Des unemployment appeal hearing what to expect quitting - my situation explained
So I walked off my job at a warehouse distribution center back in January and honestly didn't think twice about it at the time. The conditions were genuinely unsafe - broken equipment that kept getting flagged and ignored, a supervisor who screamed at people on the floor, and I'd filed two internal complaints that went nowhere. Filed for unemployment right after and got denied almost immediately. The denial letter said I voluntarily quit without good cause connected to the work, which I thought was completely wrong given everything I documented. I filed my appeal within the 30 day window and now I have a hearing scheduled for next month. I have no idea what I'm walking into. I've never done anything like this before. The letter says it'll be a phone hearing with an appeals officer, that I can bring documents, and that my former employer will likely be participating too. That last part really threw me off - I didn't realize they'd actually be there arguing against me. I've been collecting my weekly UI benefits while the appeal is processing (my claim shows approved for now pending the appeal outcome which I guess is a thing) and I've been keeping up with my job search activities logging everything in the CACTUS portal. I just don't know what the actual hearing is going to look like, what questions they'll ask, how formal it is, what happens if I lose, can I appeal again after that. Any help from people who've been through this would be really appreciated. Specifically my situation involved quitting due to working conditions so I'm wondering if that changes anything about how the hearing goes.
78 comments

Mia Roberts
Been through two of these, so let me break it down. The phone format trips people up - you'd think it's less stressful than in person but honestly it's harder because you can't read anyone's face and the pacing feels weird. The appeals officer opens by swearing everyone in, reads a brief statement about the case, and then typically asks your former employer to present their side first since the burden to show good cause for quitting falls on you as the claimant. So your employer goes, then you respond, then there's a back and forth period where both sides can ask questions. The officer asks their own questions throughout. It usually runs 45 minutes to an hour and a half depending on how complex the documentation is.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorGot it, thanks. Does the appeals officer make a decision right there at the end of the call or does it come later?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Almost always comes in writing after, usually within 2-3 weeks. They almost never announce the decision on the call itself. You'll get a written decision mailed to your address on file and it also shows up in your CACTUS account under the appeals section.
0 coins
The Boss
Yeah I had the same experience, decision came about 10 days after my hearing by mail. The officer said nothing about which way it was leaning during the whole call.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
Wait, so the employer actually participates in the hearing? I always thought the appeals were just between the claimant and DES. Didn't realize the company got to show up too.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Yep they absolutely can and often do, especially for voluntary quit cases because those are the ones where the employer has the most to gain by the denial being upheld. For layoffs it's less common but for quits, anticipate them being there.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
My former employer sent an HR rep and their own attorney to mine. I was just me with my documents. It felt really uneven honestly.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorOkay, that's honestly alarming to hear. Should I consider getting any kind of legal help or is that overkill for a UI appeal hearing?
0 coins
Jasmine Quinn
Honestly the phone hold situation with Arizona DES before my own appeal was what almost broke me. I needed to ask a specific question about submitting documentation before the hearing and I called probably 15 times over three days without getting through. A friend told me to try Claimyr - it's a service that gets you connected to an actual Arizona DES agent without you sitting on hold forever. I used it and got through in maybe 20 minutes, got my documentation question answered, and went into my hearing prepared. The site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y if you want to see how it works before trying it. Would have saved me so much stress if I'd known about it earlier in the process.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorAppreciate that - actually been trying to get through to DES to ask about submitting my safety complaint documentation and cannot get anyone on the line. Might look into this.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
Same experience here, hold times are brutal. Anything that helps you actually talk to someone is worth knowing about.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
Does that work for getting general claim questions answered too or only appeal-related stuff? I have a pending adjudication issue that's been sitting for weeks.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
I used to think quitting for any reason meant you were automatically out of luck with unemployment, like there was no way to win an appeal if you left voluntarily. Turns out that's not how it works at all - what matters is whether your reason for leaving would have pushed a reasonable person in the same situation to do the same thing. Unsafe working conditions, documented complaints that went ignored, a hostile work environment - those can absolutely qualify. I had a situation where I quit because my hours got cut so severely it wasn't worth the commute and I actually won my appeal because I had text messages showing management had promised stable hours.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorThat's actually reassuring. I have written internal complaint forms and email threads showing I flagged the equipment issues and they were never addressed. Is that the kind of documentation I should be leading with?
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Yes exactly. Anything in writing that shows you told them about the problem and gave them a chance to fix it before you left is gold. The appeals officer is basically asking themselves whether you tried to resolve it before walking out. If you have that paper trail, you're in a much stronger position than someone who just said the conditions were bad.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
This is the key piece most people miss going in. You have to show you didn't just leave at the first sign of trouble, that you tried to work it out first.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
What kind of documents should actually be brought to the hearing though, like in what format? I'm trying to figure out if I need to fax things or email them in advance or if I can just reference them verbally on the call.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
You should submit documents before the hearing, not during. The notice you received should have an email or fax number for pre-hearing submissions. Generally you want to get them in at least 5-7 days before the hearing date so both sides and the appeals officer have them in advance.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
Okay good to know. What about photos, like if someone had photos of the unsafe conditions?
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Photos work, yes. Label them clearly and include a brief written description of when they were taken and what they show. The more context the better.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
I'm going through almost the same exact thing right now, except I quit because my employer kept changing my schedule without notice which made it impossible to handle my childcare arrangements. They denied my initial claim too. I'm stressed out of my mind about the hearing.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Schedule changes that make it impossible to maintain your employment situation can count - but you'd want to show you told them about the conflict and asked for a solution before leaving. Did you ever put anything in writing to management?
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
I sent a few texts but that's it. Nothing through official work channels.
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Text messages count. Screenshot them and submit them before the hearing. Even informal documentation is better than nothing, especially if the content clearly shows you raised the issue before quitting.
0 coins
Anthony Young
Something I wish I'd known - there's usually a point in the hearing where the appeals officer asks very specific questions about the timeline, like exactly when you filed the complaint, exactly when management responded or didn't, exactly when you decided to quit. I stumbled badly on this because I hadn't organized my timeline in advance. After my hearing I told my cousin who had a similar situation coming up and she actually called Arizona DES beforehand using Claimyr to ask about timeline documentation requirements - she said the agent walked her through exactly what the officer would be looking for. She went in way more prepared than I did. Worth using claimyr.com before your hearing date.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorTimeline prep - hadn't even thought about that specifically. So I should basically put together a written chronology of every incident and complaint with dates?
0 coins
Anthony Young
Exactly that. Date of each equipment issue you observed, date you reported it, who you reported to, their response or lack of one, and then the date you quit. The cleaner and more specific your timeline, the more credible you sound.
0 coins
The Boss
This helped me too. I made a one-page timeline document and submitted it as an exhibit before my hearing. The officer actually referenced it multiple times during the call.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Does the format of the timeline matter? Like does it need to be formatted a certain way or can it just be a plain typed list?
0 coins
Admin_Masters
I went through a voluntary quit appeal last year and lost, and I want to be honest about that since most posts are about winning. I quit because I genuinely couldn't stand my manager anymore - personality conflicts, feeling disrespected, that kind of thing. No written documentation, nothing formal. The appeals officer was actually pretty kind about it but explained that personal frustration without documented workplace issues that crossed a certain threshold wasn't enough. I lost the appeal and had to pay back the benefits I'd received during the pending period.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorThat's hard to read but I genuinely appreciate the honesty. My situation is different in that I do have documentation of safety violations, but it's a good reminder that the documentation is what makes or breaks it.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
Yeah the safety angle is much stronger than what I had. I'm not trying to discourage you, just want people to know it's not automatic even when you feel you have a good reason.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
This is actually really useful context. A lot of posts make it sound like any bad working condition automatically qualifies. The documentation piece is what separates the ones that win from the ones that don't.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
Quick question since I'm reading all this - if someone loses their appeal, is there another level you can take it to after that or is the appeals officer's decision the end of the road?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
There is a further step - you can appeal to the Appeals Board which is a separate review body above the appeals officer level. After that if you still disagree you can take it to Superior Court but at that point you're really in legal territory and it gets complex.
0 coins
Matthew Sanchez
Interesting, didn't realize there were multiple levels. Does the Appeals Board review happen automatically or do you have to file another appeal?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
You have to initiate it yourself within a set timeframe after receiving the appeals officer decision. It doesn't happen automatically. The decision letter will explain your options and deadlines.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
Random thing I noticed but worth mentioning - when I was dealing with my own appeal situation I tried every way I could think of to reach Arizona DES and nothing was working. Eventually someone in a different forum thread mentioned Claimyr and I tried it. What surprised me was I could actually ask specific questions about my appeal case, not just general stuff - the agent I reached looked up my actual file and confirmed they had received my submitted documents. That peace of mind alone was worth it. claimyr.com if you want to try it.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
Wait, really? They can confirm receipt of specific documents? That's what I've been trying to find out about my submitted evidence.
0 coins
Ella Thompson
Yes, the agent I spoke with actually pulled up my case. I'd assume results vary depending on who you get but that was my experience.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
That's the part that always kills me - not knowing if what you submitted actually made it into the system. The confirmation alone would be worth the effort.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
Does having an attorney or any kind of representative change how the hearing goes? Like does the appeals officer treat the case differently if one side has legal representation and the other doesn't?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Formally no, the process is the same. Realistically, an experienced representative knows how to frame things, what questions to ask, and how to object if something improper comes up. If your employer brings legal representation and you're unrepresented, it can feel unbalanced even if the rules treat both sides equally.
0 coins
Nora Bennett
Is there any kind of free legal help available for unemployment appeals specifically?
0 coins
Ryan Andre
Community Legal Services in Arizona handles some unemployment appeal cases at no cost depending on your income. Worth checking them out if you're concerned about going in alone against a represented employer.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
I had no idea how formal these hearings were until I was in one. I went in thinking it would be a casual conversation and it was much more structured than that - sworn testimony, exhibits, the whole thing. The appeals officer was professional but the structure was definitely more like a formal proceeding than a simple review.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorHow did you prepare for the oath part, like was there anything specific you had to do or was it just a standard verbal swear in?
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
Just verbal, they asked me to confirm I'd tell the truth and that was it. Nothing you need to prepare for specifically. But it does set the tone for how seriously they're treating everything you say.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
The sworn testimony part is what made me realize I needed to treat every single word carefully. It's not like chatting with HR, everything carries weight.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Okay so I have a dumb question maybe - when the employer participates in the hearing, can they bring up things that weren't in the original denial letter? Like new reasons why the quit wasn't valid?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Not really a dumb question at all. Generally the hearing is supposed to address the reason for the denial, but employers can and do bring up additional context. The appeals officer has discretion about what's relevant. It's one of the reasons going in prepared for anything is better than only prepping for the specific denial reason stated in the letter.
0 coins
Charlotte White
So they could potentially bring up stuff like my attendance record or prior warnings even if that wasn't the reason DES denied me?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
They might try to introduce it as context, yes. It may or may not be given weight by the officer. Having your own documentation in order helps because then you're not just reacting to whatever they bring up.
0 coins
The Boss
I've been following this thread and something that helped me prepare was practicing the actual answers out loud before my hearing. I wrote out the questions I thought I'd get and answered them out loud into my phone as a recording, then listened back. You hear yourself fumble or contradict yourself in ways you don't notice when you're just thinking through answers in your head.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorRecording myself - genuinely hadn't thought of that. Did you do it with someone playing the other side, or just solo?
0 coins
The Boss
Solo, just me answering into my phone. Would have been better with someone else but I didn't have anyone available to do that with. Even solo it caught a few places where my explanation wasn't as clear as I thought it was.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
This is a great idea actually. Might do this tonight. The timeline of my situation gets complicated when I try to explain it quickly.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
Something no one has mentioned yet - the week before my hearing I was a mess mentally and kept second guessing everything. What helped was remembering the appeals process exists specifically for situations like this, it's not a long shot, it's the designed channel for reviewing disputed decisions. The appeals officers aren't there to rubber stamp denials, they actually do rule for claimants in documented cases.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorNeeded to hear this honestly, been spiraling a bit. The documented safety complaints are real and documented, I just need to trust the process.
0 coins
Victoria Charity
You have more than most people going in. Written complaints, ignored safety issues, that's the substance they're looking for.
0 coins
Admin_Masters
This framing helped me too even though my outcome wasn't what I wanted. The officer was genuinely listening, not just going through motions. I lost on the merits not because the process was rigged.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
Quick logistical thing - what happens to your weekly UI benefits and your job search requirements during the period between filing the appeal and the hearing? Do you have to keep logging job searches even though the whole situation is in limbo?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Yes you absolutely have to keep filing weekly claims and logging job search activities throughout the appeal period. Stopping those would put you at risk of losing benefits for the weeks you stopped, independent of the appeal outcome.
0 coins
Evan Kalinowski
Even if the appeal might result in the whole claim being reversed anyway?
0 coins
Mia Roberts
Even then yes. The weekly certification and job search requirements run on their own track. The appeal is about the original denial decision. You could win the appeal and still lose benefits for specific weeks where you didn't certify or meet job search requirements.
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
The job search requirement thing confused me for the longest time too. I thought being in an appeal somehow paused all the normal requirements. Went a couple weeks without filing because I assumed the whole thing was frozen while the appeal was pending, and then had to explain the gaps later. Don't do what I did.
0 coins
Aurora Lacasse
Wait - what happened with the gap weeks? Did you lose those benefits permanently?
0 coins
Lauren Zeb
I had to file late certifications and explain the gap. Some of those weeks got approved anyway, some didn't. It was a mess that could have been avoided by just continuing to file like normal throughout.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorOkay, confirming with myself right now that I will keep filing every week no matter what. Good warning.
0 coins
JacksonHarris
Last thing worth adding from my experience - I had a question the night before my hearing about a specific piece of documentation and was completely panicking about whether to submit it or not. I'd heard Arizona DES had a pre-hearing submission deadline and didn't know if I'd missed it. I tried Claimyr and got connected to an agent within about 25 minutes at like 8am. The agent confirmed my submission had been received and that the officer would have it. I went into the hearing not wondering if my key document even made it into the file. If you're in that position the day before or morning of, it's worth having that option available. claimyr.com is the site.
0 coins
Grace Lee
AuthorDay-before panic is exactly what I'm anticipating. Good to have that option in my back pocket.
0 coins
Charlotte White
Does it work for reaching someone early in the morning or only during regular business hours?
0 coins
JacksonHarris
I connected at 8am which is when Arizona DES phone lines open, so right at the start of business hours. I wouldn't expect it to work outside of their actual operating hours since it's connecting you to a real agent.
0 coins
Oscar Murphy
The timing matters a lot - I've found early in the day before the queues get backed up tends to give you better results regardless of method.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
Has anyone had a situation where the employer just didn't show up to the hearing? Wondering if that happens and what it means if it does.
0 coins
Mia Roberts
It does happen and when it does, the hearing still proceeds. The appeals officer doesn't automatically rule in your favor just because the employer is absent - they still review the evidence and may ask you questions on their own. But practically speaking, an absent employer means no one is there to contradict your account which puts you in a stronger position.
0 coins
Daniel Washington
That makes sense. I guess I was hoping absent employer equals automatic win but that would be too easy.
0 coins
The Boss
Had an employer no-show in my case and I still had to explain everything fully. Officer asked tough questions even without the employer there. But yes, the fact that no one was challenging my version helped the overall dynamic.
0 coins