Can I just create a new account on myEDD if my SDI Online login is completely broken?
Okay so I'm losing my mind a little here. I had a disability claim going through SDI Online and somewhere between my doctor submitting the medical certification and me trying to log back in to check the status, my myEDD account stopped working. It's not a password thing — I went through the whole reset flow twice and it just loops me back to the login page. I've been out of work since my back procedure about three weeks ago and I have zero visibility into whether EDD has even matched my medical cert to my claim. My question is literally in the title: can I just create a new account with a different email and start fresh? I don't want to lose whatever is attached to my old account but I also can't just sit here not knowing if my claim is processing. Has anyone done this or know if it would mess things up?
69 comments

JaylinCharles
Creating a second myEDD account to get around the broken one is not really how the system works. Your SDI claim is tied to your Social Security number on EDD's end, not to the email you used to log in. If you open a fresh account with a different email, you'd be starting with a blank dashboard — your existing claim doesn't follow the new login. The fix is getting the original account unlocked, not making a new one.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorThat makes sense — so the claim itself lives on EDD's side and the account is just a window into it. I figured there had to be a catch with the new account idea. Any idea how long the account unlock process actually takes through EDD's tech support?
0 coins
JaylinCharles
No good answer on timing, unfortunately. The SDI phone line (1-800-480-3287) can sometimes verify your identity and push things along faster than the online help flow, in my experience. Tech support tickets can sit for a while.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
Agreed that a second account won't pull up the existing claim. The SSN link is exactly why EDD can still find your file even if your login is a mess — but you do need to get that account issue resolved before you can certify or see payment details in SDI Online.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
Notice of Computation came in my mail around week two of my claim and I hadn't even been able to log in to SDI Online yet because of a similar account issue. I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent on the disability line. The agent pulled up my claim and told me which quarter of my wages they used for the benefit calculation and what my weekly amount was before I could even see it online myself. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Getting that figure directly from the agent at least let me know the claim was moving.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorWait, the Notice of Computation actually came by mail automatically? I've been staring at the broken login like that was my only option. I should check my actual mailbox more carefully. Did the agent confirm anything about whether the medical cert had been received, or just the computation side?
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
The agent only confirmed what was in the computation — the base period quarter they used and the weekly amount. For the medical cert status I had to get the account fixed to see that screen. But knowing the amount was settled stopped the worst of my guessing.
0 coins
Freya Collins
The Notice of Computation doesn't mean the claim is approved, just so nobody goes down that road. It's just EDD telling you what your potential weekly benefit would be if you're found eligible. The actual payable decision comes separately.
0 coins
LongPeri
Went through almost this exact login loop after my wrist surgery. The thing that finally worked for me was going through the identity verification step again from scratch rather than just the password reset. There's a difference between resetting your password and re-verifying your identity, and the loop you're describing sounds more like the second problem.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorI haven't tried the identity re-verification separately — I assumed the password reset covered everything. Going to try that tonight.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
The identity verification piece catches a lot of people. If the system flagged something during your original login that didn't resolve cleanly, the password loop just goes in circles because the underlying issue is the identity hold, not the credentials themselves.
0 coins
LongPeri
Exactly. Fixing the credential won't help if the identity layer is what's stuck. The re-verification path is different and usually faster once you find it in the account settings.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
Three weeks out from your procedure without being able to confirm the medical cert was received sounds genuinely stressful. For what it's worth, your doctor's office can confirm on their end whether the submission went through in SDI Online — they get a confirmation when it posts. That's worth a quick call to the office to settle at least that part while you sort out your login.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorThe office confirmed they submitted it but couldn't tell me whether EDD had matched it to my claim on their side, which is the part I actually need to know.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
That's the distinction — the office seeing a submitted confirmation is their system; EDD actually matching it to your claim receipt number is EDD's side. Those two steps don't always sync instantly, which is part of why the receipt number your doctor uses matters so much.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
My doctor's office submitted with the wrong receipt number the first time and EDD couldn't match the cert. Had to have them resubmit. Would double check that the number they used matches exactly what SDI Online gave you when you filed.
0 coins
Liv Park
I had the same panic about losing claim data if I touched the account. What reassured me was realizing that EDD's records of my claim, the dates, the certifications, the payment history, all sit on EDD's servers, not inside my myEDD login. The login is basically just an ID badge that gets you to the door. Breaking the badge doesn't erase what's behind the door.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorThat framing actually helps a lot. I've been treating the broken login like the broken claim, and they're two separate things.
0 coins
Liv Park
Right, and it's why calling the disability line directly is worth doing even when the online account is broken. The agent can see your claim's actual status without you needing the portal.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
Came here to say the same thing. My claim kept processing normally for weeks while my SDI Online access was messed up. The payments came through fine. The portal problem was a portal problem, not a claim problem.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Does a new myEDD account actually let you file a brand new claim though? I always wondered if EDD detects the SSN and links the two accounts anyway. Not that it's the right move, just curious how the system handles it.
0 coins
JaylinCharles
EDD's system would tie any new claim to your SSN on their backend regardless of which login email you used. So you'd end up with two accounts pointing to the same person, which creates its own mess — including potential flags when you try to certify or receive payments.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Yeah that sounds like a situation that makes everything worse. The original account fix is clearly the cleaner path.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
The phone line at 1-800-480-3287 is the fastest resolution for the account loop in my experience. Calling in lets an EDD rep confirm your identity verbally and sometimes they can flag the account issue on their end to push you back through to tech support with a note. It's not a guaranteed same-day fix but it moves faster than a plain help ticket.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorHas anyone had luck calling in the morning versus later in the day? I've tried twice around noon and gotten a busy signal both times.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
My only successful call was pretty early, before 9 a.m. Pacific, but that's just my own two tries. No guarantee on what works for someone else.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
EDD's disability line hours are 8 to 5 Pacific, Monday through Friday. The phones tend to be jammed right when they open and during lunch. That's all I know from my own experience — your mileage may vary on actual wait times.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
My claim had a weird gap where two weeks showed pending for longer than expected and I couldn't tell if EDD had paid them or skipped them. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the disability line and she told me exactly which weeks had been paid out and which one was still sitting. Turned out one week was held because I'd returned to work part time for a few days and EDD was waiting on how to calculate the partial payment. The agent walked me through what I'd need to report to get it resolved.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorThat part time partial payment calculation is something I hadn't thought about. Good to know you can get that level of detail directly from an agent.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
The agent was pretty specific — she named the actual weeks and amounts. Didn't have to guess at any of it once I had her on the line.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
The partial week pay situation trips a lot of people up. Going back to work even one or two days during a claim week is something you're supposed to report to EDD, and how they calculate what's payable for that week is their call.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
My sister told me to just make a new account when she had problems and EDD sorted it out fine — but I'm realizing from this thread that might have just been coincidence rather than the right move. Did anything bad actually happen to anyone here who tried the second account route?
0 coins
JaylinCharles
The person above who explained the SSN link covers the main risk — two accounts tied to the same SSN can create a flag on the payments side. It doesn't necessarily mean disaster, but it's an extra complication you don't want when you're already waiting on a pending claim.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
Fair enough. The 'just try it' approach makes me nervous for someone actually depending on those payments right now.
0 coins
Raúl Mora
For the account loop specifically: if you filed on paper with the DE 2501 instead of through SDI Online, the online portal issue is basically irrelevant to your claim moving forward — paper claims process on EDD's end without any need for you to log in. But it sounds like you filed online, which means you do need that login working to certify continuing eligibility down the line.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorYeah, definitely filed online. And I know I'll need the portal access for the ongoing certifications, so getting it fixed is non-negotiable. Just feels urgent since I can't confirm anything right now.
0 coins
Raúl Mora
For the certification cadence: EDD sends the Disability Claim Continued Eligibility Questionnaire, the DE 2593, after a certain stretch on the claim. Missing that return window costs you benefits. So you're right that the login fix can't just wait indefinitely.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
Had a coworker go through the duplicate account thing and EDD eventually merged the records but it took weeks of back and forth. Not worth the hassle when the account unlock is a one-time fix. Keep the original account and get it unlocked.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorWeeks of back and forth sounds like a nightmare on top of an already slow process. Sticking with the original account for sure.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
The worst part for her was that she couldn't tell which account EDD was actually pulling from when she called in, so every call required re-verifying which record they were looking at. It delayed her Notice of Computation arriving in a usable form.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
I'll add one point about the medical cert matching problem the person above mentioned: if EDD can't match the certification to your claim because of a receipt number issue, that's something worth calling in about rather than waiting to see if it resolves. EDD won't always flag it to you — the claim just sits. I called in a while back when my claim was about to end and I needed to file for more time. Ended up walking through the extension process with the agent and she confirmed the DE 2525XX had come through from my provider and was being processed.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorHow did you end up reaching an agent? I've had two busy signals and I'm starting to feel like the phone line is basically inaccessible.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
Claimyr handled the hold time for me on that extension call — the agent I ended up talking to was EDD's own. Had a specific answer within the same call about where the DE 2525XX stood. That wait problem is real but it's not permanent.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
The extension being a separate form from the original claim is something a lot of people don't realize. The DE 2525XX has to come from the provider, not from the claimant. You can't just call and ask EDD to extend it yourself.
0 coins
Freya Collins
To get back to the actual question — nobody should touch the new account option in this situation. The right path is: get the existing myEDD account unlocked through EDD's tech support or the phone line, confirm with your doctor's office that they used the correct receipt number on the medical certification, and then check the actual mail for a Notice of Computation or any other EDD correspondence while the online issue gets fixed. Those three things together give you the most complete picture of where the claim actually is.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorOkay. Receipt number check with the doctor's office is first on the list tomorrow. And I'll go through the identity re-verification path rather than just the password reset tonight. The mailbox was apparently already giving me information I was ignoring.
0 coins
Freya Collins
Once you're back in the account and can confirm the cert is matched, the pending status should start moving pretty quickly. After EDD gets both the claimant's statement and the medical certification, most payments are issued within a couple of weeks.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
The two-week window the person above mentions is after EDD receives a fully completed claim — both parts in and matched. If the cert is in but unmatched, the clock on that window hasn't really started yet.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
Something nobody should do is file an entirely new DI claim thinking it replaces the broken account. I've seen that confusion go sideways — the new claim has its own seven-day waiting period from scratch, which means another week of benefits lost. Your existing claim already ate that waiting period. Keep the original claim, fix the login, don't file new.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorI hadn't even considered filing a whole new claim, but good to call that out explicitly. So the seven-day waiting period is per claim, not a one-time thing for the account?
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
Every new claim starts a fresh seven-day waiting period that EDD doesn't pay. It's not a processing delay — it's a built-in non-payable stretch. Your current claim is past that window, which is worth protecting.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
I thought the waiting period was just while EDD reviewed things. Had no idea it was actually non-payable days baked into every claim. That changes how I'd think about whether to file anything new.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
The SDI Online message feature is worth using even when the portal is acting strange. If you can get in far enough to reach the Request Claim Update screen, pick the right request type and write out your question, that creates a record of your inquiry. Not as fast as a phone call but it documents your attempt, which matters if anything is disputed later.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorI haven't been able to get past the login screen at all, so the message feature is locked out for me right now. But I'll keep it in mind once the account is fixed.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
Once you're back in, that path is: open SDI Online from myEDD, pick the claim ID, then Request Claim Update. The request type options cover most of the common questions about pending status and certification receipt.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
Had a moment of panic when I thought I'd have to restart my whole claim from zero because of a login problem. The EDD phone rep I eventually reached confirmed the claim was completely intact — she could see every date and certification on her end. The portal being broken on my side didn't affect any of it.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorHearing that the claim data was fully intact on EDD's side is exactly the reassurance I needed. The login feels catastrophic but it sounds like it really is just the login.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
That's the right read. Your claim's dates, the medical cert, whatever EDD has received — none of that lives in your browser session. The session just lets you see it.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
Employer notification is a separate thing from the SDI claim itself, worth flagging. Some employers have their own short-term disability or leave plans that run alongside an SDI claim, and they may need you to file paperwork with them directly. EDD doesn't handle that side — your HR department does. If your employer has that kind of plan, the login problem doesn't affect your EDD claim, but you don't want to miss your employer's separate deadline either.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorMy employer does have a leave policy but I handled that paperwork the first week. Good reminder though — I'd assumed EDD and my employer were somehow coordinated on this.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
EDD and your employer are not coordinated. Each is completely separate. EDD decides the SDI side based on wages and the medical certification, and your employer manages their own leave policy on their own timeline. The good news is fixing your EDD login doesn't require your employer to do anything.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
If the identity verification path in the account settings doesn't clear the loop, Ask EDD — EDD's online contact form — is an option for account access issues that doesn't require you to log in first. You'd be submitting from outside the portal, which is exactly the workaround for a login that won't open.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorAsk EDD works without being logged in? I assumed it was only for people who could already access their account.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
You can reach it from EDD's site without logging in — it's a general contact form. It's not instant, but for a login-related problem it creates a ticket on EDD's end that someone has to address.
0 coins
LongPeri
Ask EDD and the SDI phone line are the two reasonable escalation paths when the portal itself is the problem. Phone tends to be faster if you can get through; Ask EDD is more reliable for creating a paper trail.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
The whole thing of your doctor submitting the cert but you not knowing if it was matched sounds like the most stressful part of this. The mismatch isn't always obvious from either side. Your doctor's office sees 'submitted.' EDD sees 'received but unmatched.' You see nothing because you can't log in. Three separate systems all saying different things.
0 coins
Brianna Muhammad
AuthorThat is exactly the disconnect I've been experiencing. Everyone involved seems to think something is fine but I can't get a unified view of the full picture.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
The receipt number is the link that connects all three systems. If your doctor submitted with the right one, the match should be there on EDD's end. If not, the cert is floating unattached somewhere. That one number is worth confirming even before the login issue is resolved.
0 coins
Freya Collins
Confirming the receipt number with the doctor's office is free and takes about five minutes. It's genuinely the highest-leverage thing to check while everything else is in progress.
0 coins