Back to Covered California

Charlotte White

Can you keep covered plan while on Medi-Cal — trying to figure out if I need to cancel

Okay so I got put on Medi-Cal a few months ago after I lost my job and my income dropped. The thing is, I had a Silver plan through Covered California before that, and I'm honestly not sure what happened to it. When I log into my account it still shows the plan listed there but I know Medi-Cal is active because I've been using that for doctor visits. My question is can you keep covered plan while on Medi-Cal, like is there some rule that you have to cancel it or does it just sit there? I haven't been paying the premium on the Covered California plan since I thought Medi-Cal replaced it automatically. Now I'm worried I might owe back premiums or that my Medi-Cal could get messed up somehow. Really just trying to understand what I'm supposed to do here and whether I need to contact anyone.

Cancellation date on my Covered California plan was something I had no idea about until I actually phoned in. I enrolled in Medi-Cal mid-year after a job change, and my Covered California plan was still showing as active in the account for weeks after. I let Claimyr (claimyr.com) handle the hold time, and the representative found that my plan had not been cancelled yet — the cancellation request was still needed from my side, and she told me the last day it would be in effect once I submitted the request through the account. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Covered California: https://youtu.be/9y0sXw7pbJU. I went into the account that same day, submitted the cancellation for the end of the month, and no more premium came out after that. If your plan is still showing active and you're not paying the premium, the insurance company may treat that as a missed payment and cancel for nonpayment — which is a different kind of cancel than doing it yourself.

0 coins

The plan still showing in the account even after Medi-Cal started — did the representative say whether any months of that plan were actually billed to you while Medi-Cal was running? Asking because I'm in almost the same spot and have no idea if I owe anything to the insurance company for the overlap period.

0 coins

She didn't say anything about what I owed the insurance company — that part she said to take up with them directly. What she confirmed was the date the cancellation would take effect once I submitted it, and that was the piece I actually needed. The insurance company side of a bill question is their territory, not Covered California's.

0 coins

Not paying and waiting for it to cancel on its own sounds easier but it really isn't. If the insurance company closes the plan for nonpayment, you may not be able to come back until the next open enrollment or a qualifying life event. Submitting the actual cancel request through the account is the cleaner way out.

0 coins

I used to think being enrolled in Medi-Cal automatically ended any Covered California plan at the same time. Turns out that's not how it works — I had both technically active for about six weeks because nobody cancelled anything. My cousin was in a similar situation and kept paying the Covered California premium for two months before she figured out what was going on. The two programs don't talk to each other in real time and cancel one when the other starts. You have to go in yourself and submit the cancellation for the Covered California plan.

0 coins

Both active at the same time for six weeks — does that mean you were getting billed for the Covered California plan the entire time Medi-Cal was also running? That's what I'm afraid happened to me.

0 coins

Yeah, the Covered California plan's insurance company kept sending a bill during those weeks. I called them and they handled the adjustment for the period after Medi-Cal started, but I had to explain the situation. Covered California's part was just submitting the cancellation — the billing dispute was entirely with the insurance company.

0 coins

Covered California and the insurance company really are two separate things here. The rule is that Covered California handles the enrollment and the cancellation request; the insurance company handles the bill. Those are two different calls if something went wrong on both sides.

0 coins

The way it was explained to me by an enroller when I had a similar transition: Medi-Cal and a Covered California private plan can't both be covering the same person at the same time in a way that makes practical sense — you'd be paying a premium for a plan you're not supposed to be using if Medi-Cal is active. The right move is to cancel the Covered California plan with an end date that lines up with when Medi-Cal started. The account lets you pick the end date when you submit the cancel request; you want the last day of the month that Medi-Cal began.

0 coins

Can you actually go back and pick an end date that already passed, or does the system only let you pick future dates? I'm asking because if the person above has had Medi-Cal for a few months already, they might need a retroactive cancel date.

0 coins

Covered California's site says you generally can't cancel for months that have already passed. For anything involving an end date in prior months, the person would need to contact the service center to see how that gets handled — it's not something you can just do in the account on your own.

0 coins

Retroactive cancellations are definitely something to ask the service center about rather than assume. The account tool is straightforward for future dates but anything in the past is a different conversation.

0 coins

I went through almost this exact thing last year. When my income dropped and I ended up on Medi-Cal, I assumed the Covered California plan would just drop off. It did not. I had to log in, go to my account, and submit a cancellation request. The site says to do it at least 14 days before the date you want it to end so the end date lands on the last day of the month. I also want to be clear: Covered California can't refund premiums you already paid to the insurance company — that part has to be handled with the insurer separately.

0 coins

The 14-day thing is what worries me — I've been sitting on this for a few months without doing anything, so I'm definitely not getting a retroactive end date through the normal process. Sounds like I need to call the service center.

0 coins

Phoning in is probably the right next step at this point. The account is good for future-dated cancellations where you have enough lead time, but for anything more complicated the service center is where you'd sort it out.

0 coins

Worth double-checking that Medi-Cal is fully active before submitting anything. If there's any gap or pending status on the Medi-Cal side, cancelling the Covered California plan too early could leave the person without any coverage at all.

0 coins

I want to flag something I got completely wrong when I was going through this. I thought keeping the Covered California plan open while on Medi-Cal gave me some kind of backup coverage — like if Medi-Cal denied something, I'd have the other plan to fall back on. That's not how either program works. If you're enrolled in Medi-Cal, Medi-Cal is your coverage. The Covered California plan isn't functioning as a backup; it's just generating a premium bill that isn't accomplishing anything.

0 coins

Are there any situations where someone on Medi-Cal can legitimately keep a Covered California plan at the same time, or is it always one or the other? I keep seeing people ask this and nobody seems to give a clear answer.

0 coins

The application determines eligibility — if someone qualifies for Medi-Cal based on income and household size, that's what the application sends them to. A person can't be on Medi-Cal and also receiving the premium tax credit on a Covered California plan at the same time, because Medi-Cal eligibility means you don't qualify for the APTC. Someone could pay full price for a Covered California plan without any financial help while also being on Medi-Cal, but that would be an unusual situation and not the norm.

0 coins

The income side of this is what trips most people up. The premium tax credit is tied to income and household size, and once someone qualifies for Medi-Cal the financial help on a Covered California plan goes away. So even if you kept the plan, you'd be paying the full premium with no APTC. Most people cancel once they realize that.

0 coins

Application submission date was the first thing I wanted confirmed when I phoned in earlier this year — I'd had a plan through Covered California and also ended up on Medi-Cal at the same time after a household income change, and I wasn't sure if the transition had even processed correctly. Claimyr sat on hold for me that afternoon, and the representative confirmed the date my updated application had gone through and that the case had moved to the county for Medi-Cal review. She also said the Covered California plan was still showing active and that I would need to submit the cancellation myself. I went in and did that before the end of the week.

0 coins

The case moving to the county for Medi-Cal review — does that mean Covered California itself is no longer involved at that point, or does the service center still handle questions about the plan cancellation side?

0 coins

Covered California still handles the plan cancellation — that part stays on the Covered California side even after Medi-Cal picks up the eligibility question. The county handles the Medi-Cal case itself, but the cancellation of the private plan is submitted through the Covered California account or by phoning the service center.

0 coins

The county and Covered California really do operate separately here. I had a question about my Medi-Cal benefits after the transition and was told by the service center to contact my county office for anything on the Medi-Cal side. The Covered California service center will only answer about the enrollment and the plan.

0 coins

My plan kept showing in the account for so long after Medi-Cal started that I genuinely thought there must be a reason — like maybe Covered California was keeping it in reserve or something. There's no such thing. The plan just stays there until you cancel it, the insurance company keeps expecting payment, and if you stop paying they cancel for nonpayment on their own timetable. Neither outcome is as clean as submitting the cancellation yourself through the account.

0 coins

Cancelled for nonpayment by the insurance company is actually worse than a voluntary cancellation in terms of what happens next. With a voluntary cancel you know the exact end date. With a nonpayment cancel the insurance company picks the date and you may not find out until you try to use the plan or get a notice.

0 coins

That was exactly what I was afraid of — finding out the plan was cancelled on some date I didn't choose when I needed something from the insurance company. Submitting the cancel yourself at least gives you the end date in writing.

0 coins

Had a family member whose kids were on Medi-Cal and the parents were on a Covered California Silver plan — that's a situation where two programs really do coexist in one household. The kids were covered through Medi-Cal, the parents had the private plan. So it's not that you can never have both in a household, it's that the same person generally can't use both at once. The application sorts all of this out based on each person's income and situation.

0 coins

Mixed families like that are pretty common — Covered California calls them mixed-program families. Each person in the household lands where their own eligibility puts them. The parents' plan and the kids' Medi-Cal run side by side without any conflict.

0 coins

Does a mixed-program household file one application or separate ones for the parents and the kids? I always assumed it was separate but maybe not.

0 coins

It's one application for the whole household. The application checks everyone's eligibility at the same time — Medi-Cal for some members, a Covered California plan for others, depending on income and household size. You don't file separately.

0 coins

I called the service center a while back when I was in a similar situation — plan still showing, Medi-Cal active, didn't know what to do. The hold time was rough on a Tuesday afternoon. The person I eventually reached told me to submit the cancellation for the last day of the current month and that the account would confirm the end date. After I submitted it, the plan showed as ending on that date and the insurance company stopped billing.

0 coins

The account showing the end date after the cancel was submitted — did it update right away or did it take a couple of days before you could see the confirmed date in there?

0 coins

Mine updated pretty quickly, within the same day if I remember right. But I wouldn't count on that being the same for everyone — the account just showed the end date I'd selected and confirmed the request was in.

0 coins

Before I dealt with my own cancellation I had the same question as you but about a renewal — I'd done nothing during renewal and wasn't sure what plan the account had defaulted me into. Getting through to the service center took forever. I tried again the next morning and finally got through; the representative told me which plan the renewal had kept and when the renewal deadline had passed. That was the information I needed to decide whether to cancel or switch during the remaining window.

0 coins

The renewal defaulting you into something you didn't actively pick — that's something I hadn't even thought about. So if someone does nothing during renewal while they're on Medi-Cal, Covered California just re-enrolls them in the same plan automatically?

0 coins

That's what the renewal does if you take no action — it keeps you in the same plan with the same household and income on file. If you're on Medi-Cal at the time, you'd still have the Covered California plan renewed unless you cancel it. The renewal doesn't check whether Medi-Cal is active.

0 coins

Automatic re-enrollment is the default during open enrollment if nothing is changed. For someone in this situation it's one more reason to submit the cancellation before the renewal period rather than letting it roll over.

0 coins

Tried to figure out from the account itself whether my Medi-Cal was really active before I cancelled the other plan. The Covered California account doesn't actually show your Medi-Cal status — it only shows the plan you enrolled in through Covered California. For Medi-Cal status you have to either contact your county office or look for the notice Medi-Cal would have sent you confirming enrollment.

0 coins

That's something a lot of people get confused about — thinking the Covered California account shows everything. It only shows what's in Covered California's system. Medi-Cal sits with the county and doesn't appear in the Covered California account view.

0 coins

My county sent a letter when Medi-Cal was approved. That letter was the confirmation. The Covered California account just kept showing the old plan like nothing had changed.

0 coins

Waiting to cancel the Covered California plan until you have written confirmation from the county that Medi-Cal is fully active is the safer move. Cancel too early and find out Medi-Cal wasn't actually in effect yet, and you'd have a gap.

0 coins

Plan start date on my account had me completely confused during my own transition — I saw a date listed and didn't know if it meant the Covered California plan was still active from that date forward or if the Medi-Cal start date was what I should be looking at. I ended up talking to a Covered California representative through Claimyr, who pulled up the account and confirmed the date the Covered California plan was scheduled to begin in a previous enrollment and that it was currently still active. That was what I needed to hear before I submitted the cancellation.

0 coins

The start date and the active status being two different things in the account — did you end up being billed for the period between that start date and when you finally cancelled?

0 coins

The billing question was between me and the insurance company. What the representative confirmed was just the enrollment status and the plan's start date — she was clear that anything about the actual bill was for me to take up with the insurer. I submitted the cancellation for the end of the following month and the plan showed as ending then.

0 coins

Covered California's role really is just the enrollment record — active, cancelled, the dates. What the insurance company charged during that time is entirely separate and that's where you have to follow up if there are billing questions.

0 coins

Renewal deadline and the plan the account had me in were the two things I needed to confirm after my income changed mid-year. I let Claimyr do the waiting so I didn't have to sit on hold, and the representative read out the renewal deadline and confirmed the plan the account had renewed me into. She also said I could still cancel if I did it in time. That was the conversation that finally got me moving on the actual cancel request in the account.

0 coins

Phoning to confirm those two things before making a move is exactly what I should have done when I was in the same position. I guessed at the renewal date and almost missed the window to do anything.

0 coins

Confirming the plan name before you cancel is especially important if you're in a mixed household where some members are on Medi-Cal and others have a Covered California plan — you want to make sure you're only cancelling the right person's enrollment.

0 coins

Someone upthread mentioned the 14-day rule for submitting a cancellation before the end date you want. I want to make sure that's clear for anyone reading: Covered California's own guidance says to submit the cancellation at least 14 days before the date you want coverage to end, with the end date being the last day of a month. If you need it to end June 30, the request goes in by June 16. That math matters if you're close to the end of the month.

0 coins

The 14-day rule — does that apply even if you're trying to cancel because you've been on Medi-Cal for months already? Because 14 days works fine going forward but doesn't help the person sort out the past months.

0 coins

For past months the account can't process a retroactive cancel on its own. That's a service center call. The 14-day rule is for future-dated cancellations where you're doing it yourself through the account.

0 coins

Phoning the service center for anything involving a date that's already passed is the right call. The account tool for cancellations is clean and straightforward for future dates, but once you're asking about months that are already gone it needs a human on the other end.

0 coins

What nobody told me when I first landed on Medi-Cal was that the premium tax credit doesn't work once Medi-Cal is your coverage. I'd been on Medi-Cal for three months and still had a Covered California plan in my account that was supposedly getting APTC applied to it. When I finally sorted it all out, the APTC shouldn't have been applied for those months since I was Medi-Cal-eligible — that created a tax situation I had to deal with the following year at filing time. I'm not a tax person so I can't say exactly what that means for anyone else, but I'll just say make sure you deal with this promptly rather than letting it drift.

0 coins

The APTC and Medi-Cal eligibility being in conflict is something a lot of people don't think about until tax season. The recommendation in a situation like this is to cancel the Covered California plan as soon as Medi-Cal is confirmed active so the financial help stops being applied incorrectly going forward.

0 coins

Exactly what I'd tell anyone now. And for the tax side of whatever I owed, I had to talk to a tax preparer — that part is not something the service center weighs in on. They handled the enrollment record; the tax question was separate.

0 coins

Tax implications from overlapping enrollment are definitely something for a tax professional or the Franchise Tax Board, not the service center. The service center can confirm enrollment dates and when the financial help was applied, but they won't tell you what it means on your return.

0 coins

My situation was a little different — I moved from out of state, applied through Covered California, and ended up getting sent to Medi-Cal because my income was low enough. I had no idea that one application handled both and that Covered California would route me to Medi-Cal automatically. So I never even had a Covered California plan to cancel; the application just went straight to the county. That part was confusing to understand at first but it made sense once I re-read the eligibility results in my account.

0 coins

The application routing you to Medi-Cal without you choosing it — did your account still show any Covered California plan listed, or was it completely blank on the private plan side?

0 coins

Completely blank on the Covered California plan side. The account showed my eligibility results and said the case was sent to the county for Medi-Cal. No private plan was ever assigned to me. It was only the original question you posted that made me realize some people have both listed at the same time.

0 coins

That routing to the county is what's supposed to happen when Medi-Cal is the right program for someone's income and household. The confusion happens when a person already had a Covered California plan before their income changed and the system didn't automatically close the old one out.

0 coins

I'll add something from my own enroller experience since I've seen this question from clients a few times. The clearest way I know to put it: the two programs can exist in one household but the same individual generally can't be drawing from both at the same time. If you qualified for Medi-Cal, that's the program for you. The Covered California plan staying open doesn't mean Covered California is covering you — it means the insurance company is still expecting a premium check that you may or may not be sending.

0 coins

The insurance company expecting a premium check even though Medi-Cal is active — does the insurance company know Medi-Cal started, or are they just billing based on whatever the original enrollment said?

0 coins

They bill based on what their enrollment record shows. The insurance company doesn't automatically find out when Medi-Cal starts; Covered California's cancellation request is what triggers the notification on that side. Until the cancel is in, the insurer bills as if the enrollment is still active.

0 coins

Submit the cancellation, then follow up with the insurance company directly about anything that happened during the overlap. That's the two-step most people end up having to take when they let this run too long.

0 coins

Reading through all of this I realize I had the same misunderstanding as the person who posted originally — I assumed the two programs couldn't coexist even in a household and that one must have been a mistake. The mixed-program family situation clears that up. Kids on Medi-Cal, parents on a Covered California plan is totally normal. The mistake is one individual being enrolled in both and paying for a plan that Medi-Cal is replacing.

0 coins

Is there any notice from Covered California when someone becomes Medi-Cal eligible mid-year? I'd think there should be some kind of message in the account saying the plan is no longer appropriate.

0 coins

There's usually a notice about the eligibility change, and the account should reflect the updated eligibility results. But the cancellation of the old plan doesn't happen automatically — that action still falls to the person. The notice informs; it doesn't cancel.

0 coins

That's the gap that trips people up. Getting a notice saying you now qualify for Medi-Cal doesn't mean the Covered California plan was ended. You still have to go submit the cancel request or call the service center, especially if the transition happened months ago.

0 coins

Coming back here because I finally got some resolution. I phoned the service center and explained that Medi-Cal had been active for about three months while the Covered California plan was still showing open and unpaid. The representative confirmed the plan was still active in the account and walked me through submitting the cancellation for the end of this month — the soonest future date that works with the 14-day lead time. For the billing questions about the months I didn't pay, she said to contact the insurance company. So that's my next call. At least I know what I'm dealing with now.

0 coins

Getting the cancellation submitted is the right first move — billing cleanup with the insurance company goes a lot smoother once the enrollment is officially closed on the Covered California side.

0 coins

Glad you got through to someone. The end-of-month end date is the right choice — cleaner than mid-month and no ambiguity about when the plan stops and when any other coverage has to pick up.

0 coins

Related posts

Covered California AI

Expert Assistant
Secure