Back to California Disability

Tobias Lancaster

Can SDI use alternate base period if wages not current period — my claim got way less than I expected

So I've been out for about six weeks after a pretty rough back injury and I finally got my Notice of Computation in the mail. The weekly amount on there is way lower than what I expected and I think I know why. I was between jobs for about five months before this happened, so the base period they used is pulling from wages when I was barely working. I've heard there's something called an alternate base period that SDI can use if your regular base period wages are low, but I honestly don't know if that's automatic or if I have to request it, or even if the alternate one would actually use my more recent earnings. Has anyone dealt with this? My current paystub has a lot more hours on it than whatever quarter they calculated from and I don't understand why they wouldn't just use my most recent wages.

Waiting period question tripped me up too when my benefit amount came out lower than I expected. Ended up reaching EDD by phone through Claimyr (claimyr.com) and asked the agent about my waiting period dates. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent confirmed my claim start date and which day my waiting period actually ended, so I knew exactly when my first payable day was.

0 coins

When you got through to the agent, did they look up your base period details too or just the waiting period?

0 coins

Just the waiting period on that call. I had my claim ID ready and they pulled it right up. The base period question I had to put through SDI Online separately.

0 coins

four mornings i've tried that line. rings twice then the whole thing drops. been at this since week two of my claim.

0 coins

The alternate base period is real but it isn't automatic. If your regular base period pulls from a time when your wages were low, you can ask EDD to look at an alternate base period that uses more recent quarters. Check the Notice of Computation first to see which quarter they used, then compare it to what you actually earned in a later quarter.

0 coins

So I have to actually ask them to switch it? It won't happen on its own if the alternate would give me more?

0 coins

Correct. You have to contact EDD and ask them to review it. They don't automatically apply whichever is higher.

0 coins

wait so people are just getting less than they should because nobody told them to ask? that seems like a big thing to leave out of the paperwork

0 coins

The base period is typically the 12 months ending about five months before your claim start date, broken into four quarters, and they use the highest-earning one to calculate your weekly amount. So if you were between jobs during that window, yeah, that explains a low Notice of Computation. The alternate base period can shift that window to capture more recent wages.

0 coins

That five-month gap before the claim start date is exactly the problem. I was barely working during that whole stretch.

0 coins

Makes sense then. Your more recent higher-earning quarters might fall inside the alternate base period window. Worth asking EDD to run both calculations so you can compare.

0 coins

EDD's disability calculator on their site can give you a rough idea before you even call.

0 coins

The 12-month base period uses four specific quarters and the highest-paid one sets your weekly benefit amount. If $300 or more in SDI-taxed wages shows up in that period, the claim is valid, but the amount might still be low. The alternate base period shifts the whole window forward to include wages closer to when you stopped working.

0 coins

Mine definitely had over $300, the number just came out low because those quarters were part time.

0 coins

Right, the $300 threshold just establishes eligibility. The actual weekly amount depends on what you earned in the highest quarter, so a part-time stretch pulls that number down hard.

0 coins

This whole base period thing really catches people off guard when they were between full-time jobs.

0 coins

Went through this after I had a wrist thing that kept me out of the salon for two months. My Notice of Computation looked nothing like what I thought I'd get because I had a slow stretch the year before. Nobody mentioned the alternate base period until a coworker brought it up. EDD is not super upfront about it.

0 coins

Did you end up getting them to recalculate yours?

0 coins

I did! Called and asked them to look at the alternate period and they did. My amount went up. Took a bit of back and forth but it was worth asking.

0 coins

Good to know asking actually works. I assumed once the Notice of Computation was out that was the final number.

0 coins

If your recent wages are higher than what that base period shows, ask EDD to look at the alternate. Have your pay stubs or any documentation of recent earnings ready when you call or message them through SDI Online.

0 coins

does it matter what kind of work, like gig stuff vs w2

0 coins

If SDI taxes were coming out of those gig payments they should count. If they weren't, they won't. Check your stubs for the CASDI line.

0 coins

yeah the CASDI deduction is the one that matters for this

0 coins

We dealt with something like this for my wife's claim after our second kid. Her maternity leave wages from the job before that weren't showing up right in the base period window. EDD has the calculator on their site, worth running your numbers through it before you call, anyway.

0 coins

Is the calculator on the main edd.ca.gov site? I want to try running my numbers before I do anything else.

0 coins

Yeah edd.ca.gov, look for the disability benefits calculator. Plug in what you actually earned per quarter and it'll estimate what you should be getting.

0 coins

Running the numbers first is a good move so you go into the call knowing exactly what you're asking for.

0 coins

The quarter they used to set my benefit amount didn't look right to me either, so I phoned EDD. Got through to an agent using Claimyr and they confirmed which quarter of my base period was actually used. Turned out they had pulled from a quarter where I had taken unpaid leave for a family situation, not my best-earning quarter. The agent walked me through what the alternate base period would look like on my file.

0 coins

I need to ask about which quarter they used on my claim because my Notice of Computation looks off too. Going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the Notice of Computation in front of you. The agent pulled everything up fast once I had those.

0 coins

The base period quarter question seems like exactly the thing you need a live person for because SDI Online doesn't really spell out which quarter they chose.

0 coins

My sister went through something similar after a surgery. Her wages in the standard base period were from when she worked part time at a second job, not her main income. She ended up requesting the alternate base period review and it made a real difference in her weekly amount.

0 coins

How long did it take for them to adjust the amount after she requested it?

0 coins

Honestly I'm not sure of the exact timeline. She said it took a bit and she had to stay on top of it. I'd check with EDD directly for your situation.

0 coins

Always better to hear it from EDD than go off someone else's timeline.

0 coins

Spent two weeks assuming the number on my Notice of Computation was locked in. It's not locked in. Asked EDD. They looked. Mine was fine in the end but I didn't know I could ask until I actually talked to someone.

0 coins

Two weeks of just accepting a low number is exactly what I'd do. Good to know it's not final until you actually push on it.

0 coins

Yeah, the notice doesn't exactly say 'you can dispute this calculation.' You kind of have to know to ask.

0 coins

The alternate base period thing is genuinely one of those SDI rules that more people should know about! If your regular base period window falls during a gap in employment or a part-time stretch, it's not automatically your best option.

0 coins

edd should just check both and use the better one automatically tbh

0 coins

Right? But they don't, so the ask has to come from you. Worth it though!

0 coins

Agree. The person has to know enough to request it, which is a lot to ask when you're already dealing with being out of work.

0 coins

THREE WEEKS trying to get through on that phone line. No exaggeration. Either the hold music cuts out after twenty minutes or I get a recording that just ends the call. Meanwhile my claim is sitting there with a weekly amount that makes no sense based on what I earned this year.

0 coins

That line is brutal. Best I could do was keep trying different mornings.

0 coins

I've tried Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday. Nothing. It's not a 'right time of day' problem for me anymore.

0 coins

same situation here. been trying mornings for two weeks and get the same recording every time

0 coins

There's also an earnings threshold to be eligible at all. At least $300 in SDI-taxed wages has to show up in the base period, standard or alternate. If neither period clears that, the claim won't be payable. But if you're asking about a low amount rather than a denial, you've already cleared the threshold and it's just a calculation question.

0 coins

Mine was approved, the number just seemed low. So I think I cleared it, just not with great wages in those quarters.

0 coins

Then you're in the right place asking about the alternate base period. The threshold isn't the issue, the quarter selection is.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation should actually tell you the quarter they used, worth reading it closely before you call.

0 coins

Payment method on my claim had an issue that was holding things up, so I phoned EDD. Used Claimyr and got through to someone. Agent checked my account and confirmed the payment was set to go to the Money Network card but my address on file was outdated, which was causing a delay. Had it corrected on the spot.

0 coins

Address on the Money Network card being wrong is exactly what happened to me. Used Claimyr too after I saw my payment date pass with nothing showing. Agent confirmed the date the payment was issued and that the card just hadn't been activated. Sorted it out that day.

0 coins

I didn't even know address issues could hold up the card. Been trying that phone line most mornings this week and getting nowhere.

0 coins

The card activation step is easy to miss. Took me longer than I'd like to admit to figure out mine hadn't gone through yet.

0 coins

If I'm reading this right, my wages from the last few months before my injury might not even be in the standard base period at all because of that five-month gap in the calculation? So I basically need to either contact EDD about the alternate or just accept the lower amount?

0 coins

That's about right. The standard base period ends several months before your claim start, so very recent wages often fall outside it. The alternate base period can bring those in. Contact EDD and ask them to review it.

0 coins

Okay so just asking them to 'review for alternate base period' is enough to get the ball rolling?

0 coins

Yes. Tell them your claim ID and explain that your recent wages were higher than what the standard base period captured. They'll look at both windows.

0 coins

The SDI Online message system through myEDD is another way to ask about the base period without waiting on hold. Go into your claim, pick Request Claim Update, and write out the question. It's not instant but it's logged and someone has to respond.

0 coins

I didn't know you could message them directly through myEDD. That might be easier than trying to get through by phone.

0 coins

It's under Request Claim Update once you open the claim. Worth trying if the phone line keeps dropping on you.

0 coins

Used that for a question about my wife's claim. Took a few days but they did respond, anyway.

0 coins

my CASDI deduction shows on every check from my current job but wasnt on the checks from the temp agency i worked before. does that mean those temp wages dont count at all

0 coins

If CASDI wasn't deducted from those temp agency checks, those wages likely don't count toward the SDI base period calculation. The deduction is what ties wages into the SDI system.

0 coins

ugh so my two months at the temp place are basically invisible to edd

0 coins

For SDI purposes, yes. Only the wages with the CASDI deduction would factor into either base period.

0 coins

Medical certification for my current claim got filed by the wrong provider initially, so I called EDD. Went through Claimyr and got an agent. They confirmed EDD hadn't received a certification under my claim ID yet and told me which receipt number to give the correct provider so they could match it. Got the certification filed that same week.

0 coins

That exact thing almost derailed my claim too. Called EDD four mornings straight and either got a busy signal or the line just ended. Never got a person. How did you end up getting through?

0 coins

Tried Claimyr. It handled the hold time and my phone rang when an agent picked up. The whole call was straightforward once I got through.

0 coins

Agent confirming the receipt number mismatch is exactly the kind of thing you can't sort out without talking to someone. Good that you got it fixed fast.

0 coins

Does anyone know if requesting the alternate base period can mess with your claim in any way? Like delay a payment or flag something? I want to tell a friend to ask but I don't want it to cause problems.

0 coins

Asking EDD to review the alternate base period shouldn't hold up an existing payment. It's a calculation review, not a new claim. That said, check with EDD directly for your friend's specific situation.

0 coins

Makes sense to ask EDD before worrying about it. The worst case is they look and say the standard base period is already the better one.

0 coins

Okay good, I'll pass that along. She's nervous about touching anything on the claim while payments are going.

0 coins

Quick check for anyone reading this thread: if your Notice of Computation amount seems off, compare the quarter listed on the notice to what you actually earned in your most recent quarters before the claim. If recent quarters are higher, the alternate base period conversation with EDD is worth having!

0 coins

This is basically exactly my situation. The notice quarter and my recent quarters are really far apart in terms of earnings. Definitely going to contact EDD about this.

0 coins

Good luck! Use SDI Online messaging or the phone line, either works. The calculator on EDD's site is a good sanity check first.

0 coins

Useful summary. Notice of Computation quarter versus actual recent earnings is the thing to compare.

0 coins

Bottom line: if the notice shows a low amount and you have recent higher wages, ask EDD to check the alternate base period. Don't sit on it. The longer you wait the longer you're at the lower amount.

0 coins

Heard. Going to reach out today. I've been waiting on this too long already.

0 coins

Good. Have your Notice of Computation and your recent pay stubs ready when you do.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure