Back to California Disability

DeShawn Washington

California EDD sent SDI benefit amount letter but I never applied eligible

So something really confusing happened and I'm hoping someone can help me make sense of it. Got a letter in the mail from EDD last week that shows a weekly benefit amount and it looks like a Notice of Computation for a disability claim. The thing is, I never filed for SDI. I didn't even know I could file, honestly. I've been out of work recovering from a back procedure for about three weeks now and my HR told me to just use my sick days. Now this letter shows up with a dollar amount on it and I don't know if someone filed on my behalf, if it's some kind of error, or if maybe my employer did something? I've never touched SDI Online and I definitely didn't submit any claimant's statement. Has anyone gotten a notice like this when they didn't start the claim themselves? Should I call EDD? I'm worried this is either a mistake or something worse like identity fraud on my account.

A Notice of Computation by itself doesn't mean a claim has been fully processed or approved. It shows what the potential weekly amount would be if a claim were active. The question worth asking EDD directly is whether there is an actual claim filed under your name and Social Security number, because if there is one you didn't start, that's something they need to know about right away.

0 coins

Is there a way to check in SDI Online without calling? I set up a myEDD account just now but I'm not sure what I'm looking at.

0 coins

Log into myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and open SDI Online from there. If a claim shows under your name that you didn't file, write down the claim ID and contact EDD the same day.

0 coins

Okay I can see something in there. There's a claim ID and it shows a start date. I genuinely did not create this.

0 coins

Weeks marked paid on a claim you never opened, that's exactly the kind of thing worth getting a live person about. SDI Online showed two weeks as paid on what I thought was just a pending notice, so I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the phone, and they had a full set of paid weeks showing under my claim already. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent told me which weeks had actually been issued payment and confirmed the dates, which helped me figure out what was happening with my own timeline.

0 coins

Wait, what even is Claimyr? I've been redialing the EDD number for two days straight and nothing goes through.

0 coins

Basically it stays on hold with EDD in your place and your phone rings once a live person there picks up. No more redialing yourself.

0 coins

Oh that actually makes sense. My thing would be asking about a medical certification my doctor says she submitted but EDD hasn't matched to anything yet.

0 coins

Every morning for a week I've hit that same wall on the disability line. Ends the call without warning every single time.

0 coins

If a claim got filed under your name and you didn't do it, that's fraud, plain and simple. Call EDD and report it. Don't sit on this.

0 coins

This. Don't overthink it. Call and say someone filed without your permission.

0 coins

Is there a form I fill out or do I just explain it over the phone?

0 coins

Start with the phone. Number is 1-800-480-3287. Tell them exactly what you told us, that a claim exists in your name and you never filed it.

0 coins

There's another possibility worth considering. Sometimes an employer-side error or even a glitch in EDD's system can generate a Notice of Computation before a claim is actually complete. The notice by itself is not an approval and doesn't mean payments went out. But a fully filed claim appearing in SDI Online that you didn't create is a separate issue, and that one really does need to be reported as potential fraud.

0 coins

The claim in SDI Online shows a claimant's statement was submitted. I truly don't know how that happened under my login.

0 coins

That's the part that makes it sound like unauthorized access to your myEDD account rather than just a system error. Change your password immediately and then contact EDD.

0 coins

Changing it now. Thank you for saying that, I hadn't thought about the account access angle.

0 coins

EDD sending letters about claims that people never filed is genuinely a thing that happens, usually because someone got your info and used it. I went three weeks trying to reach anyone on that disability line. Eventually gave up and used the Ask EDD form online but they just sent back a template response about processing times. Zero help.

0 coins

Ask EDD is useless for anything that needs an actual answer. Agree with the people saying to keep trying the phone.

0 coins

Tried every day for three weeks. The call just dies before it even rings through half the time.

0 coins

The SDI Online message feature sometimes works for straightforward questions, but for something like a fraudulent claim they're going to want you to reach a person.

0 coins

From an organization standpoint, here's what I'd document before calling EDD: the date on the Notice of Computation, the weekly amount it shows, the claim ID from SDI Online, and the start date listed on the claim. Having all of that in front of you when you get through will make the call faster.

0 coins

That's really helpful, I'll pull all of that together. The notice date and the claim start date are actually different by about a week.

0 coins

That gap is normal. The start date is when the disability period supposedly began, the notice date is when EDD generated the computation. Keep both noted.

0 coins

Should she also write down what her actual medical situation is in case they ask? I'm in a sort of similar boat where I need to file for real and I don't even know what details to have ready.

0 coins

For a real filing you'd need your last day worked, the date the disability started, and the name and contact info for the physician who will certify. For a fraud report, focus on the account and claim details as described above.

0 coins

wait if someone filed under your name does that mean they could be getting paid too? like actual money going somewhere thats not you

0 coins

That's the concern, yes. If a fraudulent claim is fully submitted with a medical certification, EDD could issue payments. That's why finding out quickly whether any weeks show as paid matters.

0 coins

SDI Online doesn't show any payments issued yet as far as I can tell, just the claim and the notice. But I want to confirm that with EDD directly.

0 coins

yeah definitely get someone on the phone asap then

0 coins

DE 2525XX came into my situation late and I had no idea what to do with it, so I figured I'd share since people are talking about claims going sideways. The extension form for my own disability claim was sitting unsubmitted while I was still recovering, and I eventually got an EDD agent on the line through Claimyr about where the extension stood. The agent confirmed the DE 2525XX hadn't been submitted by my doctor's office yet and that my claim would stop at the end of that benefit period if it didn't come in. Called the office, they sent it same day, anyway.

0 coins

Claimyr actually worked out for my own claim too and I was grateful for it. When I phoned about which quarter of the base period was used for my benefit amount, the agent told me the highest-paid quarter they had on file and which 12-month window it fell in. Really cleared up why my weekly amount was lower than I expected.

0 coins

What did you do after the agent told you the quarter? Did that change anything on your end?

0 coins

Mostly it just confirmed the number was right, even if I didn't love it. At least I knew I wasn't missing wages they should have counted.

0 coins

the extension piece is the part that always catches people off guard. glad someone mentioned it.

0 coins

Change the myEDD password and also check whether the email address on the account is still yours. Fraudulent claim filers sometimes change the contact email so notices go to them, not you. If the email has been changed, note that for EDD when you report.

0 coins

Checked and the email is still mine, thankfully. Password is already changed.

0 coins

Good. EDD will likely ask both of those things early in the fraud report call.

0 coins

When you do reach EDD, ask them specifically whether any medical certification has been submitted on the fraudulent claim. A claim can sit without one and no payment would issue, but if someone got a provider to certify it somehow, the situation is more urgent.

0 coins

Is it possible for someone to get a fake certification submitted? That part scares me.

0 coins

It does happen in organized fraud cases, which is why EDD takes these reports seriously. Just give them the full picture of what you found in SDI Online.

0 coins

EDD's fraud investigations unit handles this kind of thing. They see it enough to know what to look for.

0 coins

Claim start date on mine got entered wrong by one digit and it held everything up for two weeks. Called EDD through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the date that was actually on the claim in their system, which let me tell right away it wasn't what I'd put in my claimant's statement. EDD corrected it and the pending status cleared.

0 coins

That sounds like marketing to me. A service that just magically gets you through to EDD?

0 coins

Had the same thought when I first saw it mentioned. Used it about six weeks into my own claim, specifically to ask about the DE 2593 that EDD sent me. The agent confirmed they'd received it and what date it was logged. It was just a person at EDD who pulled up my claim.

0 coins

Okay, that's more concrete than I expected. Might actually try it.

0 coins

DE 2593, is that one I'd need to deal with if my claim gets sorted out and I actually file for real?

0 coins

The DE 2593 is a continued eligibility questionnaire EDD sends out after you've been on automatic payment for about ten weeks. You return it within 20 days or benefits can pause. You'd only see it if you file a legitimate claim and stay on it long enough.

0 coins

Honestly the scariest part of your situation is not knowing how long it sat there before the letter showed up. Like someone could have been monitoring your mail too if they knew your address. Might be worth a heads up to your post office just in case.

0 coins

That's a thought I hadn't had. The letter came to my correct address so maybe they didn't change that at least.

0 coins

Small relief. But still worth documenting the postmark date so you know exactly when it was mailed.

0 coins

Notice of Computation sitting in my stack for a week before I realized the benefit amount on it didn't match what EDD's calculator had estimated. Used Claimyr and reached an EDD agent who pulled up my Notice of Computation and read off the figures, then told me which wage quarter drove the amount. Turns out one quarter of my earnings hadn't been reported yet by my employer and that was the gap.

0 coins

When you talked to that agent, did you have your Notice of Computation in front of you at the same time, or were you going off memory?

0 coins

Had it right in front of me, lol. Cross-referencing what they read versus what the letter said in real time was the only way I caught where the difference was.

0 coins

been trying that disability line most mornings for about two weeks and i can never get past the first menu without it dropping.

0 coins

Two weeks of that is exhausting. The SDI Online message option is worth a shot for simpler questions while you keep trying the phone for the bigger ones.

0 coins

If the claim turns out to be fraud and you have never actually applied, do you need to do anything to officially close it, or does EDD just cancel it on their end after you report?

0 coins

EDD handles the closure and investigation on their end once you report. What they may ask you to do is sign a statement confirming you didn't file. Follow whatever instructions the agent gives you on that call.

0 coins

Got it. And in the meantime does EDD freeze the fraudulent claim while they investigate so no payments go out?

0 coins

EDD typically acts on suspected fraud quickly, but the agent you reach will tell you exactly what their next step is for your specific claim. Don't assume anything is frozen until they confirm it.

0 coins

You said HR told you to use sick days. Did you tell HR about this letter? They should probably know someone may have used your work info to file a fake SDI claim.

0 coins

I haven't told HR yet. That's a good point, they might have information about how my employment details got used.

0 coins

Worth a quick email to HR today. They deal with EDD paperwork regularly and might spot something you'd miss.

0 coins

EDD's site does have an online fraud reporting option through Ask EDD in addition to the phone. For something this serious I'd still push for the phone, but submitting through Ask EDD at the same time creates a written record of when you first reported it.

0 coins

Creating that paper trail from day one is smart. If EDD later questions when you became aware of the claim, you have a timestamped submission.

0 coins

I'll submit through Ask EDD today and keep trying the phone. At least one of them will get through.

0 coins

also just want to say if you do end up actually needing SDI for real for your back thing, the doctor has to submit the medical certification through SDI Online with the receipt number you get after you file part a. they cant just mail it in randomly

0 coins

To add to that, filing on paper is also an option with the DE 2501, but the online route through SDI Online is faster. Either way the physician submits their part within 49 days of when the disability started, using the receipt number if online or completing Part B if on paper.

0 coins

right yeah i meant online is faster but good to know there is a paper option

0 coins

Actually helpful to know for when I do file for real. But first I have to get this fake one sorted out.

0 coins

One thing that's not being said here: even if EDD clears the fraud, you're still going to want to file your own legitimate claim for your back recovery, and you're still bound by the 49-day window from when your disability started. Don't let the fraud chaos eat up all your time and then miss your own filing deadline.

0 coins

Oh that's a really important point I hadn't connected. My disability started about three weeks ago so I still have time but I need to move on both things at once.

0 coins

Exactly. Report the fraud, file your own claim. Same week if you can manage it.

0 coins

The 49-day clock runs from the disability start date regardless of what else is going on with EDD. Worth marking that date on your calendar so you don't lose track of it.

0 coins

Checking back to see if you've gotten through to EDD yet. The first real step of clearing this up is that phone call, and everything else kind of waits on what they find in your account.

0 coins

Still haven't reached a live person. I've tried the number twice today and both times it dropped. Submitted through Ask EDD at least.

0 coins

ask edd bought me maybe three days before i gave up and kept trying the phone. hope you get through faster than i did.

0 coins

While you're waiting to get through, write out a simple timeline: date your disability started, date you got the EDD letter, date you discovered the claim in SDI Online, date you changed your password. Having that written down before the call makes you sound clear and organized, which helps.

0 coins

Already doing this actually. Thank you. It's also helping me feel a little less panicked to have something productive to do.

0 coins

Good. You're handling this the right way.

0 coins

Any update? Hoping the fraud report got filed and EDD got moving on this for you.

0 coins

Finally reached someone this morning. Reported the fraudulent claim, they flagged it and said they'd follow up by mail. Also filed my own legitimate claim for the back recovery through SDI Online while I still had time. Waiting on the medical certification from my doctor's office now.

0 coins

Filing your own claim at the same time was exactly the right move. Hope the certification comes in fast and your legitimate claim gets sorted quickly.

0 coins

Make sure your doctor uses the receipt number from your new filing when they submit through SDI Online. That's what links their certification to your specific claim.

0 coins

Already gave the receipt number to the office. They confirmed they'll submit the medical certification within the next couple of days.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure