Back to Arizona Unemployment

NebulaNomad

If I am terminated for poor performance can I collect unemployment? Arizona DES rules explained

So my manager pulled me in last Thursday and let me go. The reason on my termination paperwork says 'performance not meeting company standards' - no write-ups, no formal warnings, just suddenly gone after 14 months at this logistics company. I'm trying to figure out where I stand with Arizona DES because I keep reading conflicting things online. Some sites say getting fired automatically disqualifies you, others say it depends on the situation. My biggest question is: if I am terminated for poor performance can I collect unemployment? I need to know before I spend time filing because I really can't afford to waste any more time right now. Bills are due, savings are thin, and I have no idea how long adjudication might take even if I do qualify.

Performance terminations are actually one of the more claimant-friendly situations in Arizona DES's eligibility rules. The key thing to understand is that Arizona DES distinguishes between being fired for misconduct versus being fired because you just weren't cutting it at the job. Poor performance without deliberate wrongdoing on your part is generally NOT considered disqualifying misconduct. You should file right away - don't wait. Even if adjudication takes a few weeks, your benefit year starts from when you file, not when you're approved.

0 coins

Wait so the fact that there were no write-ups or warnings - does that actually help my case or is it irrelevant to DES?

0 coins

It can actually help you a lot. If your employer tries to claim misconduct, the lack of documented warnings makes it harder for them to prove you were warned and willfully continued the behavior. Keep any emails or records showing you were trying to do the job.

0 coins

This matches what happened to my brother-in-law. Got let go for 'not meeting targets' in sales and DES approved him no problem. The employer didn't even contest it.

0 coins

Spent probably 6 hours total trying to reach Arizona DES by phone after my own termination situation last spring. What finally got me actually talking to a live agent was using Claimyr - it basically works through the hold queue for you so you end up speaking directly with someone at DES. The site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y that shows exactly what it does. I needed to ask about whether my situation counted as misconduct or performance and I genuinely could not get through any other way.

0 coins

Claimyr is new to me - did you have any trouble with it or was it pretty straightforward to set up?

0 coins

Straightforward for me. Within a reasonable amount of time I had an actual DES agent on the line explaining exactly how my termination would be categorized. Worth it just for the peace of mind of hearing it from an actual person.

0 coins

Bookmarking this, I've been trying to reach DES for two weeks about a totally different issue and can't get through to save my life.

0 coins

Ask Arizona DES specifically this: 'Was there a deliberate act on my part that caused the termination?' That's really the crux of the whole thing. Because here's how it works - Arizona law says you're disqualified for misconduct, and misconduct means you deliberately did something wrong or ignored rules you knew about. Struggling to perform a job, not being fast enough, not hitting numbers, not clicking with the management style - none of that is deliberate wrongdoing. It's just not working out. DES agents hear this distinction all day long.

0 coins

Makes sense. My old boss actually told me verbally I was 'just not a good fit' before the HR paperwork said performance. Does what he said matter at all?

0 coins

Document that verbal statement however you can - even just write down the date and exact words in a note to yourself right now. If this goes to adjudication and your former employer contests your claim, the 'not a good fit' language strongly suggests they can't point to specific willful misconduct.

0 coins

my manager said the same thing to me once and i still got disqualified lol so it really depends on what the employer writes on the DES separation paperwork more than what they said out loud

0 coins

Filed and got approved after a performance termination two years ago at a warehouse job. The whole adjudication process took about 11 days in my case. What helped was that when I filed I was really specific in describing that I was not warned, not given a performance improvement plan, and was not accused of theft, insubordination, or any policy violation. I basically described it as 'employer decided my output wasn't meeting expectations' and left it at that. DES approved without asking me for additional information.

0 coins

11 days is way faster than what I was mentally preparing for. Did you have to submit any documentation during that period?

0 coins

Not in my case - they just reviewed what I submitted in the initial filing and what the employer reported. Some people do get asked for more info though, so just be ready with any emails or documents if they come back to you.

0 coins

11 days sounds like a dream. Mine took 31 days and I nearly lost my apartment waiting. And I was approved in the end too which made the whole wait feel even more unnecessary.

0 coins

the timeframe varies SO much. heard of people getting approved in a week and others waiting two months for the exact same situation basically

0 coins

One thing people get confused about: 'terminated for cause' doesn't automatically mean DES will deny you. Employers sometimes use that phrase loosely to mean anything other than a layoff. What actually matters to Arizona DES is whether the reason qualifies as statutory misconduct under ARS 23-619.01. Performance issues typically don't meet that legal threshold. File your claim, answer everything honestly, and let the adjudication process work.

0 coins

ARS 23-619.01 is worth looking up if you want to understand exactly what DES considers misconduct. The legal language is dry but it basically confirms what everyone here is saying - performance alone isn't it.

0 coins

Okay this is really helpful context. So even if my termination paperwork says 'terminated for cause' I shouldn't panic about that specific wording?

0 coins

Correct - don't let that phrase throw you. The DES adjudicator looks at the actual facts, not just what box the employer checked. 'For cause' is not a legal determination of misconduct, it's just employer HR language.

0 coins

BEEN THROUGH THIS. My former employer tried to claim I was fired for 'repeated poor performance and failure to improve' and DES still approved me because they couldn't show I was deliberately ignoring feedback or willfully doing a bad job. I contested their characterization during adjudication and won. The whole appeals system exists for exactly this reason - even if you get denied initially, you can fight it.

0 coins

How did you contest it - like what did you actually submit or say to DES to push back on the employer's version?

0 coins

Got a letter asking for my side of the story during adjudication. Wrote a detailed explanation of my work situation, mentioned there were no formal write-up documents, explained that I was doing my best given the resources I had, and said I never refused any work assignment. Kept it factual and calm.

0 coins

This is the part people don't realize - DES actually does hear your side. It's not just rubber-stamping whatever the employer says.

0 coins

Quick reality check on weekly claims since you're new to this: even while your claim is in adjudication, you need to be filing your weekly certifications. If you don't file every week, you lose those weeks permanently. Log into the CACTUS portal and file even when your status shows pending. This trips up a lot of first-timers.

0 coins

Oh wow I did not know that. So I should start filing weekly even before DES has made a decision on whether I even qualify?

0 coins

Exactly. File every week from the moment your claim is active. If you get approved, they'll pay all the weeks you filed going back to your start date. If you forgot to file some weeks, you can't reclaim that money later.

0 coins

wish someone had told me this. i missed two weeks during adjudication thinking i should wait for approval first and lost like $800 total. the DES rep told me there was nothing she could do about missed weeks.

0 coins

Something worth asking Arizona DES about directly: 'Was I given a chance to correct the performance issue before termination?' This matters because if your employer never told you there was a problem or never gave you a reasonable opportunity to improve, that actually weakens any argument that you were 'at fault' for the situation. No PIP, no written warnings, terminated without warning - that pattern tends to favor the claimant in adjudication.

0 coins

No PIP, no written warnings at all in my case. Only feedback was occasional verbal comments about being 'slower than average' but nothing documented.

0 coins

That verbal-only pattern with no documentation is a pretty common scenario that DES adjudicators see. Keep track of the fact that nothing was formalized in writing - it's relevant context for your claim.

0 coins

Using Claimyr to actually speak with a DES agent was the move for me when I had almost the exact same set of facts - performance termination, no paper trail of warnings. The agent walked me through what to include in my statement and I was approved. claimyr.com if you need to get someone on the line without spending hours on hold.

0 coins

my coworker got fired for 'not meeting productivity standards' at our old call center job and was denied at first. then she appealed and the appeal hearing officer reversed it because the employer couldn't produce any documentation that she'd been warned. So even worst case scenario of an initial denial isn't necessarily the end of the road

0 coins

How long did her appeal take from denial to the reversal?

0 coins

think it was around 6 weeks total from filing the appeal to getting the written decision. she got backpay for all the weeks she'd filed during that whole time.

0 coins

Appeals do take a while but the success rate when you have no documented warnings is actually pretty solid from what I've seen. Employers who do sloppy HR paperwork essentially help the claimant's case without realizing it.

0 coins

Ask your former employer's HR department for a copy of your personnel file before you file with DES. Here's why - you have a right to request it in Arizona and it shows you exactly what documentation they actually have on you. If the file is thin, that's good for you. If there are write-ups in there you forgot about, you want to know that before DES asks rather than being surprised. Takes maybe a week to get but worth it if you have time.

0 coins

Can they refuse to give me my own personnel file?

0 coins

Arizona doesn't have a specific statute requiring private employers to provide access, so they technically can decline. But many HR departments do provide it on request, especially after termination. Worth asking via email so you have a written record of the request.

0 coins

i didn't even think of doing this. wish i had before my adjudication because i found out later my employer had submitted a bunch of stuff DES never showed me

0 coins

For getting answers fast when you need a live human at Arizona DES - Claimyr.com is what I'd point you to. Had a termination situation where I needed to understand how DES was going to code my separation and the phone lines were impossible. Used Claimyr and ended up with a DES agent on the line who answered every specific question I had about my case. Demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y shows what to expect.

0 coins

Third time I'm seeing Claimyr mentioned in this thread - seems like it genuinely works for getting through. Going to try it since I've been trying to call DES myself and hitting walls.

0 coins

Definitely worth it for a situation like yours where you have specific questions about how your termination will be classified. Reading general information online only gets you so far - an actual agent can look at your claim and give you real answers.

0 coins

DES phone lines have been brutal lately. Called four times over three days and either got disconnected or just gave up after 90 minutes on hold each time.

0 coins

The employer also has to file separation information with DES when you file a claim. What they write in that employer response can affect your adjudication outcome. Some employers just write the basic reason and move on. Others write detailed statements trying to characterize the termination as misconduct. You have no control over what they submit but you do get a chance to respond through your own adjudication statement.

0 coins

Is there any way to find out what the employer submitted before I write my own statement?

0 coins

Not easily upfront - typically you'd see it if the claim goes to a hearing stage or if DES specifically asks you to respond to something the employer said. During initial adjudication it's usually just both sides submitting independently.

0 coins

This is exactly why your initial statement should be comprehensive. You can't anticipate every argument your former employer might make so just be thorough about describing your own situation accurately.

0 coins

just wanted to say this thread helped me too. been sitting on the same question for a week because i was scared to file thinking i'd definitely be denied for getting fired. going to go file right now based on what everyone here said

0 coins

Honestly same - I was really hesitant to even start the process. Good luck with your claim.

0 coins

File sooner rather than later. Every day you wait is a day you won't get paid even if you're approved. Arizona DES doesn't backdate further than your filing date.

0 coins

One more thing: job search requirements kick in immediately once you file. Arizona DES requires you to document job search activities every week - at least two verifiable employer contacts per week. Some people get approved and then lose benefits partway through because they weren't keeping their job search log current. Make sure you understand that requirement from day one.

0 coins

Two contacts per week - does that mean actual applications or can it include things like attending a job fair or setting up an Indeed profile?

0 coins

Applications and direct employer contacts are the main ones DES wants to see. Job fairs can count as one contact. Just setting up a profile by itself probably won't count - you need active outreach to specific employers each week.

0 coins

ARIZONA@WORK career centers can also help you track this stuff and they're free. Some locations will even verify your job search activities for you which is helpful if DES ever audits your log.

0 coins

didn't realize the job search requirement starts immediately and not just after you're approved. good to know

0 coins

My situation was similar - let go for 'consistent underperformance' in a customer service role, had been there almost two years. Filed with Arizona DES fully expecting to fight for it. Got approved in adjudication without having to do anything extra beyond the initial filing. I think the fact that I'd been there almost two years actually helped because it showed I wasn't a problem employee who kept getting fired everywhere.

0 coins

14 months at this company for me - hopefully that works in a similar way.

0 coins

Tenure does seem to matter in how DES weighs things. Someone who lasts over a year at a job is harder to characterize as a generally problematic employee.

0 coins

Makes sense. 14 months is solid. If you were really the nightmare employee your former employer wants to claim you are, they would have done something about it way earlier.

0 coins

Something I never see mentioned: if DES approves you but the employer appeals the determination, you're still entitled to continue receiving benefits during the employer appeal process. Don't stop filing your weekly claims if you hear your former employer is contesting the DES decision. You keep getting paid while the appeal plays out and you only have to repay if you ultimately lose at the highest appeal level AND the board decides it was fraud-related.

0 coins

Wait so the employer can appeal AFTER DES already approved me? I didn't know that was a possibility.

0 coins

Yes, both sides can appeal. If DES approves you, employer has 15 days to appeal. If DES denies you, you have 15 days to appeal. That's why you absolutely keep filing every week no matter what.

0 coins

This is really important information. People sometimes panic when they hear 'employer is appealing' and stop filing. Don't stop. Keep filing every single week.

0 coins

I went through an employer appeal and kept receiving benefits throughout the whole process. DES upheld their approval at the appeal hearing and I never had to pay anything back.

0 coins

Ask yourself this before filing: 'Did I do anything that someone could call intentional rule-breaking?' If the answer is genuinely no - you weren't stealing, weren't insubordinate, weren't showing up drunk, weren't harassing anyone - then performance is basically your answer and performance is typically not disqualifying. Arizona DES sees hundreds of these cases. You're not in uncharted territory.

0 coins

No, nothing like that at all. It was purely output-related - not fast enough, not hitting productivity metrics. No behavioral issues, no policy violations.

0 coins

Output-based termination with no behavioral component is about as clean a performance case as you can have. File your claim and don't overthink the eligibility question.

0 coins

This framing really helps actually. Breaking it down into 'was it intentional rule-breaking' vs 'was I just not good at the job' makes it much clearer.

0 coins

Last thing worth knowing: even if adjudication takes longer than expected, you can contact Arizona DES to check on status. The CACTUS portal sometimes shows a status of 'pending' for weeks without updating even when someone is actively reviewing your case. If you've been waiting more than 3 weeks with no movement, reaching out is worth it. Claimyr is an option worth considering for getting through to an agent if the standard phone lines are killing you - claimyr.com.

0 coins

Good to know there's a way to push for status updates without just sitting and waiting indefinitely.

0 coins

DES agents can actually see notes on your file and tell you where things stand - whether it's waiting on employer response, assigned to an adjudicator, etc. That information isn't visible in the portal but it exists on their end.

0 coins

Three weeks is a reasonable benchmark before escalating. Under that, you're probably fine waiting since adjudication timelines genuinely vary that much just based on caseload.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure