Back to California Disability

Louisa Ramirez

Can paid family leave be denied after employer paid full maternity pay? What I found out about my SDI claim

So I had my baby eight weeks ago and my company gave me full pay the entire time I was out, which was great, but now I'm trying to file for Paid Family Leave for bonding and EDD is saying I might not get anything because I already received compensation during that period. I'm so confused because I thought PFL and what your employer pays you were completely separate things. My disability portion for the pregnancy itself already closed out, and now I'm trying to get the bonding benefits but I'm panicking that the whole thing is about to get denied. Has anyone actually had this happen where their employer paid them fully and then PFL got denied because of it? I don't even know if I should be filing through SDI Online right now or waiting to hear something first. I don't want to lose out on weeks I'm entitled to if there's a way to still get them.

Payment method on my own claim threw me off for a bit, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to sort it out. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed the payment was going to a Money Network prepaid debit card, not a bank account, so I needed to set up direct deposit in SDI Online if I wanted it in my checking account. On the actual PFL question though, whether employer pay blocks bonding benefits really does depend on how your employer set it up and what EDD decides when they review the claim. File and let EDD make the call.

0 coins

The Money Network card thing caught me off guard too. Had a Notice of Determination sitting there I didn't understand, so I used the same service to get an agent on the phone. She told me the notice had an Appeal Form attached and I had 30 days from the date on it to send it in if I disagreed. Filed the appeal the next day.

0 coins

Wait, so the appeal form comes with the denial notice itself? I think I may have thrown away an envelope without opening it, not sure. How do I find out if I missed the 30-day window?

0 coins

If you missed it you can still appeal but you'd need to explain why it was late. The administrative law judge looks at the reason. I'd pull up SDI Online and check what notices are there before assuming anything.

0 coins

Forty-nine days is the deadline that tripped me up when I filed my own disability claim years ago, and I nearly missed it. The rule your post is really asking about is different though: EDD decides whether employer-provided pay counts as wages that would affect your PFL, and that determination happens when you file. The two systems are separate in concept, but EDD still reviews what you received during the claim period. File the PFL bonding claim in SDI Online and answer the questions about other pay honestly. EDD makes the call, not your employer and not you.

0 coins

Thank you, filing honestly is what I planned to do. Do I put the full amount my employer paid me, or just note that I received full pay? I don't want to fill it out wrong.

0 coins

Report whatever the application asks for. If it asks whether you received wages or compensation during the period, say yes and put the amount. EDD uses that to figure out what, if anything, is payable.

0 coins

My cousin went through something kind of similar and was so stressed about this exact part of the form. She just answered everything honestly and EDD sorted it out. It took a couple weeks but she got a determination letter.

0 coins

There's a distinction worth noting here between your disability portion and the bonding portion. The pregnancy disability part runs through SDI as a Disability Insurance claim, and bonding after that is a separate Paid Family Leave claim. They're both under the SDI umbrella but they're filed separately and have different rules. Your DI claim closing out is normal. The PFL bonding claim is what you file now, and EDD evaluates it on its own. The question of whether your employer's full pay affects it is genuinely something EDD decides based on how that pay was categorized.

0 coins

Okay that actually helps a lot. So the DI piece closing is not the problem, the PFL piece is what I'm worried about. How do I file the PFL bonding claim, is it through the same SDI Online portal?

0 coins

Yes, same place. Log into myEDD, go into SDI Online, and you'll file a new PFL claim from there. It's a separate form from the DI one you already did.

0 coins

Yep, myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ is where everything lives. The PFL application is right there once you're in SDI Online.

0 coins

Tried that phone line six mornings in a row before my PFL claim got figured out. Six mornings. The line either rang endlessly or cut off. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr about the medical certification on my claim. The agent confirmed they had received the certification from my provider and that it was matched to my claim. That was the piece I couldn't get confirmed any other way.

0 coins

Six mornings and nothing? I've been at it four days myself, calling around 8am and getting cut off every single time. How does Claimyr even do that, it sounds too good to be true to me.

0 coins

I had the same doubt. What happened was I ended up talking to an actual EDD employee, not a recording, not a third party. The agent had my claim on her screen. That's all I can tell you.

0 coins

Had the same certification concern on my own claim. The agent I reached told me the form had come in from my provider and gave me the date it was received. That matched what my provider's office said they submitted, so I stopped worrying about it.

0 coins

Okay, the certification date is exactly what I need confirmed. Mine was submitted by my doctor's office but SDI Online just says pending and I have no idea if they got it. I'll give it a try.

0 coins

Employer paying you full salary during leave doesn't automatically block your PFL claim. It depends on whether that employer pay was run as a supplement on top of SDI or whether EDD considers it wages for the same days. That's EDD's call when they review. File, answer everything straight, and wait for the determination.

0 coins

Mine was just regular payroll, not labeled as a supplement or anything. My company didn't say anything about coordinating with SDI, they just kept paying me my full salary. Does that change how EDD looks at it?

0 coins

Might. EDD reviews what you got and decides. That's why the honest answer on the form matters.

0 coins

The base period question also comes into play. The benefit amount EDD calculates uses the highest-paid quarter in a 12-month base period from about 5 to 18 months before your claim start date. Regular salary during leave doesn't necessarily show up in that period anyway. The Notice of Computation EDD sends will show the exact quarter they used.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window is the number that matters if you get a denial. Not 60, not 45. If EDD sends a Notice of Determination that says the claim isn't payable, the Appeal Form comes with it and you send it back within 30 days of the date on that notice. A late appeal can still be reviewed but you have to explain why it was late.

0 coins

Good to know. So if they deny the PFL bonding claim I have 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal?

0 coins

Correct. Date on the notice, not the date you receive it. Open it the day it arrives.

0 coins

Learned that the hard way on a different claim. Date on the notice is what counts.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period, which is one less thing to stress about! With the DI pregnancy claim there's the unpaid seven-day waiting period at the start, but when you move into the PFL bonding claim right after, there's no waiting period on that one. So your bonding benefits can start right from the day after your DI claim ends if everything is approved!

0 coins

Wait, so the seven-day waiting period is only on the DI side, not on PFL? I thought the waiting period applied to everything under SDI. That's actually a relief if true.

0 coins

Correct! EDD is clear about it. PFL does not have a benefit waiting period. The waiting period is only for Disability Insurance claims.

0 coins

That's right and it's worth knowing before you plan your leave. The first seven days of a DI claim are non-payable. PFL bonding has no such requirement.

0 coins

my company paid me too when i had my kid and i still filed pfl after, edd didnt deny mine but i also wasnt getting both at the same time. the pregnancy disability ended then i filed pfl bonding right after so the timelines didnt overlap

0 coins

That's what I was hoping to hear. Were you paid by your employer during the DI part, the PFL part, or both?

0 coins

just during the disability part, company policy stopped paying after 6 weeks so by the time i filed pfl bonding i wasnt getting employer pay anymore

0 coins

That overlap is probably the key detail. If the employer pay stopped before the PFL bonding period started, there's nothing to coordinate. The question is trickier when both are running at the same time.

0 coins

File the claim, report what you received accurately, and let EDD make the determination. If they deny it, appeal within 30 days. That's the whole path.

0 coins

Short and to the point, appreciate that. Just filing and being honest is really the only thing in my control right now.

0 coins

Exactly. Overthinking the outcome before EDD decides doesn't help. Get the application in first.

0 coins

SDI Online is straightforward for the PFL bonding claim if you have your information ready. You'll need the baby's birth date, your last day of work before leave, your employer's information, and your claim receipt number if you're continuing from a DI claim. The application walks you through it.

0 coins

Do I need the receipt number from the DI claim specifically, or is there a new one generated for PFL?

0 coins

PFL bonding is filed as a new claim so it gets its own receipt number. Having your DI information nearby doesn't hurt in case the application asks about it, but it's a separate process.

0 coins

The SDI Online interface links the two in your account history but they are distinct claim IDs. You'll see both once the PFL claim is submitted.

0 coins

Is PFL bonding the same as the SDI claim or is it a totally different thing? I keep seeing people say SDI and PFL like theyre the same program but my HR said something different and now im confused.

0 coins

Both programs fall under the SDI umbrella in California, but they are separate benefits. Disability Insurance pays when you can't work due to your own health condition. Paid Family Leave pays for bonding with a new child or caring for a seriously ill family member. Same SDI Online system, different claims with different rules.

0 coins

Okay so HR was right that theyre different but theyre both in the same portal. Got it, that clears it up.

0 coins

And importantly, PFL is not for your own medical condition. If you're still unable to work after the baby, that stays a DI claim. PFL bonding is for when you're medically cleared but want that bonding time.

0 coins

The waiting period was the thing I could not figure out on my own claim until I talked to an EDD agent through Claimyr. The agent looked at my claim and told me the waiting period had already been served during my first week of disability, so the first payable day was day eight. I had been counting from the wrong date entirely.

0 coins

What exactly is Claimyr? Haven't heard of it.

0 coins

It waits on EDD's line in your place and your phone rings when a live agent picks up. That's basically the whole thing.

0 coins

Hm. The question I'd need answered is which quarter they used in my base period, because the Notice of Computation I got shows an amount that seems lower than I expected. Might be worth trying.

0 coins

been trying that disability line since tuesday, four calls, all cut off before anyone picks up. if this actually works i'd use it just to talk to a person once

0 coins

Eight weeks for a C-section is the typical certification period, right? My sister had one and her doctor certified eight weeks and that's what EDD went with. For a vaginal birth it's typically six weeks. Just wanted to throw that in since the DI pregnancy part closes based on what the provider certified.

0 coins

Mine was a vaginal birth and my provider certified six weeks, which is exactly what DI covered. So now I'm past that and it's the bonding piece I want.

0 coins

Then you're right on track. Six weeks DI, then PFL bonding after. You've got the sequence right, just need EDD to process it.

0 coins

The provider can certify beyond the typical period if there are complications. That goes through the same SDI claim with an extension form from the doctor, not a new DI claim.

0 coins

EDD sends the Notice of Computation once the claim is set up. Seeing it doesn't mean you're approved. It just shows the potential weekly amount they calculated from your base period wages. Approval comes separately.

0 coins

Used Claimyr to ask which quarter of the base period EDD used on my own claim, because the amount on my Notice of Computation seemed off. The agent told me they'd used the highest-paid quarter of the four in my base period and gave me the exact quarter. Turned out one of my quarters had a low-wage month that dragged it down and the other quarter really was the highest. The number on the notice was right.

0 coins

Got the same kind of Notice of Computation confusion on my bonding claim. Used Claimyr too and was glad I did. The agent confirmed the receipt number was matched to my claim and the certification was showing as received on their end.

0 coins

Wait, did EDD give you the exact dates for which quarter they pulled? I've been staring at my own notice wondering how they arrived at the weekly amount.

0 coins

The agent told me the quarter and the year it was from. I went back and looked at my pay from that period and it matched what I expected once I added it up.

0 coins

If EDD denies the PFL claim does that show up in SDI Online or only by mail? I'm scared of missing a notice and then missing the appeal window.

0 coins

EDD mails the Notice of Determination to the address on your account. It also shows in SDI Online. Check both so you don't miss it, and remember the 30-day window runs from the date printed on the notice.

0 coins

Okay checking my address in myEDD right now. I moved a few months ago and I'm not sure I updated it.

0 coins

Address updates are in your myEDD profile. Do that before you file the PFL claim so the notice goes to the right place.

0 coins

Filing while still unsure of the outcome is the right move. EDD can't review a claim that hasn't been filed, and waiting doesn't protect you, it just shortens the window you have.

0 coins

That's what I keep telling myself. Waiting feels safer but it doesn't actually do anything.

0 coins

Exactly. File, report everything accurately, and you'll know where you stand once EDD sends the determination.

0 coins

The at-least-300-dollar SDI wage requirement in the base period is the floor for eligibility. If your wages in that 12-month period had any quarters where you weren't earning much, it's worth checking your Notice of Computation carefully to make sure the right quarter was used. If you think the wrong period was pulled, that's something to raise with EDD.

0 coins

I've been working full time for three years at the same company so I'm not worried about the wage floor. But I hadn't thought about which quarter they'd use for the amount.

0 coins

Full time for three years, you're almost certainly fine on eligibility. The quarter selection matters more for the weekly benefit amount than for eligibility itself. The calculator on EDD's site can give you an estimate before you see the actual Notice of Computation.

0 coins

The benefit calculator is listed under the Disability Insurance section on edd.ca.gov. Worth running the numbers before the notice arrives so you have something to compare it against.

0 coins

been off since the birth and employer pay stopped at week four, so now im trying to get pfl going and the whole process feels really slow. pending for 10 days now on the bonding claim.

0 coins

Ten days pending on a PFL claim is not unusual. EDD says most payments go out within two weeks after they receive a properly completed claim. If you filed recently and the medical certification is in, you may just be in that window.

0 coins

the certification came from the midwife, hopefully that counts

0 coins

A licensed midwife is on EDD's list of who can certify a claim. You should be fine.

0 coins

Something people miss: reporting going back to work part time while on PFL is just as important as reporting it on a DI claim. You report it to EDD and they determine how a partial week is paid. Don't assume it doesn't matter because PFL is bonding and not medical.

0 coins

didnt know that applied to pfl bonding too, thought it was only the disability side where you had to report hours

0 coins

Applies to both. If you're working any hours during a PFL week, report it.

0 coins

My coworker got an overpayment notice because she went back part time and didn't report it right away. EDD caught it and sent the notice. Not worth the headache.

0 coins

The SDI Online message option is worth using if you can't get through by phone. In myEDD, open SDI Online, pick your claim, choose Request Claim Update, pick the request type and write your question. It's not instant but it creates a record of what you asked.

0 coins

Is there a way to ask specifically about whether the employer pay will affect my PFL eligibility through that message option?

0 coins

You can write whatever your question is. Whether they give a specific answer before they process the claim is another matter, but it's worth asking.

0 coins

Ask EDD, EDD's online contact form, is another option alongside the SDI Online message. For something as specific as how employer pay was categorized, a written question with details attached gives EDD something to respond to.

0 coins

Update from me: filed the PFL bonding claim yesterday through SDI Online. Answered all the questions about the employer pay honestly and noted the full amount and dates. Now just waiting for EDD to send something. No notice yet, still shows pending. I'll post again when I hear anything.

0 coins

That's the right move. Pending is normal at this stage.

0 coins

Fingers crossed for you. The waiting is the hardest part honestly.

0 coins

Watch your mail and your SDI Online account. When the determination comes, read the date on it immediately and act within 30 days if anything is wrong.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure