write that date down right now. Also pull every pay stub from the weeks EDD is questioning and your claim certifications for those same weeks, so you can show exactly what you reported and when.

0 coins

Pulled up my bank statements and I do have the pay stubs from when I went back part time. Those weeks are the ones EDD flagged.

0 coins

Those are exactly what you need. Line up each week side by side, what you earned and what you certified to EDD, so the picture is clear.

0 coins

my cousin said edd can take the whole payment but that doesnt sound right to me honestly

0 coins

That part isn't right. EDD withholds a portion of each payment toward the overpayment, not the full amount. The notice itself will show the withholding amount.

0 coins

ok good because my cousin was freaking her out more than necessary lol

0 coins

The thing I'd want to know is what the notice actually says you were overpaid for. Mine said I was overpaid because my part-time earnings in a certain week exceeded what I was supposed to receive, but my calculation disagreed with theirs. Having the specific weeks and amounts they cite is important before you write your appeal explanation.

0 coins

Mine lists specific week-ending dates and a total amount. It doesn't really explain the math behind it though.

0 coins

That's common. Your appeal explanation is where you show your own math, with the pay stubs backing it up. You're essentially telling them here's what I earned, here's what I certified, and here's why the overpayment amount is wrong.

0 coins

This is the right approach. Lay it out week by week and let the documentation do the talking.

0 coins

The appeals process for SDI overpayments is not fast and EDD will keep withholding during it. Keep filing your certifications on time so the payments don't stop entirely on top of everything else.

0 coins

Wait, do I keep certifying even while the appeal is pending?

0 coins

Yes. Your claim keeps going. The appeal is a separate process from the payments.

0 coins

I did not know that. I assumed an appeal froze everything.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim had numbers that didn't line up with what I expected, so I tried Claimyr to reach someone at EDD and ended up on the phone with an agent. The agent told me which quarter of my wages they'd used for the base period and read me the weekly amount off my own notice. Cleared up why the amount came out the way it did.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in and I have no idea if the weekly amount is right. I want to ask EDD which quarter they used to calculate it. Going to try Claimyr for that.

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and claim ID on hand. The agent pulled everything up fast once I had those ready.

0 coins

Good to know there's a way to actually reach someone. The phone line has been impossible for me too.

0 coins

You reported your hours, you've got the records to prove it. That's your appeal right there. File it, state your case clearly, attach the pay stubs, done.

0 coins

That framing actually helps me. I was overthinking how complicated the letter needed to be.

0 coins

Keep it straightforward. Here are the weeks, here's what I earned, here's what I reported. Don't bury it in a wall of text.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD reverse an overpayment after an appeal? Like fully reverse it, not just reduce it?

0 coins

Mine got reduced significantly after I showed my pay stubs. Full reversal I haven't seen personally but it probably depends on what the documentation shows.

0 coins

I've read accounts of full reversals where the claimant proved they reported everything correctly. No promises, but it happens.

0 coins

An administrative law judge reviews the evidence and decides. If the records show correct reporting, the finding can go fully in the claimant's favor.

0 coins

I'm kind of scared about this whole thing even though my situation is different. I haven't gotten an overpayment notice but I'm on a DI claim right now and terrified I'll do something wrong. What counts as reporting correctly when you go back part time?

0 coins

Report your earnings for the week you earned them on your certification, not when you got paid. EDD handles the calculation of how a partial week pays out.

0 coins

So the date I worked is what matters, not the date my paycheck arrives?

0 coins

Exactly right.

0 coins

And keep your pay stubs. Every single one.

0 coins

The notice being confusing is actually really common. EDD's overpayment notices tell you the amount and the weeks but the math explanation is minimal. Your appeal is your chance to put your own version of events on record.

0 coins

Mine really is just the total amount and the weeks. No formula.

0 coins

That's pretty standard from what I've seen. Write out the weeks they listed one by one and show your earnings for each. That's your answer to their math.

0 coins

The original question about whether EDD can take every dollar of your payments, they can't take it all. You'd still receive something on each payment, with a portion going toward the overpayment balance. If the appeal goes in your favor they'd stop the withholding.

0 coins

That's a relief even if partial. I need those payments to cover rent while I'm still out.

0 coins

File the appeal now and note in it that you're still on an active claim and need payments to continue. The process runs in parallel.

0 coins

Weeks on my claim got marked paid in ways that didn't match what I was seeing in SDI Online, and I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr. The agent read off exactly which week-ending dates had issued payments and which were still pending on my claim. Cleared it up fast.

0 coins

The pending weeks on my claim have been sitting there for a while now. I tried Claimyr too once I saw no movement, and once the agent pulled up my claim they found the medical certification had come in but hadn't been matched to the claim yet. Agent said a notice would go out once it processed.

0 coins

ive been hitting that phone line every morning for a week and a half, nothing ever goes through

0 coins

The match thing was my whole holdup. Once the agent flagged it I stopped worrying and just waited for the notice.

0 coins

Just to flag something I noticed about the appeal form itself. The DE 1000A has a space for a detailed explanation but it's small. You can attach additional pages. Write your explanation on separate sheets if you need more room and label them clearly as attachments to the DE 1000A.

0 coins

That's good to know because there's a lot to explain and I was wondering if I'd fit it on the form.

0 coins

Attach as many pages as you need. Reference them in the form's explanation field.

0 coins

Always mail it with something that shows it was sent, so you have a record.

0 coins

the waiting period on my claim confused me at first too. thought it was a processing delay but its actually the first seven days that just dont pay, period

0 coins

That's right. The waiting period is seven non-payable days at the start of every new claim. It's not processing, it's just not covered. First payable day is day eight.

0 coins

yeah once i understood that the timeline made more sense

0 coins

Good to know, that tripped me up early on too.

0 coins

The DE 2525XX my doctor submitted for my extension didn't show up matched to my claim for over a week. I ended up talking to an EDD agent using Claimyr and the agent confirmed they had received the form and it was just pending processing. Told me to watch for a notice once it posted.

0 coins

I've tried that disability line so many times. I dial at exactly 8 a.m. and it either rings endlessly or cuts off. I can't see how anyone gets through. How is Claimyr actually different?

0 coins

Honestly I had the same question before I tried it. The way it works is it stays on the line with EDD in your place and your phone picks up once an actual EDD employee is there. I didn't have to sit on hold at all.

0 coins

Got to that line early on a Thursday and it still hung up on me after about four minutes. Good to know there's something that handles the hold part. Used it myself once and the agent confirmed the receipt number on my claim matched what my doctor's office had submitted.

0 coins

Alright, that's more than I've managed on my own. I'll probably try it.

0 coins

If you end up losing the appeal or only getting a partial reversal, the overpayment balance doesn't disappear but EDD works out repayment from future payments over time. It's not a one-time wipeout situation.

0 coins

That's the part I really needed to hear. I thought they'd just zero out my next payment entirely.

0 coins

Nope, it's structured. The notice usually says the percentage or amount per payment.

0 coins

The SDI Online message center is another option to ask EDD directly about the overpayment calculation if you want something in writing before you file the appeal. Open your claim, go to Request Claim Update, and send the question there.

0 coins

I didn't know about that message option in SDI Online. Going to send a message tonight asking them to explain the calculation.

0 coins

It can take a few days to get a response but at least you have a written record of what they say.

0 coins

Screenshot whatever they send back too. Good documentation for the appeal file.

0 coins

File the appeal before anything else. Thirty days goes fast and once it passes you need reasons for the delay on top of everything else.

0 coins

Filing it this week. Got the DE 1000A, got the pay stubs, writing the explanation tonight.

0 coins

Good. Send it to the return address on the notice, keep your copy.

0 coins

Circling back to the original worry: California EDD cannot take your full SDI payment in one shot to cover an overpayment while you're still actively on the claim. The withholding is partial. Appeal the decision, show your records, and let the administrative law judge see that you reported correctly.

0 coins

Thank you. This thread genuinely helped me understand what I'm dealing with. Filing the appeal this week with everything attached.

0 coins

You've got the documentation, you reported your time. That's the case right there.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure