Medi-Cal share of cost deduction $600 maintenance need allowance for widow social security — is my NOA wrong?
My mother-in-law moved in with us about eight months ago after her husband passed. She's 74 and her only income is Social Security survivors benefits. She applied for Medi-Cal through the county a few months back and got approved, but the Notice of Action they sent shows a share of cost that feels way too high to us. She's on a fixed income and her Social Security check isn't that large, but the number on the NOA doesn't seem to match what I've been reading online about a maintenance need amount that widows are supposed to get. I've been trying to figure out if the county subtracted that $600 allowance before calculating what she owes each month, or if they just ran the numbers without it. The NOA itself doesn't show us the math, just the final share of cost figure. She doesn't have any other income, no pension, no rental, nothing. Just the survivors check. Has anyone dealt with this where the county might have missed a deduction that should have brought the share of cost down? She only gets care some months so the SOC resets, but I want to make sure the amount they're telling providers is actually right before her next appointment.
85 comments

Grace Johnson
Renewal form came back to me last October and I had no idea whether the county got it because BenefitsCal just showed pending with no update. I let Claimyr (claimyr.com) handle the hold time and ended up talking to a worker who pulled up my case and told me the form had been received and gave me the exact due date they had on file. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. That date matched what I'd sent so I stopped worrying about it. For what you're asking about the maintenance need allowance, that is definitely a Non-MAGI calculation and the county worker is the right person to walk through the specific numbers with. The NOA won't show every line of the math, so calling the county directly and asking them to explain the deductions they applied is the clearest path.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorAppreciate this, glad the county had the form on file for you. I'm going to try calling the county directly like you said and ask them to show me the deduction breakdown. The NOA really does just show the final number, nothing else.
0 coins
Jayden Reed
Pending with no update for weeks is so stressful, glad that worked out. I've been in the same boat with a renewal and BenefitsCal not moving at all.
0 coins
Nora Brooks
My aunt went through something similar after her husband died and I helped her figure out the Non-MAGI rules. The way it worked on her case, the county is supposed to subtract a maintenance need allowance from the person's income before they calculate the share of cost — the idea is to leave enough for basic living expenses. The $600 figure you're seeing mentioned online for a widow or widower is part of that Non-MAGI calculation. If the county didn't apply it, or applied the wrong figure, the share of cost on the NOA would come out higher than it should. The number on the Notice of Action is what the provider uses, so if it's off, the provider collects the wrong amount.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorThat matches exactly what I was afraid of. So the maintenance need allowance should reduce the income they count before they get to the share of cost number. If they skipped that step or used a different figure, the whole SOC is wrong.
0 coins
Eli Wang
How did your aunt get it fixed? Did she have to file a State Fair Hearing or did the county just correct it when she called?
0 coins
Nora Brooks
She called the county and asked them to go line by line through what they counted as income and what deductions they applied. They found the error on that call and sent a corrected Notice of Action within a couple of weeks. No hearing needed, though the worker did say if the corrected NOA still looked wrong she had 90 days from its date to request one.
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
Few things here worth separating out. The share of cost on her NOA is specific to Non-MAGI Medi-Cal, which is what people 65 and older are usually on. MAGI Medi-Cal, the kind most working-age adults get, has no share of cost at all. So if someone is telling your mother-in-law her share of cost doesn't sound right for regular Medi-Cal, they might be thinking of a different program. Non-MAGI is its own set of rules and the maintenance need deduction is part of those rules, not something that applies to everyone. The county calculates it based on her household size and income type.
0 coins
Zane Hernandez
Had no idea MAGI and Non-MAGI were so different. My mom got approved last year and has no share of cost, but she's 61 so I guess that's why.
