Back to California Disability

Anita George

Can I get SDI while working light duty part time after surgery

So I had a pretty significant back surgery about three weeks ago and my surgeon cleared me for light duty starting next week, maybe 15 or 20 hours a week at a desk job my employer is offering temporarily. My normal job is physical, loading and unloading, so I can't go back to that yet. I've been on SDI since the surgery and payments have been coming through fine. What I can't figure out is whether SDI keeps paying me for the hours I'm not working, or does the whole claim just stop the moment I go back in any capacity? I reported to my employer that I'm cleared for light duty but I haven't told EDD yet because I genuinely don't know what happens next. Do I need to call them? Update something in SDI Online? I don't want to mess up my claim or end up with an overpayment notice later.

Payment method on my claim was showing wrong after I filed, card vs direct deposit, and I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to sort it. The agent confirmed the deposit election hadn't saved and walked me through what to submit to fix it. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. What you're asking about, light duty and partial weeks, that's something you have to report to EDD. How much of your wages they offset against the SDI is EDD's call, but you do have to report it.

0 coins

My extension form is sitting unacknowledged in SDI Online and I want to ask an agent whether it was received. Plan to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I get on with someone?

0 coins

Claim ID, your receipt number from when you filed, and the name of the form you submitted. Agent can tell you whether it shows in the system.

0 coins

Good to know you can at least find out if the form landed. I've tried that line four mornings straight and got the busy tone every time.

0 coins

The question to put to EDD is exactly what your weekly wages will be for those partial weeks, because that's what they use to figure out what's payable. You're right not to just stop reporting, because going back in any capacity, even reduced hours, affects the weekly benefit. EDD calculates partial week payments based on what you earn versus what your weekly benefit amount is, and they decide the formula. The important thing is that you report those earnings when you certify; don't sit on it.

0 coins

So I keep certifying every two weeks and just put in what I actually earned those weeks? I wasn't sure if the whole claim got closed out the moment I stepped foot back in.

0 coins

Certifying with actual earnings is exactly right. The claim doesn't automatically close when you return part time. It closes when you're back to full duty or your doctor releases you fully, whichever EDD recognizes.

0 coins

Does that mean the waiting period I already served at the start stays served, or does a new one start because I went back even part time? I'm panicking a little about this.

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period is at the beginning of the original claim and you've already served it. No new waiting period starts because you're doing partial weeks on the same claim.

0 coins

EDD's line is a nightmare, I spent most of a Tuesday last month on hold and it just cut me off. If you have a simple question about partial wages, try the Request Claim Update inside SDI Online first. It's not fast but at least it doesn't hang up on you.

0 coins

I've been hesitant to use that because I worry it just goes into a void. Did yours actually get a response?

0 coins

Took about a week but yes, an actual answer. Not the fastest but it worked for a basic question.

0 coins

Same. Used it once about a form. Got a response, just slow.

0 coins

Wait, I thought once you go back to work at all, even light duty, SDI stops paying entirely? My sister told me you lose the whole benefit the minute you're employed again. Is that actually true?

0 coins

That's not how it works. Going back part time while still unable to do your regular job doesn't end the claim automatically. You report your earnings and EDD pays for what you can't yet do. Full duty is a different situation.

0 coins

Oh thank goodness. I've been dreading going back for a few hours because I thought I'd lose everything. That changes things a lot.

0 coins

Your sister probably had a different situation, or maybe she was on a different type of benefit. It's a really common mix-up.

0 coins

The piece worth pinning down before you go back is what 'regular or customary work' means for your claim. EDD's standard is whether you can do the job you normally do, not whether you can do any job at all. So if loading and unloading is your regular work and you can't do that yet, the basis for your claim is still there even during light duty. That's exactly what your doctor's certification should reflect.

0 coins

This is the part that tripped me up on a past claim. My employer said 'you're cleared for desk work' and I assumed EDD would view that as fully back. They didn't, because desk work wasn't my regular job.

0 coins

Right, and the medical certification is what backs that up with EDD. If your doctor says you can't yet perform your regular duties, that's the documented reason the claim continues.

0 coins

So keep the doctor in the loop on exactly what the light duty is and make sure they're certifying based on the actual job, not just 'this person can sit at a desk'.

0 coins

The medical certification side tripped me up when I was out after my procedure last spring. SDI Online showed my claim sitting there with no update, so I tried Claimyr to reach someone. The agent pulled up my claim and said the certification my provider sent was under a slightly different name than my account, which was why it was stuck. Got that fixed and the claim moved.

0 coins

The mismatched name thing happened on my claim too, and I've used Claimyr as well. Once I got an agent and they confirmed the certification was matched up, I asked about the Notice of Determination I'd received because I didn't understand why my benefit amount looked lower than expected. The agent explained what the notice showed and told me I had 30 days from the date on it to appeal if I disagreed with the amount.

0 coins

30 days goes fast tbh. i almost missed mine just because i thought id have more time

0 coins

The name mismatch thing is so avoidable if you give the receipt number to the provider's office directly. That way they're pulling your exact claim, not searching by name.

0 coins

Reminder to myself to triple-check that my surgeon's office has the right receipt number. I do not want a name mismatch holding things up when I'm already dealing with the partial week question.

0 coins

Report your earnings every single week you work any hours. Don't wait until the end of a pay period or bunch it together. EDD expects it week by week when you certify, and anything you don't report on time is what creates overpayment problems later.

0 coins

By 'every week' do you mean I switch from the two-week certification cycle to something weekly? Or is two weeks still the cycle and I just enter each week's hours separately within it?

0 coins

Two-week cycle stays the same. You enter each week's earnings for each week within that period. Keep your pay stubs for every partial week so your numbers match.

0 coins

Paycheck records matter a lot here. Dates, gross amounts, hours. If there's ever a discrepancy with what EDD has, you want your paperwork to be exact.

0 coins

Your employer offering you that temporary desk position is actually pretty considerate. Some of my clients who've been out have come back to nothing, no modified duty, no accommodation at all. Take the light duty if it helps financially, just make sure EDD knows what you're earning.

0 coins

Yeah, my employer has been decent about it. I just want to make sure I'm not accidentally blowing up the SDI claim by going back in any capacity.

0 coins

You won't, as long as you report it. The mistake people make is not reporting and then getting hit with an overpayment notice six months later.

0 coins

Had a coworker deal with an overpayment from not reporting a part-time week. It was a whole ordeal.

0 coins

I'm not sure about this but doesn't light duty count as being able to work, and doesn't that mean EDD would say you don't qualify for disability anymore? I think the rule is you have to be totally unable to work to get SDI. Not sure though.

0 coins

The standard isn't total inability to work, it's inability to perform your regular or customary work. Someone doing a modified desk assignment while unable to lift is still unable to do their regular job, which is what the claim covers.

0 coins

Okay that makes a lot more sense. I was worried about this same thing for my own situation. Knowing it's about your actual job and not just any job is a big deal.

0 coins

This comes up constantly and the phrasing really matters. 'Regular or customary work' is what EDD is looking at, not 'any work imaginable'.

0 coins

you have to tell edd you went back even if its just a few hours. they find out from your employer anyway so just report it yourself, way less hassle

0 coins

Makes sense. I'd rather over-communicate than deal with an overpayment down the line.

0 coins

exactly. overpayments are brutal to deal with. just report it

0 coins

EDD has seen every version of partial return to work. Report what you earn, let your doctor's certification speak to what you can't do yet. The system handles it, slowly.

0 coins

' Slowly is doing a lot of work in thatsentence.

0 coins

It always is.

0 coins

at least it handles it at all i guess

0 coins

For the weeks you're working partial hours, write down the start date, end date, gross wages, and hours worked for each week before you certify. EDD's weekly earnings question is based on gross, not net, and having the numbers in front of you prevents mistakes.

0 coins

Gross not net, okay that's one I would have gotten wrong. I've been thinking in take-home terms.

0 coins

Almost everyone thinks net at first. Gross wages are what SDI uses, so pull the number before taxes come out.

0 coins

Writing this down right now. Gross, per week, with dates. Got it.

0 coins

My waiting period question was something I honestly got confused on with this service. Tried Claimyr to reach someone because SDI Online wasn't showing what I expected. The agent confirmed my seven-day waiting period ran from my actual disability start date, not from when my doctor's certification came in, and that cleared up why the first payable week looked the way it did on my notice.

0 coins

Tried that line six different mornings across two weeks and got the busy signal or a disconnection every single time, so I'm doubtful anything gets through. What actually happened when you dialed in?

0 coins

I ended up talking to an actual EDD disability agent. She pulled up my claim right there and confirmed the start date and which week the waiting period covered. That was it.

0 coins

Waiting period starting from the disability date, not the certification date, is a mix-up I see a lot. The certification can come in days later and it doesn't shift the clock.

0 coins

Alright. My own claim start date is something I've been unsure about because I had a gap between my injury and when I stopped working. Might have to try reaching someone to get that confirmed on my specific claim.

0 coins

If your employer is classifying the light duty weeks on payroll differently than your regular wages, like a different pay code or a different rate, make note of that too. EDD will be looking at wages earned in those weeks, and you want what you report to match what your employer records.

0 coins

The light duty rate is actually lower than my regular rate, which I didn't expect. So my gross for those weeks will be less than usual.

0 coins

That's actually fairly common for modified assignments. Keep the stubs for those weeks specifically, because the amount matters to how EDD calculates the partial week benefit.

0 coins

The rate difference surprised me too when I went back modified after my procedure. Had no idea desk-rate would be less than floor-rate on the same payroll.

0 coins

The base period question on my own claim was something I needed confirmed. Called EDD using Claimyr and an agent told me exactly which quarter of my wages they used to calculate the benefit, and what the weekly amount came out to based on what was in my highest-paid quarter. Knowing that number helped me plan the partial-week math.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned here.

0 coins

You run your phone through it and it handles waiting on EDD's line, then you get the agent on the other end. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Okay. The question I'd want answered is whether my claim start date is correct, because I filed a few days after my surgery and I'm not sure if EDD used the surgery date or the filing date. That's the thing I'd bring to them.

0 coins

Filing date vs disability start date is worth getting straight. Mine were five days apart and it mattered for which week the waiting period started.

0 coins

One thing that helps with partial weeks is keeping a simple log, even just a note on your phone, day by day while you're on light duty. Date, hours, gross pay. Certification day comes around and you have everything right there.

0 coins

I already started a notes doc for this. Way better than trying to reconstruct it from memory two weeks later.

0 coins

Exactly. Future you will thank present you.

0 coins

wish i had done this. reconstructed mine from texts to my manager and it was not fun

0 coins

Worth double checking whether your surgeon's certification actually covers the partial return scenario. Some providers just write 'return to light duty' without specifying that you're still restricted from your regular work. If EDD reads it as a full release, that's a problem.

0 coins

This is a good flag. I'll ask the surgeon's office to make sure the certification notes the specific restrictions, not just a blanket light duty release.

0 coins

Ask them to be specific about what you can't do, loading, lifting, the physical parts of your normal job. Vague certifications cause delays.

0 coins

Exactly right. The more specific the clinical restrictions on the certification, the cleaner the claim. 'Unable to lift over ten pounds' beats 'modified duty only' every time.

0 coins

If EDD sends you the DE 2593 during your partial return period, fill it out and return it within 20 days or benefits stop. That form asks if you're still unable to work your regular job, and your answer should be accurate to what your doctor has certified.

0 coins

What is the DE 2593? I don't think I've seen that one yet.

0 coins

After a certain number of automatic payments EDD sends it to check if you're still eligible. It's a continued eligibility questionnaire. Miss the deadline and they cut the payments off.

0 coins

20 days from when EDD sends it, not when you receive it. Open any mail from EDD the day it arrives and act on it.

0 coins

Something worth noting for anyone reading this: if your doctor needs to extend the claim beyond the original certification period, that's a separate form the doctor submits, the DE 2525XX. You don't file a new claim. EDD typically sends it out with the final payment notification, but it's worth confirming with your doctor's office that they know how to find and submit it.

0 coins

Good to know. My current certification runs another five weeks, but if the surgeon decides I need longer off full duty, I didn't know there was a form for that. I'll mention it at my next appointment.

0 coins

My doctor had no idea what the DE 2525XX was when I asked. Had to look it up myself and send them the instructions.

0 coins

It's unfortunately common for smaller practices to be unfamiliar with EDD's extension process. Bringing it up proactively at the appointment saves time.

0 coins

The partial return to work situation actually resolved better than I expected on my own claim last year. EDD applied the offset correctly, the SDI kept paying for the weeks I was still restricted, and it didn't drag out. Just report everything and let EDD do the math.

0 coins

This is genuinely reassuring to hear. I've been dreading this transition but it sounds like as long as I report accurately and my doctor's certification is specific, it should work the way it's supposed to.

0 coins

That's really the whole formula. Accurate reporting, specific certification, and don't ignore anything EDD mails you.

0 coins

Agreed. The times it goes sideways are almost always when someone forgot to report a week or let a form sit too long.

0 coins

Your surgeon's office should also confirm they submitted the medical certification under your exact SDI Online account information and used the receipt number you gave them. Mismatches between the provider record and your claim are one of the most common reasons a partial-return claim stalls.

0 coins

I gave them the receipt number when I first filed. I'll follow up to make sure they still have it on file and used it.

0 coins

Good. If they filed it without the receipt number, there's a chance it's floating unmatched. Easy fix once you confirm.

0 coins

At some point your surgeon will release you for full duty and the claim ends. Until then, every partial week is reportable and EDD handles the rest. That's the whole process, as undramatic as it sounds.

0 coins

Honestly I appreciate the undramatic take. I've been treating this like a minefield when maybe it's just a form and some math.

0 coins

It mostly is. The minefield version usually involves someone not reporting something.

0 coins

^^^ this. the drama is almost always from not reporting

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure