Am I eligible for unemployment if fired for poor performance? Arizona DES situation
So my manager called me into HR three weeks ago and that was it - handed me a termination letter citing 'failure to meet performance standards' after about 14 months at this logistics company. No write-ups before that, no formal PIP, nothing on paper. Just suddenly not meeting standards apparently. I've been in warehousing my whole career and never had anything like this happen before. I went ahead and filed with Arizona DES like the next day because rent doesn't wait around. But now I'm kind of spiraling because I keep reading conflicting stuff online about whether getting fired for performance means you automatically get denied. My claim has been sitting in adjudication for going on 11 days and I have no idea what's actually being evaluated. Did anyone actually go through this with Arizona DES? Like specifically fired for performance reasons - not misconduct, not quitting - and end up getting approved? I really need to understand what I'm looking at here before I get a letter in the mail that wrecks my whole situation.
68 comments

Ezra Bates
Fourteen months at one job and they let you go without any documented warnings first - that detail actually matters a lot here. The way Arizona DES looks at it, there's a pretty meaningful difference between getting fired for misconduct versus getting fired because you weren't hitting whatever benchmarks they set. Misconduct is the disqualifying kind - things like stealing, showing up drunk, violating a clear policy on purpose. Poor performance is a different animal entirely. If the company couldn't show you were warned, given a chance to improve, and still fell short, Arizona DES tends to land on the side of approving the claim. You should be in okay shape here.
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
No write-ups and no PIP is actually huge. I went through almost the exact same thing in 2024 - fired for 'not meeting expectations' in a fulfillment role. Arizona DES approved me because the employer couldn't produce any documentation of corrective action. The adjudication letter asked me to provide my side of the story and I basically just explained there was never any formal warning process.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
Does the lack of a PIP actually matter legally or is that just one factor they weigh? I always thought Arizona DES could deny based on performance regardless of whether there was a written improvement plan or not.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
It's a factor not an absolute rule. Arizona DES is weighing whether the employer gave you a fair shot to fix things. No documentation makes it harder for them to argue you were adequately warned.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
Performance firing adjudication cases at Arizona DES take longer than most people expect. 11 days is pretty normal honestly - mine dragged out to almost three full weeks before I got a determination. The thing that slows it down is DES has to contact your former employer and get their version, then give you a chance to respond. If your employer is slow to reply to DES that adds time. Keep filing your weekly claims through CACTUS the whole time the adjudication is running, that part doesn't pause.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
AuthorThree weeks feels like forever when you're watching your savings. So they actually reach out to the employer directly during adjudication? I wasn't sure if I needed to be proactively sending them documentation or if they gather it themselves.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
Both, kind of. They contact the employer automatically but if you have anything that supports your side - emails, any notes you saved, offer letter, anything showing expectations weren't communicated - you can submit that through your CACTUS portal account. It doesn't hurt to be proactive about it.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
This is accurate. My adjudication took 19 days for a performance-related termination. Employer apparently took over a week just to respond to DES. The waiting is brutal but keep those weekly claims filed no matter what.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
Before I found a way around it I spent probably six or seven hours total across different days trying to get a live person at Arizona DES on the phone. Constant busy signals, hold music that just cuts off, one time I sat on hold for 40 minutes and then the line dropped. I had a performance-related termination case in adjudication and genuinely needed to talk to someone about what documentation I should be gathering. Somebody in a different thread mentioned Claimyr - claimyr.com - basically it navigates the DES phone system for you and calls you back when an actual agent is on the line. There's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y. I was skeptical but I'd already wasted so many hours so I tried it. Got a callback and actually talked to an agent who told me exactly what my adjudication was looking at and what I could submit. For anyone fighting to get through to DES while their claim is in limbo, it was genuinely worth trying.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
Six or seven hours trying to call and nothing - yeah that's exactly what the DES phone situation is like. I haven't tried Claimyr but honestly at that point what do you have to lose. Did the agent you reached actually have access to your specific claim file or were they just giving you generic info?
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
They pulled up my actual claim. Told me the specific reason it was flagged for adjudication and what the employer had submitted. That's what made it worth it - actual case-specific information, not a script.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
Bookmarking this for when I inevitably need it. DES phone access is honestly one of the most frustrating parts of the whole unemployment process.
0 coins
Lily Young
I got fired for performance back in early 2024 and panicked thinking I'd automatically be denied. Here's what I wish someone had told me straight up: Arizona DES distinguishes between intentional bad behavior and just not being good enough at your job. If your employer can't prove you knew exactly what was required and deliberately chose not to do it, the performance firing usually doesn't count as misconduct. You have to actually respond when DES contacts you during adjudication though - don't ignore those notices.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
AuthorThe notices part - do they contact you by mail, through the CACTUS portal, or both? I want to make sure I don't miss anything while this is being reviewed.
0 coins
Lily Young
CACTUS portal is where the official notices show up but DES also sends physical mail to your address on file. Check both. And make sure your contact info in CACTUS is current because that's where they'll send requests for additional information if they need any.
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
Agree with all of this. The portal is the more reliable one to watch - mail can get delayed. Set up notifications in your CACTUS account if you haven't already so you get emails when something new is posted there.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
everybody always says performance firing is fine but i got denied once for performance and it really messed me up financially. turned out the employer told des i had been verbally warned multiple times and even though there was nothing in writing DES believed them. so just be ready for the possibility it could go either way
0 coins
Ezra Bates
Verbal warnings being credible to DES is a real thing - they don't require written documentation as the only form of notice. The employer's testimony about verbal warnings can carry weight. That's why the OP's situation - no documented warnings AND apparently no verbal ones either - is relatively favorable.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
yeah fair point i probably should have kept notes when my supervisor said stuff to me in passing. didn't think it was going to turn into a whole thing
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
That gap between casual feedback and formal warning is exactly where these cases get complicated. Worth noting for anyone reading - if you're in a performance situation before it reaches firing, document every conversation you have with management about your work.
0 coins
Justin Chang
My adjudication for a performance termination was resolved faster than I expected because I called DES and got some clarity on what they actually needed from me. The trick was getting through - I'd heard about Claimyr from a coworker and ended up using it. The site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y. The agent I spoke to flagged that my employer had submitted a form claiming I'd received warnings, so I was able to gather some counter-evidence before the determination was issued. Without that call I would have had no idea what was in my file.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
AuthorYour employer submitted something saying you'd received warnings - did you have any way to dispute that? Like what kind of counter-evidence were you able to put together?
0 coins
Justin Chang
I pulled together emails from the same period where my manager was complimenting certain aspects of my work - basically showed the narrative of 'ongoing poor performance with warnings' didn't match what was actually in writing. DES takes that kind of documentary evidence seriously.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
This is a really important point. Employers sometimes overstate the warning situation when they respond to DES because they want to avoid paying into UI. Having documentation of what was actually happening is valuable.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
Never even thought about the fact that employers can submit their own version of events during adjudication. I always assumed DES just looks at the termination letter.
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
The other thing worth knowing is that even if Arizona DES initially denies your claim, a performance-related firing is one of the more appealable denial reasons. I volunteered at an ARIZONA@WORK resource center for a bit and watched people win appeals on exactly these kinds of cases. The appeal process gives you a formal hearing where you can present your side directly. Most people who get denied don't realize they have 15 days from the determination date to file that appeal.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
Author15 days goes fast. Is there anything you have to do differently when filing an appeal versus the initial claim? Like does it require different documentation?
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
The appeal is essentially a request for a formal hearing. You file it through your CACTUS account or by calling DES. At the actual hearing you can bring documentation, give testimony, even have someone represent you. It's more formal than the initial adjudication process but still not a courtroom situation.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Went through an appeal hearing in 2023 for a different reason and I'd say prepare like you're going to have to explain your whole employment history from day one. The hearing officer asks detailed questions.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
I work in HR at a mid-size company and from the other side of this I can tell you most managers when they fire someone for performance have almost nothing documented. They put off having the hard conversation for months, then one day they're done and HR has to scramble. If you weren't formally placed on a performance improvement plan or given written warnings, your former employer probably has very little to work with when Arizona DES contacts them. That favors you.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
The scramble you're describing is so real. I've heard from friends in management that they often just say 'performance issues' on the separation documentation because it feels safer to them than specifying anything, and that vagueness actually ends up helping the former employee's UI claim.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
Exactly - vague termination paperwork combined with no documented corrective action process is kind of the worst case for the employer in a DES adjudication. If they can't be specific, DES has less to work with on their end.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
This thread is making me feel so much better about my own situation honestly
0 coins
Lauren Wood
my cousin got fired for performance last year at a restaurant and got approved within like 2 weeks so it definitely can happen fast. he said he just told them his side of the story when they asked and that was basically it
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
Two weeks is on the faster end but not unheard of. Restaurant situations can sometimes be simpler because the documentation trails are often thinner on both sides.
0 coins
Lauren Wood
yeah he said his employer couldn't even remember what dates supposedly happened so their response to DES was pretty weak
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
For anyone who needs to actually reach DES during adjudication and keeps striking out on the phones - I had genuinely terrible luck calling for about two weeks straight. A friend suggested Claimyr and I want to mention it here because it actually worked when nothing else did. You go to claimyr.com and the idea is it handles the hold queue for you and gets you a callback when an agent picks up. There's a demo at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y. When I finally got through, the agent looked at my claim and I found out the adjudication had actually been resolved two days prior and they just hadn't sent the notice yet. I would have kept refreshing CACTUS in a panic if I hadn't called.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
Resolved and not notified yet - that's such an Arizona DES thing to have happen. The gap between when a determination is made and when the claimant actually gets the notice seems way longer than it should be.
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
It was wild to find out it was already done. The agent said the mailed notice was processed but the portal update lagged behind by like a day or two. If you're waiting anxiously, calling to check is worth it.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
I've literally been refreshing my CACTUS account every few hours for a week. Knowing there might be a lag between the actual determination and what shows in the portal is both reassuring and frustrating.
0 coins
Paige Cantoni
Something that tripped me up during my adjudication was not understanding that I was supposed to respond to the DES questionnaire within a specific window. I thought my initial claim had all the info they needed and sort of went quiet after filing. Got a request for additional information through CACTUS and didn't see it for almost four days because I wasn't checking carefully enough. Almost ran out of time to respond. If you have any trouble getting in touch with DES to ask questions about what they need - I ended up using Claimyr at claimyr.com to actually reach someone who explained what the questionnaire was asking - that's an option when the hold times are destroying you.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
AuthorFour days without checking and almost missing the response window - that's a good warning. How long is the response window they give you when they request additional information during adjudication?
0 coins
Paige Cantoni
The notice I got gave me 10 days to respond. Probably varies. But four days of me not noticing left me very little buffer. Checking daily isn't optional during adjudication.
0 coins
Lily Young
10 days goes fast when you're stressed and not sleeping well. The notices in CACTUS don't always come with a super obvious alert either - you kind of have to log in and look rather than waiting for something dramatic to flag it.
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
Turn on the email notification settings in CACTUS if you haven't. It'll at least ping you when something new is in your account so you're not relying purely on remembering to log in.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
im probably going to get downvoted for this but i've heard people say you should just admit at the initial claim stage that your performance was bad so DES takes your honesty into account. is that actually true or is that bad advice
0 coins
Ezra Bates
That's not quite how Arizona DES adjudication works - it's not about honesty points. What matters is factual accuracy about what happened. You shouldn't misrepresent anything but you also don't need to volunteer more negative information about yourself than what's directly asked. Answer what they ask, accurately.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
Agreeing with the above. DES isn't scoring your character, they're trying to establish whether the separation falls into the misconduct category or not. Stick to facts about what your job requirements were, what process the employer followed, and what actually led to the termination.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
There's another layer here that I ran into - even after you get approved, your first week is typically an unpaid waiting week under Arizona DES rules. So whatever week you filed is likely not going to generate a payment. I was confused when I got approved and then the first week showed as a waiting week with no benefit amount attached. Thought something was wrong. It's just standard procedure.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
AuthorWaiting week applies even when approved after adjudication? So that just extends the gap between losing your job and seeing any money.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Yeah the waiting week is counted from your initial claim date, not from when adjudication resolves. So if your claim was approved after adjudication, that first week was already counted. You don't necessarily lose an additional week - it was baked in from the start.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
I did not know this and I am filing this week so this is incredibly relevant to me right now thank you
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
Worth verifying in your specific CACTUS account because the waiting week timing can get confusing depending on exactly when you filed relative to when each benefit week starts.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
The job search requirements kick in basically from day one even while adjudication is running, right? I always see people surprised that DES expects you to be actively looking for work and logging contacts even before your claim is approved. If you're in adjudication you still need to be meeting the weekly job search activity requirements or you can get in trouble later.
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
Two job search activities per week is what Arizona DES currently requires. And yes, you have to log them in CACTUS when you file your weekly claim. If your claim gets approved retroactively and you haven't been logging job searches, that can create issues.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
Exactly - people assume adjudication is some kind of pause button on everything but it's really just a pause button on payment. All the ongoing requirements keep running.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
Does a job search activity have to be an actual application or do other things count? Like attending a workshop or updating a resume?
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
It's broader than just applications. Arizona DES accepts things like submitting an application, attending a job fair, using ARIZONA@WORK services, or doing certain professional networking activities. You log the type and employer/contact info in CACTUS each week.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Just want to say this thread has been more useful than anything I found on the actual Arizona DES website. The site explains what unemployment is in very official language but doesn't really address what happens to real people in specific situations like getting fired for performance. Thank you to everyone who shared their actual experience here.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
That gap between official policy language and what actually happens during adjudication is exactly why forums like this exist. The DES website won't tell you that employer documentation quality matters or that verbal warnings carry different weight than written ones.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
AuthorAgreed - reading actual experiences from people who went through performance-related adjudication has helped me understand what I'm actually facing way better than refreshing the official FAQ page.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
One thing I haven't seen mentioned - if you get denied and don't appeal, you're not necessarily locked out forever. There are circumstances where you can refile later or where new information changes the outcome. I'm not an expert on this but I had someone at ARIZONA@WORK explain that a denial on one claim doesn't automatically disqualify you from future claims if your situation changes. Don't treat a denial as a permanent door closing.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
This is partially right. A denial related to the specific separation can affect your benefit year for that filing period. But yes, your eligibility isn't permanently destroyed - future employment, different separations, those get evaluated on their own. The key thing is always to appeal within that 15-day window rather than letting a denial become final without challenging it.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
The 15 days thing - I didn't know that before this thread either. That seems like a critical piece of information DES should put in much larger font on the determination letter.
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
To bring this back to the original question for anyone who finds this later: getting fired for poor performance in Arizona does not automatically disqualify you from unemployment benefits. Arizona DES distinguishes between misconduct - which typically does disqualify you - and performance-based termination, which generally does not. The key factors are whether you intentionally did something wrong versus whether you just weren't meeting the employer's standards, and whether the employer actually documented and communicated those standards to you. Respond promptly to any DES notices during adjudication, keep filing your weekly claims, and document anything that supports your account of the termination.
0 coins
Keith Davidson
AuthorThis summary is exactly what I needed when I first posted. Still waiting on my adjudication result but I feel a lot less panicked about the outcome based on everything in this thread.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
Good summary. The intentionality distinction is the core of it - DES is essentially asking whether you chose to fail or whether you just fell short. Those lead to very different determinations.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
Saving this whole thread. Performance terminations seem way more nuanced than the simple 'fired equals denied' thing I always assumed.
0 coins