Back to California Disability

Nora Bennett

Can I get disability after a workers comp settlement in California EDD?

Signed the settlement papers on my workers comp case about six weeks ago — shoulder injury from a warehouse job, took almost two years to resolve. The thing is, I'm still not fully recovered. My orthopedic surgeon says I can't go back to lifting and my old position doesn't exist anymore anyway. A coworker mentioned that once workers comp closes out, you might be able to file for California SDI if you're still unable to work. I honestly have no idea how that works or if the settlement changes anything. Has anyone actually been through this? Like, went from workers comp to filing a DI claim? I don't want to assume I can and then get denied after waiting weeks for a decision.

Went through almost exactly this after a back injury settlement two years ago. The key thing that tripped me up at first was not knowing that California EDD says it's not common to get workers comp and SDI paid at the same time — but once workers comp is fully closed and you're not receiving any workers comp payments anymore, the picture changes. The question becomes whether you still have a certified medical condition stopping you from doing your regular or customary work. If your surgeon will put that in writing through SDI Online, you've got the foundation for a DI claim. What you filed with workers comp has nothing to do with what EDD decides on disability.

0 coins

That's the part I keep going back and forth on — whether the settlement being done actually clears the way. My surgeon is still treating me and would likely certify, so at least that part seems possible.

0 coins

Workers comp closing out was the same trigger for me filing SDI. The two programs really are separate buckets even though the injury is the same injury.

0 coins

The SDI program is specifically for non-work-related illness or injury, which is where people get confused — your original injury happened at work, so it was workers comp territory. But EDD's own language on this is that the two don't usually overlap. It doesn't say you can never file SDI after workers comp ends. If you're still medically unable to work after the settlement closes out, you're not being paid workers comp anymore, and a licensed health professional certifies your disability through SDI Online, EDD will evaluate the DI claim on its own terms. File through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and have your doctor submit the medical certification with the receipt number you get when you file Part A.

0 coins

Okay so the receipt number goes to the doctor's office and they look up the claim on their end? I had no idea the process worked that way.

0 coins

Yep, your doctor needs that receipt number to find and submit the medical certification in SDI Online. Without it they're basically searching blind, make sure you pass it along the same day you file your part.

0 coins

Filing through myEDD is way smoother than the paper form. Got my receipt number on screen right after submitting and forwarded it to my doctor's office same afternoon.

0 coins

DE 2500E came in after my final workers comp payment cleared, and I had already filed my SDI claim by then. Payment date was what I couldn't get a straight answer on from SDI Online alone — the status just said pending with no payment shown. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to someone at EDD's disability line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent looked up my claim and told me the specific date my first payment had been issued and which weeks it covered, so I stopped panicking about whether anything had gone wrong.

0 coins

The pending limbo is what I'm most dreading. Good to know there's a way to get an actual date out of them.

0 coins

Pending with no payment date showing is so stressful when bills don't stop. At least you got a real answer from the agent.

0 coins

Had the same pending situation after my claim went in. The status screen tells you almost nothing useful while you're waiting.

0 coins

There's a timing thing worth flagging here. After you file Part A in SDI Online, EDD needs the medical certification from your provider, and after they have both, EDD typically contacts you about the claim's status within 14 days. The first seven days of your claim are a non-payable waiting period — that's not EDD processing slowly, that's literally a built-in unpaid period before any benefits start. A lot of people coming off workers comp don't realize this and think their claim is stuck when it's actually just in that first week. First payable day is day eight of the disability period.

0 coins

Nobody told me about the seven-day thing. So even if everything goes perfectly, the first week just doesn't pay at all?

0 coins

Exactly. It's baked into the law, not a glitch. PFL actually doesn't have that waiting period, which confuses people, but DI claims always have the first seven days as non-payable.

0 coins

Spent two weeks convinced my claim was broken before my coworker explained the waiting period to me. EDD doesn't make it obvious anywhere during the filing process.

0 coins

My physical therapist tried to submit my medical certification and it got rejected — apparently they're not on EDD's list of providers who can certify a DI claim. Wasted almost a week before my actual physician filed it. For anyone reading this after a workers comp settlement: your workers comp doc might be a different type of provider than what SDI accepts. EDD's list includes licensed physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, and a few others. Physical therapists are not on it. Double check before your provider spends time trying to submit.

0 coins

My ortho is an MD so I should be fine, but that's a really good thing to check. I could easily have assumed any treating provider would work.

0 coins

Physical therapist certification not being accepted is a common trip-up. The workers comp world and the SDI world have different rules about who counts as a certifying provider.

0 coins

Learned this the same way — my PT was willing to do it but couldn't. Had to go back to my orthopedist to get it done right.

0 coins

After workers comp ends and you're filing SDI, make sure you're not also filing for unemployment at the same time. Can't collect both SDI and unemployment for the same days — EDD is explicit about that. If you're medically unable to work you're a DI claimant, not an unemployment claimant, because unemployment requires you to be able and available for work every week. Some people coming off workers comp settlements try to run both simultaneously and that creates overpayment problems down the road.

0 coins

Hadn't even thought about unemployment because I know I still can't work. But yeah I could see how someone might think they qualify for both.

0 coins

The able and available to work requirement for unemployment is what disqualifies most people who are still out on a medical condition. DI is the right program if your doctor is still keeping you out.

0 coins

Made the mistake of filing unemployment while waiting to hear on my DI claim because I thought I could switch later. Got flagged for overlapping dates and had to sort it out with EDD. File the right one first.

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up in my mail about ten weeks into my DI claim and I nearly missed the 20-day return window because I didn't know what it was. That's the Disability Claim Continued Eligibility Questionnaire EDD sends after your fifth automatic payment. You have to return it within 20 days or benefits stop. My claim was already complicated because I'd come off a workers comp settlement and I wanted to make sure EDD actually had it, so I ended up phoning the disability line. Claimyr got me to a live agent — the agent confirmed the form had been received and told me which weeks were still pending on my claim. Filed the questionnaire on time and payments continued.

0 coins

20-day window is tight if the form gets lost in a pile of mail. Setting a reminder to watch for it around week ten.

0 coins

DE 2593 caught me completely by surprise too. The transition from automatic payments to that questionnaire is not explained clearly anywhere during the initial filing.

0 coins

Ten weeks in is roughly when a lot of people start to relax and stop watching their mail carefully. That's exactly when the form shows up.

0 coins

EDD also sends a DE 2500A every two weeks if you're not on automatic payment — that's a different form, the Claim for Continued Disability Benefits. The DE 2593 is only for people who have automatic payments set up.

0 coins

Workers comp settlements sometimes include a provision about future medical treatment — worth reading yours carefully to know if there are any restrictions on how your injury gets documented going forward. That's not really an EDD question, more of a legal one, but how your ongoing treatment gets characterized can affect what your doctor puts in the medical certification. Not saying it disqualifies you, just that it's worth a conversation with whoever handled your workers comp case before you file SDI.

0 coins

My attorney actually flagged something similar before the settlement closed. He said make sure the settlement language doesn't limit future treatment because I'd still need ongoing care.

0 coins

Settlement language is its own world and varies a lot. For the SDI filing itself, what matters is whether your provider can honestly certify that you can't do your regular work right now. The rest is between you and your workers comp attorney.

0 coins

Tried calling EDD's disability line three separate mornings in a row after my claim went pending and either got a busy signal or sat on hold until the line disconnected. Eventually sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online — went to myEDD, opened SDI Online, picked the claim, and found that option. Got a written response in a few days confirming my medical certification had been received. Not as fast as talking to a person but it at least answered the specific question I had.

0 coins

Good to know the Request Claim Update option exists. I had no idea you could send a specific question that way inside SDI Online.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update feature is underused. Most people don't find it because the interface isn't obvious, but it does work and creates a paper trail.

0 coins

Sent one about my medical certification matching question and got a response within 72 hours. Way less stressful than trying to get through on the phone.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation is what EDD sends once they've figured out your potential weekly benefit amount. It doesn't mean you're approved — a lot of people assume getting the notice means the claim is good to go. It just shows the weekly and maximum amounts EDD calculated from your wages in the base period. Your actual eligibility gets decided separately. If the claim isn't payable, you'd get a Notice of Determination instead, which comes with an appeal form. Keep the appeal deadline in mind: 30 days from the date on the notice, not from when you receive it.

0 coins

Okay that's an important distinction. I would have assumed the Notice of Computation was essentially an approval letter.

0 coins

So many people think the Notice of Computation means they're in the clear. It's really just EDD showing their math on the wage calculation, not a decision on whether you can receive benefits.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice for an appeal is strict. Got caught almost missing it because I counted from when it arrived in my mailbox.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in on my claim after EDD initially said I wasn't eligible — the reason given didn't match my actual situation at all. Called EDD's disability line, 1-800-480-3287, and couldn't get through after a week of trying. Claimyr got me to an agent at that number who pulled up my claim and read me exactly what the Notice of Determination said and what the specific disqualification reason was. Appealed using the DE 1000A with a detailed explanation of why the determination was wrong, sent it to the address on the notice. Waiting on the ALJ hearing now.

0 coins

Knowing the exact disqualification reason before writing the appeal makes a huge difference. Flying blind on an appeal sounds like a nightmare.

0 coins

DE 1000A is the appeal form that comes with the Notice of Determination. If yours gets lost, a detailed letter sent to the return address on the notice works as a substitute — just include all the specifics about why you disagree.

0 coins

Appeals take longer than anyone warns you about. The 30-day filing window is firm though, so get the form in even if you need more time to build out the full argument.

0 coins

EDD calculates your weekly benefit amount from your highest-paid quarter in a 12-month base period that ends about five months before your claim starts. The tricky part coming off workers comp is figuring out what wages even show up in that base period — if you were off work for a long stretch during your workers comp case, your reportable wages might be lower than you expect, which would lower the DI benefit amount. Use the disability benefits calculator on EDD's site to run an estimate before you file, and then your actual Notice of Computation will show the real number.

0 coins

This is something I completely hadn't thought about. I was barely working during the workers comp case so my wages in that window are probably not great.

0 coins

Lower wages in the base period is a real issue for people coming off long workers comp claims. The benefit amount still needs to be based on at least $300 in SDI-covered wages in the base period to qualify at all — worth running the estimate first so you're not surprised.

0 coins

EDD's calculator is pretty easy to use if you have your pay stubs or W-2s from that period. Runs the estimate in a couple of minutes.

0 coins

Something that helped me understand the SDI versus PFL split: SDI disability insurance is for your own medical condition stopping you from working. PFL, Paid Family Leave, is a totally different claim — it's for bonding with a new child or caring for a seriously ill family member. They're funded the same way through that CASDI deduction on your paycheck, but they're completely separate programs with separate claims. Coming off workers comp you'd be looking at DI, not PFL, but I've seen people mix them up here constantly.

0 coins

Had to look up what CASDI even was on my pay stub. Didn't realize I'd been contributing to SDI the whole time I was working.

0 coins

The CASDI deduction going to both programs through the same contribution confuses everyone at first. Your paystub doesn't break out DI versus PFL, it's just the one line item.

0 coins

Filed within 49 days of when my disability started — almost missed that window because I was still dealing with workers comp paperwork at the same time and lost track of the SDI calendar. EDD won't take a late-filed claim without good cause, so if you're still in that window, file the Part A now and sort out the medical certification details after. Getting the claim in preserves your start date.

0 coins

49 days is the cutoff to file and also for the doctor to get the certification in? Or is that two separate deadlines?

0 coins

Two separate but related deadlines. You file your part within 49 days of the disability start date, and your provider also has 49 days from that start date to get the medical certification in. The form receipt number you get when you file is what your doctor uses to find the claim.

0 coins

Filing Part A immediately when you're within that window is always the right call. Nothing locks in until the medical certification follows, but you need Part A submitted first to get that receipt number to your provider.

0 coins

Payment method threw me — expected an EDD debit card and was confused when a Money Network prepaid card showed up instead. That's the current card EDD uses for disability payments, not Bank of America anymore. Direct deposit is an option too if you file through SDI Online; you set it up during the claim. Just something to know so you don't panic when an unfamiliar card arrives in the mail.

0 coins

Glad you said that. I would have definitely questioned a Money Network card and potentially delayed activating it thinking it was a mistake.

0 coins

EDD switched from the Bank of America card a while back. The Money Network card looks different but it works the same way — activate it when it arrives or set up direct deposit ahead of time through SDI Online.

0 coins

EDD at minimum needs at least $300 in SDI-covered wages during the base period to establish a valid DI claim. If your time off during the workers comp case left you under that in the relevant quarters, you'd want to know before filing rather than wait for a denial. That said, workers comp settlements sometimes involve back wages or settlements that may have been reported differently — that's something worth asking EDD directly about your own case rather than assuming either way.

0 coins

My workers comp settlement had a wage component but I'm not sure how it was reported for tax or SDI purposes. Definitely need to ask EDD about that.

0 coins

Wage reporting questions like that are genuinely case-specific. EDD's SDI Online has the Request Claim Update option, or Ask EDD on their site works for general questions before you even file.

0 coins

Went back to work part time after my DI claim was approved — ortho cleared me for light duties only. Had to report those hours to EDD. Didn't know exactly how EDD would calculate the partial week, and the SDI Online status didn't explain it. Phoned EDD to ask and the agent just said to report accurately and EDD would determine the benefit for that period. Keep that in mind if your surgeon eventually clears you for some light work before you're fully released: reporting is required, and what you get paid for a partial week is EDD's call.

0 coins

Partial return to work is probably months away for me but it's good to know what that looks like. I'll make sure to report rather than guess.

0 coins

Reporting partial work accurately protects you from an overpayment notice later. Had a coworker who didn't report a couple of light-duty days and ended up with an overpayment demand she had to appeal.

0 coins

Overpayment appeals follow the same process as eligibility appeals — 30 days from the date on the overpayment notice, DE 1000A, and a detailed explanation. Better to avoid it by reporting correctly from the start.

0 coins

The 52-week cap on DI benefits is worth knowing about upfront. California SDI pays for a maximum of 52 weeks on a single disability claim. If your injury is severe enough that you need more than a year, you'd exhaust DI before you're recovered, and you'd have to look at other options at that point. For most people it's not an issue, but coming off a workers comp settlement with a serious injury it's something to have on your radar from the beginning.

0 coins

52 weeks is actually more than I was expecting. My surgeon's recovery estimate is under a year so hopefully I won't hit the cap.

0 coins

Extensions within the 52 weeks work through your doctor submitting a DE 2525XX, the Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate. EDD sends that form with the notice of your final scheduled payment. Your doctor doesn't file a whole new claim, they add to the existing one — up to that 52-week ceiling.

0 coins

If the medical recovery genuinely extends past the SDI limit, that becomes a conversation with your doctor and possibly your attorney about what programs or options exist at that point. SDI's ceiling is what it is.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure