Medi-Cal denied because unemployment benefits count as income — now what?
Lost my job in August and filed for unemployment the same week. I figured Medi-Cal would be an easy approval since I wasn't working, but the Notice of Action came back as a denial. The letter says my weekly unemployment payments push my household income past the limit for the program I applied under. I'm a single adult, no kids, and the unemployment is literally the only money coming in right now. I uploaded everything through BenefitsCal — ID, the letter from EDD showing my weekly amount, my last pay stub from the job I lost. The NOA gave me 90 days from its date to ask for a State Fair Hearing if I disagree, but I'm not sure I actually disagree? Like, I don't know if the county got the numbers wrong or if unemployment just counts the same as a paycheck and I'm actually over the limit. Has anyone been through this? Did appealing do anything, or is a denial like this usually correct?
71 comments

Lourdes Fox
Went through almost this exact situation last year, so let me share what I learned. Unemployment benefits do count as income for Medi-Cal — they're treated the same as wages when the county figures out whether you qualify. So if your weekly payments add up to more than the income limit for your household size, the denial can be correct even though you're not employed. That said, it's worth double-checking the math on your NOA. The county uses your expected monthly income, so they annualize or average the weekly amount. If your benefit amount changed partway through or EDD adjusted it, the number the county used might be off. You can also check DHCS's eligibility chart to see where the cutoff is for a single adult and compare it to what your NOA says your income is.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorOkay, so it's not a mistake in how they're categorizing it, unemployment really does count. My NOA lists the weekly amount times roughly 4.3 to get a monthly figure. That math looks right from what I can see. So I'm probably just over the limit.
0 coins
Bruno Simmons
If you're over the limit for regular Medi-Cal, the county should point you toward Covered CA for a subsidized plan. Sometimes a denial NOA mentions that, sometimes it doesn't. Worth checking whether you got any paperwork about that alongside the denial.
0 coins
Aileen Rodriguez
Are you sure they applied it correctly though? I thought unemployment was like a government payment, not actual income, so it shouldn't count the same as a job.
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
It does count — DHCS treats unemployment compensation as income the same way it treats wages. The exception for not counting certain government payments is for things like Supplemental Security Income, not unemployment. The NOA usually spells out exactly which income type was used.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorYeah, the NOA actually lists it under 'income counted' and labels it as unemployment compensation. So it seems like the county did it right, as much as I hate that answer.
0 coins
Zane Gray
Pending was all BenefitsCal showed on my case for weeks after I applied, and when the BIC never arrived after my approval I had no way to confirm anything had actually been mailed. I tried the Medi-Cal line a few times and kept running into holds that went nowhere. Eventually I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with the Medi-Cal line for you so you end up speaking directly with a live agent. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. The agent pulled up my case and confirmed the BIC had been sent to an old address I hadn't updated after I moved. She told me to report the address change through BenefitsCal and contact my county office so they could send a new one to the right place. That's exactly what I did, and the card showed up about two weeks after I reported the update.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorWow, good to know that option exists for the phone line. I've been dreading the hold situation. My problem is probably not fixable by phone since the denial seems accurate, but filing for a Covered CA plan might mean I need to reach someone to understand what my options are.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
The address thing gets so many people. If anything on your case has wrong contact info, letters and cards end up lost and you have no idea until something breaks.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Wait — if unemployment counts as income and you're over the limit, does that mean you have no coverage at all right now? Like, is there any kind of Medi-Cal you could still qualify for even if you're over the regular income threshold?
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
For most adults under 65, it really is just the income-based Medi-Cal, and if you're over the limit, that's the denial. But the NOA should say whether you were considered for other programs. Some situations — like a disability — open up other pathways, but those have their own eligibility rules and sometimes look at assets too.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorMine just says the income-based program and doesn't mention other categories. I don't have a disability claim or anything like that, so I think I'm just in Covered CA territory now.
0 coins
Bruno Simmons
Covered CA plans with a subsidy can actually be pretty reasonable if your income is at the level where unemployment puts you. The subsidy is based on how close you are to the poverty line, so being just over Medi-Cal's threshold doesn't mean you pay full price for a plan.
0 coins
Monique Byrd
I had a denial for the same reason two years ago — my unemployment check each week looked small but when the county multiplied it out monthly it crossed the line. What I didn't know was that if my unemployment ran out or got reduced, I could reapply for Medi-Cal immediately. You don't have to wait for a renewal cycle or anything. The day your income drops back below the limit, you can put in a new application.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorThat's actually really helpful. My benefit is only approved through the end of the year, so if I haven't found a job by then my income drops to zero and I'd want to know I can reapply right away.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
Reapplying as soon as income changes is the right move. The county goes by what your income looks like at the time of the new application, not what it was when you were denied before.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
I want to push back a little on just accepting the denial. Even if unemployment counts as income, the county has to use the right figure. Did the NOA say what weekly amount they used? Because if EDD adjusted your payment at any point and the county used your original award amount instead of the adjusted one, the math could be wrong in a way that would change the outcome.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorGood point — my EDD amount did get adjusted once after a weekly certification issue. The NOA lists a figure that matches my original award, not the adjusted lower amount. I might actually have grounds to contact the county on this.
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
If the county used an income figure that doesn't match what you're actually receiving, that's worth flagging. You can contact the county office and show them the corrected EDD documentation, or upload it in BenefitsCal as a reported change. If the adjusted amount puts you back under the limit, the county may need to look at the case again.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
Exactly. And if they still say no after you show them the right number, that's when the State Fair Hearing option matters — you'd have documentation that the income used was incorrect.
0 coins
Haley Stokes
NOBODY explained this to me when I got denied. I thought unemployment was totally separate from Medi-Cal income counting because it's from the government. I argued with the county worker for like twenty minutes before she showed me in the rules. It is 100% counted, same as a paycheck. Lost that whole argument lol.
0 coins
Aileen Rodriguez
I literally thought the same thing before this thread. Makes sense now that I read it out more carefully but it's genuinely counterintuitive.
0 coins
Monique Byrd
The 'government payment' logic trips a lot of people up. Things like SSI are excluded, but unemployment, disability insurance from the state — most of those count. The NOA lists exactly which income types went in, which is the fastest way to check.
0 coins
Bruno Simmons
The Covered CA option when you get a Medi-Cal denial is worth taking seriously. You have a special enrollment period triggered by the denial — you don't have to wait for open enrollment. The denial NOA is essentially your documentation that you need to move to a different coverage type, and Covered CA will want to see it.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorDoes the special enrollment period have a deadline from the denial date? I've had the NOA for about two weeks already.
0 coins
Bruno Simmons
Covered CA's enrollment windows are their own rules and I'd check directly with them on the timeline. The number is 1-800-300-1506. I wouldn't sit on it too long though given that you're currently uninsured.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Two weeks out from the denial and uninsured is stressful. Getting to Covered CA quickly makes sense, especially if the adjusted EDD amount still puts you over Medi-Cal's limit after the county looks at it.
0 coins
Asher Levin
I keep seeing people say to just accept the Medi-Cal denial and move to Covered CA, but has anyone actually tried appealing when unemployment is the income? I want to know if there's any angle where the hearing goes differently.
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
If the county used the right income figure and you're genuinely over the limit, a State Fair Hearing isn't going to change the eligibility rule itself — the hearing judge can't override the income threshold. What a hearing can do is catch a mistake in how the county calculated your income, or whether they should have considered another program. So the appeal is worth something only if the county got the numbers wrong or missed something.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
The case in this thread might actually be one where the hearing matters — if the county used the original EDD award instead of the adjusted lower amount, that's exactly the kind of factual error a hearing can fix. The poster should check that before writing off the appeal option.
0 coins
Serene Snow
Moving from one county to another while my Medi-Cal case was open caused so much confusion that I eventually ended up on the phone trying to sort it out. I'd been reporting my new address in BenefitsCal but wasn't sure the Inter-County Transfer had actually started. Used Claimyr to get a live Medi-Cal agent on the line — it holds the place in the queue so you're the one talking to the agent. She looked up my case and confirmed the ICT was initiated and told me my old county's managed care plan would end at the close of that month and I'd need to pick a plan in my new county through Health Care Options. That was exactly the information I needed to stop worrying and get the new plan sorted.
0 coins
Asher Levin
The ICT process stressed me out when I moved counties too. Good to know there's a way to actually confirm it's moving and not just sitting somewhere.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
Health Care Options at 1-800-430-4263 is the number for the plan selection piece once the transfer is confirmed. Good to have that separate from the county Medi-Cal line.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
Have you looked into whether any of your medical bills from before the denial could be covered retroactively? I know Medi-Cal has something for old bills from the months before you applied, and even if you end up not qualifying going forward, there might be something there for bills you already have.
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
Retroactive Medi-Cal covers bills from up to three months before your application date, but only if you would have qualified in those earlier months. If your unemployment income was the same back then and already put you over the limit, retroactive coverage likely wouldn't apply either. Worth asking the county office about your specific situation though.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorI didn't have any major bills in those months, so I think this is less of an issue for me personally, but I didn't even know that program existed. Good to know for the future.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
My sister kept telling me unemployment didn't count as income for Medi-Cal because she'd heard it somewhere, so I didn't even think to appeal when I got denied — I thought the denial itself was wrong. Turns out she was mixing it up with how some other programs count it. Ended up six weeks without coverage because I was waiting for a 'correction' that was never coming.
0 coins
Monique Byrd
Six weeks uninsured while waiting is rough. The right move when you're not sure if a denial is an error is to contact the county directly and ask them to walk you through the income calculation on the NOA. If the numbers are right, at least you know and can move on to Covered CA.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorYeah, I'm glad I asked here before assuming the denial was a mistake and just sitting on it. Sounds like the fastest path is confirming the income figure and then getting to Covered CA if it's accurate.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Is the State Fair Hearing thing actually useful, or is it just a way for people to feel like they did something? I've never heard of anyone actually winning one over an income calculation.
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
Hearings are genuinely useful when the county made a factual error — wrong income figure, didn't count the right household size, missed a document you sent in. If the rule was applied correctly to the right facts, the hearing judge follows the same rules the county does. It's not a way around the income limit, but it is a check on whether the county applied the limit to accurate information.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
I've seen people get coverage reinstated through hearings specifically because the income used was outdated or based on a document the county got wrong. It's not a hail mary, it's a fact-check with a neutral judge.
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
Did you try asking the county to reconsider before filing for a hearing? I think there's a step where you can just contact the eligibility worker and show them corrected information without going all the way to a formal appeal. That's what I did when my renewal got messed up — I didn't have to request a hearing, I just brought in the right documents.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorI didn't know that was an option. Can you just upload corrected documents through BenefitsCal and message the county, or does it have to be in person?
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
You can report changes and upload documents through BenefitsCal, and you can also contact the county office by phone or in person. Getting it in writing through BenefitsCal gives you a record of when you submitted things. I did mine in person but either way should work.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
Doing both — uploading in BenefitsCal and following up with the county office by phone — means you have documentation and confirmation. If they're using the wrong EDD figure, getting the corrected one in front of them quickly matters.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
Two pay stubs listed in BenefitsCal as 'uploaded' on my pending application and still no movement after five weeks. I had no idea which documents the county was actually still waiting on. I tried Claimyr to reach a live agent on the Medi-Cal line, and she told me one of the two stubs I'd uploaded wasn't showing as received on the county's end — the file had an issue — and that she could see they were waiting for a current bank statement I didn't know was needed. I sent both things the same day and got my NOA about ten days later.
0 coins
Asher Levin
The file not showing as received thing is terrifying. You think you did everything right and the county is seeing something completely different.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
So BenefitsCal showing 'uploaded' doesn't mean the county sees it as received? That's a gap I had no idea existed.
0 coins
Romeo Barrett
That's what the agent told me — there can be a difference between what BenefitsCal shows on your end and what comes through on the case. Getting a worker to confirm what's actually showing on the case is the only way to know for sure.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
I went through a Medi-Cal denial last spring and the thing that really helped me understand it was asking the county eligibility worker to explain the income calculation line by line. They're usually willing to do that over the phone or in person, and it either confirms the denial is right or surfaces the mistake. Either way you're not guessing.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorThat's what I'm going to do — call the county and ask them to walk through the numbers with me, specifically comparing the EDD figure they used to my adjusted award letter.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
Bring the EDD letter that shows the adjusted amount when you call or if you go in. The worker can see your case in real time and if the figure is wrong they can note it on the spot.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
I keep second-guessing myself about whether I should file for the State Fair Hearing now just to protect myself while I figure out if the income figure is wrong, or if that's premature. Like, can you request a hearing and then drop it if you work it out with the county directly?
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
You can request a hearing and also work directly with the county at the same time — they're not mutually exclusive. If you get it resolved with the county before the hearing date, you can withdraw the request. The main reason to file sooner is the 90-day window from the NOA date: if you wait too long and can't reach the county in time, you lose the hearing option.
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
Filing it as a precaution while you work on the income figure correction is actually the more careful move. You're not locked in to going through the hearing if the county fixes it.
0 coins
Alana Willis
The yellow renewal envelope showed up while I was dealing with a job change, and I returned the form but had no confirmation the county received it before the due date. I tried Claimyr to reach a Medi-Cal agent, and while I was on the phone she confirmed the renewal form had been received and logged two days before the due date. That was all I needed to know — my case was fine and I didn't need to do anything else before the renewal date.
0 coins
Justin Trejo
Good to know there's a way to confirm receipt. I always assumed if I sent it in I'd just have to wait and hope.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
The county getting the form and your end showing it sent are two different things, same as the document upload issue someone mentioned earlier in the thread. Confirming directly is the only clean answer.
0 coins
Bruno Simmons
If your adjusted EDD amount does end up putting you back under the Medi-Cal income limit and the county reopens the case, make sure you understand what coverage start date would look like. The Notice of Action is what tells you when coverage begins — don't assume it goes back to your original application date automatically.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorNoted — I'll read whatever NOA comes out of this carefully and not assume anything about dates.
0 coins
Monique Byrd
The NOA is the document that settles the start date question. Everything else is a guess until that letter comes.
0 coins
Lia Quinn
If the county confirms they did use the wrong EDD figure and they correct it and approve you, ask them specifically whether Medi-Cal can cover any bills you had in the months since your original application date. Sometimes when a denial is reversed because of a corrected income figure, the coverage question includes what happens to the gap period.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorI hadn't even thought about that angle. If I've had any medical needs in the weeks since the denial, knowing whether those could be covered would really matter.
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
The retroactive Medi-Cal rules cover up to three months before the original application date, not necessarily the gap after a denial. What happens to a denial-to-approval period is something to ask the county office directly — the answer depends on how they process the corrected case.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
Medi-Cal Rx is a separate line if you end up with a prescription situation while this is all getting sorted — 1-800-977-2273. If you're in a gap where your Medi-Cal hasn't been approved yet and you need medication, they may be able to help figure out what's covered under your situation.
0 coins
Teresa Boyd
AuthorGenuinely good to know. I've been putting off a prescription refill because I didn't know if any coverage was active.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
Fee-for-Service Medi-Cal covers some things while a plan assignment is pending. But if the application is still denied, that probably doesn't apply until something changes.
0 coins
Asher Levin
Coming back here because I checked my own old NOA after reading this thread — the county had used an income figure on mine that I'm now not sure was correct either. I had a pay period with reduced hours right before I lost the job, and I don't know if the county averaged my income or used my final check's rate. How do I know which one the county used?
0 coins
Lourdes Fox
Your NOA should list the income amount the county counted and label it by type — wages, unemployment, etc. If it shows a monthly or annual figure, you can reverse-engineer it to see what paycheck amount they started from. If it doesn't match either your regular rate or your reduced-hours check, that's the conversation to have with your eligibility worker.
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
Bringing in multiple pay stubs — both the regular-rate ones and the reduced-hours one — when you contact the county lets the worker see the full picture and explain which figure they used and why.
0 coins