Back to California Disability

Alexis Robinson

California EDD SDI reopening claim after going back to work too soon

So I went back to work about six weeks into my claim because I thought I was ready, and three weeks later my doctor told me I need more time off. My back just hasn't healed the way we expected after the procedure, and my employer actually agreed I shouldn't be at the warehouse doing what I do. I reported to EDD when I went back and my payments stopped. Now I'm trying to figure out if I reopen the same SDI claim or if I have to start fresh with a whole new one. My original claim was filed through SDI Online earlier this year. I still have the same condition, same doctor. Do I even have a new waiting period to deal with? Does the medical certification start over completely? I'm not sure if the 52-week clock resets or if I'm still inside the original claim window. Any help appreciated because every time I try to call the EDD disability line I get the busy signal or it just disconnects me after sitting on hold.

Claim start date was something I had to get sorted out the hard way on mine. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent because I kept hitting busy signals for three days straight. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my start date had been recorded differently than what I expected from when I first filed, which was messing with my base period. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Once I had the right start date confirmed I could actually understand the rest of what was happening with my claim.

0 coins

The start date thing threw me off too. How did your base period end up shifting because of that? I always assumed EDD just used the first day you reported the disability.

0 coins

The agent said the base period looks back from your claim start date, so the exact date really matters for which quarter they use to calculate your amount. My Notice of Computation had numbers on it that didn't make sense until the date was fixed.

0 coins

Had a similar issue where the date I thought my claim began and the date EDD had on file were different by almost two weeks. Definitely worth verifying that before anything else.

0 coins

Whether you reopen or file fresh actually comes down to timing. If you're still within 52 weeks of your original claim's start date, your doctor can submit the extension form — that's the DE 2525XX — to continue the same claim rather than you having to start a brand new one. The 52-week total runs from that original start, so you'd want to know exactly how many weeks you've used so far. The seven-day waiting period applied when you first filed; it doesn't reset just because you returned to work briefly and then went back out.

0 coins

Wait, so I don't do anything on my end? My doctor just submits the DE 2525XX and that continues the same claim?

0 coins

Your doctor's office handles that form, yes. EDD sends it out with the final payment notice when your original approval period ends, but your doctor can also access it through SDI Online. The key thing is that your physician certifies the continued disability on that same claim rather than starting a Part A from scratch.

0 coins

Didn't realize the form came with the final payment notice. I thought you had to request it separately every time.

0 coins

EDD sends the DE 2525XX with the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification when you're near the end of an approved period. That's the one that signals your last payment is coming. But your doctor can submit it through SDI Online independently if they need to — the claim is still open.

0 coins

Confused about something — when you went back to work and payments stopped, did SDI Online show the claim as closed or still open? I'm in a similar spot where I returned part time and I'm not sure if mine is still active or if I'd have to refile everything.

0 coins

Mine just stopped showing new payment activity but I never got anything that said it was officially closed. That's part of why I'm unsure whether I'm reopening or continuing.

0 coins

Part-time return while on disability is handled differently than a full return. If you go back part time, you're supposed to report your wages each week and EDD adjusts the payment for that week. A full return to work is what actually closes the active claim period.

0 coins

So if I only went back part time and kept reporting, the claim might still technically be in the same period? That's not what I expected at all.

0 coins

My coworker told me I'd have a whole new waiting period if I had to reopen. But I went through almost this exact situation last year — out for a shoulder thing, went back for a few weeks, then needed more time — and I did not have a new seven-day wait. The original waiting period I served at the start was it. The doctor submitted the continuation form and payments resumed without me having to sit out another week unpaid.

0 coins

That tracks with what I've read. The waiting period is for the initial claim, not every time there's a gap in payments.

0 coins

Really glad someone clarified this. I'd been dreading another unpaid week on top of everything.

0 coins

The hardest part for me was getting the doctor's office to actually submit the DE 2525XX promptly. They didn't realize the form had a name or that they had to file it in SDI Online versus just calling EDD.

0 coins

Filing a whole new DE 2501 would basically reset your waiting period because it creates a brand new claim with a new start date. That's the wrong path if you're inside the 52-week window on your original claim. The continuation route through the DE 2525XX keeps everything under the same claim ID and preserves the waiting period you already served. You'd want your doctor to reference your original claim, not start a new one.

0 coins

Does the 52 weeks run continuously from the first day, or does it pause when you're back at work?

0 coins

Runs continuously from the original start date. The clock doesn't stop during the period you were back at work. So if your claim started, say, eight months ago, you have somewhere around four months of potential remaining DI benefits — depending on what your Notice of Computation shows.

0 coins

Eight months into this whole ordeal counting the original filing. So I need to check my Notice of Computation again and do the math from there.

0 coins

Notice of Computation numbers were confusing me until I got EDD on the phone. I'd been dealing with a hand injury and my claim had pauses in it too. Claimyr got me to an agent who went through my Notice of Computation line by line with me and confirmed the weekly amount and the total maximum I had left on the claim. That cleared up whether continuing made sense over refiling.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation — does it also show how many weeks you've actually used versus how many are left?

0 coins

The agent told me the total maximum amount on the notice and explained how the payments I'd received tracked against it. She could see on her end what had been issued and what remained.

0 coins

Mine went out when the claim was first approved. Should I look at that original one or will EDD send a new one if I continue the claim?

0 coins

Your original Notice of Computation stays relevant because it shows the weekly rate and max. If anything changes — like if EDD recalculates based on new quarters — you'd get an updated one. Otherwise the original is the reference document for the same claim.

0 coins

Is there any concern about the gap in time between when you stopped working again and now? Like if too much time passes before the doctor submits the continuation form does that cause problems?

0 coins

The 49-day window applies to the initial medical certification for a new claim. For an extension on an existing claim, the DE 2525XX process is different — but you don't want months going by without anything filed. Get your doctor moving on it sooner rather than later.

0 coins

Good to know. I was wondering if someone could technically delay the continuation form for months and still pick up where they left off.

0 coins

Practically speaking, the longer the gap the more questions EDD may have. No one should assume an indefinite window. Your doctor certifying the ongoing disability and submitting the form is what keeps things connected to the original claim.

0 coins

Slight tangent but relevant — when you reported that you returned to work and your payments stopped, did EDD actually confirm receipt of that report or did they just stop paying? I'm asking because I reported a return to work on mine and the system showed me going silent for weeks before anything updated. Thought I'd done something wrong.

0 coins

Honestly I just submitted through SDI Online and payments stopped. Never got a confirmation message per se, they just ceased.

0 coins

Same experience here. No notice that I'd done it correctly, just silence. Eventually got a letter but it took a while.

0 coins

The lack of confirmation is infuriating but apparently normal. The system processes the return-to-work report and closes the payment period, it just doesn't send you a congratulations for doing it right.

0 coins

Which weeks were actually paid on my claim got jumbled at some point and I had to untangle it. Ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr to sort it out — the agent went through each two-week period and confirmed which ones had issued and which were still showing open on my claim. After getting my head around which weeks were paid I could figure out exactly where I stood on the 52-week clock.

0 coins

How far back did the agent go? Like did they go all the way to your original claim start?

0 coins

She went back to the beginning of my claim and walked through which periods had payments posted. It told me I had used more weeks than I thought I had, so the 52-week thing was more urgent for me than I realized.

0 coins

That's actually a smart move before deciding whether to continue or refile, knowing exactly where the week count stands.

0 coins

My doctor's office initially said they'd just call EDD to extend my claim and didn't realize they had to file anything through SDI Online. Got corrected by EDD when I finally got through — the DE 2525XX has to go through SDI Online, not a phone call from the provider.

0 coins

The doctor's office calling to report things verbally versus actually submitting a form is such a common mix-up. EDD doesn't record verbal calls from providers as formal submissions.

0 coins

Mine already has SDI Online access from the original claim. Glad I know to specifically ask them about the DE 2525XX by name.

0 coins

Ask them by name, yes. When I said 'extension form' the receptionist had no idea what I was talking about. 'DE 2525XX' got to the right person immediately.

0 coins

Naming the form specifically at the front desk is genuinely the move. I've had to do it with two different offices now.

0 coins

Does any of this change if your employer is offering some kind of partial wage replacement through their own plan? Like if the company has short-term disability insurance layered on top, does that affect the SDI piece?

0 coins

Whether your employer has their own plan alongside state SDI is worth asking EDD directly about how your specific case counts. Some employers run what's called a Voluntary Plan instead of state SDI, and the rules there are handled differently. Worth a direct question to EDD on your own situation rather than assuming.

0 coins

Makes sense to ask EDD rather than guess. I'll check with HR too about which plan my paycheck's deductions actually go to.

0 coins

Went back to work too early after a knee issue last year and then had to come back out. My situation ended up being simpler than I feared — the doctor submitted the DE 2525XX, it got matched to my original claim ID, and payments resumed. I did not file a new claim and there was no second waiting period. The only wrinkle was that my doctor's office submitted the form but used the wrong claim ID at first, so it sat unmatched for about ten days before someone noticed.

0 coins

How did you catch the wrong claim ID? Did EDD reach out or did you have to discover it yourself?

0 coins

I noticed in SDI Online that nothing was updating after what should have been enough time, so I had the doctor's office double-check which claim ID they'd entered. Turned out they had a typo. They resubmitted with the right one and it moved pretty fast after that.

0 coins

The claim ID matching issue is worth flagging here because it's exactly the kind of thing that creates a fake delay. Everything can be submitted correctly but if the numbers don't match you're just waiting on nothing.

0 coins

Exactly. Have your doctor confirm the claim ID before they hit submit, not after they say they filed it.

0 coins

DE 2525XX got submitted for my extension but I wasn't sure if EDD had actually received it. Reached out through Claimyr about it — the agent confirmed EDD had received the form and that it was attached to the right claim, and also told me the claim would need physician certification covering the specific weeks I was requesting. That part I hadn't realized: the form has to cover the actual dates of your continued disability, not just be submitted generally.

0 coins

The dates on the DE 2525XX being specific to the weeks you're requesting — did EDD tell your doctor that or did you have to relay it?

0 coins

The agent gave me that information and I passed it to the doctor's office, who then confirmed the dates on their end before it was finalized. EDD doesn't contact providers proactively with that kind of guidance in my experience.

0 coins

Worth double-checking with the doctor's office that the certification period they've written actually covers the weeks you're out, not just a vague ongoing timeframe.

0 coins

Came into this thread confused about something — there's a myth going around in my circle that if you go back to work at all, even for a week, your SDI claim automatically closes permanently and you have to start from zero. That's not what I'm reading here, and I want to confirm: a brief return followed by needing more time off doesn't mean the original claim is gone?

0 coins

Correct, that's not how it works. Returning to work ends the payment period for those weeks, but the claim itself doesn't vanish. If you're within 52 weeks of the original start date and your physician certifies that you need more time, the DE 2525XX continues under the same claim. The idea that any return kills the whole claim is wrong.

0 coins

That's a relief. I'll make sure to pass that along because a few people in my situation have been talking about not bothering to try to continue because they assumed it was over.

0 coins

The 'claim dies if you go back' idea probably comes from people who returned, their payments stopped, and they never tried to continue it. So from the outside it looks like the claim ended, but it was just never extended.

0 coins

Something I ran into — my doctor initially said she wasn't sure she could certify the continuation because my original condition had shifted somewhat, even though it was still related. Is that a problem for the DE 2525XX? Like does it have to be the exact same diagnosis or can it be a complication from the same original issue?

0 coins

Whether your doctor can certify the continuation is a question for them and EDD, not really something the form itself draws a hard line on in terms of naming the condition exactly. Your doctor certifies that you're still unable to perform your regular work and for what period — EDD makes the eligibility call from there.

0 coins

Makes sense. She ended up being willing to certify it once I explained that I wasn't asking her to make a legal argument, just to describe what's going on clinically and let EDD decide.

0 coins

That framing probably helped a lot. Doctors sometimes think they're being asked to guarantee an outcome rather than just report the medical facts.

0 coins

How long does it typically take for EDD to start payments again once the DE 2525XX is filed and matched? I'm asking because rent doesn't pause while EDD processes things and I'm trying to figure out if I need a bridge plan.

0 coins

EDD says most payments go out within two weeks of receiving a properly completed claim — meaning both the claimant's part and the medical certification are in and matched. For a continuation it's similar, but I'd check SDI Online to watch when the form shows as received rather than just trusting a submission date from the doctor's office.

0 coins

Two weeks from when they receive the completed form is the number I'll plan around. Good to have something concrete.

0 coins

And 'received' by EDD versus 'submitted' by the doctor's office can be two different dates. Keep checking SDI Online until you see it reflected on your end.

0 coins

Quick note on the SDI Online side of this for anyone following along: once the DE 2525XX is in the system and processing, you should see the claim status update in SDI Online. If it's been more than the two-week window and nothing has moved, that's the moment to contact EDD — either through the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online or by calling 1-800-480-3287.

0 coins

Should I be checking under my original claim ID in SDI Online or will there be a new entry?

0 coins

Same claim ID. The continuation attaches to the existing claim, so when you open your original claim in SDI Online you should see the updated certification and any new payment activity there.

0 coins

Good to know it stays under the same ID. I was worried about losing track of documentation if EDD somehow created a parallel entry.

0 coins

My neighbor told me she just filed for unemployment when she ran out of SDI the first time around rather than bothering with an extension. I know that's a totally different thing but I'm wondering if people mix those two up a lot.

0 coins

They are fundamentally different. Unemployment requires you to be able to work and looking for work. If you're still medically unable to do your job, you don't qualify for UI — you'd be on DI. Someone who mixes them up and files UI while still disabled could end up with a problem. The right path is the SDI continuation if still disabled, then UI when you're recovered and available to work.

0 coins

Yeah I thought as much. She might have actually recovered by the time she filed UI, so maybe it was fine in her case, but it's definitely not a substitute for SDI.

0 coins

Can you collect UI and SDI at the same time for the same days? Asking because I've heard conflicting things.

0 coins

You can't. EDD is clear that you can't receive both for the same days. One at a time, and the right one depends on whether you're still unable to work.

0 coins

Workers' comp question — if the injury that put you on disability originally was borderline work-related but you filed SDI instead of workers' comp, does reopening the SDI claim create any issue? Or is that a 'talk to someone who knows workers' comp' situation?

0 coins

EDD itself notes it's not common to get paid workers' comp and state disability at the same time, with some exceptions. The specifics of how those two interact on your particular situation is well above what anyone here can answer. That one really does need someone who can look at the actual facts of your case — EDD and possibly a workers' comp attorney.

0 coins

Fair, that was more of a general curiosity than a real issue on my claim. Mine is clearly not work-related so I don't have to worry about it.

0 coins

The other thing worth remembering is that SDI is capped at 52 weeks total on a single claim regardless of gaps and returns to work. So if someone is at week 50 of their original claim window and thinks they have a full 52 more weeks because they worked for a while in the middle, that's not how it works. The 52-week period started on day one of the original claim.

0 coins

Okay so I need to actually add up all the weeks from my original start date, not just the weeks I was receiving payments. The weeks I was back at work still count toward that 52.

0 coins

Exactly that. Count from the original start date to today and subtract from 52. That's your remaining potential window, though your actual remaining benefit amount also depends on what your Notice of Computation shows for your maximum.

0 coins

This is the clearest explanation of the 52-week rule I've seen. The idea that the clock pauses during a return to work is definitely a misconception I had.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure