UCC Filing Required for Promissory Note vs Security Agreement - Which Takes Priority?
I'm dealing with a complicated situation where we have both a promissory note and a separate security agreement covering the same collateral (manufacturing equipment worth about $275K). The borrower defaulted and now there's another creditor claiming they have priority because they filed a UCC-1 first, even though our promissory note was signed earlier. I thought promissory notes automatically created security interests but our attorney is saying we should have filed a UCC-1 for the security agreement portion. Can someone explain the difference between these documents for UCC filing purposes? I'm confused about when you need to file and when you don't. The equipment is still at the borrower's facility and we need to know our legal position before the other creditor tries to repossess.
37 comments
Join the conversation
Omar Fawzi
A promissory note by itself doesn't create a security interest - it's just evidence of the debt. The security agreement is what actually grants you rights in the collateral. If you have a security agreement covering that equipment, you absolutely should have filed a UCC-1 to perfect your interest. The other creditor probably has priority if they filed first and you didn't file at all.
0 coins
Chloe Wilson
•Wait, I thought promissory notes could include security language? I've seen notes that reference collateral.
0 coins
Omar Fawzi
•They can include security provisions, but then they're functioning as both a note and security agreement. The key is whether there's clear language granting a security interest in specific collateral. Even then, you still need to file a UCC-1 to perfect against third parties.
0 coins
Diego Mendoza
This is exactly why I always recommend uploading your loan documents to something like Certana.ai before funding closes. Their document verification tool would have caught this gap between your promissory note and security agreement instantly. You can upload both documents and it will flag any inconsistencies or missing perfection steps. Would have saved you this headache.
0 coins
Freya Johansen
•I've never heard of that service. Does it actually review the legal language or just check basic info?
0 coins
Diego Mendoza
•It does a comprehensive cross-check of all your documents. Uploads PDFs and verifies that debtor names match, collateral descriptions align, and that you have all the pieces needed for proper perfection. Pretty straightforward to use.
0 coins
Anastasia Romanov
UGHHH this is so frustrating! I'm dealing with something similar where the bank gave me a promissory note but I'm not sure if there's a separate security agreement. How do I even know if I have a security interest or just an unsecured debt? This whole system is ridiculous - why can't it be more straightforward?
0 coins
Omar Fawzi
•Look for language in your documents that says something like 'Borrower grants Lender a security interest in...' followed by a description of collateral. If you only have a promissory note with no collateral language, you're probably unsecured.
0 coins
Anastasia Romanov
•The note mentions 'secured by equipment' but doesn't have a detailed list. Is that enough?
0 coins
Omar Fawzi
•That's borderline. A proper security agreement should have a detailed collateral description. 'Equipment' alone might be too vague depending on your state's requirements.
0 coins
StellarSurfer
First thing - pull a UCC search on your debtor immediately to see what other filings are out there. The filing date and time stamps will determine priority, assuming all security interests were properly created. But like the previous poster said, if you didn't file a UCC-1 for your security agreement, you might not have perfected your interest at all.
0 coins
Freya Johansen
•Good point. I should have done this months ago. Where's the best place to run a comprehensive UCC search?
0 coins
StellarSurfer
•Most Secretary of State websites have search functions, but you'll want to search in every state where the debtor is located or where the collateral might be. Some services aggregate multi-state searches.
0 coins
Sean Kelly
Been doing commercial lending for 15 years and this confusion comes up constantly. Here's the simple version: promissory note = IOU for the money. Security agreement = gives you rights to take collateral if they don't pay. UCC-1 filing = tells the world about your security interest so other creditors know you were there first. You need all three pieces for a fully secured and perfected loan.
0 coins
Zara Malik
•This is super helpful! So even if my promissory note mentions collateral, I still need a separate security agreement document?
0 coins
Sean Kelly
•Not necessarily separate documents, but you need separate functions. Some lenders use a combined note and security agreement document. The important thing is having clear security language and then filing the UCC-1 to perfect.
0 coins
Luca Greco
•What happens if you have the security agreement but forgot to file the UCC-1? Are you completely out of luck?
0 coins
Sean Kelly
•You'd still have a security interest between you and the borrower, but you'd be subordinate to perfected creditors and certain other parties like lien creditors. Basically, other people could jump ahead of you in line.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
OMG I think I'm in the same boat! We have a $180K equipment loan with just a promissory note and I don't think we ever filed anything with the state. The borrower is now behind on payments and I'm panicking that we have no security. How screwed are we?
0 coins
Omar Fawzi
•Check your loan documents carefully first. Sometimes the security language is buried in the fine print or in a separate document you might have overlooked.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•I found something called a 'Security Agreement and Financing Statement' in the loan folder. Does that sound right?
0 coins
Omar Fawzi
•That sounds promising! The financing statement portion should have been filed as your UCC-1. Check with your state's Secretary of State database to see if there's a filing under your debtor's name.
0 coins
Diego Mendoza
Just want to circle back on the document verification thing - I actually had a similar situation last year where we thought we had proper security agreements but there were name mismatches between the promissory note and UCC filing. Used Certana.ai to upload all our loan docs and it immediately flagged the inconsistency. Saved us from finding out the hard way during a default situation.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
•How much does something like that cost? We're a smaller lender and can't afford expensive compliance tools.
0 coins
Diego Mendoza
•I can't speak to pricing but the value was definitely worth it for us. Catching one major filing error pays for itself pretty quickly when you're talking about six-figure loan amounts.
0 coins
Aisha Hussain
The priority issue is going to depend on whether both creditors properly perfected their interests and when. If the other creditor filed a UCC-1 and you didn't, they'll likely have priority even if your underlying documents were signed earlier. The UCC is all about giving public notice of security interests.
0 coins
Freya Johansen
•That's what I was afraid of. So timing of perfection matters more than timing of the underlying agreement?
0 coins
Aisha Hussain
•Generally yes, assuming both parties have valid security agreements. An unperfected security interest can still be valid between you and the debtor, but it's subordinate to perfected interests in most cases.
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
Similar thing happened to a colleague - they had solid loan docs but never filed the UCC-1. When the borrower went bankrupt, they ended up as an unsecured creditor and recovered almost nothing. The trustee challenged their security interest because there was no public filing. Don't let this drag on - you need to figure out your perfection status ASAP.
0 coins
Freya Johansen
•That's terrifying. I'm calling our attorney first thing Monday morning.
0 coins
Anastasia Romanov
•Wait, can you file a UCC-1 after the fact if you forgot initially?
0 coins
GalacticGladiator
•You can file late, but it won't give you priority over creditors who filed properly before you. It's better than nothing though.
0 coins
Ethan Brown
For future reference, always run your loan documents through a verification process before funding. Whether that's internal legal review or a service like Certana.ai, you need to catch these gaps early. The distinction between promissory notes and security agreements trips up even experienced lenders sometimes.
0 coins
Yuki Yamamoto
•Agreed. We've started using document verification tools for every deal over $100K. Too much risk otherwise.
0 coins
Freya Johansen
•I'm definitely implementing better document review procedures after this mess.
0 coins
Zoe Dimitriou
This is a really common issue that catches a lot of lenders off guard. Based on what you've described, it sounds like you may have an attachment problem (the security agreement part) but definitely have a perfection problem (no UCC-1 filing). The other creditor likely has priority if they properly perfected first, regardless of when your note was signed. I'd strongly recommend getting an emergency consultation with a UCC attorney ASAP - don't wait until Monday. Some states allow for late filings that can still protect you against future creditors, and there might be other legal strategies available depending on the specific language in your documents and the other creditor's filing. Time is critical here, especially with equipment that could be repossessed.
0 coins
Melina Haruko
•This is excellent advice about getting emergency legal consultation. I'm curious though - are there any immediate steps Freya can take to protect her position while waiting for attorney guidance? Like documenting the current location/condition of the equipment or sending formal notice to the borrower? It seems like every day that passes could potentially strengthen the other creditor's position or give them more opportunity to act.
0 coins