Back to California Disability

Michael Adams

Can I get unemployment if my job is gone after SDI leave

So my doctor cleared me to go back last week and I went to contact my employer and basically found out the position was eliminated while I was out on SDI. No warning, no letter, just gone. I'm still kind of in shock honestly. I've got bills stacking up and I need to know, can I get unemployment if my job is gone after SDI leave? I don't even know which way to turn first. Do I file for UI right away or does something else happen first? Anyone been through this?

Yeah the short answer is you can file for unemployment once you're cleared to work and actually available. The key thing EDD cares about is whether you're able and available to work every week you're claiming UI. While you were still on disability you couldn't claim UI because you weren't available, but the day your doctor says you're good to go, that's when unemployment can start. File as soon as possible because they don't pay you for weeks before you filed.

0 coins

So I don't have to wait for anything from EDD to close out my SDI claim first? I can just go file UI now?

0 coins

File UI now. Don't wait around. The SDI side wraps up on its own, it doesn't hold up your UI filing.

0 coins

Does that mean the last day of SDI and the first day of UI can be right next to each other, like no gap? I'm in a similar boat and terrified of ending up with nothing in between.

0 coins

EDD's own language on this is that you can't receive both for the same days. So your last SDI day and your first UI day would just line up with no overlap, not a gap you lose money on.

0 coins

DE 2525XX came back denied for my extension request, so I had to figure out what was actually in EDD's system about my claim. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the line with an EDD disability agent. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed the DE 2525XX was received but the physician's signature field was flagged, so it hadn't been processed. Video on getting a live EDD disability agent: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. My doctor's office resubmitted it the same day after I passed that along to them.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I've never heard of it before.

0 coins

You phone EDD and it handles the hold time for you, your phone rings when an EDD agent picks up. What would you need to ask them about?

0 coins

My situation is an extension too, the DE 2525XX. I sent mine in over three weeks ago and SDI Online just still says pending. That's exactly the kind of thing I'd want to ask about.

0 coins

The signature thing is a killer. My doctor's office did the same thing on my first claim years back. Had to get them to redo the whole form.

0 coins

There is one thing worth knowing about the able-and-available question. When I went through something similar after knee surgery, I assumed I could file UI for the weeks I was on light duty restrictions before my doctor fully cleared me. EDD considered me not fully available during that time. The rule is you have to be ready to do your regular or customary work, not just some modified version of it, to claim unemployment benefits each week.

0 coins

My doctor cleared me with no restrictions at all, full release. So that part I should be okay on.

0 coins

A full release with no restrictions puts you in a good position for that piece of it.

0 coins

Wait, does that mean if my doctor clears me for light duty only I still can't file UI? That's what I have right now and I was going to file next week.

0 coins

EDD's standard is able and available to do your usual work each week you claim UI. Light-duty-only might complicate that if your usual job is physically demanding. Worth asking EDD directly about your specific situation rather than guessing.

0 coins

Employer eliminated the position while you were out. That's going to come up in the UI claim. EDD will ask why you're no longer working, and 'position eliminated' is a layoff, which is exactly what UI covers. Not your fault, not a quit.

0 coins

Good, because I was worried they'd treat it like I quit or something since I wasn't there in person.

0 coins

You didn't quit. You were on approved disability leave and came back to no job. That's a layoff.

0 coins

Same thing happened to a guy on my crew. Filed UI, got it. EDD classified it as a layoff, no fight about it.

0 coins

wait can they even do that legally, eliminate your job while youre on sdi? doesnt that count as wrongful termination or something

0 coins

Whether there's job protection depends on things like CFRA or FMLA, which are separate from EDD entirely. For the CFRA question you'd want to look at the Civil Rights Department's resources. EDD decides the UI claim, not the job protection side.

0 coins

ok so for getting paid through ui that part is separate from whether the layoff was legal got it

0 coins

Exactly. EDD handles whether you get unemployment benefits. Any question about whether the job elimination was lawful goes somewhere else entirely, not through EDD.

0 coins

SDI Online showed my claim start date as a week later than my actual first day out, which would have meant losing seven days of potential benefits. Tried the EDD disability line for three mornings straight and got nothing past the hold music cutting out. Ended up using Claimyr to get to an agent and she confirmed the start date in the system and what week the claim actually opened at. Turned out there was a mismatch between the date on my Part A and what my doctor submitted.

0 coins

Claimyr worked perfectly for me too! The agent I reached confirmed my payment method had been updated to direct deposit, which I wasn't sure had gone through, and told me which account number EDD had on file. So relieved to have that confirmed!

0 coins

Did she say how long before it would actually hit the account?

0 coins

She said payment had already been issued that morning! So it was just a matter of the bank's processing after that.

0 coins

How did they fix the start date mismatch? Like did EDD change it or did the doctor have to refile something? Not sure how that works and I'm kind of scared I have the same issue.

0 coins

My doctor's office had to submit a corrected certification with the right first date. EDD couldn't just change it on their end without the provider confirming it, at least that's what the agent told me.

0 coins

File the UI claim and list the last day you received SDI benefits as your last day of work for those purposes. EDD will sort out the overlap question from there. The main thing you're establishing is that you're now ready to work and your job no longer exists.

0 coins

Is there a specific field in the UI filing for noting the SDI history or do I just explain in a text box?

0 coins

There's a section asking why you're no longer working. 'Laid off or position eliminated' is the right answer there. The SDI history comes up if EDD has questions, but you're not hiding it.

0 coins

The base period for UI is calculated differently than SDI. EDD looks at wages in a different set of quarters, so even if your highest earning period fed your SDI claim, your UI benefit amount could come out different. Check EDD's site for the UI benefit calculator once you file.

0 coins

Hadn't even thought about that. So the UI amount isn't based on the same thing my SDI was based on?

0 coins

Different base periods, different formulas. UI and SDI are calculated separately. Your Notice of Computation for UI will show you what they came up with once the claim is filed.

0 coins

The UI Notice of Computation is called something different than the SDI one but it works the same way in terms of showing you the benefit amount. Definitely look it over carefully when it comes.

0 coins

im in kind of a related situation but not the same. i was on SDI and my employer didnt eliminate the job, they offered me a different position that pays less. does that count as a job being gone? not sure if i can still file for the wage difference or something

0 coins

A lower-paying offer complicates things. Whether refusing it or accepting it affects a UI claim depends on a bunch of specifics EDD would have to look at, like how different the work is and the wage difference. That one's worth calling EDD about rather than relying on forum answers.

0 coins

yeah i figured it wasnt a simple yes or no. i'll ask EDD. thanks

0 coins

EDD is going to want specifics on that one. Document everything about the offer in writing before you do anything.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my SDI claim showed a weekly amount that seemed way lower than what I expected based on my hours. Spent a week trying to get through on the phone. Eventually got to an agent through Claimyr and she walked through which quarter of my wages they'd used for the base period. Turned out one quarter of my tips hadn't been reported by the salon owner correctly, so the wages in the system were lower than what I actually earned.

0 coins

Honestly I figured anything called Claimyr was just paid promotion scattered across forums. But after three weeks of that line cutting out at the same point every morning, I tried it and got to an agent in one shot. She checked my Notice of Determination and read me exactly what reason code was on it, so I finally knew what I was appealing.

0 coins

I had the same doubt at first, same thought actually. But the agent I reached told me which weeks on my claim were still showing pending and which had already been issued. After that I stopped second-guessing it.

0 coins

Fair enough. The Notice of Determination reason code actually let me write a real appeal instead of just saying 'I disagree.' Mailed it with the DE 1000A within the 30 days on the notice.

0 coins

Tips not being reported right sounds like a whole separate headache on top of the SDI claim.

0 coins

It really was. I had to get documentation from my own records to show what I actually earned. EDD said to have all of that ready before anything else could move.

0 coins

you cant get both SDI and UI at the same time right? just making sure i understand

0 coins

Not for the same days, no. EDD is clear about that. While you're unable to work and on disability, UI isn't an option because UI requires you to be able and available to work every week you're claiming it. The two pick up where each other leaves off.

0 coins

ok so its one then the other, not both running at same time. makes sense

0 coins

How long does it even take once you file UI? My buddy waited almost four weeks before he saw anything.

0 coins

UI processing times vary. EDD doesn't give a fixed date. File and check UI Online; that's really all you can do from your end.

0 coins

Four weeks sounds brutal when bills are already piling up from the SDI period.

0 coins

Yeah he was not having a good time. Eventually came through but those weeks were rough.

0 coins

What happens if EDD denies the UI claim because they think you voluntarily quit? Is there an appeal process?

0 coins

Any UI denial comes with a Notice of Determination that includes an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date on that notice to appeal. Send a detailed explanation of why you left or why you were separated, in writing, to the address on the form. A layoff due to position elimination is worth fighting if they get it wrong initially.

0 coins

Good to know there's a formal appeal path. I'd want to have my paperwork from the employer ready showing the position was eliminated before I even filed.

0 coins

Documentation of the layoff is exactly the right thing to gather before you need it. Anything in writing from the employer about the position being eliminated.

0 coins

Does PFL factor into any of this? I keep seeing people mention it and I'm not sure where it fits when someone's job has been eliminated.

0 coins

PFL is for bonding with a new child or caring for a seriously ill family member. It's a separate program from DI. If someone's situation was a pregnancy disability claim on SDI, they might move from SDI to a PFL bonding claim after recovery. But PFL doesn't replace UI if the job is gone. Those are different things.

0 coins

Oh okay so PFL isn't what you'd go to when the job disappears. Got it.

0 coins

PFL and UI can't run at the same time for the same days either, same as SDI and UI. Each one covers different circumstances.

0 coins

File UI and don't overthink it. You were laid off. That's what unemployment is there for.

0 coins

Yeah you're right. I've been spinning on it for days and I just need to go do it.

0 coins

Log into myEDD and file. The system walks you through it.

0 coins

Workers comp came up at my job when someone else was injured, and I always mix up which is which. Workers comp is for injuries at work, right? SDI is for stuff that happens off the job?

0 coins

Exactly right. Workers comp covers work-related injuries. SDI covers non-work-related illness, injury, pregnancy, childbirth. EDD itself says it's not common to get both at the same time, though there are some exceptions they handle case by case.

0 coins

That clears it up. The original question is definitely SDI territory since it sounds like the injury or condition wasn't work related.

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period on SDI trips everyone up at first. I assumed for the longest time it was just processing time and that I'd eventually get paid for those days once EDD caught up. Nope. That first week is just gone, no payment ever covers it. The eighth day is when benefits actually start.

0 coins

Wait, so those first seven days are never paid no matter what? I had no idea. I thought it would come through eventually.

0 coins

Never paid. It's not a processing lag, it's a built-in unpaid waiting period that is part of every new DI claim. PFL doesn't have one, but DI does.

0 coins

I read somewhere that the waiting period was eliminated at some point. Is that wrong?

0 coins

That's incorrect as it stands. EDD's current rules include a seven-day unpaid waiting period for DI claims. The first payable day is the eighth day of disability. Worth checking EDD's site directly if you want to confirm, but the waiting period is still in effect.

0 coins

does the sdi claim close automatically when you go back to work or do you have to do something

0 coins

You report returning to work through SDI Online. It doesn't just close automatically when you go back. Report it promptly so payments stop on the right date.

0 coins

ok so you actively tell them, got it. dont want an overpayment situation

0 coins

Overpayments are a real headache, report it the same week you go back.

0 coins

Has anyone had EDD try to say SDI payments affect the UI base period wages?

0 coins

SDI benefit payments themselves aren't wages, so they don't go into the UI wage calculation. What matters is your actual earned wages from your employer in the base period quarters, not the SDI benefit checks you received while out.

0 coins

That's what I figured but good to have it confirmed.

0 coins

Filed the UI claim this afternoon. Had to list the reason as position eliminated and noted the last day of my SDI certification as the last day attached to the job. The online system was pretty clear actually once I got into it. Now just waiting to see what comes back.

0 coins

Good. Now you check UI Online and wait. If anything comes back wrong, the DE 1000A is your friend.

0 coins

Glad you got it in. Keep any paperwork from the employer about the position being eliminated somewhere you can find it fast.

0 coins

Already photographed everything and put it in a folder. After going through SDI I learned pretty quick to keep records of everything.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure