< Back to California Disability

Joshua Hellan

Can I get UI benefits after doctor refused to extend my SDI claim for IBS while on ADA leave?

Feeling stuck in a catch-22 situation here... My employer denied my ADA accommodation request for my IBS condition and placed me on continuous Leave of Absence until late March 2025 when they'll reassess. They told me to have my doctor extend my SDI claim until then, but my doctor REFUSED saying that IBS isn't severe enough to warrant disability leave from work! She basically said I should be able to work despite my symptoms (easy for her to say when she's not running to the bathroom 10+ times during meetings). Now I'm in this weird limbo - can't work because my employer won't accommodate me, but can't get SDI because my doctor won't certify. Would I qualify for unemployment insurance in this situation? Has anyone dealt with something similar? I'm freaking out about paying my mortgage next month!

Jibriel Kohn

•

sounds like ur doc is being a jerk tbh. IBS can be super serious!! but ya UI probably wont work cuz u have to be able & available to work to qualify

0 coins

Joshua Hellan

•

That's what I was worried about. But technically I AM available to work - just with accommodations that my employer won't provide! This is so frustrating.

0 coins

This is a complex situation that crosses between disability law and benefits. Here's what you need to understand: 1. For UI, you generally must be able and available for work without restrictions, which might be problematic given your IBS condition. 2. Since your doctor won't extend SDI, you could try getting a second medical opinion from another doctor who better understands how IBS impacts your specific work situation. 3. Your ADA situation is separate from your benefits situation. If your employer is denying reasonable accommodations for a legitimate medical condition, you might have an ADA claim worth pursuing. In the meantime, I suggest appealing your doctor's decision. Request a formal letter explaining why she's denying certification, then take that to a second opinion. Document everything.

0 coins

My cousin had similar problem with rheumatoid arthritis! Her first doctor wouldn't extend SDI but second one did. Worth trying new doctor.

0 coins

James Johnson

•

Unfortunately UI probably won't work in your situation. To qualify for unemployment, you need to be able to work, available for work, and actively seeking work without restrictions. Since your employer has documentation that you requested accommodations due to a medical condition, EDD would likely determine you're not eligible for UI. Your best options are: 1. Appeal to your doctor or seek a second opinion 2. File a complaint with DFEH about the ADA accommodation denial 3. Contact the Patient Advocate at your healthcare provider The gap between disability and unemployment benefits is a real problem in California's system. Many people fall into this exact situation.

0 coins

This is EXACTLY why I hate the EDD system so much!!! You need the doctor to cooperate but they have NO IDEA how bad these conditions actually affect daily work. And then when they won't help you're just supposed to what??? Starve? Go homeless? The whole system is broken!!!

0 coins

Mia Green

•

have you tried calling EDD directly to ask them? thats what i would do tbh

0 coins

Emma Bianchi

•

Good luck with that! I tried calling EDD about my disability claim for 3 weeks straight and couldn't get through. Busy signals, disconnects, or 3+ hour wait times that ended with being hung up on. Complete nightmare.

0 coins

James Johnson

•

One more thing to consider - if your employer has already approved a continuous Leave of Absence, ask if it's a paid leave or if you qualify for any company-provided disability benefits. Some employers offer short-term disability programs separate from state SDI. Also, double check if you qualify for FMLA/CFRA protection during this leave period. While these don't provide income, they protect your job while you sort this out. Regarding your doctor - be very specific about how your IBS impacts your job functions. Many doctors don't understand how symptoms translate to workplace limitations. Bring documentation of your specific job duties and explain exactly how your symptoms prevent you from performing them without accommodation.

0 coins

Joshua Hellan

•

Thank you so much for this detailed advice. My LOA is unfortunately unpaid, and I've already used all my FMLA time earlier this year when my symptoms were at their worst. I'm going to try your suggestion about being more specific with my doctor about how IBS affects my specific job duties. I work in customer service where bathroom breaks are timed and limited, which is impossible with my condition.

0 coins

My sister had kinda the same thing happen but with migraines. She found out you can appeal the doctor's decision not to certify for SDI! You need to fill out the DE 2501 form yourself (Claim for Disability Insurance Benefits) and submit it along with other medical documentation. Then when EDD asks your doctor to verify, if they say no, you request a review. Worth trying at least!

0 coins

Jibriel Kohn

•

omg thats actually rly helpful i didnt kno u could do that! did it work for ur sister??

0 coins

Joshua Hellan

•

UPDATE: I spoke with an EDD representative today (thanks for the Claimyr tip - it actually worked!). They confirmed that I likely won't qualify for UI since my work restrictions would limit my ability to accept suitable employment. They suggested I either appeal my doctor's decision on SDI or file for State Disability with a different doctor who better understands my condition. I have an appointment with a gastroenterologist next week for a second opinion. Fingers crossed they'll understand how debilitating IBS can actually be in a customer service environment where bathroom access is restricted!

0 coins

That's great progress! Make sure to bring documentation to your gastroenterologist about your specific job requirements and how IBS impacts those specific duties. A specialist will likely have a much better understanding of how IBS can be disabling in certain work environments. Best of luck!

0 coins

Samantha Howard

•

Good call on getting a specialist involved! Gastroenterologists definitely understand IBS severity better than primary care docs. When you go to your appointment, I'd suggest keeping a detailed symptom diary for the week leading up to it - track frequency, urgency, pain levels, and specifically how it would interfere with work tasks. Also mention if you've tried any medications or dietary changes that haven't helped. The more documentation you have showing this isn't just "manageable stomach issues," the better your case will be. Really hoping this works out for you - customer service with IBS sounds absolutely brutal with those bathroom restrictions!

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today