Are tips subject to unemployment tax? Arizona DES situation explained
So I've been bartending for the past six years at a pretty busy spot downtown, and my hours got slashed so bad last month that I finally filed for UI with Arizona DES. The whole process has been a headache but I got to a point where I'm trying to understand how my wages are actually being calculated because my base hourly is basically nothing - most of my income was tips. What I'm confused about is whether my tips even count toward my unemployment benefits or if DES is only looking at my reported hourly wages. My W-2 from last year shows my tips as income obviously but I genuinely don't know if those tip amounts factor into what unemployment uses to calculate my weekly benefit amount. Are tips subject to unemployment tax the same way regular wages are? Because if employers aren't paying FUTA and SUTA on my tip income, does that mean tips basically disappear when it comes to my UI claim? I asked my manager about it and she kind of shrugged and said she reports tips for payroll taxes but wasn't sure about unemployment specifically. I really need to figure this out because my weekly benefit amount seems way lower than I expected based on my total earnings last year.
86 comments

Joy Olmedo
Just got my determination letter two days ago after filing in mid-March and I had almost the same exact confusion when I was bartending before my layoff. The short answer is it depends on how your employer handled payroll. Tips that go through your employer's payroll system - like credit card tips that your employer processes and includes in your paycheck - those get reported as wages and your employer pays SUTA (state unemployment tax) on them. But cash tips that you self-report to your employer but they don't actually run through payroll the same way... it gets murky. Arizona DES bases your benefit amount on wages your employer actually paid SUTA on.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
Authorok that actually makes sense now - so the question is really whether my employer was paying unemployment tax on the tips they processed, not just whether tips are income generally?
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
This is correct. The key distinction is what's in the employer's quarterly wage reports to Arizona DES. If tips were included in those reports, they count. If not, they don't show up in your base period wages at all.
0 coins
Joy Olmedo
Exactly. And honestly most bartenders and servers find their benefit amount is a lot lower than expected because of this. It's one of those things nobody tells you when you take a tipped position.
0 coins
Kiara Greene
Week 3 of waiting on my adjudication and I saw this thread and had to jump in. Before I get into my tip situation - has anyone here actually managed to get through to Arizona DES by phone? I've been trying for two weeks and either get a busy signal or get put on hold for two hours and then disconnected. I finally used Claimyr (claimyr.com) - it basically works through the hold process for you so you end up speaking directly with a live DES agent. There's a video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y showing how it works. I actually got to talk to someone who explained how my employer was reporting my tips on the quarterly wage reports, which answered my question way faster than any forum could.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
Authortwo weeks of trying to get through - yeah that sounds about right honestly, I haven't even attempted calling yet because I heard it's basically impossible
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
i used to try calling at like 7:58am right when they open and still couldn't get through. gonna look into that claimyr thing
0 coins
Paloma Clark
The phone situation with DES is genuinely awful. I spent three days trying before I found another way. Good tip about Claimyr.
0 coins
Heather Tyson
My base period just got calculated and I want to share what I learned going through this whole thing as a former server. When I finally got my award letter and the amount seemed low, I pulled my last four complete calendar quarters of W-2 info and compared it to what DES was showing as my base period wages. The difference was almost exactly equal to the cash tips I'd reported to my employer but that weren't actually processed through payroll. Turns out my restaurant was only paying SUTA on the hourly portion and the credit card tip amounts - not on the cash tip adjustments.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
Authorwait so even if you tell your employer about cash tips, if they don't run it through payroll with SUTA paid on it, DES won't count it?
0 coins
Heather Tyson
That's what happened in my case. My employer was technically compliant for income tax purposes because I reported the tips - but for unemployment tax purposes, only wages they actually paid SUTA on get included in your base period. It's a really frustrating gap in the system for tipped workers.
0 coins
Raul Neal
This is a really common issue and I don't think enough people know about it before they take tipped jobs. The tax treatment of tips for income tax vs unemployment insurance purposes is genuinely different.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
omg this explains SO much. I had the same thing happen when I filed last year working at a hotel. My benefit amount was like half what I thought it would be
0 coins
Christian Burns
Approval came through on my claim yesterday after almost a month and I had a tip wage question too so I'll add what I know. Under Arizona law, tips are considered wages for unemployment insurance purposes IF the employer includes them in the wages reported to DES on their quarterly reports. The employer pays SUTA on those reported wages. So technically tips CAN be subject to unemployment tax - but whether they actually ARE depends entirely on your specific employer's payroll practices. Some employers in the service industry do it right and report everything. Others only report base wages.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
Authoris there a way I can find out what my employer actually reported to DES without having to get them to tell me directly?
0 coins
Christian Burns
Yes - when you log into your CACTUS portal account, you should be able to see the base period wages DES has on file for you. Compare that to your total W-2 wages including tips. If there's a gap, that's probably the unreported tip amount. You can also request your wage history from DES directly.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
The CACTUS portal actually shows this? I never knew that. Going to check mine right now because I have the same situation working at a steakhouse.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Somewhere around week five of my claim, still waiting on a decision, but I had to reach out to DES about exactly this tip reporting question and I'll say that Claimyr was the only thing that actually got me to a live person. I'd been going in circles on the phone for days. The agent I talked to confirmed that my employer had been including my credit card tips in the quarterly wage reports but not my cash tips - so my base period wages were higher than I initially feared but still not my full earnings. Useful to know before you panic.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
Authorthat's reassuring that at least credit card tips are usually in there - most of mine were card tips anyway so maybe my situation isn't as bad as I feared
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
Fingers crossed for you. The agent was actually pretty helpful once I got through. She said tipped workers should always pull their base period wage info early in the process so there are no surprises on the award amount.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
Five weeks and still waiting is brutal. Hope your claim moves soon.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
Letter arrived about my own claim two weeks back and I want to add something that might help here. The federal FUTA tax and Arizona SUTA tax both technically apply to tips that flow through an employer's payroll system. So from the government's perspective, yes - tips are supposed to be subject to unemployment tax. The problem is enforcement and how individual employers handle their payroll. Large chain restaurants tend to be better about this than small independent places because they have HR and payroll departments that do it correctly. If you worked somewhere smaller, there's a decent chance they were only paying SUTA on base wages.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
AuthorI work at an independent bar, so that's... not great to hear probably
0 coins
Diez Ellis
Might still be fine - some smaller places do it right. The only way to know for sure is to check what's in your base period on the CACTUS portal like others mentioned. If you need to dispute anything, you can request a wage investigation through DES.
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
This is accurate. Chain vs independent definitely makes a difference in my experience. I worked for a regional bar group and they had it all set up correctly, every tip category went through payroll.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
the enforcement piece is so frustrating. like employers who don't do this right are basically screwing their employees out of unemployment coverage they think they have
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Got to the weekly certification step last week and have been reading this thread trying to figure out my own bartending UI situation. I want to make sure I understand - when I certify weekly, do I need to report tip income I'm still making from my part time shifts separately? Like is that considered wages I need to report?
0 coins
Christian Burns
Yes absolutely - any wages you earn during a week you're certifying for, including tips, need to be reported on your weekly claim. DES will apply the earnings deduction formula to calculate your partial benefit for that week. Underreporting wages including tips can lead to an overpayment situation which is a whole mess to deal with.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Good to know, I wasn't sure if tips counted the same as hourly wages for the weekly reporting part. I'll make sure to include everything.
0 coins
Joy Olmedo
The weekly certification reporting and the base period wage calculation are two separate things - both matter but for different reasons. During weekly claims you report everything you earned. For your benefit amount calculation, it's about what your employer reported historically.
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
Partway through my second appeal hearing and I regret not figuring out the tip wage thing earlier in my process. I actually used Claimyr back when I was first dealing with my claim status and had a really good conversation with an agent about how my employer had been handling tip reporting. Knowing that information earlier would have helped me understand my benefit calculation better from the start rather than being confused for months.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
Authoran appeal hearing already - hope that goes well for you. what ended up being the dispute about if you don't mind sharing?
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
My situation got complicated because I had two jobs - bartending plus some work at another venue - and there was confusion about how DES calculated my base period from multiple employers. The tip reporting was just one piece of a bigger puzzle.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Multiple employer situations sound incredibly complicated to deal with through DES. Hope your appeal comes out in your favor.
0 coins
Laila Prince
Just filed last Friday, so I'm right at the beginning of this whole thing. Reading this thread is both helpful and kind of terrifying. My whole thing is that I worked at a restaurant for three years where probably 60% of my income was tips and I have no idea how my employer was handling the SUTA side. Is there any way to find out before I even get my award letter?
0 coins
Raul Neal
Once your claim processes you can check the CACTUS portal - it'll show what DES has as your base period wages from employer quarterly reports. Usually takes a week or two after filing to show up. If the numbers look way lower than your W-2 wage totals, that's your signal that tips weren't all being reported for unemployment tax purposes.
0 coins
Laila Prince
Got it, so just wait until the portal updates and then compare against my W-2
0 coins
Isaiah Cross
Exactly. And if there IS a discrepancy and you believe tips should have been included, you can file a wage investigation request with DES - they'll go back to the employer and verify what was reported on the quarterly wage reports. It doesn't always go your way but it's worth doing.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
3 years of tips not being reported for UI purposes would be a really significant difference in your benefit amount. Definitely worth investigating if that's the case.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Step two of adjudication apparently, whatever that means - my portal just changed status. Anyway I bartended for eight years before this and want to share something nobody mentioned yet. Even if your employer was paying SUTA on your tips properly, Arizona has a maximum weekly benefit amount. Last I checked it was around $320 per week. So even if your full tip income was included in your base period, there's a ceiling on what you can receive. Tipped workers who made good money often hit that ceiling from their hourly wages alone and the tip reporting question becomes less important. For lower earners it matters a lot more.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
Authoryeah I've seen that max benefit number floating around - what's the formula for calculating where you'd land relative to that cap?
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Arizona DES uses roughly 1/25th of your highest quarter wages in the base period to calculate your weekly benefit amount, up to that maximum. So if your highest quarter earnings reported to DES were $8,000, your weekly amount would be around $320 - which is also the max. The formula is on the DES website but honestly it's easier to just look at your award letter.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
the max being $320 is pretty brutal when you think about how much rent costs now. Even if everything calculates perfectly for a tipped worker you're still looking at pretty minimal income replacement
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Two months into my claim, finally approved last week, and I went through this entire confusion about tips and unemployment taxes. What I found out through my employer's HR actually - after I pressed them pretty hard - was that they had been including all tips (cash and card) in their quarterly wage reports to DES for the entire time I worked there. My benefit amount reflected my real total earnings. Not every employer is doing it wrong, some smaller places do it correctly too.
0 coins
Laila Prince
That's genuinely good to hear, gives me some hope about my situation
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
Worth asking HR directly and also cross-referencing with your CACTUS portal numbers. If they match your W-2 you're probably fine.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
Authorgood to know it's not automatically a disaster just because it's a smaller place - I'll check the portal numbers once my claim processes further
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
First week of waiting and already losing my mind. Question slightly related to this - I had a week where I made almost all tips and basically no hourly wages because my employer was messing around with my scheduled hours before I got fully laid off. Would DES look at that week weird during the investigation period or adjudication?
0 coins
Raul Neal
DES looks at quarterly wages not weekly earnings for your base period calculation, so one weird low-hour week wouldn't necessarily cause problems. The adjudication process is more about whether you're eligible - able and available for work, the reason for separation from your job, etc. The wage calculation is a separate thing that happens more automatically.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
ok so adjudication and the wage calculation are actually two separate processes - I was mixing those up
0 coins
Heather Tyson
Lots of people mix those up. Adjudication is about eligibility determination. Base period wages are what they use to calculate your benefit amount once you're found eligible. Both matter but they're distinct steps.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
About six weeks in now. I want to bring up something tangentially related - when I was in a similar situation trying to understand why my benefit amount seemed off, the hardest part was just getting DES on the phone to explain anything. I eventually got through and an agent walked me through exactly how my employer's quarterly wage report lined up with what I'd earned. That conversation was way more useful than trying to decode the portal myself. Claimyr was how I finally reached someone - I'd wasted so many hours on hold before that.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
How long did it take once you got through to actually get the explanation about the wage reports?
0 coins
Dominique Adams
The agent was pretty efficient once I had her on the line, maybe 15 minutes to pull up my employer's report history and explain what was included and what wasn't. The hard part is always just reaching someone.
0 coins
Laila Prince
15 minutes to get answers that would have taken weeks of forum searching, that math makes sense
0 coins
TommyKapitz
Reading this whole thread and want to add my situation from a different angle - I'm an employer, not a claimant. I run a small bar and we do include all tip income that flows through our POS system in our quarterly SUTA reports. It costs us more in tax but I think it's the right thing to do for employees. The question of whether tips are subject to unemployment tax has a clear legal answer - yes they are supposed to be - but enforcement is spotty and many small employers don't realize they should be including credit card tips in their SUTA-taxable wage base.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Finally an employer perspective on this. So you're saying most small bars and restaurants might be unintentionally doing this wrong?
0 coins
TommyKapitz
Not all intentionally wrong - a lot of small business owners use basic payroll software and may not have it set up correctly to include tips in the SUTA wage base even when they're including them for other tax purposes. It's a configuration issue as much as an intent issue.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
This is really useful context. So it's not necessarily that employers are trying to avoid paying SUTA on tips, sometimes they just have a payroll setup that doesn't capture it correctly.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
This matches what my employer's HR person told me when I asked - they said their payroll system was configured specifically to include tips because their accountant had flagged it as important. Sounds like not everyone gets that memo.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
Finally got my determination about a week and a half ago and I want to share the specific thing the determination letter says about my wages because it might help people here understand what DES is actually working from. The letter lists your base period by quarter - four quarters total - and shows the wage amount DES has from your employer for each quarter. For me, those numbers were significantly lower than my quarterly earnings because my employer had been reporting only my hourly wages as the SUTA wage base. I could visually see the difference between what I actually earned and what DES had.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
Authorso the determination letter itself shows the quarterly breakdown - that would make it really easy to compare against W-2 info
0 coins
Angel Campbell
Exactly, and that's what you want to do immediately when it arrives. Line up each quarter against your pay stubs or W-2 data. The discrepancy, if there is one, jumps out pretty fast.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
This is probably the most practically useful thing in this whole thread for me right now. Going to remember to do this when my letter comes.
0 coins
Paloma Clark
Just past my second week of job search activities, logging everything in my job search record as required. Somewhat off topic but related - when I do find a new job and report wages, do I report tip income I'm earning at my new job the same way I'd report regular hourly wages on my weekly certification?
0 coins
Christian Burns
Yes - when you go back to work and are filing partial claims during transition, you report gross earnings for the week including tips. DES uses that to figure out your partial benefit for that week. The rule is you report what you actually earned in the week you worked, not when you got paid.
0 coins
Paloma Clark
Makes sense, so tips I earn in a given week go on that week's certification not the week they appear in my paycheck
0 coins
Christian Burns
Correct. Earned when worked is the standard. A lot of people mess this up and report based on paycheck timing which can cause issues.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
Three weeks post-filing, in adjudication still. This thread has been incredibly helpful. One thing I'm still unclear on - if I do a wage investigation and DES determines my employer should have been paying SUTA on tips they weren't reporting, does that change my current benefit amount retroactively? Or does it only affect future claims?
0 coins
Raul Neal
If a wage investigation results in DES requiring your employer to amend their quarterly wage reports to include tips, your base period wages would be recalculated and your weekly benefit amount could increase. It's not instant and can take a while but it can apply to your current claim going forward. Worth pursuing if there's a real discrepancy.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
So it could actually result in a higher payment going forward even on the current claim - that's worth doing then
0 coins
Diez Ellis
Theoretically yes, though the timeline on wage investigations can be long and your claim might wrap up before it's resolved. Still worth filing if the discrepancy is significant.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
From the employer side, if DES comes back with a wage investigation we take it seriously. We'd have to submit amended quarterly reports which would then flow through to the claimant's base period recalculation.
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
Got my first weekly certification done yesterday - was nervous about it but pretty straightforward honestly. Coming back to the original question though because I think there's one piece nobody addressed fully. Even if your employer paid SUTA on your tips and they're in your base period, there's still the question of whether your base period high quarter wages bump you up meaningfully or just barely move your weekly benefit amount. For bartenders making decent money, the tip income might not change much once you're already at the max benefit. But for part-timers or people with lower tip income, getting those tips included could be the difference between a livable benefit and almost nothing.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
AuthorYeah that makes sense - for me personally I was making decent money so I might already hit the ceiling even with just the wage portion, but I'd still want to know the number is accurate
0 coins
Evelyn Kelly
Definitely worth knowing either way. I'd check the portal numbers and at minimum understand what your employer reported before just accepting the award amount without question.
0 coins
Noland Curtis
The max being what it is means a lot of tipped workers are kind of in a weird spot - even if everything is reported correctly the replacement income is still pretty low relative to what they were making
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
Just wanted to add from week seven of my claim that I wish I'd found this thread earlier. I never questioned my benefit amount when I got my determination letter and just assumed it was what it was. After reading this I checked my CACTUS portal and my base period wages are definitely lower than my W-2 totals by a noticeable margin. Going to file a wage investigation request now. Better late than never I guess.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
Good for you for checking - it's never too late to file the wage investigation while your claim is active. Make sure you have your W-2 handy to reference the specific quarterly earnings you're comparing against.
0 coins
Jenna Sloan
Got it - I'll pull the W-2 and document the quarterly discrepancy before I submit the investigation request
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
This is exactly why threads like this exist. A lot of claimants just accept the first determination without realizing there might be a basis to request a review.
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Somewhat of a different angle coming in here - has anyone thought about the broader issue that tipped workers are kind of systematically disadvantaged when it comes to unemployment benefits? Even when everything is done right, the fact that employer SUTA tax is capped at a certain wage base means that for high earners, some of the tip income might exceed the taxable wage base and not factor in anyway. The whole system wasn't really designed with the gig-adjacent tipped economy in mind.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
The SUTA wage base in Arizona is actually relatively low compared to some states, which caps how much any employer pays and therefore caps the wages that count for UI calculation purposes. It's a structural issue.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
As an employer I think about this too. The taxable wage base for SUTA purposes is set by law and there's not much any individual employer can do about it. We pay tax on wages up to the annual limit per employee and that's what it is.
0 coins
Kingston Bellamy
AuthorOkay so there might be a cap on the wages that even count for SUTA purposes, so even if your employer does everything right, very high tip earners might still see their benefit capped not just by the weekly max but by the wage base issue too
0 coins
Abby Marshall
Exactly. It's layered. Multiple points where tip income can effectively fall out of the UI calculation even with fully compliant employers.
0 coins