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
Exactly, she'd be under MAGI rules at 61 so no SOC. Once someone hits 65 or qualifies through disability, the Non-MAGI rules can kick in and that's when the share of cost calculation with all those deductions becomes relevant.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorGood to have that clarified. She's 74 so definitely Non-MAGI territory. The SOC on the NOA is what the doctor's office is quoting her and I just need to know the county ran that number correctly.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
Calling the county and asking them to walk through the deductions is the right move. When I had a question about my father's Non-MAGI calculation a couple of years ago, the worker on the phone actually read me the income figure they used and the deductions they subtracted before getting to the SOC amount. They could not tell me whether the number would change going forward or guarantee anything, but they could tell me what was on the case right then. If the maintenance need allowance wasn't applied, that's something they can see on their end.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorDid your father's worker have to transfer you to a different unit or was the regular county line able to pull up those details?
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
Regular county line. The worker said they could see the eligibility detail on the case. They mentioned that if he disagreed with what they found, the Notice of Action had a State Fair Hearing option within 90 days of its date.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
This is reassuring to know the front-line workers can actually see the calculation detail. I always assumed you had to go to a supervisor.
0 coins
Lola Perez
Is the $600 amount she's reading about the right figure for 2026 or is that an older number? I thought these amounts get updated and I don't want her to call the county assuming a specific dollar figure only to find out it changed.
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
Honestly a fair point to raise. The maintenance need allowance figures in Non-MAGI calculations can be adjusted over time and the county works from whatever the current figures are. Rather than arguing a specific number on the phone, the cleaner approach is to ask the county what maintenance need allowance they applied to her case and compare that to what's on DHCS's current guidelines. If they applied something lower than the current amount, that's the discrepancy.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorGood catch. I'll ask the county what amount they used rather than leading with a number and potentially confusing the conversation.
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
The SOC resets every month and she only pays it in months she actually gets care, right? So even if the number is slightly off, the impact is only in months she uses services. I went through this with my own Non-MAGI case and it took me a while to understand the SOC isn't a monthly bill that goes to Medi-Cal — it goes to the provider, only when she gets care that month.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorYes, that part I understood — the provider collects it up to the SOC amount and then Medi-Cal covers the rest. But if the SOC is too high because a deduction was missed, she ends up paying more out of pocket to the provider in those months she does have appointments. Especially with her next one coming up, I want the right number on file.
0 coins
Jayden Reed
I mixed this up for so long and thought I had to send a check to Medi-Cal every month. Really relieved when someone finally explained that the SOC is owed to the doctor, not to the county.
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
So many people get confused on that. The Notice of Action shows the SOC amount but doesn't always make it clear who you pay it to.
0 coins
Riya Sharma
Has she contacted the county already, or are you still at the stage of figuring out what to even ask them? Because framing the question the right way on the call makes a difference. Saying 'I want to know what maintenance need allowance was applied to my case before the share of cost was calculated' is a lot clearer than 'I think my share of cost is wrong.' The worker can answer the first one directly.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorHaven't called yet. Still trying to understand enough to ask the right question, which is why I came here first. That framing you gave is exactly what I needed — I'll use it.
0 coins
Riya Sharma
Also ask them to tell you the gross income figure they counted. If her Social Security survivors amount is on the case correctly, and the maintenance need deduction is applied, you can at least verify both inputs even if you can't see the full formula yourself.
0 coins
Santiago Diaz
This is the exact kind of practical thing that would have helped me six months ago. I just said 'I think there's a mistake' and the worker didn't know where to look.
0 coins
Millie Long
BIC never showed up after my coverage started and I wasn't sure if the county had even sent one. I let Claimyr handle the hold time on the county line and ended up with a worker who checked and told me a new BIC had been sent and gave me the date it was mailed. Went to the mailbox the next day and there it was. For the share of cost question here, what I'd add from my own Non-MAGI experience is that the worker can read you what income and deductions are showing on your case. The maintenance need allowance should be visible on their end as a line in the calculation.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorGood to know the BIC situation got sorted. And glad to hear the worker can actually see the deduction lines — that's what I need them to read back to me for my mother-in-law's case.
0 coins
Eli Wang
I've been waiting on a BIC for almost three weeks and was starting to wonder if I should call or wait longer. Sounds like calling to ask is the right move.
0 coins
Millie Long
Three weeks is enough to check on it. The worker on my case was straightforward about whether it had been sent.
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
Wait, is she on Medicare too? Because a lot of people 74 and on Social Security also have Medicare Part A and B, and if that's the case the county handles Medi-Cal differently for her — they look at whether Medi-Cal can help with Medicare costs. That doesn't eliminate a share of cost but it changes what the county is calculating against. Just making sure because the whole Non-MAGI calculation can look different for someone who also has Medicare.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorShe does have Medicare. I should have mentioned that. Does that change how the maintenance need allowance works in the Non-MAGI calculation, or is it the same deduction either way?
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
Honestly I'm not certain of the exact interaction when Medicare is in the picture — the county would know. What I can say is that having both is common and the county checks both programs when someone applies. The worker can tell you what they counted for her case specifically.
0 coins
Nora Brooks
Having Medicare and Medi-Cal at the same time is called being dual-eligible and it's very common for someone her age. The county would have seen that when she applied. How the SOC interacts with Medicare costs is something to ask the worker directly since it depends on what services she's using and through which program.
0 coins
Debra Bai
My grandmother dealt with something like this and honestly the county just made an error. The worker who processed her application left out a deduction and the NOA came back with a share of cost almost double what it should have been. She called, the worker confirmed the deduction was missing, and they issued a corrected NOA. Took about two weeks to get the corrected letter. The important thing is the corrected NOA is what providers go by going forward.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorTwo weeks for a corrected NOA is actually faster than I expected. And you're right that until a corrected one comes, the provider is working from the wrong number.
0 coins
Debra Bai
Exactly. So in the meantime, if she has an appointment coming up, it might be worth letting the provider know there may be a correction pending and to hold off collecting the SOC until the corrected NOA arrives. Though that's between her and the provider.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
I'm confused about something. If she's 74 and on Social Security, wouldn't she be on Medicare, not Medi-Cal? My neighbor kept saying Medi-Cal was for low-income people and Medicare was for seniors. Are they both a thing at once?
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
They are absolutely both a thing at once and it's one of the most common mix-ups. Medicare is federal health coverage tied to age or disability, and Medi-Cal is California's low-income program. If someone is 65 or older and also low-income, they can have both. Medicare usually covers most of the care and Medi-Cal can help with what Medicare doesn't, including sometimes the Medicare premiums. The county checks for Medicare when someone applies for Medi-Cal at that age.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
Wow okay that makes sense. So Medi-Cal isn't just for younger people on low incomes, it's also for older adults who don't have enough to cover what Medicare leaves out.
0 coins
Nora Brooks
Exactly. And the Non-MAGI rules, including things like the maintenance need allowance and the share of cost calculation, exist specifically for this group — older adults, people with disabilities, people on Medicare. The rules are more involved than what younger working-age adults deal with under MAGI.
0 coins
Laura Lopez
SOC amount on my own Non-MAGI notice looked off to me after my income dropped because my part-time hours got cut. I used Claimyr to reach my county's line and ended up speaking with a worker who read me exactly what income figure was showing on my case and what the share of cost on the notice came to. The income figure they had on file was from before my hours changed, which explained the discrepancy. I reported the change through BenefitsCal and they said to expect a new Notice of Action after the county processes the update. For your mother-in-law's situation, the same approach applies — ask the worker to read back what income they counted and what deductions they applied.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorHours getting cut and the county still running the old income number is exactly the kind of thing that would throw off the SOC. Good that you found it. I'll follow the same approach and ask them to read back both the income figure and the deductions for her case.
0 coins
Santiago Diaz
Reporting income changes within 10 days is something I never knew about until I was already late. Good reminder that changes need to go in fast.
0 coins
Laura Lopez
The 10-day window is real. I reported mine as soon as I could once I realized how the timing worked. The worker said the update was in the system but that the Notice of Action from the county would be what confirmed the new SOC.
0 coins
Eli Wang
Does the State Fair Hearing option on the NOA have a deadline? I know someone mentioned 90 days earlier in this thread but I want to make sure that's right and not something that varies. My mom has a situation where her NOA might be wrong too and I want to know how long she has to do something about it.
0 coins
Nora Brooks
Ninety days from the date printed on the Notice of Action is the window to request a State Fair Hearing. That date is on the NOA itself. She can also try talking to the county eligibility worker first without filing the hearing — that call sometimes resolves it faster. But the 90-day clock on the hearing runs regardless of whether she's also talking to the county.
0 coins
Eli Wang
So the 90-day deadline runs from the NOA date, not from when she received it. That's important to know since mail takes a few days.
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
Exactly, the date on the notice is the clock. So if the letter sat in the mailbox for a few days or got delayed, that time is already gone. File sooner rather than right at the deadline if the goal is to request a hearing.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
Calling the county is easier said than done from what I've seen. Their line in Tulare rings and rings and I've sat on hold for over an hour without getting anyone. I totally understand why people here are saying call but the practical reality is getting through is its own obstacle.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
The hold times in Tulare are genuinely brutal. I've tried calling at 8 in the morning thinking it would be faster and still waited a long time.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorThis is my fear too. I'm going to try but I really can't sit on hold for an hour with a full house to manage.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
BenefitsCal messages are another option but in my experience the response time there is also slow. In-person visits to the county office are quicker for some people since at least you're in the queue physically.
0 coins
Samuel Robinson
Application date on my case was something I needed confirmed because BenefitsCal showed it had been submitted but I had no letter after several weeks. I let Claimyr sit on hold while I handled other things, and when I ended up with a worker on the line, she confirmed the application had been received and read me the date the county had it logged. That settled it for me. For the SOC issue here, the same county line is the right place — the workers on eligibility cases can see the full Non-MAGI calculation detail.
0 coins
Santiago Diaz
Weeks of waiting with just a 'submitted' status and no letter is nerve-wracking. Glad the worker could confirm the date they had on file.
0 coins
Samuel Robinson
It was a relief to have a date confirmed rather than just trusting that something went through. The worker also said a Notice of Action would be coming by mail and to watch for it.
0 coins
Zane Hernandez
Going back to the original question for a second — if the county does confirm they missed the maintenance need deduction, what happens to months she already paid the higher SOC amount to a provider? Can she get that money back?
0 coins
Nora Brooks
That's something to ask the county directly. The Notice of Action they issue governs what providers collected, and a corrected NOA changes things going forward. What happens to amounts already collected before the correction is a question for the county worker and possibly the provider.
0 coins
Zane Hernandez
Makes sense. Hopefully the corrected NOA comes before she has too many more appointments at the wrong amount.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorShe hasn't had any appointments yet this month so if we can get the county to confirm and issue a corrected NOA quickly, the timing might work out. I'll call tomorrow morning.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
Worth knowing that the Social Security survivors benefit type can matter in how the county counts the income. There are different types of Social Security payments and the county distinguishes between them in Non-MAGI calculations. Her survivors benefit should still be subject to the maintenance need deduction, but the worker looking at her case will confirm how it was classified. If it was miscoded as a different income type, that could also affect the SOC.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorI hadn't thought about whether the type of Social Security payment matters separately from the amount. I'll ask the county worker to confirm how her survivors benefit was classified on the case.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
Just mention it's a survivors benefit specifically, not a retirement or disability payment, and ask what income type they have coded for it. The worker can check that on the spot.
0 coins
Riya Sharma
Her BIC should still work while this is being sorted out, right? The share of cost question is about how much she pays the provider, not about whether she has active Medi-Cal coverage. The two are separate and her coverage shouldn't be interrupted just because there's a question about the SOC calculation.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorThat's a relief to hear. As long as her coverage is active and the BIC is valid, she can still go to her appointment and we can sort out the SOC amount with the county at the same time.
0 coins
Riya Sharma
Exactly. The SOC is settled between her and the provider at the time of service. Active coverage is what the BIC shows and that's separate from the SOC dispute. Keep the appointment, make sure the provider knows there may be a pending correction, and sort it out with the county in parallel.
0 coins
Jayden Reed
I didn't realize the BIC and the SOC were so separate. I thought if anything was under review the whole coverage might pause.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
My mother had her Non-MAGI case reviewed last year and the county sent an updated NOA on its own after she reported a change in her income. The new NOA had a lower share of cost and showed the corrected amount the provider would collect. She didn't have to do anything beyond the initial call to report the issue — once the county updated the case, the new NOA came by mail.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorThat's encouraging. If calling to report the potential error triggers a case review and a corrected NOA, that might be all it takes. I'll make sure I frame it as a possible error in the deduction applied, not just a complaint about the amount.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
That framing made a difference for her too. She said 'I think a deduction may have been missed' and the worker knew exactly where to look rather than just defending the original number.
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
I want to flag one thing nobody's said yet — if the county agrees the deduction was missed and they correct the NOA, the corrected SOC applies from the date of the correction forward, not necessarily from when she first got approved. So any months between approval and the correction where she paid the higher amount to a provider, that may already be settled. The correction is not automatically retroactive. At least that's how it played out on a case I know of. Worth asking the county worker about the effective date of any corrected NOA.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorThat's an important detail. I'll specifically ask the worker what effective date the corrected NOA would carry and whether there's any way to address the months before the correction.
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
The county worker should be able to tell you the effective date of the corrected notice. Beyond that, if she disagrees with the effective date, the State Fair Hearing option exists within 90 days of the corrected NOA's date.
0 coins
Santiago Diaz
Didn't know you could also request a hearing specifically about the effective date on a corrected NOA. Thought hearings were only for denials.
0 coins
Lola Perez
Has anyone dealt with the county taking more than a few weeks to issue a corrected NOA after they acknowledge the error? I'm wondering what the wait looks like after the initial call.
0 coins
Debra Bai
In my grandmother's case it was about two weeks from the call to the corrected letter arriving. I can't say if that's typical but it wasn't as long as I expected.
0 coins
Nora Brooks
Timelines can vary by county and how busy the office is. The worker on the call might give a general sense but won't commit to a specific date for the new letter. If nothing comes after a few weeks, calling again to ask if the correction was processed is reasonable.
0 coins
Lola Perez
Good to know. I have a similar situation I might be dealing with soon and wanted to get a sense of timing before I call.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
Can she request a State Fair Hearing before she even calls the county, or does she have to try the county first?
0 coins
Cassandra Moon
She can request a State Fair Hearing directly without going through the county first — the request goes to the California Department of Social Services and can be made by phone at 1-800-743-8525. But trying the county first often resolves things faster. The 90-day window from the NOA date runs either way, so the practical move is to call the county promptly while also being aware the hearing deadline is there if needed.
0 coins
Gabriel Freeman
Makes sense to try the county first since it might just be a quick fix, but good to know the hearing option doesn't require going through the county as a prerequisite.
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
Came back to say something that might help with the call: her Notice of Action has a date on it. That date is what the county uses as the effective date of the share of cost amount, and it's also the start of the 90-day window for a State Fair Hearing if she needs one. Write that date down before the call and have it ready because the worker may ask for it to pull up the right version of the case.
0 coins
Aurora St.Pierre
AuthorGood practical tip. I have the NOA in front of me now and the date is printed at the top. I'll keep it out for the call.
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
Also keep the NOA handy in general because the worker might reference the case number on it. Having all of that ready makes the call go faster.
0 coins
Victoria Brown
Writing down the NOA date before calling is something I didn't do the first time and had to dig for it mid-call while trying to stay on the line. Having it ready matters.
0 coins